skip to main content (press enter)

CBC Global Header Navigation


'Emergency' appendix surgery can wait: MDs

Last Updated: Tuesday, September 21, 2010 | 2:51 PM ET

Acute appendicitis may not require emergency surgery, U.S. and Canadian doctors have found.

Removing an appendix is one of the most common surgical procedures performed worldwide and accounts for an estimated 25,000 hospital stays in Canada each year, researchers say.

'It's probably safe to postpone operations to the light of day.'— Dr. Avery Nathens

Although it is assumed the disease would be more severe and complications worse the longer a patient waits to have an appendectomy because of the risk that an appendix might burst, a new study suggests otherwise.

Delays of 12 hours or more before the surgery did not appear to harm how patients fared 30 days after the surgery, the study of 32,782 patients who had undergone the procedure showed.

"It's probably safe to postpone operations to the light of day," said the study's senior author, Dr. Avery Nathens, division head of general surgery at St. Michael's Hospital in Toronto.

The study, in Tuesday's issue of the Archives of Surgery, divided participants into three groups, depending on how long they waited for the operation after being admitted to the hospital:

The patients had their appendectomies between 2005 and 2008.

Of the total:

  • 24,647 or 75 per cent had surgery within six hours of being admitted to the hospital.
  • 4,934 or 15 per cent had their appendectomies after waiting six to 12 hours.
  • 3,201 or nearly 10 per cent waited more than 12 hours.

Complications, deaths and length of hospital stay were not clinically significant between the groups, Dr. Angela Ingraham of the American College of Surgeons in Chicago and her colleagues found.

The findings could help surgeons to prioritize patients, and identify those who really need an operation in the middle of the night.

For Canadian hospitals, the challenge now is to ensure patients with appendicitis have the opportunity to receive their surgery during the day, when operating rooms tend to be busy with elective surgeries like cancer operations and hip replacements, said Nathens, who is also director of trauma at St. Mike's.

For patients, Nathens said, the key message is that research suggests it isn't the time waiting at the hospital that matters most, but how long they wait at home before going to emergency.

The researchers acknowledged some limitations of the study, such as not knowing how much time had elapsed between when symptoms arose and when the patients arrived at the hospital. They also didn't know whether surgeons triaged patients to operate first on the cases that seemed the worst.

Let weary surgeons sleep

Several generations of general surgeons have the indelible memory of a beeper going off just as they drift to sleep, alerting them to a patient in the emergency department with acute appendicitis, Dr. John Hunter of the department of surgery at Oregon Health & Science University in Portland said in a journal commentary accompanying the study.

The surgeons would then spend between four hours to the whole night examining, imaging and treating the patient, leading to yawns and struggles to pay attention the next day.

The main benefit of the latest findings is to validate the practice of treating acute appendicitis urgently rather than as an emergency, Hunter said.

"The ability of a surgeon to sleep through the night results in a day without the fatigue engendered by a sleepless night caring for a patient with acute appendicitis," Hunter said.

"A secondary benefit is the savings to the hospital generated by minimizing staff and anesthesiologist presence late in the evening and during the wee hours of the morning."

Pediatric researchers have also found similar results in smaller studies on children, Nathens said.



Health Headlines

Build breast cancer survivors' physical limits: MD
Breast cancer survivors with physical limitations may be at higher risk of dying from causes other than cancer, new U.S. research suggests.
Hospital user fee plan dropped by Quebec
The Quebec government has dropped part of its controversial plan to introduce health-care user fees.
Heart valve innovation could help frail: study
An artificial heart valve could help some people too frail to survive having their chest opened up in surgery, a new study suggests.
Huntington's insight given by stem cells
Studying Huntington's disease in human embryonic stem cells show signs of the disease in cells just a few days old, Australian researchers say.
UN launches mother-child campaign
A global campaign that aims to save the lives of 16 million mothers and children over the next five years was launched by UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon on Wednesday with as much as $40 billion US in commitments from world governments and private aid groups.

People who read this also read …

Top Headlines


Gun registry survives Commons vote
MPs have voted 153-151 to save the gun registry, with enough New Democrat MPs voting with the Liberals and Bloc to scrap a bill aimed at killing the program.
Igor cleanup underway in Newfoundland Video
People across many parts of Newfoundland are without power as crews tackle the aftermath of Hurricane Igor, a storm that swept a man to sea and crumbled bridges and highways.
Charities paid $762M to private fundraisers VideoAudio
A CBC investigation finds Canadian registered charities paid $762 million to third-party fundraisers between 2004 and 2008, all of it deducted from donations and often dwarfing guidelines set out by the Canada Revenue Agency.
Jackie Burroughs of Road to Avonlea dies
Jackie Burroughs, the stage and screen actress best known for her role as schoolteacher Hetty King on TV's Road to Avonlea, has died at the age of 71.
Canadian archers bow out of Delhi Games
Canadian archers Kevin Tataryn and Dietmar Trillus have become the first Canadian athletes to pull out of the Commonwealth Games since concerns emerged this week over the condition of the athletes village in New Delhi.