The Movable Buffet

Dispatches from Las Vegas
by Richard Abowitz

Category: Vegas Monorail

Monorail's New Dubious Record

January 30, 2007 | 11:23 am
Looking for some quiet time in busy Las Vegas? How about taking a ride on the monorail. The Las Vegas Monorail continues to be a joke and an embarrassment. The embarrassment is the failure of the monorail to find riders and the joke is how the officials for the monorail continue to respond by explaining away their pathetic numbers. The Review-Journal reports today, "The Las Vegas Monorail saw a ridership collapse by more than 30% in 2006, capping a disappointing year with its worst ridership month ever in December, according to monorail statistics."
How did things get so bad? The monorail responded to having too few customers by charging the ones they had more. Despite the predictable result , the monorail sort-of predicted anyway that ridership would rise 11%. This is consistent with the way the monorail has worked with numbers since opening in 2004. Back then the monorail estimated that it would have 50,000 riders a day. The actual number for last month: 15, 430. No worries. The lords of the monorail have another plan for success: an airport extension. The only huge caveat is that someone has to pay $500 million for building it. You can see why the Review-Journal reports the monorail is rated by one expert agency as a junk bond at risk for default.
So, how have monorail officials responded to this dismal outlook? No worries (of course). First monorail spokeswoman Ingrid Reisman denied that anyone made that pesky 11% rise in ridership prediction that the Review-Journal reminds readers the head of the monorail made on December 14, 2005. Even better is Reisman's apples and oranges celebration of the terrible numbers on ridership, telling Review-Journal: "The monorail's current daily ridership...still far exceeds most rail systems throughout the country." Maybe when the Vice President's term ends, they can hire Mr. Cheney to crow about this and the other tremendous successes of the Las Vegas Monorail

Monorail Still Falls Short

October 18, 2006 | 12:27 pm

I was an English major and that means I have been wrong about a lot during my time in Vegas when it comes to the business side. One of my favorite errors: The Palms is going to fail. Yes, that was my thought when it opened in 2001. My thinking was that the local's casino was spending too much on promotion, celebrity and one season of an MTV show to survive that kind of expenditure with its off-Strip location. Back then, I would smugly point out to people how the Rio sits between the Strip and the Palms and had been trying for years to do the same thing with almost no success.

I could not have been more wrong. Instead, at least as much as any Strip property, the Palms has brought on the new Vegas: bottle service nightclubs with a young Hollywood glow. Certainly the Palms achieved a name recognition better than many Strip properties. People just happen to stay at the Imperial Palace or the Monte Carlo on the Strip, perhaps, because of a good room rate. But, even if they can't get a room, tourists want to go see the Palms while in Vegas. It has become a destination, as they say.

More recently, I was wrong about Wynn Las Vegas, which I thought cost so much to build that it would make an excellent casino for the next owner after its debt load came crashing down around Wynn. I was especially sure this would happen after Wynn opened with locally loathed nightclubs and unpopular shows like "Le Reve" and, briefly, "Avenue Q." But that hasn't even come close to happening and it looks like the profits from Macau will make this entire issue moot.

But I was sure right about one thing: the Las Vegas monorail. I've blogged repeatedly about the monorail's failings and they continue. Since it only reaches from the MGM to the Sahara, the monorail does not cover the entire Strip; nor does it reach downtown and forget about something obviously useful like the airport. (The monorail airport extension was planned to be completed at some point, though right now that only seems likely if contractors accept Monopoly money.)

Built to run behind the Strip, the monorail even deprives tourists of the fantastic neon views, volcano, water show and hubbub that accompany our most famous street. How could it not occur to anyone that, unlike locals who avoid that stretch of street, tourists want to see the Strip when in Las Vegas!

No wonder the double-decker Deuce buses that travel the Strip are far more popular with visitors. The monorail only offers an efficient trip to vacationers who want to travel between certain casinos. Who could have thought that vacationers prefer sightseeing to efficiency?

Besides being ill-conceived, the monorail has also been fantastically mismanaged. One example: when there were too few riders the price of the tickets was raised, resulting in even fewer riders. Long pegged at junk status, the monorail bond has now been downgraded to an even lower and more wretched junk grade, according to Fitch Ratings. The Review-Journal reports that Fitch Ratings "cited greatly weakened ridership, flat revenues," not to mention no hope of anything getting better anytime for any reason.

Told you so.


Kicking the Can Vegas-Style

July 5, 2006 | 12:47 pm
Vegasmonorail_i1b45kkf_2 The monorail has had a lot of problems. At first they were technical but lately they've involved the more simple issue of not enough riders. But this is new. Amazingly, the monorail system had to be briefly shut down on Sunday after one of the trains hit a trash can. The can was tossed from the sixth floor of the self-parking garage at the Flamingo. That is quite an impressive throw. Sports teams might want to talk to this person once garage surveillance tape help police grab a suspect.

Mono Failing to Spread

February 13, 2006 |  7:01 am
The Las Vegas monorail continues to fail, fail, fail. Last month saw its lowest ridership ever as well as its bond falling ever further into junk status. Monorail officials warn that unless this changes they won't be able to float more bonds to expand the monorail. Duh.  Yet, earlier on the Buffet, I reported, on how the monorail is depending on this expansion to become successful. How could this problem not have been anticipated? Any guesses?

Las Vegas has Mono

February 3, 2006 |  7:46 am
Vegasmonorail_i1b45kkf_1
The monorail has so far suffered from maintenance problems and low ridership. It cost $650 million to build the four mile track that opened in July 2004. The monorail's most recent triumph, written about on the Buffet, involved getting GM to give much needed sponsorship money to defray the lack of riders. In fact, plans to expand the monorail north past the Sahara and into downtown were long ago put on indefinite hold. But the "Las Vegas Sun" is reporting that a total lack of any tangible success, has inspired the operators of the Las Vegas monorail to reach for even more grandiose visions. In fact, Monorail President Curtis Myles has a name for the problem plagued monorail's various issues, the past:
I look at those things as things that happened that we can't do anything about now. I'm more interested in the future and moving forward.
Just forward in a slightly different direction, of course. The latest plan involves spending 1.8 billion (that's right this is to solve the problem that the $650 million investment isn't going well) and expand the monorail to the McCarran airport. How about not?

Got Monorail, anyone want it?

December 15, 2005 |  7:44 am
Vegasmonorail_i1b45kkf
The Las Vegas Monorail has been plagued with system failures, lower than expected ridership and competition from the Strip's cheaper "The Deuce" busses not to mention taxis and limos. So, what is the solution to not enough customers? Charge the ones you have more! That's right, according to the Review-Journal,  the latest attempt by the Las Vegas monorail to reach its revenue goals is to raise the base fare from $3 to $5 for tourists. Locals, who have little need for the four mile monorail that runs parallel to the Strip from the MGM to the Sahara, can get a cheaper $1 per trip ticket. But that won't be easy since locals won't actually be allowed to buy the $1 pass at any of the monorail stations, rather we must travel to Citizens Area Transit bus stations to get monorail tickets.
Tentative plans to expand the monorail to downtown were long ago abandoned (excuse me, indefinitely postponed). And, with the monorail requiring $650 million in 2006 to meet operating costs and debt payments it is looking like this may well wind up being one of the biggest fiascos in Las Vegas history.
(photo by PRN)


Advertisement

About the Bloggers

Recent Comments


Categories


Recent Posts
Movable Buffet: Final entry |  November 4, 2009, 1:05 pm »
Photos from Fangoria: Trinity of Terrors |  November 1, 2009, 8:45 am »
Oops, I am a tourist (and it's expensive) |  October 31, 2009, 10:00 am »
Fright Dome: Huge haunted houses at Circus Circus |  October 30, 2009, 11:47 am »

Archives