The Duhks Cover: Sting, Tracy Chapman, Gillian Welch et al.
(plus: the Top Covers of 2006)
November 23rd, 2008 — 09:24 am
I didn’t do a “best-of” list last year, and I wasn’t planning on doing one this year. But back in 2006, before the coverblog started, I posted a Top Songs of 2006 tracklist for my own amusement on my now-abandoned personal blog; the focus wasn’t covers, but the list included several, including Jenny Lewis and co. version of Traveling Wilburys hit Handle With Care at number 7, and Teddy Thompson’s Leonard Cohen cover Tonight Will Be Fine coming in a respectable fourth. It was, I am just now realizing, my very first music blog post; looking back, I’m quite pleased with how well it turned out.
Tied for number ten with The Be Good Tanya’s delicious interpretation of Prince hit When Doves Cry was a wonderful cover of Tracy Chapman’s Mountains O’ Things by Acadian folk-rock band The Duhks; though the songs ended up low on the totem pole, of all the tunes on that list, those two remain the ones I listen to most often today. Here’s what I had to say about that:
Two Canadian bands with female vocalists from opposite ends of the trad-alt-folk spectrum cover black American songwriter hits from the mid eighties. Exceptionally well. With banjo.
Ironically, though their playing styles are disparate, the originals were conversely so. The rough backporch plucking of Doves reframes the beatperfection of Prince’s original; the crisp, bright acadian-rock turn of Mountains brings the distance of a greek chorus to folkie Chapman’s raw, plaintive lament. And so on.
Both The Be Good Tanyas and The Duhks are known for strong covers; to combine them would be foolhardy and unwieldy. A coin flip says we’ll save the Be Good Tanyas for another day; happily, there’s much to say about both the collected coverage and the uniquely authentic modern sound of The Duhks.
I was lucky enough to see The Duhks live several times, most notably in a combined form with The Mammals billed as Platypus, a perfect taxonomy geek joke. Though their lineup has changed in the last year, and their newest album was a bit more poppy overall, in my mind’s eye, they’re still a wonderfully punk-looking collection of young folks, flitting around the stage with spunk and a keen eye for combining the traditional instruments and reels of their native Winnipeg with a fuller percussive beat.
Theirs is a particularly Acadian form of folk rock, almost celtic at times, funky with plucked strings and chunky with old-timey fiddle and strum patterns, its hybrid nature and its overall tone and timbre consistent with the burgeoning neotraditional movement we’ve been going on about here on Cover Lay Down. Their live performance is practically trancelike, and their album work is only slightly more Nickel Creek than Uncle Earl, balancing evenly between the traditional world and something new and reverent. As today’s set reveals, the sound is both thoroughly enjoyable, and perfectly suited to the discerning tastes of those who prefer their neotrad a bit more polished.
One-shot 2007 side project Turtle Duhks, which featured Jordan McConnell and Jordan Podolak of The Duhks and Lydia Garrison of Turtle Island Dream, leaned more towards the delicate, ragged appalachian side of the trend; the track featured below is somewhat of an anomaly on True Lover, but it is an exquisite conceit nonetheless, melodic and sweet, masterfully interpreted from the original recording by Akwasasne Nation wolfclan member Bear Fox, and in the original Mohawk language, too.
- The Duhks: Rock of Ages (orig. Gillian Welch)
(from Your Daughters & Your Sons, 2002) - The Duhks: Camptown Races (orig. Stephen Foster)
(from Beautiful Dreamer: The Songs of Stephen Foster, 2004) - The Duhks: Everybody Knows (orig. Leonard Cohen)
- The Duhks: Love is the Seventh Wave (orig. Sting)
(from The Duhks, 2005) - The Duhks: Mountains of Things (orig. Tracy Chapman)
- The Duhks: Turtle Dove (trad.)
(from Migrations, 2006) - The Duhks: Political Science (orig. Randy Newman)
(from Sail Away: The Songs of Randy Newman, 2006) - Turtle Duhks: Sky World (orig. Bear Fox)
(from True Lover, 2007)
Fast Paced World was released in August to mixed reviews; I have heard the bulk of it, and though it is indeed transitional and a bit more singer-oriented, I think it marks a solid stop on the path that has become the Duhks’ march to folkfame and due recognition. There’s also some great sound in the live recordings from Merlefest 2007, which represent the first official recordings featuring new vocalist Sarah Dugas; their live version of Zeppelin classic Whole Lotta Love offers especially strong evidence that The Duhks are still The Duhks.
Out of respect for the label, I have chosen not to post any songs from those most recent works, but I recommend both, and all the albums previous; if you’re buying music this week or just thinking ahead for the folklover on your holiday list, head on over to The Duhks’ webstore to pick up their collected works, to FestivaLink.net for the Merlefest show, and to Sugar Hill for the Turtle Duhks project.
Oh, and Today’s Bonus Coverfolk is the rest of the covers off that 2006 Top Songs list. You didn’t really think I’d leave you hanging, did you?
- The Be Good Tanyas: When Doves Cry (orig. Prince)
- Teddy Thompson: Tonight Will Be Fine (orig. Leonard Cohen)
- Jenny Lewis and The Watson Twins ft. Ben Gibbard, Conor Oberst, and M Ward: Handle With Care (orig. The Traveling Wilburys)
Cover Lay Down publishes new coverfolk features Wednesdays, Sundays, and the occasional Friday or holiday. Like it? Vote for us!