The New York Times


June 18, 2011, 1:00 pm

‘You Might Remember This’

Jeff Scher

Jeff Scher presents his animated art.

In 2007 I posted an animated portrait of my son Buster’s first years called “You Won’t Remember This.” “You Won’t Remember This Either,” covering the toddler years but featuring my younger son, Oscar, followed in 2009. This new film continues the series and features Buster from ages six to 10. While these films portray childhood, the perspective is parental. If Buster had made this film it would be all baseball, and the actual point of view, looking up at grownups twice his size, would surely feature more chins and nostrils. The angle might seem a small thing, but it can alter the feeling in subtle ways. Looking at children, our perspective is angled down and as they look up, we see eyes, those big ones, looking up like lasers. And, like every portrait, these films are double portraits, simultaneously reflecting the sensibility of who made them as well as who they picture.

The slice of childhood depicted here makes it feel like we’re creeping up on the middle of our journey together. The bubble of babyhood has burst and there have been great leaps in physical prowess, but the shell of adulthood has not yet hardened and the children remain vulnerable. As parents, we remain indispensable, but the intoxicating and scary scent of future independence is in the air. School is at the center of most days, and the balance between social and academic development and the need to just be a kid swings back and forth constantly. Being a parent has similar conflicts: while I’m insisting he do his homework, I’m wishing we were fishing, too. But we’ve both signed on to be (or become) functional citizens, and the homework gets done.

All three films are about memory, which I like to think of as single grains of sand culled from the steady flow in the hourglass of our life and turned to pearls, to be strung and locked away where they wait, slowly fading. Buster might actually remember some of the moments depicted in this film; some he might remember because of this film. I will remember them all, having now engraved them in memory with crayon, paint and pencil.

Shay Lynch’s score indispensably compliments the film’s emotions and rhythms. It was remarkable to hear the piece evolve from a spare piano rhythm to a fully orchestrated work. I suggest it be played nice and loud, through good speakers.


Jeff Scher is a painter and experimental filmmaker. His work is in the permanent collection of numerous museums, among them the Museum of Modern Art, and has been screened at film festivals around the world, including opening night at the New York Film Festival. He has also created work for HBO, PBS, the Sundance Channel and, most recently, a music video for Bob Dylan. A selection of his films, “The Best of Times,” was just published as an iPhone and iPad app. Mr. Scher teaches at the School of Visual Arts and at N.Y.U. Tisch School of the Arts. Music for Mr. Scher’s videos in The New York Times are by Shay Lynch.

Inside Opinionator

July 12, 2011
Strange Waters

The Civil War on land pitted former West Point friends against one another. It was a much different matter at sea.

July 10, 2011
The U.S. Capitol at War

The Civil War turns the U.S. Capitol, still under construction, into a barracks.

More From Disunion »

July 12, 2011
Friends in Revolution

Facebook and Twitter have their place in social change, but real revolutions take place in the street.

July 7, 2011
On Gay Rights, Moving Real-Life Friends to Action

How one Web site capitalized on the bonds among friends to mobilize people in New York’s gay marriage campaign.

More From Fixes »

July 12, 2011
On Experts and Global Warming

We non-experts are in no position to argue against the consensus of expert scientific opinion.

July 9, 2011
Let Be: An Answer to Hamlet’s Question

The crisis of thought and action may never be resolved, but fear not.

More From The Stone »

July 11, 2011
Vocationalism, Academic Freedom and Tenure

A new book questions how necessary academic freedom is in the context of higher education today.

July 4, 2011
What Does the First Amendment Protect?

Two recent Supreme Court decisions and the protection of speech.

More From Stanley Fish »

July 10, 2011
The Old Internet Neighborhoods

The Internet forum, that great old standby of Web 1.0., has become an endangered species.

July 2, 2011
How Games Steer Us Through Life

A digital distraction keeps a child balanced between boredom and frustration — but it has its limits.

More From Virginia Heffernan »

July 8, 2011
I Owe William Jennings Bryan an Apology

A childhood prank and, decades later, a ‘Don Giovanni’ moment.

June 17, 2011
Waiting (and Waiting) in the Wings

On the life of understudies, the state of Broadway theater and ‘The Book of Mormon.’

More From Dick Cavett »

July 8, 2011
Just Sign Here

Michele Bachmann’s signing of a conservative “marriage vow” pledge in Iowa raised ire in the blogosphere.

July 1, 2011
Dead in the Water?

The bizarre controversy surrounding the flotilla to Gaza gets washed ashore in Greece.

More From The Thread »

July 7, 2011
Sex and the Supremes

A Supreme Court decision on the First Amendment reminds us that as a nation we look more askance at sex than at violence.

July 1, 2011
Conservative Cash Crop

Michele Bachmann likes to feed the Republican base. But rigid ideology meets mushy reality when it comes to the Bachmann family farm.

More From Timothy Egan »

July 6, 2011
After Tahrir, New Voices in a Global Fugue

In the work of some young composers, music from cultures long divided are sounding together for the first time.

June 22, 2011
Finding the Score Within

How Jimi Hendrix and Bela Bartok saved my life, and why I became a throat-singing composer.

More From The Score »

July 5, 2011
Banned From the Barn

Even without state gag laws on the books, farms are doing a pretty good job of shutting out reporters all on their own.

July 1, 2011
Make Food Choices Simple: Cook

The one place where dinner is most easily done right is in your own kitchen.

More From Mark Bittman »

July 3, 2011
‘Stars & Stripes’

An animated film celebrating Sousa and the Fourth.

June 18, 2011
‘You Might Remember This’

The artist’s third memory film in a series chronicling his sons’ growing up.

More From Jeff Scher »

July 2, 2011
This Summer, the Guilt Is Gratis

It’s that season again. Of the many telltale hallmarks of summer in New York City, perhaps the most unsung are the sidewalk volunteers.

May 4, 2011
Goodbye to All That

How can I leave the city I love?

More From Townies »

June 29, 2011
Common Sense and Sensibility

The Supreme Court’s decision distinguishing between child and adult suspects is common sense. So why was the court divided?

June 15, 2011
Activists by Invitation

If Congress really dislikes “judicial activism” it needs to do a better job of writing laws.

More From Linda Greenhouse »

June 23, 2011
Did My Brother Invent E-Mail With Tom Van Vleck? (Part Five)

An interview with a pioneer of computer science, some speculation regarding the early hackers, and the series concludes.

June 22, 2011
Did My Brother Invent E-Mail With Tom Van Vleck? (Part Four)

An interview with one of the pioneers of time-sharing systems, as the e-mail series continues.

More From Errol Morris »

June 23, 2011
Did My Brother Invent E-Mail With Tom Van Vleck? (Part Five)

An interview with a pioneer of computer science, some speculation regarding the early hackers, and the series concludes.

June 22, 2011
Did My Brother Invent E-Mail With Tom Van Vleck? (Part Four)

An interview with one of the pioneers of time-sharing systems, as the e-mail series continues.

More From Errol Morris »

Opinionator Highlights

Thumbnail
Friends in Revolution

Facebook and Twitter have their place in social change, but real revolutions take place in the street.

Thumbnail
On Experts and Global Warming

We non-experts are in no position to argue against the consensus of expert scientific opinion.

On Gay Rights, Moving Real-Life Friends to Action

How one Web site capitalized on the bonds among friends to mobilize people in New York’s gay marriage campaign.

Thumbnail
Arguing From the Facts

As a recent debate on the budget shows, inductive reasoning can take us only so far.

The Moral Logic of Survivor Guilt

The sense of guilt and betrayal surviving soldiers feel originates not just in what they’ve done, but in who they are.

Previous Series

Thumbnail
Line by Line

A series on the basics of drawing, presented by the artist and author James McMullan, beginning with line, perspective, proportion and structure.

Thumbnail
The Elements of Math

A series on math, from the basic to the baffling, by Steven Strogatz. Beginning with why numbers are helpful and finishing with the mysteries of infinity.

Thumbnail
Living Rooms

The past, present and future of domestic life, with contributions from artists, journalists, design experts and historians.

Thumbnail
Specimens

This series by Richard Conniff looks at how species discovery has transformed our lives.