Is it cheaper to put the heating on high for a short time or longer at a lower temperature?

By This Is Money, Ask The Experts

|

Is it economical to run a gas boiler fed central heating system at max temperature and therefore get to a set room temperature quickly and then turn off the boiler?

Or is it better to have the heat coming from the radiators for a longer period by setting the boiler at a minimum temperature.

Also does running a boiler at max temperature have detrimental effects on the boiler?

Basically, Is it cheaper to whack the heating on high for a short amount of time or longer on a lower temperature?

G.W, via email

Keeping warm: Is it cheaper to put the heating on high for a short amount of time or low for a longer period?

Keeping warm: Is it cheaper to put the heating on high for a short amount of time or low for a longer period?

A home energy expert, from not-for-profit energy group Ebico, replies:

A house will heat up from cold more quickly the hotter the radiators are. 

On the face of it, therefore, operating a boiler at maximum means a warm home, quicker. 

However, the efficiency of a central heating system – and this is particularly true for modern condensing boilers – depends a very great deal on the correct matching of boiler power output to the size and number of radiators.

So, key to keeping your home warm with the central heating system at minimum cost, is having the correct boiler installed in the first place, and then using the correct power output setting.  

If you set your boiler output too high, then the temperature at which the water returns to the boiler after circulating through the radiator system will be too high for it to recover much heat from the boiler’s exhaust gases (the process that normally makes condensing boilers much more efficient).  

Try operating the boiler with as low an output setting as is consistent with achieving the required warmth in your home in a reasonable time.

Do be aware, however, that operating at low boiler output temperatures will also mean that water in your domestic hot water tank will take longer to warm-up too – so a little trial-and-error will be required.   

 


Home Energy Expert is a free energy advice service from Ebico, the UK’s only not-for-profit energy company and National Energy Action, the UK’s leading fuel poverty charity, committed to improving the quality of life of low income households and campaigning for warm homes.

Home Energy Expert has teamed up with This is Money to answer any burning questions about energy in your home. If you want to improve your energy efficiency and save money then email your question with Home Energy Expert in the subject line to: editor@thisismoney.co.uk.
For more information click on to: www.ebico.org.uk

 

Here's what other readers have said. Why not add your thoughts, or debate this issue live on our message boards.

The comments below have not been moderated.

To get maximum efficiency is to turn radiators in the rooms you spend most of your time, turn all of the upstairs off. Put the boiler on when the temp drops below 15 degrees for 1 hour manually when required. We've cut gas consumption by -50% instead of using the thermostat combined with timer settings of 5am-7.00am, 11am-12pm, 7pm-8.30pm everyday which was one of the most efficient way of running on an auto cycle. Gas prices are so high now you have to weigh up consumption with cost of total comfort.

Click to rate     Rating   (0)

I have an oil condensing boiler and have found that the liquid run-off occurs between 15-30 minutes of the boiler firing. This means that it is working at its most efficient and recovering exhaust gas heat.. Since temperatures are starting to warm up at this time of year, I have the heat on for 45 minutes, off 1hr 15mins and so on with radiator therostats up fairly high. The rooms warm up quickly and the boiler is operating at maximum efficiency each time. As people have said, it is trial and error.

Click to rate     Rating   (0)

Why doesn't this article give a clear answer to the simple question asked? The last paragraph, "Do be aware, however, that operating at low boiler output temperatures will also mean that water in your domestic hot water tank will take longer to warm-up too......" is incorrect advice for those with a condensing boiler, where hot water and central heating circuits are independent of each other.

Click to rate     Rating   2

A badly written article which gives no sense of what the actual answer is!

Click to rate     Rating   10

Oh dear! Free speech out of the window again. Are you Big Brother?

Click to rate     Rating   3

It's simple keep the heater on LOW when you go to bed -say 18c and turn it up 2-4 degrees depending on what room temp you prefer in the daytime . This is especially the case in older damp houses but generaly a more economical way to heat yr house . Yes of course a jumper helps 1-2dgrees too . Thank you paul

Click to rate     Rating   (0)

Definately the latter for us. First year in our new house we had heating on as and when needed thru the winter and set quite high, so it got too hot, turned it off, got cold again, turned it on again, etc, etc, and at the end of the year we still owed a bit.. The following and subsequent years I pay the same per month as before but now we left it on all day in winter but on very, very low, and every year I now get a rebate of around £200...

Click to rate     Rating   3

It's more economical switched off!!!

Click to rate     Rating   3

You should check the installation requirements before fitting a radiator thermostat to the hall radiator. I believe that the system has to have one radiator which must accept hot water so that the boiler is not damaged.. - David Butcher, Barnsley, 13/4/2012 10:15 Thank you for your comment I realise that where ever the wall thermometer is there must be a radiator without a thermostatic valve or presumably a vale set at max. Just may be, this is acceptable it there are 3 heated towell racks fully on in the system

Click to rate     Rating   2

keep on for several hours, on half of boiler capacity, if your still cold either go to bed and listen to oldham radio or read something, or yes why did we not think of this put your old m&s; wooley on and a pair of long johns and a wooley hat.

Click to rate     Rating   3

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

Your name and location will appear next to your comment.
You have 1000 characters left.
Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.
For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.
Terms