The photograph that shamed Mexico: Health director suspended after shocking image of indigenous woman giving birth on a clinic LAWN when nurses denied her treatment went viral

  • Pregnant Irma Lopez, 29, and her husband - both ethnic Mazatec - walked October 2 to clinic in Oaxaca, but were turned away by nurses  
  • Photo of grimacing Lopez kneeling on patch of grass outside clinic with her newborn son still attached by umbilical cord set off firestorm online
  • Clinic director Dr Adrian Cruz was suspended pending state and federal investigations 
  • Nurses at health clinic blamed 'misunderstanding' on language barrier and being short-staffed 
  • Mayor of town where clinic is located said in July another woman gave birth on the lawn
  • Nearly one in five women in the state of Oaxaca gave birth outside hospital in 2011

By Daily Mail Reporter and Associated Press Reporter

PUBLISHED: 20:39 EST, 9 October 2013 | UPDATED: 16:23 EST, 10 October 2013


A disturbing photograph of an indigenous woman from Mexico delivering a baby on a patch of grass outside a medical center has set off a firestorm online and sparked a national debate that led to the  head of the clinic that turned the mother away being suspended.  

The shocking image, taken by a passerby, shows 29-year-old Irma Lopez , who is of Mazatec ethnicity, squatting after giving birth, her face contorted in pain and her tiny newborn son still bound by the umbilical cord and lying on the ground.

The government of the southern state of Oaxaca announced Wednesday that it has suspended the health center's director, Dr. Adrian Cruz, while officials conduct state and federal investigations into the October 2 incident.

Scandalous: This disturbing photo of Irma Lopez, 29, squatting in pain outside a Mexican health clinic after giving birth without help from the staff caused outrage after appearing on the front page of La Razon de Mexico

Scandalous: This disturbing photo of Irma Lopez, 29, squatting in pain outside a Mexican health clinic after giving birth without help from the staff caused outrage after appearing on the front page of La Razon de Mexico

Mrs Lopez, a married mother of three, said that she and her husband were turned away from the Rural Health Center of the village of San Felipe Jalapa de Diaz by a nurse who said she was only eight months pregnant and ‘still not ready’ to deliver, even though the woman was reportedly fully dilated.

The couple, who are Mazatecs and do not speak Spanish, could not understand much of what the nurse was telling them beyond the word ‘no,’ so they went outside.

Addressing the controversy later, the nurses blamed the incident on the language barrier and claimed that they did not have enough staff on hand to treat the woman due to a partial work stoppage.

 

More...

An hour and a half later, at 7.30am, the woman’s water broke. Knowing that the time has come, Lopez kneeled on the grass outside the clinic and started pushing while grabbing the wall of a house.

‘I didn't want to deliver like this. It was so ugly and with so much pain,’ she said, adding she was alone for the birth because her husband was trying to persuade the nurse to call for help.

Eloy Pacheco Lopez, who was among a number of people drawn to the site by the mother’s screams, took the photo and gave it to a news reporter. It ran in several national newspapers, including the full front page of the tabloid La Razon de Mexico, and was widely circulated on the Internet.

Happy mother: Irma Lopez stands next to her newborn son Salvador at a clinic in the town of Jalapa de Diaz, Mexico, where a health center director was suspended for failing to help her during birth

Happy mother: Irma Lopez stands next to her newborn son Salvador at a clinic in the town of Jalapa de Diaz, Mexico, where a health center director was suspended for failing to help her during birth

Pacheco López also shared the image on Facebook, writing that 'after waiting and demanding attention for two hours, she gave birth in the yard of the hospital after being ignored by personnel under the direction of the supposed doctor Adrian René Cruz Cabrera,' Latin Times reported.

The case illustrated the shortcomings of maternal care in Mexico, where hundreds of women still die during or right after pregnancy. It also pointed to still persistent discrimination against Mexico's indigenous people persists.

Suspended: Health director Adrian René Cruz Cabrera

Suspended: Health director Adrian René Cruz Cabrera

‘The photo is giving visibility to a wider structural problem that occurs within indigenous communities: Women are not receiving proper care. They are not being offered quality health services, not even a humane treatment,’ said Mayra Morales, Oaxaca's representative for the national Network for Sexual and Reproductive Rights.

Lopez said she and her husband walked an hour in the dark to the clinic from the family's one-bedroom hut in the mountains of northern Oaxaca.

It would have taken them longer to get to the nearest highway to catch a ride to a hospital. She said that from the births of her two previous children, she knew she didn't have time for that.

Silvia Flores, the mayor of the town where then now-infamous medical center is located, told the site Clarin that it was the second time in a year that a woman in labor has given birth on the lawn: in July, another indigenous woman delivered a baby on the same grass patch.

The Mexican federal Health Department said this week that it has sent staff to investigate what happened at the Rural Health Center of the village of San Felipe Jalapa de Diaz.

The National Human Rights Commission also began an investigation after seeing news reports.
Nearly one in five women in the state of Oaxaca gave birth in a place that is not a hospital or a clinic in 2011, according to Mexico's census.

Health officials have urged women to go to clinics to deliver their babies, but many women say the operating hours of the rural centers are limited and staffs small.

Growing brood: The 29-year-old mother of three talks to her children as her newborn son Salvador sleeps on her lap at her hut in the town of Jalapa de Diaz, Mexico

Growing brood: The 29-year-old mother of three talks to her children as her newborn son Salvador sleeps on her lap at her hut in the town of Jalapa de Diaz, Mexico

Although some have praised Mexico for improving its maternal health care, the mortality rate still stands at about 50 deaths per 100,000 births, according to the World Health Organization, similar to Libya, Barbados and Kazakhstan. The U.S. rate is 16 per 100,000.

Oaxaca is one of Mexico's poorest, most rural states and many women have died of hemorrhaging or preeclampsia - a condition causing high blood pressure and possible organ failure.

The Mexican states with the highest indigenous population have the highest rates of maternal deaths, by a wide margin.

Lopez was taken in by the clinic after giving birth and discharged the same day with prescriptions for medications and products that cost her about $30, she said. Health officials say she and her baby were in good health.

She said that poverty-stricken villagers are used to being forgotten by Mexico's health care system and left to fend off for themselves.

‘I am naming him Salvador,’ said Lopez, a name that means ‘Savior’ in English. ‘He really saved himself.’

 

Comments (813)

Share what you think

 View all

The comments below have not been moderated.

Report comment

looks like a job for obamacare...............send Obama down to mexico he has all the answers and he will fix everything.......

4
2
 Click to rate
Report comment

This will also happen under Obamacare soonly ......

15
5
 Click to rate
Report comment

This will happen under Obamacare soonly....

13
6
 Click to rate
Report comment

A dirty ground was probably where the baby was conceived so it seems fitting.

46
3
 Click to rate
Report comment

Omg how horrible!

2
12
 Click to rate
Report comment

Good luck to the mother, baby, dad and rest of family! What a mess. Not only the director, but other front line staff need to go!

3
20
 Click to rate
Report comment

I am ashamed and embarrassed to call myself a human being. We have become so self absorbed, greedy, critical and overbearing. We have no compassion for others who we deem "different". Most wars are started because we don't like other's religions, ideals and differences. How does a human being just walk past another human being who is suffering? I am sadened by what the world has become.

5
36
 Click to rate
Report comment

Some women would pay good money for a 'natural' birth experience alfresco

83
19
 Click to rate
Report comment

The reality is that she could have given birth anywhere but where was her husband or anyone else who could have made sure the baby did not land on the lawn. You also cannot see an umbilical cord. I really wonder if we are being told the full story here - no blood too by the looks of it. If it is real then it should not be happening but I am not too sure.

58
13
 Click to rate
Report comment

You do realise that where the umbilical cord is it is blurred out right? Another point - why was the whole baby blurred out yesterday but now it has been changed to still show the mums face (people complained about this) and now you show the baby?

7
9
 Click to rate
Report comment

It says in the article that she gave birth on the lawn whilst holding onto a house wall for support. Just supposing this photo was taken shortly after birth where is the house wall? Certainly not within arm's reach. This photo is staged if the details in the article are correct.

55
15
 Click to rate

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

Add your comment

By posting your comment you agree to our house rules.

Who is this week's top commenter? Find out now