What happens when pirates play a game development simulator and then go bankrupt because of piracy?
When we released our very first game, Game Dev Tycoon (for Mac, Windows and Linux) yesterday, we did something unusual and as far as I know unique. We released a cracked version of the game ourselves, minutes after opening our Store.
I uploaded the torrent to the number one torrent sharing site, gave it a description imitating the scene and asked a few friends to help seed it.
A minute after we uploaded it, my torrent client looked like this:
Soon my upload speed was maxed out (and as of the time of writing still is) and my friends and I had connections from all over the world and for all three platforms!
How does piracy feel?
The cracked version is nearly identical to the real thing except for one detail… Initially we thought about telling them their copy is an illegal copy, but instead we didn’t want to pass up the unique opportunity of holding a mirror in front of them and showing them what piracy can do to game developers. So, as players spend a few hours playing and growing their own game dev company, they will start to see the following message, styled like any other in-game message:
Boss, it seems that while many players play our new game, they steal it by downloading a cracked version rather than buying it legally.
If players don’t buy the games they like, we will sooner or later go bankrupt.
Slowly their in-game funds dwindle, and new games they create have a high chance to be pirated until their virtual game development company goes bankrupt.
Some of the responses I found online (identities obscured to protect the guilty):
Is there some way to avoid that? I mean can I research DRM or something …
And another user:
Why are there so many people that pirate? It ruins me!
As a gamer I laughed out loud: the IRONY!!!
However, as the developer, who spent over a year creating this game and hasn’t drawn a salary yet, I wanted to cry. Surely, for most of these players, the 8 dollars wouldn’t hurt them but it makes a huge difference to our future!
Trying to appeal to pirates
I know that some people just don’t even think about buying games. They will immediately search for a cracked version. For this reason, when we released the game, we also published a page which targets people who search for a cracked/illegal version. Unfortunately, due to my lack in search-engine-optimization skills, that page has had no impact yet, but I hope it will convince some to buy the game in the future.
[…]if years down the track you wonder why there are no games like these anymore and all you get to play is pay-to-play and social games designed to suck money out of your pockets then the reason will stare back at you in the mirror.
I do think it’s important to try to communicate what piracy means to game developers to our consumers. I also tried to appeal to a particular forum a day earlier after someone who I gave early-access to the Store seemed to have passed on the copy to others:
We’re just a start-up and really need your support. The game is only 7.99USD, DRM free…
Clearly, my post hadn’t worked too well since on the same forum someone posted the earlier screenshot (“Why are there so many people that pirate? It ruins me!) just a bit after I made my appeal and this was followed by many others complaining about piracy.
I still hope that it made a difference to someone.
Anyway, how many really did buy and how many did pirate our game during this first day?
The awesome/depressing results
Today, one day after release, our usage stats look like this:
Genuine version: 214 users
Cracked version: at least 3104 users
Over 93.6% of players stole the game. We know this because our game contains some code to send anonymous-usage data to our server. Nothing unusual or harmful. Heaps of games/apps do this and we use it to better understand how the game is played. It’s absolutely anonymous and you are covered by our privacy policy. Anyway, the cracked version has a separate ID so I can separate the data. I’m sure some of the players have firewalls and some will play offline therefore the actual number of players for the cracked version is likely much higher.
To the players who played the cracked version!
I’m not mad at you. When I was younger, downloading illegal copies was practically normal but this was mostly because global game distribution was in its infancy. To be fair, there are still individuals who either can’t make a legal purchase because of payment-issues or who genuinely cannot afford the game. I don’t have a quarrel with you. To the rest who could afford the game consider this:
- Would you like to see a bigger/better sequel of Game Dev Tycoon in the future? Buy the game! Creating this game was already expensive and this was just a small game. If we ever want to make a bigger/better version we need a lot of support!
- Do you hate the trend towards social or pay-to-play free games? Buy games from independent developers! (start with ours )
- Do you hate the recent trends in the industry? Buy DRM free games.
We are not wealthy and it’s unlikely that we will be any time soon, so stop pretending like we don’t need your 8 dollars! We are just two guys working our butts off, trying to start our own game studio to create games which are fun to play.
The game is DRM free, you can use it on up to three of your computers for your own use, you get copies for Mac, Windows and Linux, you can continue your game before piracy wrecked your company and we even aim to provide you with a free Steam key once the game is on Steam. All for a mere 8 bucks.
If you just want to try the game then there’s the free DEMO:
Final words
Do we need DRM?
Whether or not to use DRM isn’t clear at all to a new start-up. The main argument against it is that all it does is to inconvenience genuine customers. Fact is that any game can be cracked, so all you do is spend time on something that in the end just annoys your real customers while only slightly delaying the inevitable. The only way to protect yourself is to create an online game. I guess that’s why so many studios focus on these types of games and it’s probably a driving force to eradicate traditional single player games.
Personally, I love single players games and hope to be able to continue down this path and if more people would buy our game, we might even be able to.
Would I do this again?
This was a unique opportunity. You need a game development simulation game to make this particular joke work. The more general idea/experiment to release a cracked version which inconveniences and counts pirates can probably work for any game and might work in the long run.
If pirates are put through more trouble than genuine customers, maybe more will buy the real game. Sadly, for AAA games it is currently the other way. Customers get the trouble with always-on requirements and intrusive DRM, while pirates can just download and enjoy. A twisted world.
To our genuine customers
Thank you for your support. Your purchase is more important to us than you might think. We hope to be able to bring you more games in the future. Also, please update to the latest version of the game by using the download link from your purchase email. Before writing this blog post I’ve fixed most of the known issues
Patrick Klug
- Greenheart Games ♥
If you want to comment on this post, please do so on our forum.
If you just want to try the game then there’s the free DEMO:
[...] What happens when pirates play a game development simulator and then go bankrupt because of piracy? (2013-Apr-29) [Greenheart Games] When we released our very first game, Game Dev Tycoon (for Mac, [...]
[...] “Initially we thought about telling them their copy is an illegal copy, but instead we didn’t want to pass up the unique opportunity of holding a mirror in front of them and showing them what piracy can do to game developers,” explains Greenheart’s Patrick Klug. [...]
[...] game distribution was in its infancy,” Game Dev Tycoon co-creator Patrick Klug admits in a follow-up blog post. “We are not wealthy and it’s unlikely that we will be any time soon, so stop [...]
[...] Greenheart Games [...]
[...] – It looks like Greenheart Games took a similar approach to piracy a year later in 2013 with Game Dev [...]
[...] a bit of an experiment, the Klugs released a cracked version of their game and uploaded it themselves to a torrent site. However, in the pirated version, the [...]
[...] http://www.greenheartgames.com/2013/04/29/what-happens-when-pirates-play-a-game-development-simulato… [...]
[...] What happened then is fascinating if not surprising reading: go have a look, a laugh and perhaps shake your head a couple of times. [...]
[...] a bit of an experiment, the Klugs released a cracked version of their game and uploaded it themselves to a torrent site. However, in the pirated version, the [...]
[...] development powerhouse over the subsequent 30 several years. In a bit of an experiment, the Klugs unveiled a cracked variation of their recreation and uploaded it themselves to a torrent website. However, in the pirated model, [...]
[...] responses from pirates annoyed that piracy is ruining their game development dreams are pretty hilarious, and Greenheart Games promises it doesn’t hate [...]
[...] won’t ruin the best part of the ordeal, but you can check out the full story here. It is worth noting that around ~94% of people who played the game, were doing so on the pirated [...]
[...] bonfire, lead Game Dev Tycoon cofounder Patrick Klug included an unusual, sympathetic comment in his original blog post (which is now unavailable due to heavy traffic–Google cache [...]
[...] 创业公司Greenheart Games刚刚发布了新作《游戏开发大亨(Game Dev Tycoon)》,支持Mac、Windows和Linux平台,无DRM。开发商做了一个试验:同步发布破解版。但这个破解版内含玄机:在玩了数小时后,玩家创办的虚拟游戏公司逐渐壮大,这时候他们会收到一个通知(如图所示)——愈来愈多的玩家用非法下载代替合法购 买,长此以往公司将会倒闭。 [...]
[...] a blog post, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games said that the cracked version made up over 93 percent of all Game [...]
[...] a blog post, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games said that the cracked version made up over 93 percent of all Game [...]
[...] a parking space right next to your favourite café can seem like playing the lottery, but Park Tag wants to change all that. The startup, which is exhibiting at Disrupt NY’s Startup Alley, [...]
[...] a blog post, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games said that the cracked version made up over 93 percent of all Game [...]
[...] a blog post, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games said that the cracked version made up over 93 percent of all Game [...]
[...] a blog post, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games said that the cracked version made up over 93 percent of all Game [...]
[...] Greenheart Games has done something unique, and fascinating, with the release of their brand new game. They released a cracked version of Game Dev Tycoon that contained something that the real version did not. The results show that even people who pirate software become frustrated when someone pirates from them. [...]
[...] On the 28th of april Greenheart Games released Game Dev Tycoon on PC for $7.99/€6,49 which is a decent price for most indie games. At the same time Greenheart Games uploaded their own “cracked version” of the game onto The Pirate Bay, which is a funny thing to do if you want to mildly annoy pirates and maybe encourage them to actually buy your games. Patrick Klug founder of Greenheart Games wrote a bit about it in a blog post; [...]
[...] you liked to read their official post on this, continue on here. I haven’t personally had the chance to try this game out but just maybe I’ll give it a [...]
[...] a blog post published earlier today, Klug outlined how exactly he went about “holding a mirror” to the people that would [...]
[...] a blog post, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games said that the cracked version made up over 93 percent of all Game [...]
[...] a blog post, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games said that the cracked version made up over 93 percent of all Game [...]
[...] a blog post, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games said that the cracked version made up over 93 percent of all Game [...]
[...] a blog post, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games pronounced that a burst chronicle done adult over 93 percent of [...]
[...] a blog publish, Patrick Klug of Greenheart Games stated the cracked version composed over 93 percent of Game Dev [...]
[...] Klug, one half of Greenheart Games’s brotherly duo, wrote an enlightening blog post explaining the choice to release the fake ‘cracked’ version, along with detailing his [...]
[...] Greenheart Games veröffentlichte zudem eine erste Statistik, der zu entnehmen ist, dass am ersten Verkaufstag 93,6 Prozent (3.104 Spieler) der User mit einer gecrackten Version spielten und nur 6,4 Prozent (214 Spieler) die oben erwähnten 6,49 Euro in das Spiel investierten. Alle weiteren Details findet ihr hier. [...]
[...] Greenheart Games [...]