PMs with Open-ended Prices

Smarket is an interesting new market that lets you bet on whether the rank of books and other products on Amazon will go up or down. This is another addition to a type of market I dont think theres a good theory for yet; markets with open-ended pricing. There are several other examples including the Hollywood Stock Exchange (HSX), ProTrade, and Yahoo!s Tech Buzz Game. These markets all try to follow the real-world rise and fall of some abstract value (box office returns, on-field athletic performance, and search rank, respectively), and allow traders to bet on them.

So far, all the markets of this type use only play money, and thats part of what Im talking about when I say theres no theory. One of the innovations that makes standard Prediction Markets (of the kind I described last week) workable is that a risk-neutral market operator can sponsor a market without taking a position in the trading; that is, without taking on risk. The traders buy and sell from one another, and the operator merely facilitates the trades. Even if you add an automated market maker, you can constrain the potential costs, while still facilitating unlimited trading.

Traditional bookies learned to handicap the events they were selling bets on or they went out of business quickly. Part of the development of insurance was inventing the actuarial techniques that allowed insurers to reliably estimate how their exposure would change as they sold various policies. Modern stock markets only allow short selling when the investors back their trading with assets that the broker can rely on if prices go the wrong way. Real money prediction market operators will need the same ability to constrain losses.

With the open-ended markets, the value to be paid out to stocks that gained isnt limited, and isnt related in a simple way to the price paid by the purchasers. I would expect a theory that showed how the markets exposure is limited to start from the observation that one asset can only rise in value when another falls. This is true of Smarkets and TechBuzz because theyre based on relative rankings. Its not obvious whether its true of HSX (Box Offices returns are only weakly limited) or ProTrade (the formulas for ranking athletes havent been published.)

Its also not clear how to read the market results as predictions. In a standard Prediction Market, the traders incentive is to bid the price up or down until it matches the subjective probability, so prices should equal probabilities. David Pennock says the optimum target on TechBuzz is the square root of the search share. I think a separate analysis will have to be done of each institution, and if the rule isnt easy to understand, it will be hard to claim that traders are producing prices that follow an optimum rule.

There also isnt yet any theory regarding the feedback from underlying value to market value. Most of these markets seem to reflect changes in the underlying value by paying dividends to holders of the assets. Sometimes they (also? instead?) change the market makers current price for the asset. I expect this to make it difficult to come up with closed-form expressions of how the market operators exposure changes when assets are revalued. Remember that theres no guarantee that similar amounts of money are invested in each market, or each side of any particular issue. And this kind of distinction is where the money pump was discovered in the TechBuzz Dynamic Parimutuel Mechanism. You cant do this with real money if you dont know what your exposure is.

These markets are definitely interesting. They allow Surowieckis Wisdom of Crowds to give us a hint about the rising and falling fortunes of things we care about. I welcome efforts to turn them into markets that can make predictions, or allow insurance, hedging, and the other side effects we expect from standard Prediction Markets.

Hat tip to Dave Pennock.

5 Responses to PMs with Open-ended Prices

  1. Stock Market Information Says:

    Stock Market Information

    I couldnt understand some parts of this article, but it sounds interesting

  2. Stocks And Trades Says:

    Discover How Rich Dad Trades Stock Options

    Robert Kiyosaki, author of the Rich Dad books, is talking about stock options. Whether you are a fan of Mr. Kiyosaki or not, he is undeniably one of todays more prolific personal finance authors in the world and he wants us to know that options are t

  3. Buy Gold - Scrap Gold Prices - Legitimate Part-Time Business - Make Money FAST Says:

    Buy Gold - Scrap Gold Prices - Legitimate Part-Time Business - Make Money FAST

    D- Link Shows Off Broadband Wireless Products at Interop D- Link plans to show off its latest product solutions for network switching, security, surveillance, wireless, storage and IP- based telephony when Booth 1813 turns into a virtual business netwo

  4. Kamagra Says:


    Hi, I can\t seem to subscribe to this, Thanks.

  5. the money markets Says:

    the money markets

    Ha! I love the money markets.