B&N Nook beats Amazon Kindle & Sony Reader, here's why
I posted yesterday about the Barnes & Noble Nook and then read Mitch’s post where one of his four points about the Nook not being revolutionary focused on the apparent limited use of WiFi. I just posed a couple of questions on the Nook press call and have to now tell Mitch he is wrong about the WiFi access, but he should actually be quite pleased since there are no limits. I confirmed that you can access and purchase books via both WiFi and AT&T 3G from any place where you have access to a network, including your home WiFi network. One point of clarification regarding travel overseas. You can download books from you current library collection via WiFi overseas, but due to licensing issues you cannot browse the store and purchase new content when outside the US (yet). The Barnes & Noble store experience is just an enhanced experience that presents you with free content and also allows you to browse through books, just like you can physically in the bookstore. As I said yesterday, I think the Nook is a revolutionary product in the ebook market for a number of reasons.
Here is why I think the Nook stands out from the others and sets the bar. Some items are found in a Kindle or Sony Reader, but the Nook brings all of these together:
- Ability to purchase content via WiFi and AT&T 3G wireless connections from any location in the US
- Ability to lend ebooks to others for 14 days
- Ability to checkout and read local library ebooks for free
- Ability to browse full ebook content while connected in Barnes & Noble stores
- Sync across platforms and readers of bookmarks, annotations, last reading location
- 16-level grayscale display
- Small capacitive color touchscreen for ebook store browsing
My other question on the call pertained to what happens when you loan out a book and what happens after the 14 day loan period. The loan technology is modeled just like a real physical book so when the loaner gives a friend the book then the loaner has no access to that book. The loanee then has the book for 14 days, I forgot to ask if they can return it earlier, and when that loan period expires the license for that book is transferred back to the loaner. I am not sure if you can loan over and over, but imagine there are no limitations since it is as single license that is just being transferred around. The only requirement for the loanee is that they have to have an iPhone, BlackBerry, Nook, or other compatible device to read the content.
I found in the FAQ and wrote yesterday that you should be able to access and read local library books with the Nook and this was confirmed in another press release announcing the partnership between Barnes & Noble and Adobe. Adobe Digital Editions is supported, along with the ePub and PDF formats.
UPDATE: Mitch was able to speak further with some folks at Barnes & Noble and confirms what I was told on the call this morning in his latest blog post. Mitch also found out some good information about accessing Google Books and I have to say all of this information just confirms that my pre-order was a smart purchase that I look forward to receiving in November.
Matthew Miller is an avid mobile device enthusiast who works during the day as a professional naval architect in Seattle.
More from “The Mobile Gadgeteer”
Talkback Most Recent of 46 Talkback(s)
reverseswing10/21/2009 07:51 AM
No international support. Like the Sony not available outside the US. Again Amazon Kindle is ahead of the curve (even if the device is not as sophisticated)PedroTabs10/21/2009 08:44 AM
I don't understand that description for the Kindle. If it's faster (than the Nook -- see other reviews), takes fewer steps to do an action, has Free 24/7 web browsing, has read-to-me for the times you're on the run, how is it 'not as sophisticated' ?
Both the Nook and the Kindle have their strong and weak points. The search routines and results + dictionary lookups are much faster on the Kindle.
I like that looking up a character in a book gets me all instances of that character's name, shown 6 on a page with context surrounding it and a link to each page, rather than just one Find at a time, for instance.
- Andrysandrys112/10/2009 12:48 AM
I have a Kindle, the service for wireless is at no additional charge to download books and other content; does that apply to the Nook as well.
My only disappointment is no back light, clipping on a light causes hand fatigue from the unbalanced weight not to mention the inconvenience.
How does the Nook stack up in this area?scampisi10/21/2009 09:15 AM
ZDNet ModeratorThere is no charge for using the AT&T wireless service on the Nook. I actually have a weak Sprint signal and strong AT&T one so the Nook should work better for me than the Kindle did.
There is no backlight and a book light will have to be attached to read in the dark here too.palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller)10/21/2009 10:23 AM
Matthew, thank you for taking time to do what a reporter should always do BEFORE jumping to assumptions--ask questions.
Wonder how long it will be before Ratcliffe shows up with a new way to say he was still right...riffraffy10/21/2009 09:34 AM
to the New York Times, Wall Street Journal and TeleRead during the Q&A
that Wi-Fi outside the stores would not work and be enabled later?
I'm glad they changed their minds or corrected themselves, because I
think it's a very interesting device. My article was not primarily about Wi-
Fi limits, it was just one topic.
Mitch Ratcliffe10/21/2009 10:23 AM
he is human after all.......reverseswing10/21/2009 10:59 AM
as I pointed out about the Times in my posting. Yes, they all could have
gotten it wrong, but I haven't been able to get anyone at B&N to explain
why someone apparently said this at the press event. Moreover, Matt got
his confirmation of Wi-Fi functionality from Fleishman PR, not B&N. I
have followed up and received from Fleishman essentially the same
answer, but they did not answer my question about what was said
yesterday -- and no one at B&N seems to want to go on the record about
I've sent more follow-ups.Mitch Ratcliffe10/21/2009 02:18 PM
ZDNet ModeratorMitch, as we chatted about via email it was B&N who I was talking with and received my answers from this morning. I know your latest post clarifies this, but I just wanted to make sure the comments here were correct for readers to understand the story.palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller)10/21/2009 04:06 PM
Talkback - Tell Us What You Think
Get it the way you want it
- A Developer's View
- All About Microsoft
- Between the Lines
- Collaboration 2.0
- Dev Connection
- Digital Cameras & Camcorders
- Ed Bott's Microsoft Report
- Emerging Tech
- Enterprise Web 2.0
- Five Nines: The Next Gen Datacenter
- Forrester Research
- Googling Google
- GreenTech Pastures
- Hardware 2.0
- Home Theater
- IT Project Failures
- Irregular Enterprise
- Laptops & Desktops
- Linux and Open Source
- Managing L'unix
- On Sustainability
- Service Oriented
- Smartphones and Cell Phones
- Social Business
- Social CRM: The Conversation
- Software & Services Safari
- Software as Services
- Storage Bits
- Team Think
- Tech Broiler
- The Apple Core
- The DocuMentor
- The Mobile Gadgeteer
- The Semantic Web
- The ToyBox
- The Web Life
- Tom Foremski: IMHO
- Virtually Speaking
- ZDNet Education
- ZDNet Government
- ZDNet Healthcare
- Zero Day
White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
- Unlock Your Hidden Data Center Dell Kevin Smith, Enterprise Solutions Marketing Manager at Dell, explains why ... Download Now
- Data Center of the Future: Bitlocker Dell Hear about BitLocker?, and important component in WS08 that adds whole ... Download Now
- Image-Based Installation for Microsoft Windows Server 2008 Dell The image-based installation and systems management support in the ... Download Now