Skip to main content

Marijuana, fights, guns: Zimmerman loses key pretrial battles

By Josh Levs. Graham Winch and Victor Blackwell, CNN
updated 1:30 PM EDT, Tue May 28, 2013
  • NEW: Zimmerman's brother calls on the prosecution to drop the murder charge
  • NEW: A Martin family attorney calls this "a very important day in this case"
  • Some of the banned information may come up at trial if it's proven relevant
  • No delay; the trial will begin June 10, the judge rules

Sanford, Florida (CNN) -- Trayvon Martin's familiarity with guns, his marijuana use, and fights he may have been in cannot be brought up in George Zimmerman's murder trial, the judge overseeing the case ruled Tuesday.

At the hearing two weeks before the scheduled start of the trial, Judge Debra Nelson handed a series of victories to the prosecution when she barred the defense from introducing some information about Martin.

Defense attorneys argued that some of the evidence could prove crucial in backing up Zimmerman's claim of self-defense, depending on what the prosecution argues.

Certain evidence could ultimately be raised during the trial, however, if it is proven relevant and admissible based on what the prosecution presents, the judge decided.

Follow a live blog of Tuesday's hearing at

Nelson left the door open on one issue involving marijuana. Defense attorneys say toxicology tests show Martin had enough THC -- the key active ingredient in marijuana -- in his system to indicate he may have smoked the drug a couple of hours before the shooting. Nelson barred any mention of this from opening statements, but said she will rule later on whether it will be admissible after she hears defense experts' testimony about the marijuana use.

Trayvon Martin in a picture released on Thursday, May 23, by attorneys for George Zimmerman, the neighborhood watch volunteer accused of killing Martin without provocation 14 months ago. The evidence, Zimmerman's attorneys say, paints a different picture of the 17-year-old than the one portrayed by his family and supporters. Trayvon Martin in a picture released on Thursday, May 23, by attorneys for George Zimmerman, the neighborhood watch volunteer accused of killing Martin without provocation 14 months ago. The evidence, Zimmerman's attorneys say, paints a different picture of the 17-year-old than the one portrayed by his family and supporters.
New photos in Trayvon Martin case
New photos in Trayvon Martin case New photos in Trayvon Martin case
George Zimmerman back in court

Marijuana use in general can come up during jury selection, the judge said.

The attorneys also cannot bring up Martin's text messages. The defense argued that texts from the day of the shooting show the teen was "hostile." The judge also agreed to block previous text messages from Martin about drugs and a gun.

Zimmerman, who is out on bail, did not appear at the hearing.

He's charged with second-degree murder in the February 26, 2012, shooting. He was a neighborhood watch volunteer when he called 911 reporting "a suspicious person" in the neighborhood, who turned out to be 17-year-old Martin.

Defense: State didn't turn over some evidence

Nelson did agree, however, to a key request from the defense: to hold a hearing on whether the state failed to turn over some evidence.

The defense called Wesley White, a former employee of the state attorney's office, who said the prosecution did not turn over certain photos -- including one of a firearm in someone's hand -- as well as some deleted text messages.

Nelson agreed to subpoena the state IT investigator who allegedly issued a report about the photos and text messages.

But she denied a defense request for a delay in the start of the trial. Jury selection will begin June 10, she said.

Nelson also granted the prosecution's motion to bar evidence about why it took so long to arrest Zimmerman.

She denied a defense motion asking that the jury be taken to the crime scene, and called it "disingenuous" in light of another defense motion requesting anonymity for the jury.

The jurors will remain anonymous and will be referred to by their numbers only, she said.

Nelson set a hearing for Friday on whether the media will be allowed to show their faces.

Gun, drug texts feature in new evidence

Judge to rule on screaming heard in 911 calls

Defense attorneys also raised questions Tuesday about an analysis that suggests Martin might be heard screaming in the background of a 911 call just before the shooting.

Voice identification experts hired by the prosecution say that they don't know for certain whose voice it is, and that there isn't enough sound to make a conclusive determination.

One analyst, Alan Reich, said he believes Martin can be heard saying the word "stop."

Reich told the Washington Post that he believes the voice is Martin, but another analyst told the Post that no determination can be made.

Defense attorneys said Tuesday that in a deposition on Friday, Reich said he had not completed his report and would need another two weeks.

The defense does not want Reich's analysis admitted.

Judge Nelson ruled that in a hearing at the end of next week, the science being used for voice identification will be discussed, and she will determine whether it is admissible at trial.

If she approves the science as admissible, there's still another barrier for either side to present witnesses using that science. Once the trial begins, when either side wants to call a witness who conducted such an analysis, the judge will consider whether the scientist's qualifications give him or her adequate expertise to weigh in.

Zimmerman will not seek 'stand your ground' hearing

No gold teeth

While defense attorneys had argued in court papers that they may want other details about Martin admitted -- including an assertion that he had removable gold tooth caps -- they agreed Tuesday that they don't expect it to become relevant at trial.

Nelson ruled there will be no such mention in the trial.

Benjamin Crump, an attorney for Martin's family, previously lashed out against the defense for trying to get such details admitted.

"Is the defense trying to prove Trayvon deserved to be killed by George Zimmerman because (of) the way he looked?" Crump asked in a statement. "If so, this stereotypical and closed-minded thinking is the same mindset that caused George Zimmerman to get out of his car and pursue Trayvon, an unarmed kid who he didn't know."

Zimmerman's brother: Drop murder charge

After the hearing, Robert Zimmerman, brother of George, called on the state to drop the second-degree murder charge.

"George lived in a community plagued by crime and was the first to come forward to help his neighbors," he said. "George is a good, decent and honest man. It is now my honor to advocate for him. George is in the fight of his life quite literally. As the oldest son, the only right thing for me to do is deliver him back to our parents. The only right way to do it is by relying on truth. We are not a wealthy family but we are rich in honor."

Authorities initially "did their job when they refused to charge someone with a crime who had committed no crime," Robert Zimmerman said. "In this country, you don't charge someone with any crime solely to assuage the concerns of misinformed masses."

Daryl Parks, another attorney for the Martin family, praised Tuesday's hearing.

"Without question, today was a very important day in this case," he said.

"What was rather clear: All of the bad information put out by the defense team will not be evidence in this case," Parks added.

None of the information that was barred, he argued, "had anything to do" with the confrontation that led to Trayvon Martin being killed.

CNN's Victor Blackwell reported from Sanford, Florida; CNN's Josh Levs and Graham Winch reported from Atlanta. CNN's Jessica Thill and Rich Phillips contributed to this report.

Part of complete coverage on
Trayvon Martin shooting
updated 10:51 AM EST, Tue February 26, 2013
February 26, 2012. That was the day two strangers -- Trayvon Martin, and George Zimmerman -- met for the first and only time.
updated 10:47 AM EST, Tue February 26, 2013
The shooting death of Trayvon Martin one year ago continues to resonate among the consciousness of many Americans.
updated 1:16 PM EST, Tue February 26, 2013
The final, violent moments in the life of their son, Trayvon Martin, no longer dominate the national news, as they once did.
One year after an explosion of press attention, the question seems obvious: Has the news media learned anything about covering race issues in the wake of the Trayvon Martin shooting?
updated 8:55 AM EDT, Thu March 22, 2012
Supporters of Trayvon Martin rallyed in New York's Union Square during a "Million Hoodie March" on Wednesday, March 21, 2012.
updated 4:00 PM EST, Tue February 26, 2013
"Murderer," one e-mail's subject line said. These venom-drenched words are just a smattering of at least 400 e-mails and letters, all sent to George Zimmerman over the past 10 months.
The shooting of Trayvon Martin prompted Florida, and other states, to take another look at the law pivotal to this case, the so-called "stand your ground" law.
updated 7:55 AM EDT, Thu July 19, 2012
George Zimmerman gave his first television interview, saying he had to act after Trayvon Martin said "you are going to die tonight" and reached for Zimmerman's gun holster.
updated 11:13 AM EDT, Fri May 18, 2012
Florida, urged prosecutors to take George Zimmerman into custody after arguing his killing of Trayvon Martin was "ultimately avoidable."
updated 8:50 AM EDT, Wed May 9, 2012
The police chief in Sanford, Florida, said communities should "take a good, hard look at who is selected" for neighborhood watch programs.
updated 11:33 AM EDT, Fri March 30, 2012
Just like most any other teenager, Trayvon Martin enjoyed listening to music, going to the movies and the roller rink with his friends, friends and family said.
The Martin case renewed scrutiny of Florida's 2005 "Stand Your Ground" law -- and others like it.
updated 10:10 PM EDT, Wed April 18, 2012
The judge in George Zimmerman case has received high ratings from defense lawyers but isn't known as a "soft touch."
updated 5:31 PM EST, Mon December 3, 2012
See photos of an injured George Zimmerman that his attorneys say it were taken the night unarmed teen Trayvon Martin was killed in Sanford, Florida.