Kingdom rejects BBC claim of Zamzam water contamination

In this file photo, Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Abdullah leads the inauguration of the King Abdullah Zamzam Watering Project in Makkah on Sept. 3, 2010. The project was designed to guarantee the provision and pureness of the water of Zamzam, a well located within the Masjid al-Haram mosque in Makkah.

By BADEA ABU AL-NAJA | ARAB NEWS

JEDDAH: Saudi authorities have refuted a BBC report claiming that the Zamzam well in Makkah is polluted and that drinking the holy water could cause diseases such as cancer.

Zuhair Nawab, president of Saudi Geological Survey (SGS), denied the allegation and said his organization has taken adequate measures to ensure the safety of Zamzam well and its water.

The BBC said it had asked a pilgrim to take samples from the Zamzam water taps in Makkah and the Zamzam water being sold in bottles to compare them with the water on sale illegally.

“These showed high levels of nitrate and potentially harmful bacteria, and traces of arsenic three times the permitted level, just like the illegal water, which was purchased in the UK,” the BBC said, referring to contaminated holy water sold in some UK shops.

Nawab said his organization has been responsible for monitoring the quality of Zamzam water, which not only concerns Saudi Arabia but the whole Islamic world. “Our experts monitor the condition of Zamzam on a daily basis. Every day we take three samples from the water to carry out tests and studies, which showed that it was not contaminated,” he explained. He said the newly established King Abdullah Zamzam Water Distribution Center in Makkah is equipped with advanced facilities and where bottling takes place in accordance with international standards.

“We apply modern methods for filling bottles after sterilization,” Nawab said.

He said the contamination of the water could have caused while redistributing the water in small bottles by individuals.

Fahd Turkistani, adviser to the Presidency for Meteorology and Environment, said the BBC report focused on bottled water supplied by individuals and not by the Presidency of the Two Holy Mosques Affairs. The water supplied by the presidency undergoes close monitoring and ultraviolet rays are applied to kill harmful bacteria, he added.

Turkistani said the Zamzam water contamination could have caused by illegal workers who sell Zamzam water at Makkah gates as they use unsterilized containers. He said the Saudi government has prohibited such illegal sales of Zamzam water.

Meanwhile, a responsible source at the Presidency of the Two Holy Mosques Affairs highlighted the measures taken for the protection of Zamzam water saying the water passes through stainless steel pipes to the cooling stations and then to the Grand Mosque.

He said the presidency has given utmost importance for the preservation and distribution of Zamzam water, adding that it is closely monitored around the clock.

According to the World Health Organization, the permitted arsenic rate in natural water is up to 10 microgram per liter. If the rate goes up then the water could be harmful to the kidney and liver and cause cancer. The rate of arsenic in Zamzam water is much less than the amount permitted by the WHO.

Talal Mahjoub, a Saudi, denounced the move to create suspicion about the quality of Zamzam water.

“My family and I have been drinking Zamzam for many years. None of us have suffered any disease as a result of drinking it. If the BBC report was true, Makkans would have suffered many diseases, including cancer, because most of them drink Zamzam.”

The Saudi Embassy in London also issued a statement affirming the purity of Zamzam in Makkah.

“Scientific tests conducted on samples taken from the original source have proved the Zamzam water is good for drinking,” it said, referring to tests conducted on the water at a French laboratory. It said the Kingdom does not export Zamzam water. The King Abdullah Zamzam water complex, which was established in Makkah last September at a cost of SR700 million, can supply 200,000 bottles daily.

Comments

MOHSIN A. D.

Report abuse
It is my understanding that BBC did not claim that the Zamzam well in Makkah was contaminated. They were talking about the contamination in canned water sold in Islamic stores labelled as "Zamzam". Its my feeling that this practice of commercialization must stop.

PROF. M ZAHIDUL HAQUE

Report abuse
There is no reason to suspect that the water of the main Zamzam well has been contaminated because the concerned Saudi authorities regularly monitoring its purity through performing various scientifical tests But doubts remain for the unauthorized bottling and marketing of Zamzam water and BBC repoted about the content of such type of water. I would request the concerned Saudi authority to adopt stringent measures to stop unauthorized bottling and marketing of Zamzam water. Every year Hajis bring several thousand bottles of Zamzam water to their respective home countries for their own consumption and to present portion of the same to near and dear ones as holy gift. In this connection I would like to suggest that the packaging of raw dates should also be screened before marketing.

SHAJI MAMPAD

Report abuse
B B C must chasten the news, and ask apologize to billions of Muslims about incorrect news of holy water zamzam

JAMALUDDIN

Report abuse
the drinking of zam zam water never be harmed it cure the disease as of know since 14th century no body claim any harmful bacteria in zam zam water this water is not man made its gift of God to followers of Prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him).

SYED NEAZ AHMAD

Report abuse
A scientific test by a well-known, neutral and well-respected lab should be commssioned to allay the doubts and confusion created by the BBC report.
Latest comments

Pakistan ambassador meets imam of Prophet's Mosque

its really nice to see our muslim leaders cooperating and working in tandem with our religious

hussain at Apr 25, 2012 18:09

4 comments

Amnesty says Muslims in Europe face discrimination

referring to the article 'muslims making hijrah to europe' I wonder if Mr Mulhim who authored t

hussain at Apr 25, 2012 18:09

25 comments

Labor Ministry considers limiting IT and communications jobs to Saudis

IT and communication is not so easy as the ministry thinks that arab people will do this kind o

sukri at Apr 25, 2012 18:09

10 comments

Amnesty says Muslims in Europe face discrimination

@maltisaura <br/>the hypocrisy arises in that western countries can't live by the values they

hussain at Apr 25, 2012 18:09

25 comments

Kingdom condemns Israeli assault on East Jerusalem

Well one mistake does not justify other mistake. You seem to think if it was alright for Jordan

Ash at Apr 25, 2012 18:09

6 comments