Archive for the ‘13- Evidence that Islam is false’ Category

Evidence that Islam is false

December 10, 2011 Leave a comment

Logical proofs

November 1, 2011 4 comments

1- Would a true God keep 80 % humans unaware of Islam- his ‘only true religion’?

2- Was Allah Muhammad’s domestic servant?

3- Why will the creator of the illimitable  Universe be so concerned about tiny humans?

4- Why didn’t Angel Gabriel reveal the Quran to all Meccans, show himself to all Arabian people?

5- Why didn’t God turn Muhammad into a  scholar overnight and provide him with good stationery to record the Quran instead of relying on Muhammad’s supporters’  memory?

6- Why doesn’t God do anything supernatural today to prove that Islam is true, like rearranging stars in a way to read “Islam is true” ?

7-Why doesn’t God simply show himself to the people and declare every night- Islam is true, follow Muhammad?

8-Why has God left so much ambiguity and difference of opinion among believers in Islam, where Sunnis and Shias say that the others are not ‘real Muslims’  and where different scholars interpret things so vastly differently?

9-Would a true God have allowed different versions of the Quran to crop up within 20 years of Muhammad’s death in AD 632 so that the Caliph (Successor of Muhammad) Othman who began his reign in AD 644 had to order all other versions to be destroyed and keep only one version?

10-Will  God allow millions of killings in his name by misguided followers who genuinely believe that they are spreading faith in God and doing his work?

11-Why didn’t God give the Quran in all languages, or make everyone know Arabic?

12-Will God force people to accept his religion blindly and give death to those who leave it?

Categories: 13-C-Logical proofs

Other major blunders of the Quran

September 1, 2011 Leave a comment

There are people- strong, faithful believers, who will go to any defend to ‘explain’ errors. But in this case, it should be asked- Why should there be a need to explain contradictions in a ‘clear book’ which is supposed to be the word of God if that book is to guide humanity? Why is the help of explanations needed to understand God’s words? The best answer to show that the Quran must not be interpreted in any other way than its obvious meaning comes from the Quran itself. The Quran repeatedly claims to be a “clear book” (5:15) “easy to understand” (44:58 , 54:22 , 54:32, 54:40) “explained in detail” (6:114), “conveyed clearly”, (5:16, 10:15) and with “no doubt” in it (2:1). If at all these mistakes had any other meaning and explanation, it should have been clearly mentioned in the Quran.

1- Quran mistakes Jesus’ mother Mary for Moses’ sister Mariam

2- Quran says shooting stars are missiles to scare Jinns

3- Quran says Samaritans lived during Moses’ time, which they didn’t

4- Quran says Muhammad went to Masjid-ul-Aqsa, which did not exist in Muhammad’s time

5- Quran contradicts itself on Intercession (Must read!)

Answering claims that Islam is true

June 26, 2011 5 comments

 Miracles of the Quran or Islamic hoaxes?

1- The Miracle of Iron

2- Victory of the Romans and the lowest point on earth

3-The Quran on seas and rivers

4-The Quran on Human Embryonic Development

Here is the Islamic claim

And here is the reality and this

And also, this presentation by William Campbell. Another Islamic hoax.

5- The Quran on mountains

Here is the Islamic claim

And here is the reality   Islamic hoax.

6-Speed of Light in the Quran?

7-The Quran on Cerebrum

8-The Quran on deep seas and internal waves

9-The Quran on expanding universe and Big Bang

10- 7 layers of the Atmosphere

11-  7 layers of the Earth

12- The Miracle of 19

13- Splitting of the Moon

What all this shows is that since there is no evidence at all that Islam is true, not a single sentence in the Quran which could not have been said by 7th century Arabs, and every single sentence in the Quran can be explained from Muhammad’s own socio-cultural background, Muslims resort to such tricks. These claims are actually Islamic hoaxes, and not miracles of the Quran. And none of the so-called ‘miracles’ which are actually hoaxes are in clear language. If Allah knew that the Dead Sea is the lowest point, why didn’t he simply say so- “Dead Sea is the lowest Point”? Simple and clear! But nothing like this is said in simple and clear language in the Quran. Why should there be a need to explain these ‘miracles’ in a ‘clear book’ like the Quran? The best answer to show that the Quran must not be interpreted in any other way than its obvious meaning comes from the Quran itself. The Quran repeatedly claims to be a “clear book” (5:15) “easy to understand” (44:58 , 54:22 , 54:32, 54:40) “explained in detail” (6:114), “conveyed clearly”, (5:16, 10:15) and with “no doubt” in it (2:1). And not a single of the ‘miracles’ aka hoaxes is  in clear language.

It should also be remembered that when real scholars debate real scholars, they do not bring forward any of the above amateurish claims. For example, two real scholars (not showmen like Zakir Naik) of Pakistan, Javed Ahmed Ghamidi and Khaled Zaheer debated with Ali Sina of In that wonderful debate, all arguments and counter-arguments are excellent and worth reading. But when Ali Sina asked for evidence that Muhammad was a Prophet of God, neither of the great debators could provide any. If these ‘Miracles of the Quran’ aka hoaxes were truly miracles, these real scholars would have definite;y brought them as evidence in support of the claim that Islam is true.That great and lengthy debate can be read here.

For a full list of ‘Miracles of the Quran’ aka hoaxes, this link is very useful. Also it is very useful to see the following exposure of almost all claims of “Miracles in the Quran” in this link:

Mistakes in the Quran

June 19, 2011 5 comments

Chapter 22 Verse 47 and Chapter 32 verse 5 of the Quran says that 1 day of God= 1,000 years of man.

Contradiction: Chapter 70 Verse 4 says “The angels and spirits ascend into God in a single day the span of which is 50,000 years”.

There are many contradictions in the Quran. Even a single error is enough to dismiss the Quran as a word of God.

1- Contradictions in the Quran

2-Other major blunders

For a complete list of Quranic mistakes, this link is very useful.