Holiday shopping change deferred by council

Last Updated: Wednesday, May 12, 2010 | 7:06 PM ET

Under the current bylaws only certain Toronto retailers, including the Eaton Centre, are allowed to open on statutory holidays. Council is debating whether to allow other retailers to open on those days.Under the current bylaws only certain Toronto retailers, including the Eaton Centre, are allowed to open on statutory holidays. Council is debating whether to allow other retailers to open on those days. (Darren Calabrese/Canadian Press)

After a lengthy debate, Toronto city council has decided to maintain the status quo when it comes to shopping on statutory holidays.

Under the existing bylaw, only certain Toronto retailers, including the Eaton Centre and parts of Yonge Street, are allowed to open on statutory holidays. Council debated on Wednesday whether to allow other retailers to open on those days.

Instead of making a change, council decided it needs more time to study the bylaw and opted to defer the decision.

After sailing through the economic development committee, it looked like the proposal had a real chance. Then a strongly worded letter from the Canadian Auto Workers was circulated urging council to reject it.

The CAW says the plan is driven by the retail sector and has not offered workers a chance to be heard.

Ian Cameron speaks for hundreds CAW workers at Metro and Sobeys supermarkets.

Cameron worries that employees will be forced to work on holidays.

"If [management] wants a part-time kid to work and he won't work, management will just say to him 'fine, I don't have any hours next week,'" said Cameron. "[Workers] don't want it, they want their days off. It's the only days they are guaranteed off and they want them. They want to be able to spend Christmas with their families."

Others had so-called "family values" concerns, arguing holidays like Christmas and Easter are for family, not shopping.

For city staff who supported the plan, it was about fairness and allowing all business owners to open when they want, particularly those who don't observe Christian holdays.

Now the move to allow holiday store openings has gone back to the drawing board, with instructions for council to consult more deeply with workers.

For retiring councillor Kyle Rae, a proponent of the idea, the decision to defer is a step backward. Rae says this will just allow an unfair retail situation to continue.

"Toronto is conservative and doesn't want to change," he said.


Toronto Headlines

Mixed martial arts backers rally in Toronto
Legalizing mixed martial arts would be good for Ontario's economy, say organizers of a rally outside the legislature in Toronto on Saturday.
Huntsville gears up for G8 summit
The Ontario community hosting the G8 economic summit in June is making final preparations and hosting an open house of its summit centre this weekend.
Wearing life-jackets should be mandatory: OPP Video
Ontario Provincial Police are calling for a federal law to require all boaters to wear life-jackets on vessels up to six metres long.
Diamondbacks' fast start sinks Blue Jays
The Toronto Blue Jays are bringing the power but not exactly the starting pitching through two interleague games in Arizona.
'Made in Canada' rules under review
Canadian consumer groups are urging the government not to alter its "product of Canada" and "made in Canada" food labelling rules as Ottawa considers exempting some ingredients.

Canada Headlines

Disabled couple find home together at last Video
An Ottawa couple has finally spent the night together, almost nine months after they got married — overcoming an obstacle that many couples with disabilities face.
Woman shot dead at Edmonton LRT station
A 23-year-woman is dead after a shooting at Edmonton's Stadium LRT station Friday night.
Community remembers Que. landslide victims
More than 600 mourners gathered in Saint-Jude, Que., on Saturday to pay their final respects to a local family killed in a landslide that swallowed their home.
Thousands without power in northern B.C.
Heavy snow Friday night has left thousands of BC Hydro customers in the northeastern part of the province without power.
Surrey man dies after 'targeted' attack
A 51-year-old man is dead after what police are calling a targeted attack in Surrey, B.C., early Saturday.

People who read this also read …

Top CBCNews.ca Headlines


Insurgents hit Kandahar Airfield Video
Insurgents were repelled after launching an attack on NATO's main military base in southern Afghanistan, home to the largest contingent of Canadian Forces personnel in the country, an official says.
Faster troop pullout urged by U.K. minister
The defence minister in Britain's new coalition government visited Afghanistan on Saturday with other senior officials after saying he hopes to speed the withdrawal of British troops from the country.
India hilltop plane crash kills 158 Video
An Air India Express plane crashed and burned after overshooting a hilltop runway in southern India, killing 158 people. There were eight survivors.
Flyers push punchless Habs to brink
The Flyers not only put forth a stingy defensive effort to slow speedy Montreal, but also overcame skate issues to shut out the Habs 3-0 at the Bell Centre on Saturday afternoon.
Oil 'disaster' panel set up Video
U.S. President Barack Obama announced Saturday that former Florida senator Bob Graham and former EPA administrator William Reilly will lead a presidential commission investigating the Gulf of Mexico oil spill.