cover art

In This Moment

A Star-Crossed Wasteland

(Century Media; US: 13 Jul 2010; UK: 5 Jul 2010)

It goes without saying that there’s been a terrible glut of sound-alike metalcore bands coming from the States over the past ten years, but every once in a while you get a band that’s just unique enough to stick out. Los Angeles quintet In This Moment made a modest splash in 2007, thanks in part to the presence of statuesque, tattooed lead howler Maria Brink, but mostly because their songs displayed a knack for melody that very few of their peers could match. Beautiful Tragedy played things relatively close to the vest, but the potential was there, and the excellent follow-up The Dream came through in a big way. Produced by Ozzy Osbourne collaborator Kevin Churko, The Dream abandoned the previous record’s generic template and audaciously delved into 1980s pop metal and hard rock, proving that it’s still possible to put out quality heavy rock while delivering gigantic pop hooks. The songwriting was more refined, Churko’s production was appropriately sleek, and Brink put in a very strong vocal performance, proving to be a very adept “clean” singer.

The exuberant yet predictable 2009 cover of Blondie’s classic “Call Me” might have played the ‘80s card one too many times, however, leaving some to wonder just how heavily In This Moment would rely on the style on their third album. As if on cue, A Star-Crossed Wasteland downplays the ‘80s gimmick, finding more of a middle ground between the aggressive moments of Beautiful Tragedy and the shimmering pop of The Dream, but not before giving listeners a bit of a scare first. Lead-off track and first single “The Gun Show” is the strangest thing we’ve heard from the band to date, a plodding Pantera/Black Label Society knock-off that sees Brink returning to the feral shriek she utilized on the first album. While not a terrible track—it pushes all the down-tuned groove metal buttons effectively—the song doesn’t play to the strengths of the band at all, and is a near-disastrous way to start off the record. In This Moment is at its best when the hooks are accentuated, not playing lowest-common-denominator “dude” metal like this.

Mercifully, “The Gun Show” is an anomaly, as the rest of the new album is a huge improvement, more of what we have come to expect from the band. “Just Drive” is a perfect example of the more even balance of aggression and melody, shifting from propulsive riffs and snarled verses to a classy chorus that puts Brink’s singing front and center. “Standing Alone” is even better, guitarists Chris Howorth and Blake Bunzel launching into some very good traditional metal riffs as Brink delivers some of the most nuanced melodies we’ve heard from her yet. Potential active rock hit “The Promise” is an interesting duet between Brink and deep-voiced singer Adam Patrick, and though it shows just how much better this music sounds sung by Brink rather than Patrick’s cloying Scott Stapp impersonation, the two play off each other well enough to make the song work.

Despite the emphasis on their heavier side, the band still plunks a couple of straight-ahead power ballads on the album, the strongest of which is “World in Flames”, which unabashedly plays the melodrama to the hilt, complete with piano and a climactic solo by Howorth. Still, A Star-Crossed Wasteland consistently churns out the well-crafted rockers during its latter half, “The Road” and “The Last Cowboy” playing up the hooks, “Blazin’” and “Iron Army” focusing a little more on the crunching riffs and double-kick beats. In a day and age where some of the worst bands imaginable dominate mainstream metal (Five Finger Death Punch, Winds of Plague, the loathsome Attack! Attack!), In This Moment remains a welcome respite from the usual dunderheaded, testosterone-fueled fare, bringing a touch of class to a subgenre that has long since stopped trying to do anything remotely creative. First track aside, this album’s a gem.


Adrien Begrand has been writing for PopMatters since 2002, and has been writing his monthly metal column Blood & Thunder since 2005. His writing has also appeared in Metal Edge, Terrorizer, Sick Sounds, Metallian, graphic novelist Joel Orff’s Strum and Drang: Great Moments in Rock ‘n’ RollKnoxville Voice, The Kerouac Quarterly,,, and A contributing writer for Decibel magazine and senior writer for Hellbound, he resides, blogs, and does the Twitter thing in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada.

In This Moment - The Gun Show
Related Articles
20 Oct 2008
We all knew they were capable of catchy songs, but just not this catchy.
6 Jun 2007
On the Orange County band's debut, lead singer Maria Brink puts a welcome, fresh spin on a very tired sound.
Add a comment
Please enter your name and a valid email address. Your email address will not be displayed. It is required only to prevent comment spam.
Remember my personal information
Notify me of follow-up comments?
Now on PopMatters
Moving Pixels: Dreaming in 'Limbo'
Crazed by the Music: Irving Azoff U R A Jerk
Marginal Utility: Facebook As Kibbutz
Christmas in August with Fred Schneider (Mixed Media) [Fri, 10:30 am]
Questioning Values, With a Twist (Re:Print) [Fri, 10:00 am]
Inconsistency Stifles 'The Other Guys' Cleverness (Short Ends and Leader) [Fri, 9:30 am]
'Cairo Time': These New Modern Things (Reviews) [Fri, 8:50 am]
Perry Farrell Interviews X Japan's Yoshiki (Mixed Media) [Fri, 8:15 am]
'Quest for Honor': Step by Step (Reviews) [Fri, 7:35 am]
  1. It's a Gay Day in Chicago: Nationwide Rally for Gay Rights (Notes from the Road)
  2. By Volume 8, That Big Ol' 'Family Guy" Has Grown Pretty Lazy (Reviews)
  3. Robert Randolph and the Family Band: We Walk This Road (Reviews)
  4. Cowabunga, M@#!@&F*&%^$! (Mixed Media)
  5. 'Batwoman: Elegy' Is a Comic Masterpiece About an Openly Gay Superhero (Reviews)
  6. When Is 'Bad' Really BAD? (Short Ends and Leader)
  7. Arcade Fire: The Suburbs (Reviews)
  8. Jukebox Heroes: A Long Delayed Return to Classic Rock -- Which Can Be Pretty Damn Good (Columns)
  9. Growing Up Twisted (Reviews)
  10. Call for Book Reviewers and Bloggers (Announcements)
  11. This Just In: The Hooters’ “And We Danced” May Be the Worst Video of All Time (Sound Affects)
  12. Menomena: Mines (Reviews)
  13. Liz Phair: Funstyle (Reviews)
  14. Feeding an Addiction (Columns)
  15. Shapes and Sizes: Candle to Your Eyes (Reviews)
  16. Korn: Korn III: Remember Who You Are (Reviews)
  17. Morality in Mystery Dungeon: 'Shiren the Wanderer' (Columns)
  18. HARD Tour: 24 July 2010 - New York (Notes from the Road)
  19. The Flaming Lips: 26 July 2010 - New York (Notes from the Road)
  20. Katie Melua: The House (Reviews)
  21. Captain Jack As a Digital Weapon: Launching ‘Torchwood’ Comic #1 (Features)
  22. Pac-Man Will Die: Cynicism and Retro Game “Endings” (Moving Pixels)
  23. Best Coast: Crazy for You (Reviews)
  24. Double-Edged Sword: Making Mistakes in 'Diablo II' (Moving Pixels)
  25. Information Processing and Pleasure (Marginal Utility)
  26. Dean & Britta: 13 Most Beautiful: Songs For Andy Warhol's Screen Tests (Reviews)
  27. House of the Rising Sun Lamp: Jersey Shore UNCENSORED: Season One (Columns)
  28. Lollapalooza 2010: Opportunity Knocks, Part One (Features)
  29. Worlds Without Words: What German Expressionism Can Teach Us About Game Design (Moving Pixels)
  30. The Lady in Blue: Patricia Clarkson Romances Cairo (Features)
  1. Arcade Fire: The Suburbs (Reviews)
  2. Losing My Religion: Revealing the Hollow Reality of Lo-Fi (Sound Affects)
  3. It's a Gay Day in Chicago: Nationwide Rally for Gay Rights (Notes from the Road)
  4. Sarah Palin's Creative Vocabulization (Columns)
  5. Bing Crosby, Elvis Presley, and the Narratives of American Popular Song (Features)
  6. Jukebox Heroes: A Long Delayed Return to Classic Rock -- Which Can Be Pretty Damn Good (Columns)
  7. This Just In: The Hooters’ “And We Danced” May Be the Worst Video of All Time (Sound Affects)
  8. Captain Jack As a Digital Weapon: Launching ‘Torchwood’ Comic #1 (Features)
  9. Liz Phair: Funstyle (Reviews)
  10. All The Things They Do!: A Superstar Interview with Adam Schlesinger & Mike Viola (Features)
  11. Play It Again, Please: Grappling with Repeated Album Listens in the iPod Age (Sound Affects)
  12. Ed Kowalczyk: Alive (Reviews)
  13. Tommy Keene: Tommy Keene You Hear Me, A Retrospective, 1983-2009 (Reviews)
  14. We Built Our Own World: Hans Zimmer and the Music of 'Inception' (Features)
  15. Should History Be Rated "R"? (Short Ends and Leader)
  16. Transparent Difficulty in 'Order of Ecclesia' (Moving Pixels)
  17. Miley Cyrus: Can't Be Tamed (Reviews)
  18. Is Speed Running Artistic? (Moving Pixels)
  19. I Do Know Jack. That's the Whole Problem! (Sound Affects)
  20. Abusing the World: An Aesthetics of Demolition (Moving Pixels)
  21. Anaïs Mitchell: Hadestown (Reviews)
  22. Fooled by Skepticism (Columns)
  23. It's a Meager Bounty in 'The Bounty Hunter' (Reviews)
  24. How Does One Beat the Heat? Try Descending Into Icy Madness (Columns)
  25. Why 'Yogi Bear' Makes Me Want to Retch! (Short Ends and Leader)
Music Archive
PM Picks

© 1999-2010 All rights reserved.™ and PopMatters™ are trademarks
of PopMatters Media, Inc. and PopMatters Magazine.

PopMatters is wholly independently owned and operated.