Big Ten: J.T. Floyd
En route to West Lafayette to watch Purdue's afternoon practice. Also monitoring Joe Paterno's news conference in State College.
Send in those questions for Tuesday's mailblog, and don't forget: I'm on Twitter.
Chad from Iowa City, Iowa, writes: I personally count Iowa lucky to have the opportunity to play OSU in 2 years instead of having to wait for four. I understand and know that in order for us to take the next step towards being a team that can be considered "great" we need to be able to play them. My real problem comes with the fact that because of this situation, we won't have played illinois in each of the last 2 years due to having them off our schedule with the old Big 10 scheduling process. And Now they are the team that won't be with us for 4 years? There is no way, at any point in the Big 10, that teams should go 6 years without playing each other, even if this is the only time it ever happens. This is the ultimate lack of intimacy in the league if you don't see a team for 6 years. Thoughts?
Adam Rittenberg: Chad, I like your attitude toward the Ohio State series. To be an elite team in the Big Ten, you have to beat the Buckeyes. The Iowa-Illinois hiatus is unfortunate, and fan bases on both sides aren't pleased. It has to do with two different scheduling models (pre-expansion, post-expansion) having to blend, and the likelihood of the Big Ten going to a nine-game league schedule. The Iowa-Illinois no-plays in 2009 and 2010 were part of the old model. If Nebraska didn't enter the league and there weren't divisions, protected crossovers, etc., Illinois would be back on Iowa's slate this fall. But expansion changed the schedule situation and created new no-plays with the divisions. The longest you'll see teams not playing with an eight-game Big Ten slate from 2011 onward is four years. If the Big Ten goes to a nine-game slate -- I really think this will ultimately happen -- the gaps will be shorter. I know this doesn't help Iowa players who arrived in 2009 or 2010, but this situation is unique.
Craig from Madison, Wis., writes: I agree with you completely about Wisconsin having its home opener on Thursday night instead of sometime on Saturday afternoon. It provides national exposure to a game that most people wouldn't watch but will because they will want to watch any football they can. How do you see the Badgers handling the key players they lost, and (I know its wayyyyyyy too early) how do you see them faring in the Leaders (or whichever one it is) division?
Adam Rittenberg: You're absolutely right about the Thursday night opener, Craig. You put Wisconsin-UNLV among a bunch of noon ET kickoffs on Sept. 3, and it gets lost in the shuffle. Exposure is minimal. When you isolate the game on a Thursday night, many more people will watch. One added benefit I didn't mention Thursday is Wisconsin will have two more days to prepare for Oregon State on Sept. 10. ... As for the Badgers, they lose a lot, and I think quarterback Scott Tolzien and defensive end J.J. Watt are the most damaging departures. Sure, Wisconsin will run the ball well, but this isn't an offense that can afford mistakes from the QB spot, and Tolzien made very few last season. This will be a true test of Wisconsin's recruiting and player development. If the Badgers can reload, they absolutely will challenge for the Leaders division crown.
Boulder Buckeye from Boulder, Colo., writes: Hey Adam, You never post my questions so I am not actually expecting an answer but what the hey. I am writing to ask why you are not covering the buckeyes spring practice and instead chose to attend Northwestern's. I know you are an alum and Northwestern did have a decent season last year but come on. I bet there are about 5,000 buckeye readers to every one Northwestern reader. Also by "covering" the buckeyes I am not asking for you to detail suspensions and speculate on Coach T's potential NCAA sanctions. A little buckeye love goes a long way
Adam Rittenberg: Boulder, I think the Buckeyes get their share of coverage on the blog, although you may disagree. There are certain factors that go into when I visit a certain campus. A big one is access to players and coaches. Ohio State's first spring practice Thursday was only open to reporters for 30 minutes, and no players or coaches were available for interviews afterward. As my guy Ken Gordon points out, "When you only have 30 minutes, and it's the first practice of a spring, and the guys are not in pads, you can't possibly make any intelligent evaluations of individual players." So while I understand the excitement of Ohio State fans for the first practice, it doesn't benefit me much to go that day. Northwestern, meanwhile, had a completely open practice in full pads, and I had the chance to visit with head coach Pat Fitzgerald, both coordinators and a bunch of players afterward. The choice had nothing to do with where I went to school and everything to do with access. The good news: I'll be in Columbus next week, where I'm looking forward to catching up with the Buckeyes and (hopefully) watching a practice in pads.
George from Champaign, Ill., writes: Adam, In today's blog (March 31) you put that Nebraska hasn't played any Big Ten teams since 2003 when in fact you sir are wrong the last time that Nebraska play a Big ten team was 2005 when it played my Michigan Wolverines in the Alamo Bowl.
Adam Rittenberg: George, you've got to read the fine print, my friend. I wrote that Nebraska hadn't played a regular-season game against a Big Ten team since 2003. I used this to indicate that the Huskers haven't actively planned to play a Big Ten squad for some time. You're right about Nebraska's last meeting with the Big Ten (2005 Alamo Bowl). The Huskers actually played three Alamo Bowls against the Big Ten in the 2000s, winning them all. Here's a breakdown of Nebraska vs. the Big Ten.
Chad from Allegan, Mich., writes: Today I spent about an hour or so watching Michigan spring practice videos, reading coaches comments, and looking at the spring roster. I feel like I've done a pretty good job of creating a projected Depth Chart based. People have asked you before if Mattison and the 4-3 scheme could really make a huge difference. Based on what I've come up with, I'd say yes. If you look at projected starters, there are 6 4-star prospects, 1 5-star prospect, and 4 3-star prospects (2 of the 3-star prospects are Troy Woolfolk and J.T. Floyd.) And behind those projected starters is a ton of depth of 3-star and 4-star prospects. The talent is there. Mattison just said they are behind in the fundamentals and techniques aspect. If fundamentals and techniques are the issues because of poor coaching under Rich Rod and Greg Robinson, those can be fixed, whereas lack of talent cannot. Do you see Michigan as having a middle-of-the-pack defense this year, to go along with good and talented offense, and finish... let's say... 9-4 or 10-3?
Adam Rittenberg: Chad, it's possible, but Michigan has some significant work to do to become a middle-of-the-pack defense. I agree with you about the talent being in Ann Arbor, but the coaches have to evaluate who best can help them and at what spots. I think Michigan stuck with the 3-3-5 too long last season, and it might not have been all Greg Robinson's fault, from what I've been told. It's important to have realistic expectations with the secondary. Although Woolfolk and Floyd returning helps, the group has a long way to go. I'm really interested in whether the line takes a step forward. Michigan has a great piece to build around in Mike Martin.
Billy G. from Philly writes: If the Vest calls it a career, do you think Buckeye fans would prefer Fickell take over or going out and getting Urban Meyer? Urban's a name brand, but after years of loathing him, do you think they would ever welcome him with open arms? As a Viking fan, reminds me of being forced to support Favre after 18 years of thinking he was a phony and self absorbed schmo. I couldn't do it. but seems like Buckeye fans would take whoever can get them a BCS title.
Adam Rittenberg: Billy, I like the Vikings-Favre analogy, although there probably was more hatred for No. 4 among Vikings fans than there is for Urban Meyer in Columbus. My take on Ohio State's coaching situation has been the same long before Jim Tressel's transgressions. When this job opens up, Ohio State must do a national search and open it up to all the excellent candidates who could have interest. This is one of the best jobs in the country, and Ohio State shouldn't limit itself to a candidate, whether he's Fickell or Meyer. Open the job up, see who has genuine interest and conduct a thorough search. If Ohio State does this, it should end up with a very good coach.
Send in those questions for Tuesday's mailblog, and don't forget: I'm on Twitter.
Chad from Iowa City, Iowa, writes: I personally count Iowa lucky to have the opportunity to play OSU in 2 years instead of having to wait for four. I understand and know that in order for us to take the next step towards being a team that can be considered "great" we need to be able to play them. My real problem comes with the fact that because of this situation, we won't have played illinois in each of the last 2 years due to having them off our schedule with the old Big 10 scheduling process. And Now they are the team that won't be with us for 4 years? There is no way, at any point in the Big 10, that teams should go 6 years without playing each other, even if this is the only time it ever happens. This is the ultimate lack of intimacy in the league if you don't see a team for 6 years. Thoughts?
Adam Rittenberg: Chad, I like your attitude toward the Ohio State series. To be an elite team in the Big Ten, you have to beat the Buckeyes. The Iowa-Illinois hiatus is unfortunate, and fan bases on both sides aren't pleased. It has to do with two different scheduling models (pre-expansion, post-expansion) having to blend, and the likelihood of the Big Ten going to a nine-game league schedule. The Iowa-Illinois no-plays in 2009 and 2010 were part of the old model. If Nebraska didn't enter the league and there weren't divisions, protected crossovers, etc., Illinois would be back on Iowa's slate this fall. But expansion changed the schedule situation and created new no-plays with the divisions. The longest you'll see teams not playing with an eight-game Big Ten slate from 2011 onward is four years. If the Big Ten goes to a nine-game slate -- I really think this will ultimately happen -- the gaps will be shorter. I know this doesn't help Iowa players who arrived in 2009 or 2010, but this situation is unique.
Craig from Madison, Wis., writes: I agree with you completely about Wisconsin having its home opener on Thursday night instead of sometime on Saturday afternoon. It provides national exposure to a game that most people wouldn't watch but will because they will want to watch any football they can. How do you see the Badgers handling the key players they lost, and (I know its wayyyyyyy too early) how do you see them faring in the Leaders (or whichever one it is) division?
Adam Rittenberg: You're absolutely right about the Thursday night opener, Craig. You put Wisconsin-UNLV among a bunch of noon ET kickoffs on Sept. 3, and it gets lost in the shuffle. Exposure is minimal. When you isolate the game on a Thursday night, many more people will watch. One added benefit I didn't mention Thursday is Wisconsin will have two more days to prepare for Oregon State on Sept. 10. ... As for the Badgers, they lose a lot, and I think quarterback Scott Tolzien and defensive end J.J. Watt are the most damaging departures. Sure, Wisconsin will run the ball well, but this isn't an offense that can afford mistakes from the QB spot, and Tolzien made very few last season. This will be a true test of Wisconsin's recruiting and player development. If the Badgers can reload, they absolutely will challenge for the Leaders division crown.
Boulder Buckeye from Boulder, Colo., writes: Hey Adam, You never post my questions so I am not actually expecting an answer but what the hey. I am writing to ask why you are not covering the buckeyes spring practice and instead chose to attend Northwestern's. I know you are an alum and Northwestern did have a decent season last year but come on. I bet there are about 5,000 buckeye readers to every one Northwestern reader. Also by "covering" the buckeyes I am not asking for you to detail suspensions and speculate on Coach T's potential NCAA sanctions. A little buckeye love goes a long way
Adam Rittenberg: Boulder, I think the Buckeyes get their share of coverage on the blog, although you may disagree. There are certain factors that go into when I visit a certain campus. A big one is access to players and coaches. Ohio State's first spring practice Thursday was only open to reporters for 30 minutes, and no players or coaches were available for interviews afterward. As my guy Ken Gordon points out, "When you only have 30 minutes, and it's the first practice of a spring, and the guys are not in pads, you can't possibly make any intelligent evaluations of individual players." So while I understand the excitement of Ohio State fans for the first practice, it doesn't benefit me much to go that day. Northwestern, meanwhile, had a completely open practice in full pads, and I had the chance to visit with head coach Pat Fitzgerald, both coordinators and a bunch of players afterward. The choice had nothing to do with where I went to school and everything to do with access. The good news: I'll be in Columbus next week, where I'm looking forward to catching up with the Buckeyes and (hopefully) watching a practice in pads.
George from Champaign, Ill., writes: Adam, In today's blog (March 31) you put that Nebraska hasn't played any Big Ten teams since 2003 when in fact you sir are wrong the last time that Nebraska play a Big ten team was 2005 when it played my Michigan Wolverines in the Alamo Bowl.
Adam Rittenberg: George, you've got to read the fine print, my friend. I wrote that Nebraska hadn't played a regular-season game against a Big Ten team since 2003. I used this to indicate that the Huskers haven't actively planned to play a Big Ten squad for some time. You're right about Nebraska's last meeting with the Big Ten (2005 Alamo Bowl). The Huskers actually played three Alamo Bowls against the Big Ten in the 2000s, winning them all. Here's a breakdown of Nebraska vs. the Big Ten.
Chad from Allegan, Mich., writes: Today I spent about an hour or so watching Michigan spring practice videos, reading coaches comments, and looking at the spring roster. I feel like I've done a pretty good job of creating a projected Depth Chart based. People have asked you before if Mattison and the 4-3 scheme could really make a huge difference. Based on what I've come up with, I'd say yes. If you look at projected starters, there are 6 4-star prospects, 1 5-star prospect, and 4 3-star prospects (2 of the 3-star prospects are Troy Woolfolk and J.T. Floyd.) And behind those projected starters is a ton of depth of 3-star and 4-star prospects. The talent is there. Mattison just said they are behind in the fundamentals and techniques aspect. If fundamentals and techniques are the issues because of poor coaching under Rich Rod and Greg Robinson, those can be fixed, whereas lack of talent cannot. Do you see Michigan as having a middle-of-the-pack defense this year, to go along with good and talented offense, and finish... let's say... 9-4 or 10-3?
Adam Rittenberg: Chad, it's possible, but Michigan has some significant work to do to become a middle-of-the-pack defense. I agree with you about the talent being in Ann Arbor, but the coaches have to evaluate who best can help them and at what spots. I think Michigan stuck with the 3-3-5 too long last season, and it might not have been all Greg Robinson's fault, from what I've been told. It's important to have realistic expectations with the secondary. Although Woolfolk and Floyd returning helps, the group has a long way to go. I'm really interested in whether the line takes a step forward. Michigan has a great piece to build around in Mike Martin.
Billy G. from Philly writes: If the Vest calls it a career, do you think Buckeye fans would prefer Fickell take over or going out and getting Urban Meyer? Urban's a name brand, but after years of loathing him, do you think they would ever welcome him with open arms? As a Viking fan, reminds me of being forced to support Favre after 18 years of thinking he was a phony and self absorbed schmo. I couldn't do it. but seems like Buckeye fans would take whoever can get them a BCS title.
Adam Rittenberg: Billy, I like the Vikings-Favre analogy, although there probably was more hatred for No. 4 among Vikings fans than there is for Urban Meyer in Columbus. My take on Ohio State's coaching situation has been the same long before Jim Tressel's transgressions. When this job opens up, Ohio State must do a national search and open it up to all the excellent candidates who could have interest. This is one of the best jobs in the country, and Ohio State shouldn't limit itself to a candidate, whether he's Fickell or Meyer. Open the job up, see who has genuine interest and conduct a thorough search. If Ohio State does this, it should end up with a very good coach.
The spring superlatives series, which examines the strongest and weakest position groups on each Big Ten squad, marches on with Michigan.
Strongest position: Wide receiver
Strongest position: Wide receiver
- Key returnees: Roy Roundtree (72 receptions, 935 yards, 7 TDs); Darryl Stonum (49 receptions, 633 yards, 4 TDs); Junior Hemingway (32 receptions, 593 yards, 4 TDs); Kelvin Grady (17 receptions, 211 yards)
- Key losses: None
- The skinny: It's a close call between the receivers and the offensive line, but Michigan brings back everyone on the perimeter and must replace two starters (Stephen Schilling and Perry Dorrestein) up front. Several receivers made significant strides last season as Denard Robinson blossomed with his passing skills. Although Michigan's wideouts must limit dropped passes and adjust to a new system, they boast the experience and talent to help the unit this fall. Roundtree is a bona fide All-Big Ten candidate and Stonum, Hemingway and Grady all can stretch the field.
- Key returnees: S Jordan Kovacs (116 tackles, 8.5 tackles for loss, 2 interceptions, 1 sack, 1 forced fumble); CB Troy Woolfolk (46 tackles and a pass breakup in 12 starts in 2009); CB J.T. Floyd (66 tackles, 1 interception, 1 forced fumble, 4 pass breakups); S Cameron Gordon (77 tackles, 3 interceptions, 2 fumble recoveries, 3.5 tackles for loss)
- Key losses: CB James Rogers (40 tackles, 3 interceptions); S Ray Vinopal (33 tackles, 1 interception, 3 passes defended)
- The skinny: The secondary's struggles in 2010 were well documented as opposing teams consistently found gaps and attacked down the field. Several young players who had no business being on the field so early were tossed into the fire and got burned. The good news is Michigan should be healthier with Woolfolk's return, and players like Gordon, Floyd and Courtney Avery should benefit from a year under their belts. Michigan needs improved fundamentals from its defensive backs and far fewer breakdowns that lead to big gains for the opposition. The kicker position also could fit here after a disastrous 2010 season.
National Signing Day is just about a week away, so let's take a look at the recruiting needs for each Big Ten team.
In compiling these lists, I tried to look at positions that have depth issues for 2011 and/or 2012.
Let's start off with the Legends division.
IOWA
Running back: Marcus Coker's breakout performance in the Insight Bowl got Iowa fans excited for the future, but there's still a significant depth issue here. If Adam Robinson can't get reinstated, the Hawkeyes will be looking for No. 2 and No. 3 options behind Coker. As we've seen the past two seasons, freshmen backs will see the field at Iowa.
Linebacker: Iowa felt the losses of Pat Angerer and A.J. Edds this season, and it must continue to rebuild the depth at the three linebacker spots. Multiyear starter Jeremiha Hunter departs along with players like Jeff Tarpinian and Troy Johnson. Iowa needs to build around rising star James Morris.
Wide receiver/tight end: Iowa loses Derrell Johnson-Koulianos, Allen Reisner and Colin Sandeman this year. Also, receiver Marvin McNutt and tight end Brad Herman depart after the 2011 season. Although the Hawkeyes boast young talent at both positions, they need to build depth with this class.
MICHIGAN
Secondary: The Wolverines couldn't find many answers here in 2010, and though the return of players like cornerbacks Troy Woolfolk and J.T. Floyd will help, there are opportunities for freshmen to make an immediate impact. Michigan simply needs more options at both secondary spots in 2011.
Defensive line: It's crucial for coach Brady Hoke and defensive coordinator Greg Mattison to begin building depth up front. Future NFL player Mike Martin departs after 2011 along with Ryan Van Bergen, so Michigan needs to solidify both line positions.
Kicker: Field goals were an adventure in 2010, and Michigan simply can't have so much uncertainty at kicker going forward. The Wolverines need a reliable leg here ASAP.
MICHIGAN STATE
Linebacker: I like some of the young linebackers the Spartans bring back in 2011, but you can't overlook the losses of multiyear starters Greg Jones and Eric Gordon, not to mention reserve Jon Misch. Michigan State should have a decent group of first-string 'backers, but wants to build depth in the defensive midsection.
Offensive line: Not only do the Spartans lose three starters from the 2010 line, but they're still not where they need to be depth-wise up front to become a consistent top-tier Big Ten program. Michigan State wants to become like Iowa and Wisconsin. The big step is to keep fortifying both lines, especially on the offensive side.
MINNESOTA
Pass rusher: Minnesota finished last in the Big Ten in sacks last season (9) and hasn't had an intimidating pass rusher since Willie VanDeSteeg in 2008. The recent departure of defensive tackle Jewhan Edwards, who led the team in both sacks and tackles for loss in 2009, underscores this need.
Offensive line: The Gophers lose three starters up front, and while they boast some promising young linemen like tackle Ed Olson, the depth just isn't there yet. Minnesota's best teams had powerful offensive lines, and new coach Jerry Kill must continue to create competition up front.
NEBRASKA
Running back: The Huskers lose standout Roy Helu Jr., and while Rex Burkhead quickly will become one of my favorite Big Ten players, he might not be an every-down back for Nebraska going forward. You always want options in the backfield, and Nebraska must continue to address its run game with the 2011 class.
Wide receiver: Nebraska loses Niles Paul and wants to identify playmakers to surround Taylor Martinez or whomever starts at quarterback. Brandon Kinnie departs after the 2011 season, and while Burkhead helps in the receiving department, Nebraska needs others to emerge.
NORTHWESTERN
Running back: Although Mike Trumpy and Adonis Smith emerged as possible answers late in the 2010 season, Northwestern needs to create real competition here. The Wildcats have lacked a dominant back during the Pat Fitzgerald era and need a dangerous rushing option to complement Dan Persa.
Defensive line: The Wildcats lose only one starter (Corbin Bryant) from the 2010 squad, but four more rotation players (Vince Browne, Jack DiNardo, Kevin Watt and Niko Mafuli) depart after 2011. Fortifying the pass rush is a major priority going forward.
In compiling these lists, I tried to look at positions that have depth issues for 2011 and/or 2012.
Let's start off with the Legends division.
IOWA
Running back: Marcus Coker's breakout performance in the Insight Bowl got Iowa fans excited for the future, but there's still a significant depth issue here. If Adam Robinson can't get reinstated, the Hawkeyes will be looking for No. 2 and No. 3 options behind Coker. As we've seen the past two seasons, freshmen backs will see the field at Iowa.
Linebacker: Iowa felt the losses of Pat Angerer and A.J. Edds this season, and it must continue to rebuild the depth at the three linebacker spots. Multiyear starter Jeremiha Hunter departs along with players like Jeff Tarpinian and Troy Johnson. Iowa needs to build around rising star James Morris.
Wide receiver/tight end: Iowa loses Derrell Johnson-Koulianos, Allen Reisner and Colin Sandeman this year. Also, receiver Marvin McNutt and tight end Brad Herman depart after the 2011 season. Although the Hawkeyes boast young talent at both positions, they need to build depth with this class.
MICHIGAN
Secondary: The Wolverines couldn't find many answers here in 2010, and though the return of players like cornerbacks Troy Woolfolk and J.T. Floyd will help, there are opportunities for freshmen to make an immediate impact. Michigan simply needs more options at both secondary spots in 2011.
Defensive line: It's crucial for coach Brady Hoke and defensive coordinator Greg Mattison to begin building depth up front. Future NFL player Mike Martin departs after 2011 along with Ryan Van Bergen, so Michigan needs to solidify both line positions.
Kicker: Field goals were an adventure in 2010, and Michigan simply can't have so much uncertainty at kicker going forward. The Wolverines need a reliable leg here ASAP.
MICHIGAN STATE
Linebacker: I like some of the young linebackers the Spartans bring back in 2011, but you can't overlook the losses of multiyear starters Greg Jones and Eric Gordon, not to mention reserve Jon Misch. Michigan State should have a decent group of first-string 'backers, but wants to build depth in the defensive midsection.
Offensive line: Not only do the Spartans lose three starters from the 2010 line, but they're still not where they need to be depth-wise up front to become a consistent top-tier Big Ten program. Michigan State wants to become like Iowa and Wisconsin. The big step is to keep fortifying both lines, especially on the offensive side.
MINNESOTA
Pass rusher: Minnesota finished last in the Big Ten in sacks last season (9) and hasn't had an intimidating pass rusher since Willie VanDeSteeg in 2008. The recent departure of defensive tackle Jewhan Edwards, who led the team in both sacks and tackles for loss in 2009, underscores this need.
Offensive line: The Gophers lose three starters up front, and while they boast some promising young linemen like tackle Ed Olson, the depth just isn't there yet. Minnesota's best teams had powerful offensive lines, and new coach Jerry Kill must continue to create competition up front.
NEBRASKA
Running back: The Huskers lose standout Roy Helu Jr., and while Rex Burkhead quickly will become one of my favorite Big Ten players, he might not be an every-down back for Nebraska going forward. You always want options in the backfield, and Nebraska must continue to address its run game with the 2011 class.
Wide receiver: Nebraska loses Niles Paul and wants to identify playmakers to surround Taylor Martinez or whomever starts at quarterback. Brandon Kinnie departs after the 2011 season, and while Burkhead helps in the receiving department, Nebraska needs others to emerge.
NORTHWESTERN
Running back: Although Mike Trumpy and Adonis Smith emerged as possible answers late in the 2010 season, Northwestern needs to create real competition here. The Wildcats have lacked a dominant back during the Pat Fitzgerald era and need a dangerous rushing option to complement Dan Persa.
Defensive line: The Wildcats lose only one starter (Corbin Bryant) from the 2010 squad, but four more rotation players (Vince Browne, Jack DiNardo, Kevin Watt and Niko Mafuli) depart after 2011. Fortifying the pass rush is a major priority going forward.
A perfect 10 today: 10 items to track in Week 10 in the Big Ten.
1. JoePa goes for No. 400: The all-time coaching wins leader in major college football can reach another milestone if Penn State beats Northwestern on Saturday. Joe Paterno can join John Gagliardi and Eddie Robinson as the only college football coaches to record 400 career victories, and he can become the first man in Division I-A/FBS history to do so. This is a moment likely never to be seen again, as the 83-year-old Paterno, in his 45th year as Penn State's coach, is truly one of a kind. A win Saturday also would make Penn State bowl eligible.
2. Michigan's D tries to stop the bleeding: The Michigan Wolverines have been one-third of a team for most of the season, excelling on offense but stumbling repeatedly on both defense and special teams. Michigan's defense seemed to regress after the bye week, bringing more heat on head coach Rich Rodriguez and coordinator Greg Robinson. Rodriguez shot down talk of defensive staff changes, but he's taking on a greater role with the defense as Michigan tries to end its three-game Big Ten slide. The Wolverines on Saturday face an Illinois offense beginning to surge.
3. Endgame in West Lafayette: Two of the front-runners for Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year meet Saturday at Purdue's Ross Ade Stadium. Purdue defensive end Ryan Kerrigan has been simply unstoppable this season, cementing himself as a first-round draft pick in April with 7.5 sacks and 18.5 tackles for loss. Kerrigan leads the Big Ten in both categories, but not far behind sits Wisconsin defensive end J.J. Watt, who boasts five sacks and 13.5 tackles for loss to go along with six pass breakups, five quarterback hurries and two blocked kicks. There's plenty of mutual respect between the two stars. Kerrigan goes up against Wisconsin left tackle Gabe Carimi, another likely first-round pick.
4. Spartans rushing to rebound: Despite what he called an "embarrassing performance" at Iowa, Michigan State coach Mark Dantonio maintained that "the sky is not falling around here." He's right, too, as the Spartans still are very much alive for the Big Ten title and a possible trip to the Rose Bowl. Michigan State can get well Saturday against last-place Minnesota, and it would be well served to reignite a rushing attack that has gone cold the past three weeks. Minnesota allows a league-worst 201.8 rush yards a game and will miss starting defensive tackle Brandon Kirksey because of a suspension. Spartans backs Edwin Baker, Le'Veon Bell and Larry Caper need a big day.
5. Iowa faces trap game: Everyone in Iowa City wants to fast-forward to Nov. 20 and the Ohio State game, but the Hawkeyes first must take care of business on the road against two teams that give them trouble. Up first is Indiana, which dominated Iowa for the better part of three quarters last year and picked off Ricky Stanzi five times before the Hawkeyes rattled off 28 fourth-quarter points. Indiana beat Iowa in 2006 and 2007 and boasts a passing attack that will challenge the Hawkeyes' secondary. It's important for Iowa to keep the pedal down in Bloomington.
6. The joy of six: Three Big Ten teams -- Michigan, Illinois and Penn State -- enter Saturday's games with five victories, needing one more to become bowl eligible. One team will reach the magic number in Ann Arbor as Michigan and Illinois lock horns. The Wolverines would remove a lot of pressure by beating the Illini and virtually ensuring the end of their postseason drought. Like Michigan, Illinois hasn't been to a bowl since after the 2007 season and can continue its surprising surge with a victory. Teams like Indiana and Purdue also can inch closer to bowl eligibility with upset wins Saturday.
7. Persa back in Pennsylvania: Dan Persa was a high school star in Pennsylvania, but he barely got a sniff from Penn State in the recruiting process. He landed at Northwestern and has been the biggest reason for the Wildcats' 6-2 start. Persa, whose mother and sister went to Penn State and who grew up attending Nittany Lions games, heads back to his home state to try and spoil Paterno's 400 party. The Northwestern junior is cleared to start after suffering a concussion last week. While Persa heads home, Northwestern is at its best on the road, winning six consecutive games stretching back to last season. The Wildcats also fare well in November under coach Pat Fitzgerald, compiling a 9-4 record, including a 6-1 mark the past two seasons.
8. Scheelhaase takes aim at shorthanded secondary: Illinois quarterback Nathan Scheelhaase has put himself in the mix for Big Ten Freshman of the Year honors, and he gets another chance to shine Saturday at the Big House. Scheelhaase, who last Saturday completed 16 of 20 passes for 195 yards and four touchdowns, faces a struggling Michigan secondary that lost starting cornerback J.T. Floyd to a season-ending ankle injury this week in practice. True freshman Courtney Avery starts in Floyd's spot opposite James Rogers, the Wolverines' lone non-freshman cornerback. Illinois is a run-first offense, but don't be surprised if Scheelhaase takes to the air against the vulnerable Wolverines.
9. Penn State's quarterback situation: Freshman Rob Bolden might be Penn State's future, but sophomore Matt McGloin has been on the field at the end of back-to-back Nittany Lions victories. Bolden has fully recovered from a concussion suffered Oct. 23, and the coaches let the two quarterbacks compete for the starting job throughout practice this week. McGloin performed well in his first career start last week against Michigan, but quarterbacks coach Jay Paterno indicated after the game that Bolden still held the top job. Joe Paterno mentioned he might play both quarterbacks against Northwestern, so it'll be interesting to see how things play out.
10. Purdue turns to Robinson: Purdue expects to start its third quarterback this season as true freshman Sean Robinson gets the nod against Wisconsin. Robinson played most of the Illinois game last Saturday, completing just 7 of 20 passes for 52 yards and a touchdown. The Boilers will use Rob Henry if his throwing hand improves, but Robinson is their top option. "If he was an immature freshman, didn't have some of the same intangibles, we could be in some real trouble," coach Danny Hope said. "This guy can come over and make a commitment from a maturity standpoint to become a quarterback we can win with."
1. JoePa goes for No. 400: The all-time coaching wins leader in major college football can reach another milestone if Penn State beats Northwestern on Saturday. Joe Paterno can join John Gagliardi and Eddie Robinson as the only college football coaches to record 400 career victories, and he can become the first man in Division I-A/FBS history to do so. This is a moment likely never to be seen again, as the 83-year-old Paterno, in his 45th year as Penn State's coach, is truly one of a kind. A win Saturday also would make Penn State bowl eligible.
[+] Enlarge
AP Photo/Pat LittleJoe Paterno can reach 400 career victories by beating Northwestern on Saturday.
3. Endgame in West Lafayette: Two of the front-runners for Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year meet Saturday at Purdue's Ross Ade Stadium. Purdue defensive end Ryan Kerrigan has been simply unstoppable this season, cementing himself as a first-round draft pick in April with 7.5 sacks and 18.5 tackles for loss. Kerrigan leads the Big Ten in both categories, but not far behind sits Wisconsin defensive end J.J. Watt, who boasts five sacks and 13.5 tackles for loss to go along with six pass breakups, five quarterback hurries and two blocked kicks. There's plenty of mutual respect between the two stars. Kerrigan goes up against Wisconsin left tackle Gabe Carimi, another likely first-round pick.
4. Spartans rushing to rebound: Despite what he called an "embarrassing performance" at Iowa, Michigan State coach Mark Dantonio maintained that "the sky is not falling around here." He's right, too, as the Spartans still are very much alive for the Big Ten title and a possible trip to the Rose Bowl. Michigan State can get well Saturday against last-place Minnesota, and it would be well served to reignite a rushing attack that has gone cold the past three weeks. Minnesota allows a league-worst 201.8 rush yards a game and will miss starting defensive tackle Brandon Kirksey because of a suspension. Spartans backs Edwin Baker, Le'Veon Bell and Larry Caper need a big day.
5. Iowa faces trap game: Everyone in Iowa City wants to fast-forward to Nov. 20 and the Ohio State game, but the Hawkeyes first must take care of business on the road against two teams that give them trouble. Up first is Indiana, which dominated Iowa for the better part of three quarters last year and picked off Ricky Stanzi five times before the Hawkeyes rattled off 28 fourth-quarter points. Indiana beat Iowa in 2006 and 2007 and boasts a passing attack that will challenge the Hawkeyes' secondary. It's important for Iowa to keep the pedal down in Bloomington.
6. The joy of six: Three Big Ten teams -- Michigan, Illinois and Penn State -- enter Saturday's games with five victories, needing one more to become bowl eligible. One team will reach the magic number in Ann Arbor as Michigan and Illinois lock horns. The Wolverines would remove a lot of pressure by beating the Illini and virtually ensuring the end of their postseason drought. Like Michigan, Illinois hasn't been to a bowl since after the 2007 season and can continue its surprising surge with a victory. Teams like Indiana and Purdue also can inch closer to bowl eligibility with upset wins Saturday.
7. Persa back in Pennsylvania: Dan Persa was a high school star in Pennsylvania, but he barely got a sniff from Penn State in the recruiting process. He landed at Northwestern and has been the biggest reason for the Wildcats' 6-2 start. Persa, whose mother and sister went to Penn State and who grew up attending Nittany Lions games, heads back to his home state to try and spoil Paterno's 400 party. The Northwestern junior is cleared to start after suffering a concussion last week. While Persa heads home, Northwestern is at its best on the road, winning six consecutive games stretching back to last season. The Wildcats also fare well in November under coach Pat Fitzgerald, compiling a 9-4 record, including a 6-1 mark the past two seasons.
8. Scheelhaase takes aim at shorthanded secondary: Illinois quarterback Nathan Scheelhaase has put himself in the mix for Big Ten Freshman of the Year honors, and he gets another chance to shine Saturday at the Big House. Scheelhaase, who last Saturday completed 16 of 20 passes for 195 yards and four touchdowns, faces a struggling Michigan secondary that lost starting cornerback J.T. Floyd to a season-ending ankle injury this week in practice. True freshman Courtney Avery starts in Floyd's spot opposite James Rogers, the Wolverines' lone non-freshman cornerback. Illinois is a run-first offense, but don't be surprised if Scheelhaase takes to the air against the vulnerable Wolverines.
9. Penn State's quarterback situation: Freshman Rob Bolden might be Penn State's future, but sophomore Matt McGloin has been on the field at the end of back-to-back Nittany Lions victories. Bolden has fully recovered from a concussion suffered Oct. 23, and the coaches let the two quarterbacks compete for the starting job throughout practice this week. McGloin performed well in his first career start last week against Michigan, but quarterbacks coach Jay Paterno indicated after the game that Bolden still held the top job. Joe Paterno mentioned he might play both quarterbacks against Northwestern, so it'll be interesting to see how things play out.
10. Purdue turns to Robinson: Purdue expects to start its third quarterback this season as true freshman Sean Robinson gets the nod against Wisconsin. Robinson played most of the Illinois game last Saturday, completing just 7 of 20 passes for 52 yards and a touchdown. The Boilers will use Rob Henry if his throwing hand improves, but Robinson is their top option. "If he was an immature freshman, didn't have some of the same intangibles, we could be in some real trouble," coach Danny Hope said. "This guy can come over and make a commitment from a maturity standpoint to become a quarterback we can win with."
Big Ten teams have faced some major personnel challenges this season.
No team in America has been hit harder at key spots than Purdue, while other Big Ten squads like Wisconsin and Penn State also have lost key players.
But I can't remember a single position being ravaged more by both injuries and player departures than Michigan's cornerback spot.
The latest bit of bad news arrived Wednesday, as Wolverines coach Rich Rodriguez confirmed that cornerback J.T. Floyd will miss the rest of the season after suffering a "freak" ankle injury in practice Tuesday. Floyd's ankle isn't broken, but he suffered ligament damage and needs surgery that will keep him sidelined for a while.
The redshirt sophomore has started all eight games for Michigan and ranks third on the team in tackles with 66. Floyd also has an interception, a forced fumble and four pass breakups.
Michigan's struggles in the secondary are no secret, and this certainly doesn't make things easier.
Rodriguez said true freshman Courtney Avery will start Saturday against Illinois opposite senior James Rogers, the Wolverines' only non-freshman cornerback still available.
"We're pretty young in the secondary," Rodriguez told reporters on a conference call. "We're getting younger."
Yikes.
Remember these names?
Michigan's defense has more issues than just one position, but the Wolverines certainly would be better with some of these guys on the field right now.
Rodriguez also said Wednesday that receiver Martavious Odoms (foot) and safety Mike Williams (concussions) likely won't return this season. Running back Fitzgerald Toussaint (shoulder) will miss Saturday's game.
Not good for a team that desperately needs a win.
No team in America has been hit harder at key spots than Purdue, while other Big Ten squads like Wisconsin and Penn State also have lost key players.
But I can't remember a single position being ravaged more by both injuries and player departures than Michigan's cornerback spot.
The latest bit of bad news arrived Wednesday, as Wolverines coach Rich Rodriguez confirmed that cornerback J.T. Floyd will miss the rest of the season after suffering a "freak" ankle injury in practice Tuesday. Floyd's ankle isn't broken, but he suffered ligament damage and needs surgery that will keep him sidelined for a while.
The redshirt sophomore has started all eight games for Michigan and ranks third on the team in tackles with 66. Floyd also has an interception, a forced fumble and four pass breakups.
Michigan's struggles in the secondary are no secret, and this certainly doesn't make things easier.
Rodriguez said true freshman Courtney Avery will start Saturday against Illinois opposite senior James Rogers, the Wolverines' only non-freshman cornerback still available.
"We're pretty young in the secondary," Rodriguez told reporters on a conference call. "We're getting younger."
Yikes.
Remember these names?
- Troy Woolfolk: Multiyear starter in the secondary suffered season-ending ankle/foot injury in camp.
- Justin Turner: Decorated recruit was granted his release from the team in August.
- Vlad Emilien: Young defensive back left the team in September.
- Demar Dorsey: The Big Ten's top-rated recruit signed with Michigan in February but was denied admission in June.
- Boubacar Cissoko: Blue chip recruit started the first four games in 2009, missed two games because of a suspension, returned for a game and then was dismissed for violating team rules. Cissoko is now in jail serving time for his role in multiple robberies.
- Donovan Warren: First-team All-Big Ten selection in 2009 declared for the NFL as a junior but wasn't drafted in April.
- Adrian Witty: Signed with Michigan in 2009 but never made it to Ann Arbor because of academic issues.
Michigan's defense has more issues than just one position, but the Wolverines certainly would be better with some of these guys on the field right now.
Rodriguez also said Wednesday that receiver Martavious Odoms (foot) and safety Mike Williams (concussions) likely won't return this season. Running back Fitzgerald Toussaint (shoulder) will miss Saturday's game.
Not good for a team that desperately needs a win.
Michigan defensive end Ryan Van Bergen enjoyed the Denard Robinson Show as much as anyone.
Watching Robinson and the Wolverines offense go up and down the field last week against Connecticut also served as motivation for Van Bergen and the defense.
"Definitely feel like we're strides behind the offense in getting everything down," Van Bergen told ESPN.com this week. "We had some glimpses Saturday, and I think we'll be able to seal some things up and hopefully keep improving.
"We'll get to that level eventually."
Led by Robinson's record-setting performance, the Michigan offense overshadowed a pretty solid defensive effort against Connecticut.
The Wolverines allowed only one touchdown and held UConn scoreless in the second half. Take away a juggling 47-yard reception by Michael Smith, and Connecticut had only 296 yards in the game.
To be fair, the Huskies missed several opportunities to attack Michigan's young secondary, particularly in the first half. Connecticut had its moments, but so did Michigan's defense, none bigger than J.T. Floyd's forced fumble and Obi Ezeh's recovery near the Wolverines' goal line late in the third quarter.
"We're certainly still a work in progress, but I was really pleased to be able to limit UConn to 10 points," coach Rich Rodriguez said. "We played pretty well assignment-wise, we tackled pretty solidly. We gave up a couple big plays, but we also made a couple big plays defensively."
And the defense could have made more.
"We had two interceptions hit guys right in the hands," Van Bergen said. "There were some plays Saturday that if we sealed up, our numbers on defense would have spoken even bigger."
The challenge for Michigan's defense should get tougher Saturday at Notre Dame (NBC, 3:30 p.m. ET). Although Michigan beat the Irish last year 38-34, the defense had little to do with it.
Jimmy Clausen, Golden Tate, Michael Floyd and Armando Allen pretty much had their way with Michigan, piling up 490 yards and 27 first downs.
Clausen and Tate are gone to the NFL, but Floyd and Allen are back, along with tight end Kyle Rudolph, one of the frontrunners for the Mackey Award. They're operating in a new spread offense under first-year coach Brian Kelly, and a new quarterback, Dayne Crist, will be calling the signals.
"I would call this team significantly different," Van Bergen said. "Notre Dame did a lot more drop-back, seven-man protection for Clausen with two guys in routes. This is a bit more of a spread attack, using more receivers.
"They have a developed quick game, and it’s something we’ll have to prepare for."
Both Van Bergen and Rodriguez identified tackling as an area Michigan must improve after Week 1. With so many young players, especially in the secondary, Michigan allowed "some leaky yardage," Van Bergen said.
That can't happen against Notre Dame, which operates at a rapid pace and makes it tough to reach Crist.
"They like to up-tempo you," Rodriguez said. "They’re going to put it out in space, whether it's to their tight end or their backs or their receivers, and we've got to get them on the ground quickly. Because if not, they'll go up and down the field on you.
"We had a hard time stopping them last year, and even though it's a different scheme, this scheme may be even more difficult to stop."
One way to do it is control the line of scrimmage. Michigan failed to record a sack last week, but end-linebacker Craig Roh and others applied pressure to quarterback Zach Frazer.
Notre Dame's offensive line is supposedly better, but Michigan boasts more experience up front with Van Bergen, Mike Martin and others.
"Having our experience won't hurt us," Van Bergen said, "and their youth, they might be more inclined to get frustrated if things start not going their way. It'll be interesting to see how that develops."
[+] Enlarge
AP Photo/Tony DingDefensive end Ryan Van Bergen calls the Michigan defense "a work in progress."
"Definitely feel like we're strides behind the offense in getting everything down," Van Bergen told ESPN.com this week. "We had some glimpses Saturday, and I think we'll be able to seal some things up and hopefully keep improving.
"We'll get to that level eventually."
Led by Robinson's record-setting performance, the Michigan offense overshadowed a pretty solid defensive effort against Connecticut.
The Wolverines allowed only one touchdown and held UConn scoreless in the second half. Take away a juggling 47-yard reception by Michael Smith, and Connecticut had only 296 yards in the game.
To be fair, the Huskies missed several opportunities to attack Michigan's young secondary, particularly in the first half. Connecticut had its moments, but so did Michigan's defense, none bigger than J.T. Floyd's forced fumble and Obi Ezeh's recovery near the Wolverines' goal line late in the third quarter.
"We're certainly still a work in progress, but I was really pleased to be able to limit UConn to 10 points," coach Rich Rodriguez said. "We played pretty well assignment-wise, we tackled pretty solidly. We gave up a couple big plays, but we also made a couple big plays defensively."
And the defense could have made more.
"We had two interceptions hit guys right in the hands," Van Bergen said. "There were some plays Saturday that if we sealed up, our numbers on defense would have spoken even bigger."
The challenge for Michigan's defense should get tougher Saturday at Notre Dame (NBC, 3:30 p.m. ET). Although Michigan beat the Irish last year 38-34, the defense had little to do with it.
Jimmy Clausen, Golden Tate, Michael Floyd and Armando Allen pretty much had their way with Michigan, piling up 490 yards and 27 first downs.
Clausen and Tate are gone to the NFL, but Floyd and Allen are back, along with tight end Kyle Rudolph, one of the frontrunners for the Mackey Award. They're operating in a new spread offense under first-year coach Brian Kelly, and a new quarterback, Dayne Crist, will be calling the signals.
"I would call this team significantly different," Van Bergen said. "Notre Dame did a lot more drop-back, seven-man protection for Clausen with two guys in routes. This is a bit more of a spread attack, using more receivers.
"They have a developed quick game, and it’s something we’ll have to prepare for."
Both Van Bergen and Rodriguez identified tackling as an area Michigan must improve after Week 1. With so many young players, especially in the secondary, Michigan allowed "some leaky yardage," Van Bergen said.
That can't happen against Notre Dame, which operates at a rapid pace and makes it tough to reach Crist.
"They like to up-tempo you," Rodriguez said. "They’re going to put it out in space, whether it's to their tight end or their backs or their receivers, and we've got to get them on the ground quickly. Because if not, they'll go up and down the field on you.
"We had a hard time stopping them last year, and even though it's a different scheme, this scheme may be even more difficult to stop."
One way to do it is control the line of scrimmage. Michigan failed to record a sack last week, but end-linebacker Craig Roh and others applied pressure to quarterback Zach Frazer.
Notre Dame's offensive line is supposedly better, but Michigan boasts more experience up front with Van Bergen, Mike Martin and others.
"Having our experience won't hurt us," Van Bergen said, "and their youth, they might be more inclined to get frustrated if things start not going their way. It'll be interesting to see how that develops."
Two of college football's storied programs meet Saturday at Notre Dame Stadium, but the only thing historic about these teams are their helmets. Two spread offenses and two coaches known for their offensive creativity match wits. Both Michigan and Notre Dame recorded critical wins in their season openers, and bloggers Brian Bennett and Adam Rittenberg take a closer look at this week's matchup.
Adam Rittenberg: So, Bennett, we meet again. Good starts for both the Irish and the Wolverines on Saturday, and it should be a great one in South Bend. Let's talk offense. What do you think Knute Rockne and Fielding Yost would say about these two systems matching up?
Brian Bennett: I think both coaches would have spit in a leather helmet in disgust. What's the over/under on total number of snaps under center on Saturday? Five?
Yet, for all the talk of the spread offense, Notre Dame stuck to an old staple to beat Purdue: the running game. Running backs Armando Allen and Cierre Wood together averaged better than six yards per carry, and the Irish were happy to hand off and stick to the short passing game as the Boilermakers defense played Cover 2 and protected against the deep ball. I don't think Michigan will attack Notre Dame the same way, and the bubble wrap will have to come off quarterback Dayne Crist in Week 2.
As for the Wolverines, Denard Robinson was incredible. But I didn't see a whole lot out of the backs and receivers, and now it looks like Roy Roundtree won't play. Is Michigan a one-man offense, and can it win on Saturday that way?
AR: Good point about the Irish run game, and I think the matchup between Michigan's defensive line and Notre Dame's offensive front could decide the game. Despite the loss of Brandon Graham, Michigan boasts good experience and talent up front with Mike Martin, Greg Banks, Ryan Van Bergan and dynamic sophomore Craig Roh. They'll try to take advantage of a young Notre Dame line that, despite all the talk about weight room progress, remains unproven in my eyes.
Robinson was ridiculous against Connecticut, and you can't expect him to duplicate the performance in South Bend. Then again, the guy only needs about a foot of daylight to break through the line, and then, good luck trying to bring him down. Vincent Smith and Michael Shaw both scored touchdowns in the opener, but they'll need to be more effective out of the backfield against the Irish. Roundtree would be a big loss, but wideouts Darryl Stonum and Kelvin Grady, and tight end Kevin Koger all are good targets for Robinson, who also hooked up with Terrence Robinson for a 43-yard gain.
In many ways, Michigan won the UConn game at the line of scrimmage. How do you see the two groups matching up on Saturday?
BB: The Irish played well in the trenches against Purdue, but Michigan presents a tougher challenge. With the way Brian Kelly runs the spread, the ball is out of the quarterback's hand quickly, so that neutralizes the pass rush to some degree. The key in my mind is whether the Notre Dame line can open running lanes when the Wolverines drop men into coverage.
Defensively, the front three for Notre Dame proved stout against Purdue, and surprisingly the backups gave them a solid rotation. Ian Williams looks like a perfect fit as nose tackle in a 3-4, and Kapron Lewis-Moore and Ethan Johnson can make plays off the edge. I think the pressure is on the Irish linebackers to make plays in this game. Manti Te'o should be a stud and the perfect antidote to Robinson, but he missed a lot of tackles in Week 1. Darius Fleming is their hybrid guy, and he was stuck on the sidelines with cramps for most of the Purdue game. Once Robinson gets through the first line of defense, can the Irish contain him in the open field?
How about the Michigan pass defense? Connecticut missed some opportunities there, but the Huskies don't have guys like Michael Floyd and Kyle Rudolph at their disposal.
AR: Totally agree about Connecticut missing some major opportunities to attack downfield, especially in the first two and a half quarters. Michigan is extremely young in the secondary and likely will be down another starter, as linebacker-safety Carvin Johnson sprained his knee in the opener. Michael Floyd absolutely shredded this defense a year ago, so you can bet Notre Dame will try to get him the ball a lot on Saturday. We'll likely see a lot of Floyd vs. Floyd, as Michigan's J.T. Floyd as emerged as the team's top cornerback and forced a big fumble against UConn. Cue the Pink Floyd music.
I'm interested to see how Michigan approaches Rudolph, a matchup problem for pretty much any team he faces. Linebackers Jonas Mouton and Obi Ezeh played well in the opener, but they'll certainly be tested by No. 9. Roh brought a ton of heat against UConn, but he might have to drop back more in this game.
OK, Bennett, you're on the spot. Your Michigan-UConn pick didn't work out so great, and some of my new friends in Ann Arbor were calling you nasty names Friday night. Who wins Saturday and what's the biggest key to the game?
BB: Well, I'm happy to play the villain in Ann Arbor as long as they still let me in the bars there. I have little doubt this will be a close game, possibly as exciting as last year's shootout. Notre Dame will have its hands full with Robinson, but I think the Irish have a more well-rounded offensive attack. And they will take advantage of that young secondary while making just enough plays of their own defensively. A special-teams play might be the difference. Brian Kelly gets his first big win as the Irish squeak by.
Now tell me why I'm wrong.
AR: You're always welcome in Ann Arbor. Just tell them you know me.
It'll definitely be a close game, and like last year, we should have a dramatic finish. Michigan's young secondary concerns me, and Crist will make plays downfield to both Floyd and Rudolph. But I also have my doubts about Notre Dame's line play and the overall toughness of that team. Robinson is certainly the X-factor here, and while Michigan can't run him 29 times again, he'll make some big plays. If special teams makes the difference, Michigan could be in trouble. Notre Dame jumps ahead, but D-Rob leads the Wolverines back in the fourth quarter for a narrow win and continues to grow his legend in Ann Arbor.
Adam Rittenberg: So, Bennett, we meet again. Good starts for both the Irish and the Wolverines on Saturday, and it should be a great one in South Bend. Let's talk offense. What do you think Knute Rockne and Fielding Yost would say about these two systems matching up?
[+] Enlarge
Matt Cashore/US PresswireArmando Allen gained 93 yards on 18 carries and scored a TD against Purdue.
Yet, for all the talk of the spread offense, Notre Dame stuck to an old staple to beat Purdue: the running game. Running backs Armando Allen and Cierre Wood together averaged better than six yards per carry, and the Irish were happy to hand off and stick to the short passing game as the Boilermakers defense played Cover 2 and protected against the deep ball. I don't think Michigan will attack Notre Dame the same way, and the bubble wrap will have to come off quarterback Dayne Crist in Week 2.
As for the Wolverines, Denard Robinson was incredible. But I didn't see a whole lot out of the backs and receivers, and now it looks like Roy Roundtree won't play. Is Michigan a one-man offense, and can it win on Saturday that way?
AR: Good point about the Irish run game, and I think the matchup between Michigan's defensive line and Notre Dame's offensive front could decide the game. Despite the loss of Brandon Graham, Michigan boasts good experience and talent up front with Mike Martin, Greg Banks, Ryan Van Bergan and dynamic sophomore Craig Roh. They'll try to take advantage of a young Notre Dame line that, despite all the talk about weight room progress, remains unproven in my eyes.
Robinson was ridiculous against Connecticut, and you can't expect him to duplicate the performance in South Bend. Then again, the guy only needs about a foot of daylight to break through the line, and then, good luck trying to bring him down. Vincent Smith and Michael Shaw both scored touchdowns in the opener, but they'll need to be more effective out of the backfield against the Irish. Roundtree would be a big loss, but wideouts Darryl Stonum and Kelvin Grady, and tight end Kevin Koger all are good targets for Robinson, who also hooked up with Terrence Robinson for a 43-yard gain.
In many ways, Michigan won the UConn game at the line of scrimmage. How do you see the two groups matching up on Saturday?
BB: The Irish played well in the trenches against Purdue, but Michigan presents a tougher challenge. With the way Brian Kelly runs the spread, the ball is out of the quarterback's hand quickly, so that neutralizes the pass rush to some degree. The key in my mind is whether the Notre Dame line can open running lanes when the Wolverines drop men into coverage.
Defensively, the front three for Notre Dame proved stout against Purdue, and surprisingly the backups gave them a solid rotation. Ian Williams looks like a perfect fit as nose tackle in a 3-4, and Kapron Lewis-Moore and Ethan Johnson can make plays off the edge. I think the pressure is on the Irish linebackers to make plays in this game. Manti Te'o should be a stud and the perfect antidote to Robinson, but he missed a lot of tackles in Week 1. Darius Fleming is their hybrid guy, and he was stuck on the sidelines with cramps for most of the Purdue game. Once Robinson gets through the first line of defense, can the Irish contain him in the open field?
How about the Michigan pass defense? Connecticut missed some opportunities there, but the Huskies don't have guys like Michael Floyd and Kyle Rudolph at their disposal.
AR: Totally agree about Connecticut missing some major opportunities to attack downfield, especially in the first two and a half quarters. Michigan is extremely young in the secondary and likely will be down another starter, as linebacker-safety Carvin Johnson sprained his knee in the opener. Michael Floyd absolutely shredded this defense a year ago, so you can bet Notre Dame will try to get him the ball a lot on Saturday. We'll likely see a lot of Floyd vs. Floyd, as Michigan's J.T. Floyd as emerged as the team's top cornerback and forced a big fumble against UConn. Cue the Pink Floyd music.
I'm interested to see how Michigan approaches Rudolph, a matchup problem for pretty much any team he faces. Linebackers Jonas Mouton and Obi Ezeh played well in the opener, but they'll certainly be tested by No. 9. Roh brought a ton of heat against UConn, but he might have to drop back more in this game.
OK, Bennett, you're on the spot. Your Michigan-UConn pick didn't work out so great, and some of my new friends in Ann Arbor were calling you nasty names Friday night. Who wins Saturday and what's the biggest key to the game?
BB: Well, I'm happy to play the villain in Ann Arbor as long as they still let me in the bars there. I have little doubt this will be a close game, possibly as exciting as last year's shootout. Notre Dame will have its hands full with Robinson, but I think the Irish have a more well-rounded offensive attack. And they will take advantage of that young secondary while making just enough plays of their own defensively. A special-teams play might be the difference. Brian Kelly gets his first big win as the Irish squeak by.
Now tell me why I'm wrong.
AR: You're always welcome in Ann Arbor. Just tell them you know me.
It'll definitely be a close game, and like last year, we should have a dramatic finish. Michigan's young secondary concerns me, and Crist will make plays downfield to both Floyd and Rudolph. But I also have my doubts about Notre Dame's line play and the overall toughness of that team. Robinson is certainly the X-factor here, and while Michigan can't run him 29 times again, he'll make some big plays. If special teams makes the difference, Michigan could be in trouble. Notre Dame jumps ahead, but D-Rob leads the Wolverines back in the fourth quarter for a narrow win and continues to grow his legend in Ann Arbor.
ANN ARBOR, Mich. -- Michigan defenders J.T. Floyd and Craig Roh can empathize with their counterparts from Connecticut.
"He's a crazy animal to tame," Floyd said.
"What you saw happening out there," added Roh, "is what was happening all of practice to us."
After having Denard Robinson make them look bad for the past seven months, Floyd and Roh got to sit back and watch another defense get humiliated. Needless to say, they enjoyed the view.
So did a record crowd of 113,090 at the rededicated Michigan Stadium, as Robinson delivered a historic performance in his first career start, lifting Michigan to a 30-10 victory against UConn. Robinson shattered Michigan's single-game quarterback rushing record with 197 yards and a touchdown, surpassing Steve Smith's mark midway through the third quarter.
More surprising is what Robinson did with his arm, considered useless by some after he completed only 45.2 percent of his passes as a true freshman in 2009. He completed his first eight pass attempts and finished the game 19-for-22 for 186 yards and a touchdown.
Robinson completed 14 passes all of last season.
"I knew I always could throw the ball, it was never a question," Robinson said. "It was just getting the offense down pat."
He appeared to master coach Rich Rodriguez's spread system on Saturday.
How tough was it to stop Robinson? Connecticut defenders tried just about everything, even stealing his cleats.
"They were like, 'Take his shoe, take his shoe,'" said Robinson, nicknamed "Shoelace" for famously leaving his footwear untied at all times.
"They took them off on one of the plays," he added.
It didn't matter. Robinson could wreak havoc barefoot if he wanted to.
Rodriguez waited until Friday night to gather his three quarterbacks and inform Robinson that he'd start the opener. Rodriguez let Robinson, freshman Devin Gardner and last year's starter, Tate Forcier, take reps with the first-team offense throughout camp.
But it would have been a surprise to many, including center David Molk, if anyone but Robinson had taken the first snap on Saturday.
"Most of the guys knew," Rodriguez said. "I don't think it was a big secret. Denard was taking a lot of reps with the [starters]. ... Denard certainly had asserted himself in camp more than anyone else."
Robinson always has had the big-play skills. His first career touch as a college player resulted in an electrifying 43-yard touchdown run, on a broken play, no less.
But until Saturday, he hadn't shown the ability to consistently move an offense. Consider four of the five scoring drives he engineered against Connecticut.
Robinson finished the game with 29 carries and absorbed several big hits, including a helmet to his left hip that left him sprawled on the field. Running back Vincent Smith wasn't worried.
"He always gets up," Smith said. "Very tough."
Robinson missed a total of two plays.
As Robinson's carries total rose, Michigan quarterbacks coach Rod Smith turned to offensive coordinator Calvin Magee.
"We were like, 'We've got to be careful here,'" Smith said. "But Denard, he didn't back down. He said, 'Coach, give it to me.'"
Rodriguez didn't realize Robinson had 29 carries until looking at the postgame stat sheet. Was it too much?
"If he can carry it 29 times for 200 yards, he'll carry it 29 times for 200 yards," Rodriguez said. "I don't know if he can do that each and every game."
In the past, Michigan might not have had a choice, as Robinson was a totally one-dimensional player as a freshman. Not only did he struggle with his accuracy, but he threw four interceptions in only 31 attempts.
Third-and-long used to mean punt or turnover. On Saturday, it meant opportunity.
After Connecticut had reclaimed momentum just before halftime, Robinson converted five third downs on a 19-play drive that set up a field goal.
Two plays after returning from the hip injury, Robinson pump-faked and then hit a wide-open Terrence Robinson in stride for a 42-yard gain, setting up another touchdown.
Asked to describe the play, Denard Robinson, for the first time all day, looked confused.
"It was, uh, I can't tell you," he said.
After leaving the podium, Robinson greeted Rodriguez, telling him, "They were trying to take one of our plays, coach."
The way Robinson looked Saturday, Rodriguez could have handed Connecticut coach Randy Edsall the playbook.
"There were probably more times he should have went down the field," Rodriguez said. "But we were able to control the game from a running standpoint."
Things get tougher next week, as Robinson hits the road to face a Notre Dame team that contained Robert Marve and Purdue on Saturday.
"He did what he had to do," Rod Smith said. "We gave him the reins, he took it and ran with it. Basically, now it's going to be his to run with for a while."
Robinson didn't sound so sure after the game.
"We probably don't know who's going to start next week," he said. "We'll see."
Riiight.
Informed of Robinson's comment, Rodriguez smiled.
"Stay tuned."
"He's a crazy animal to tame," Floyd said.
"What you saw happening out there," added Roh, "is what was happening all of practice to us."
After having Denard Robinson make them look bad for the past seven months, Floyd and Roh got to sit back and watch another defense get humiliated. Needless to say, they enjoyed the view.
[+] Enlarge
AP Photo/Tony DingDenard Robinson rushed 29 times for 197 yards and a touchdown and completed 19 of 22 passes for 186 yards and a score against Connecticut.
More surprising is what Robinson did with his arm, considered useless by some after he completed only 45.2 percent of his passes as a true freshman in 2009. He completed his first eight pass attempts and finished the game 19-for-22 for 186 yards and a touchdown.
Robinson completed 14 passes all of last season.
"I knew I always could throw the ball, it was never a question," Robinson said. "It was just getting the offense down pat."
He appeared to master coach Rich Rodriguez's spread system on Saturday.
How tough was it to stop Robinson? Connecticut defenders tried just about everything, even stealing his cleats.
"They were like, 'Take his shoe, take his shoe,'" said Robinson, nicknamed "Shoelace" for famously leaving his footwear untied at all times.
"They took them off on one of the plays," he added.
It didn't matter. Robinson could wreak havoc barefoot if he wanted to.
Rodriguez waited until Friday night to gather his three quarterbacks and inform Robinson that he'd start the opener. Rodriguez let Robinson, freshman Devin Gardner and last year's starter, Tate Forcier, take reps with the first-team offense throughout camp.
But it would have been a surprise to many, including center David Molk, if anyone but Robinson had taken the first snap on Saturday.
"Most of the guys knew," Rodriguez said. "I don't think it was a big secret. Denard was taking a lot of reps with the [starters]. ... Denard certainly had asserted himself in camp more than anyone else."
Robinson always has had the big-play skills. His first career touch as a college player resulted in an electrifying 43-yard touchdown run, on a broken play, no less.
But until Saturday, he hadn't shown the ability to consistently move an offense. Consider four of the five scoring drives he engineered against Connecticut.
- 14 plays, 96 yards, six runs by Robinson
- 7 plays, 77 yards, three runs by Robinson (capped by 32-yard touchdown)
- 19 plays, 74 yards, six runs by Robinson
- 11 plays, 89 yards, three runs by Robinson
Robinson finished the game with 29 carries and absorbed several big hits, including a helmet to his left hip that left him sprawled on the field. Running back Vincent Smith wasn't worried.
"He always gets up," Smith said. "Very tough."
Robinson missed a total of two plays.
As Robinson's carries total rose, Michigan quarterbacks coach Rod Smith turned to offensive coordinator Calvin Magee.
"We were like, 'We've got to be careful here,'" Smith said. "But Denard, he didn't back down. He said, 'Coach, give it to me.'"
Rodriguez didn't realize Robinson had 29 carries until looking at the postgame stat sheet. Was it too much?
"If he can carry it 29 times for 200 yards, he'll carry it 29 times for 200 yards," Rodriguez said. "I don't know if he can do that each and every game."
In the past, Michigan might not have had a choice, as Robinson was a totally one-dimensional player as a freshman. Not only did he struggle with his accuracy, but he threw four interceptions in only 31 attempts.
Third-and-long used to mean punt or turnover. On Saturday, it meant opportunity.
After Connecticut had reclaimed momentum just before halftime, Robinson converted five third downs on a 19-play drive that set up a field goal.
Two plays after returning from the hip injury, Robinson pump-faked and then hit a wide-open Terrence Robinson in stride for a 42-yard gain, setting up another touchdown.
Asked to describe the play, Denard Robinson, for the first time all day, looked confused.
"It was, uh, I can't tell you," he said.
After leaving the podium, Robinson greeted Rodriguez, telling him, "They were trying to take one of our plays, coach."
The way Robinson looked Saturday, Rodriguez could have handed Connecticut coach Randy Edsall the playbook.
"There were probably more times he should have went down the field," Rodriguez said. "But we were able to control the game from a running standpoint."
Things get tougher next week, as Robinson hits the road to face a Notre Dame team that contained Robert Marve and Purdue on Saturday.
"He did what he had to do," Rod Smith said. "We gave him the reins, he took it and ran with it. Basically, now it's going to be his to run with for a while."
Robinson didn't sound so sure after the game.
"We probably don't know who's going to start next week," he said. "We'll see."
Riiight.
Informed of Robinson's comment, Rodriguez smiled.
"Stay tuned."
Instant analysis: Michigan 30, Connecticut 10
September, 4, 2010
Sep 4
6:44
PM ET
ANN ARBOR, Mich. -- Denard Robinson, your table is ready.
Robinson was nothing short of brilliant in his first career start, complementing his track-star speed with shocking accuracy in the passing game. He set the Michigan single-game quarterback rushing record in the third quarter and made several clutch throws on third downs to seal a 30-10 win against Connecticut.
This is how Rich Rodriguez's offense is supposed to work, with a trigger man that drives defenses nuts. Can Robinson replicate this against superior competition, beginning next week at Notre Dame? We'll find out, but he's certainly fun to watch.
Michigan's defense still has some issues, but it applied steady pressure on Zach Frazer and made several big plays, none bigger than J.T. Floyd's forced fumble against USC transfer D.J. Shoemate after Connecticut appeared to be set up for first-and-goal. Better quarterbacks likely will capitalize on the Wolverines' secondary in the coming weeks, but Rodriguez has to be pleased with the front seven.
The Wolverines really seemed to feed off the momentum from the opener, jumping on Connecticut and never truly looking back.
I'm heading down for interviews but will be back with much more from the Big House.
Robinson was nothing short of brilliant in his first career start, complementing his track-star speed with shocking accuracy in the passing game. He set the Michigan single-game quarterback rushing record in the third quarter and made several clutch throws on third downs to seal a 30-10 win against Connecticut.
This is how Rich Rodriguez's offense is supposed to work, with a trigger man that drives defenses nuts. Can Robinson replicate this against superior competition, beginning next week at Notre Dame? We'll find out, but he's certainly fun to watch.
Michigan's defense still has some issues, but it applied steady pressure on Zach Frazer and made several big plays, none bigger than J.T. Floyd's forced fumble against USC transfer D.J. Shoemate after Connecticut appeared to be set up for first-and-goal. Better quarterbacks likely will capitalize on the Wolverines' secondary in the coming weeks, but Rodriguez has to be pleased with the front seven.
The Wolverines really seemed to feed off the momentum from the opener, jumping on Connecticut and never truly looking back.
I'm heading down for interviews but will be back with much more from the Big House.
ANN ARBOR, Mich. -- Denard Robinson completed 45.2 percent of his passes last season.
The stat is worth repeating after what Robinson has done to Connecticut's secondary today. He entered the game with major questions about his passing ability, and has answered them emphatically. Robinson is 17 of 19 passing for 172 yards as Michigan leads UConn 30-10 with 11 minutes to go.
Sure, you'll see Robinson's running ability on the highlights later today and Sunday. But his passing skills, especially in the second half, have proven to be the difference in a likely Michigan win.
Robinson led another long touchdown drive -- 11 plays, 89 yards -- and completed several big throws, including a 38-yarder to Terrence Robinson after an excellent pump fake. On third-and-6 from the Connecticut 11, Rich Rodriguez made a perfect call on a Huskies blitz and Robinson flipped the ball to Vincent Smith for an easy touchdown. Robinson doesn't resemble the passer we saw last season, both with his accuracy and his decision-making.
Michigan's defense still has some issues with tackling and spacing, but the J.T. Floyd forced fumble near the goal line is looming large.
The stat is worth repeating after what Robinson has done to Connecticut's secondary today. He entered the game with major questions about his passing ability, and has answered them emphatically. Robinson is 17 of 19 passing for 172 yards as Michigan leads UConn 30-10 with 11 minutes to go.
Sure, you'll see Robinson's running ability on the highlights later today and Sunday. But his passing skills, especially in the second half, have proven to be the difference in a likely Michigan win.
Robinson led another long touchdown drive -- 11 plays, 89 yards -- and completed several big throws, including a 38-yarder to Terrence Robinson after an excellent pump fake. On third-and-6 from the Connecticut 11, Rich Rodriguez made a perfect call on a Huskies blitz and Robinson flipped the ball to Vincent Smith for an easy touchdown. Robinson doesn't resemble the passer we saw last season, both with his accuracy and his decision-making.
Michigan's defense still has some issues with tackling and spacing, but the J.T. Floyd forced fumble near the goal line is looming large.
Welcome to National Depth Chart Day. No day on the college football calendar inspires more curiosity about depth charts than the Monday before the season, when most teams release their Week 1 two-deeps.
(And then there's Purdue, which didn't include a depth chart in its game notes for Notre Dame. Ugh.)
I've had the chance to review depth charts from those programs that released them today -- two-deeps from Illinois, Michigan State and Minnesota are coming soon -- and I checked in on several coaches' news conferences.
Here's what stood out:
INDIANA
IOWA
MICHIGAN
NORTHWESTERN
OHIO STATE
PENN STATE
WISCONSIN
(And then there's Purdue, which didn't include a depth chart in its game notes for Notre Dame. Ugh.)
I've had the chance to review depth charts from those programs that released them today -- two-deeps from Illinois, Michigan State and Minnesota are coming soon -- and I checked in on several coaches' news conferences.
Here's what stood out:
INDIANA
- Even though Indiana will shift to a 3-4 defensive alignment this year, the depth chart lists a 4-3 with Darius Johnson and Fred Jones as the starting ends and Chad Sherer and Tyler Replogle flanking junior college transfer Jeff Thomas at linebacker.
- Interesting to see several veteran offensive linemen like Justin Pagan and Cody Faulkner listed as backups rather than starters. Junior Andrew McDonald steps into some big shoes at left tackle as Rodger Saffold departs to the NFL.
- The backup quarterback job remains open, as Dusty Kiel and Edward Wright-Baker are both listed as No. 2 behind Ben Chappell.
- Indiana expects big things from redshirt freshman Duwyce Wilson, listed as a starter at wide receiver, kick returner and punt returner.
IOWA
- Sophomores Micah Hyde and Greg Castillo are listed as the starting cornerbacks. Shaun Prater doesn't appear on the depth chart after dealing with a leg injury in camp. Prater hasn't been officially ruled out for the Eastern Illinois game, but I wouldn't expect to see much of him on Saturday.
- James Ferentz is listed as the starting center, a spot where Iowa might be a little thin following Josh Koeppel's motorcycle accident Monday morning.
- Starting defensive end Broderick Binns is suspended for the opener, so Christian Ballard is listed as a possible starter at both end and tackle. Mike Daniels and Lebron Daniel are the next options behind Ballard.
MICHIGAN
- Sophomores Denard Robinson and Tate Forcier and freshman Devin Gardner are listed as co-starters at quarterback. Head coach Rich Rodriguez reiterated Monday that Gardner won't redshirt this fall.
- Vincent Smith and Michael Shaw are listed as co-starters at running back, with Michael Cox behind them.
- True freshman Carvin Johnson is listed as the starter at the spur position (safety/linebacker). Pretty big surprise here, and a testament to Johnson's work in camp.
- Senior James Rogers steps into Troy Woolfolk's starting cornerback spot opposite J.T. Floyd.
- Receivers Martavious Odoms and Kelvin Grady clearly showed enough in camp to be listed as starters or possible starters against Connecticut.
NORTHWESTERN
- Sophomore running back Arby Fields returned to practice Monday and wore a no-contact jersey after being sidelined with a shoulder problem. He's listed as a co-starter at running back with Jacob Schmidt and Stephen Simmons. Northwestern wanted a clear No. 1 running back to emerge in camp, but Fields' injury changed the plan.
- Junior Bryce McNaul is listed as the third top linebacker alongside returning starters Quentin Davie and Nate Williams. McNaul won the job in camp.
- Venric Mark is the only true freshman listed on the depth chart, both as a backup wide receiver and a co-starter at punt returner. I'll go out on a huge limb (sarcasm) and predict Mark will be the man on returns for the Wildcats very shortly.
OHIO STATE
- Junior defensive end Nathan Williams, a projected starter, will miss the Marshall game with a knee injury. He should be back shortly thereafter. Solomon Thomas will start in Williams' spot Thursday night.
- Starting cornerback Chimdi Chekwa (hamstring) is questionable for the Marshall game, but corner Devon Torrence (hamstring) should be fine.
- Sophomore C.J. Barnett's strong performance in camp lifted him ahead of Orhian Johnson on the Week 1 depth chart. Johnson missed a chunk of camp with an injury.
- Start salivating, Buckeyes fans, because running backs Jordan Hall and Jaamal Berry likely will handle kickoff returns against Marshall.
PENN STATE
- Sophomores Kevin Newsome and Matt McGloin and freshman Robert Bolden are listed as co-starters at quarterback for the Youngstown State game.
- Sophomore Devon Smith's strong camp landed him a starting spot at both receiver and kick returner, and a backup role on punt returns.
- Redshirt freshman Garry Gilliam is listed as the starting tight end, as Andrew Szczerba likely will miss the opener with a back injury. Penn State obviously is thin here after losing Andrew Quarless and Mickey Shuler.
- Veterans Nate Stupar, Chris Colasanti and Bani Gbadyu are listed as the starting linebackers, with promising younger players like Michael Mauti and Gerald Hodges right behind them.
WISCONSIN
- After a very impressive camp, freshman running back James White appears at No. 3 on the depth chart behind both John Clay and Montee Ball. White also is the No. 2 punt returner behind David Gilreath. His emergence likely will result in veteran Zach Brown redshirting the season.
- Senior Blake Sorensen likely will start at outside linebacker, as Mike Taylor continues to rehab after undergoing a second procedure on his knee in camp. Culmer St. Jean and Chris Borland are listed as the other starting linebackers.
- The starting cornerback spots remain open, as Niles Brinkley, Antonio Fenelus and Devin Smith will compete in practice this week.
In all likelihood, J.T. Turner wasn't going to start for Michigan in its Sept. 4 opener.
From everything I've been told, J.T. Floyd will join veteran Troy Woolfolk as the Wolverines' starting cornerbacks against Connecticut. But Turner's decision to transfer combined with Michigan's decision not to admit prized recruit Demar Dorsey raises the anxiety level about a secondary that already sparks a ton of concern after the past two seasons.
Michigan has had little trouble luring heralded cornerbacks, namely Turner, Dorsey and Boubacar Cissoko. But for various reasons -- I'm not directly blaming anyone here -- none of them will be suiting up for the Maize and Blue this fall.
The Wolverines' depth at cornerback isn't what we thought it would be a few months ago.
Woolfolk and Floyd not only need to be good, but they need to stay healthy. And you can bet incoming freshmen Cullen Christian, Courtney Avery and Terry Talbott will have chances to see the field early.
From everything I've been told, J.T. Floyd will join veteran Troy Woolfolk as the Wolverines' starting cornerbacks against Connecticut. But Turner's decision to transfer combined with Michigan's decision not to admit prized recruit Demar Dorsey raises the anxiety level about a secondary that already sparks a ton of concern after the past two seasons.
Michigan has had little trouble luring heralded cornerbacks, namely Turner, Dorsey and Boubacar Cissoko. But for various reasons -- I'm not directly blaming anyone here -- none of them will be suiting up for the Maize and Blue this fall.
The Wolverines' depth at cornerback isn't what we thought it would be a few months ago.
Woolfolk and Floyd not only need to be good, but they need to stay healthy. And you can bet incoming freshmen Cullen Christian, Courtney Avery and Terry Talbott will have chances to see the field early.
Schedule: Rich Rodriguez and the Wolverines are on the field right now in Ann Arbor for their first preseason practice.
What's new: After losing linebackers coach Jay Hopson to Memphis, Rodriguez promoted Adam Braithwaite to safeties and outside linebackers coach. He also added special teams to the plate of secondary coach Tony Gibson, who will continue to work with free safeties and cornerbacks. Defensive coordinator Greg Robinson will work with the linebackers. There was a lot of talk this spring about the 3-3-5 defensive alignment, as Michigan must replace standouts Brandon Graham and Donovan Warren.
Sidelined: Defensive lineman Will Heininger (knee) is the only player out because of injury, and he might not play this season. Running back Vincent Smith is expected to be 100 percent for camp after undergoing offseason knee surgery. Running back Mike Shaw appears on the team's 2010 roster, although he had some eligibility issues to clear up with summer school.
Key battle: You might have heard, but Michigan's quarterback spot is undecided and Tate Forcier and Denard Robinson resume the competition today. The Wolverines also need to identify a featured running back or two, and Smith, Shaw, Michael Cox and Fitzgerald Toussaint are in the mix. Kenny Demens will push Obi Ezeh at middle linebacker, and J.T. Floyd looks to cement himself as a starting cornerback opposite Troy Woolfolk. Both kick specialist jobs also are up for grabs.
New on the scene: Michigan still needs its freshmen to play, especially on defense. Look out for defensive back Cullen Christian, defensive lineman Richard Ash and linebacker Marvin Robinson, among others. In a perfect world, Michigan could redshirt quarterback Devin Gardner, but if he's the best option, Rodriguez won't hesitate to play the freshman.
Back in the fold: Center David Molk was Michigan's best offensive lineman before knee problems cut short his 2009 season. After a strong offseason, Molk will boost a line that has enough talent and depth to be the team's biggest strength this fall. Receiver Junior Hemingway, who had a strong start last fall before being sidelined by mononucleosis, also returns to the mix.
Breaking out: If Denard Robinson builds on his spring performance, he could be the difference maker for Michigan's offense this fall. Receiver Roy Roundtree could be on the verge of bigger things after leading the team in receptions (32), receiving yards (434) and receiving touchdowns (3) last year. Hopes are high for defensive end/linebacker Craig Roh, who recorded 7.5 tackles for loss as a true freshman in 2009. Safety Cam Gordon was the star of spring practice and could be poised for a big year.
Quotable: "There's a lot of hungry football players up in Ann Arbor, and I think they're as excited as I am to get going. We have some questions, certainly, on both sides of the ball." -- head coach Rich Rodriguez
What's new: After losing linebackers coach Jay Hopson to Memphis, Rodriguez promoted Adam Braithwaite to safeties and outside linebackers coach. He also added special teams to the plate of secondary coach Tony Gibson, who will continue to work with free safeties and cornerbacks. Defensive coordinator Greg Robinson will work with the linebackers. There was a lot of talk this spring about the 3-3-5 defensive alignment, as Michigan must replace standouts Brandon Graham and Donovan Warren.
Sidelined: Defensive lineman Will Heininger (knee) is the only player out because of injury, and he might not play this season. Running back Vincent Smith is expected to be 100 percent for camp after undergoing offseason knee surgery. Running back Mike Shaw appears on the team's 2010 roster, although he had some eligibility issues to clear up with summer school.
Key battle: You might have heard, but Michigan's quarterback spot is undecided and Tate Forcier and Denard Robinson resume the competition today. The Wolverines also need to identify a featured running back or two, and Smith, Shaw, Michael Cox and Fitzgerald Toussaint are in the mix. Kenny Demens will push Obi Ezeh at middle linebacker, and J.T. Floyd looks to cement himself as a starting cornerback opposite Troy Woolfolk. Both kick specialist jobs also are up for grabs.
New on the scene: Michigan still needs its freshmen to play, especially on defense. Look out for defensive back Cullen Christian, defensive lineman Richard Ash and linebacker Marvin Robinson, among others. In a perfect world, Michigan could redshirt quarterback Devin Gardner, but if he's the best option, Rodriguez won't hesitate to play the freshman.
Back in the fold: Center David Molk was Michigan's best offensive lineman before knee problems cut short his 2009 season. After a strong offseason, Molk will boost a line that has enough talent and depth to be the team's biggest strength this fall. Receiver Junior Hemingway, who had a strong start last fall before being sidelined by mononucleosis, also returns to the mix.
Breaking out: If Denard Robinson builds on his spring performance, he could be the difference maker for Michigan's offense this fall. Receiver Roy Roundtree could be on the verge of bigger things after leading the team in receptions (32), receiving yards (434) and receiving touchdowns (3) last year. Hopes are high for defensive end/linebacker Craig Roh, who recorded 7.5 tackles for loss as a true freshman in 2009. Safety Cam Gordon was the star of spring practice and could be poised for a big year.
Quotable: "There's a lot of hungry football players up in Ann Arbor, and I think they're as excited as I am to get going. We have some questions, certainly, on both sides of the ball." -- head coach Rich Rodriguez
After taking a look Thursday at Big Ten offenses in need of repair, let's switch the focus to the defensive side. I think some of you misunderstood the selections. These are units that struggled in 2009 and need to get better this fall, not good units that lost a few key pieces from last year (i.e. Penn State's defense, Iowa's defense).
Here we go ...
IN NEED OF REPAIR
1. Indiana: Defense repeatedly has been the big problem in Bloomington, and last season was no exception. Indiana finished 10th in the league in both points allowed (29.5 ppg) and yards allowed (401 ypg). What's scary is that the Hoosiers lose three starters in the secondary and several extremely productive front-seven players in end Jammie Kirlew and linebacker Matt Mayberry.
2. Michigan: The Wolverines fell victim to a series of major defensive breakdowns in 2009, particularly during Big Ten play. They lose their top two defenders in end Brandon Graham and cornerback Donovan Warren, and still lack the type of scholarship numbers they need on that side of the ball. Michigan finished last in the Big Ten in scoring defense, total defense and rushing defense during conference games last fall.
3. Illinois: Ron Zook's offensive staff paid the heaviest price for last season's shortcoming, but the struggles on defense weren't excused, either. Illinois couldn't stop anyone during nonconference play and finished last in the Big Ten in both scoring defense (30.2 ppg) and total defense (403.2 ypg) last season (all games). Injuries and a lack of depth at key spots doomed the Illini, and Zook demoted both his defensive coordinators following the season.
FASTEST ROAD TO RECOVERY
1. Illinois: Vic Koenning was a very good hire as defensive coordinator, and he has ramped up the level of accountability for an underachieving unit. Illinois has some good pieces in linemen Corey Liuget and Clay Nurse, linebacker Ian Thomas and cornerbacks Tavon Wilson and Terry Hawthorne. If linebacker Martez Wilson stays healthy and can be a leader, Illinois could turn things around this fall.
2. Indiana: The Hoosiers coaches like their young players and incoming juco transfers, but history isn't on their side. Indiana hasn't fielded a defense ranked in the top half of the FBS for more than a decade, and the unit loses a lot of production in the front seven. Perhaps a switch to the 3-4 alignment will spark the Hoosiers, but they need to build depth, especially in the secondary.
3. Michigan: We heard quite a bit about promising young defenders this spring, guys like Cameron Gordon and J.T. Floyd who could spark the defense. But the spring game didn't ease many concerns about the group, and Michigan coaches admit they'll be relying on incoming freshmen like cornerback Demar Dorsey for a boost this fall. The talent certainly is there, but the questions will linger until after the season kicks off.
Here we go ...
IN NEED OF REPAIR
1. Indiana: Defense repeatedly has been the big problem in Bloomington, and last season was no exception. Indiana finished 10th in the league in both points allowed (29.5 ppg) and yards allowed (401 ypg). What's scary is that the Hoosiers lose three starters in the secondary and several extremely productive front-seven players in end Jammie Kirlew and linebacker Matt Mayberry.
2. Michigan: The Wolverines fell victim to a series of major defensive breakdowns in 2009, particularly during Big Ten play. They lose their top two defenders in end Brandon Graham and cornerback Donovan Warren, and still lack the type of scholarship numbers they need on that side of the ball. Michigan finished last in the Big Ten in scoring defense, total defense and rushing defense during conference games last fall.
3. Illinois: Ron Zook's offensive staff paid the heaviest price for last season's shortcoming, but the struggles on defense weren't excused, either. Illinois couldn't stop anyone during nonconference play and finished last in the Big Ten in both scoring defense (30.2 ppg) and total defense (403.2 ypg) last season (all games). Injuries and a lack of depth at key spots doomed the Illini, and Zook demoted both his defensive coordinators following the season.
FASTEST ROAD TO RECOVERY
1. Illinois: Vic Koenning was a very good hire as defensive coordinator, and he has ramped up the level of accountability for an underachieving unit. Illinois has some good pieces in linemen Corey Liuget and Clay Nurse, linebacker Ian Thomas and cornerbacks Tavon Wilson and Terry Hawthorne. If linebacker Martez Wilson stays healthy and can be a leader, Illinois could turn things around this fall.
2. Indiana: The Hoosiers coaches like their young players and incoming juco transfers, but history isn't on their side. Indiana hasn't fielded a defense ranked in the top half of the FBS for more than a decade, and the unit loses a lot of production in the front seven. Perhaps a switch to the 3-4 alignment will spark the Hoosiers, but they need to build depth, especially in the secondary.
3. Michigan: We heard quite a bit about promising young defenders this spring, guys like Cameron Gordon and J.T. Floyd who could spark the defense. But the spring game didn't ease many concerns about the group, and Michigan coaches admit they'll be relying on incoming freshmen like cornerback Demar Dorsey for a boost this fall. The talent certainly is there, but the questions will linger until after the season kicks off.
2009 overall record: 5-7
2009 conference record: 1-7 (T-10th)
Returning starters
Offense: 7, defense: 8, kicker/punter: 0
Top returners
QB Tate Forcier, QB Denard Robinson, WR Roy Roundtree, C David Molk, LG Stephen Schilling, CB Troy Woolfolk, LB/DE Craig Roh, NT Mike Martin
Key losses
RB Carlos Brown, RB Brandon Minor, C/G David Moosman, DE Brandon Graham, CB Donovan Warren, LB/S Stevie Brown, P Zoltan Mesko
2009 statistical leaders (*-returners)
Rushing: Brandon Minor (502 yards)
Passing: Forcier* (2,050 yards)
Receiving: Roundtree* (434 yards)
Tackles: Stevie Brown (80)
Sacks: Brandon Graham (10.5)
Interceptions: Donovan Warren (4)
Spring answers
1. Robinson steps up: Spring practice began with talk of Denard Robinson playing other positions besides quarterback. The session ended with Robinson looking like the Wolverines' top signal caller. A full offseason in the program paid off for Robinson, who proved why he should stay at quarterback and closed the gap with last year's starter, Tate Forcier. Robinson capped it off with a strong spring game performance, leading the offense to touchdowns on five of six possessions and firing a 97-yard scoring pass to Roy Roundtree.
2. Secondary gets boost: After a miserable year for Michigan's secondary in 2009, help arrived this spring. Cameron Gordon, a wide receiver converted to safety, was arguably the biggest star of the spring session and drew tons of praise for his big hits and his presence in the deep middle. Cornerback Troy Woolfolk had a very good spring and is ready to embrace a shutdown role. The coaches also singled out cornerback J.T. Floyd and others for their play.
3. Offensive line coming together: The offensive line should be, and needs to be, a strength for Michigan this fall, especially if Robinson is the starting quarterback. Michigan's coaching staff seemed pleased with the line's progress this spring, as the Wolverines return five players who started part or all of last season and integrate promising redshirt freshmen like Taylor Lewan and Michael Schofield. Guard Patrick Omameh made strides this spring and the line will get a big boost when David Molk returns from injury.
Fall questions
1. Starting quarterback: The quarterback race is very close after Robinson's strong spring, and Michigan could go several weeks into preseason camp before naming its starter. Head coach Rich Rodriguez challenged Forcier this spring, and the sophomore needs a good response in August. True freshman Devin Gardner is still in the mix as well, though he'll need a great camp to keep pace with Robinson and Forcier.
2. Kicking game: The situation at kicker, and especially punter, wasn't good this spring. Incoming freshman Will Hagerup needs to be the answer at punter after the loss of All-American Zoltan Mesko. Hagerup also could be a factor at kicker if Brendan Gibbons can't lock up the job. Gibbons has a very strong leg but needs to be more consistent.
3. Pass rush: Michigan loses one of the nation's most disruptive defenders in Brandon Graham, who recorded 26 tackles for loss, 10.5 sacks, two forced fumbles, two blocked kicks and a fumble recovery for a touchdown last season. The Wolverines need boosts from returning defensive linemen Ryan Van Bergen and Mike Martin, as well as production from players like Craig Roh, a linebacker hybrid who showed promise as a true freshman last fall.
ABOUT THIS BLOG
Adam Rittenberg
Rittenberg joined ESPN.com in 2008 after four years at the Arlington Heights (Ill.) Daily Herald, where he covered sports at Notre Dame, Northwestern, DePaul and several other colleges. He lives in Chicago.
