Recovery and summer are in the air, but doom mongers still lurk
The GDP growth figures announced last week for the second quarter of this year have sent most people away on their holidays in a cheerier mood than last year. The recent weather has certainly helped. But gloomy clouds may hover over the exclusive settings of Tuscan villas and beach houses in Martha’s Vineyard, where bien pensant commentators and so-called Keynesian economists ritually gather for the summer.
How can the recovery be happening when the government is pursuing austerity measures? David Blanchflower, an appointment to the Monetary Policy Committee when Gordon Brown ran the country, predicted that George Osborne’s polices could push unemployment as high as five million, a forecast warmly received in Keynesian circles. The current figure is only half that level.
The confusion within this group is such that there is not even a common line with which to explain the good news away. Nobel Prize winner Joe Stiglitz pronounces on Newsnight that there is no real recovery even in the American economy. His timing was slightly unfortunate in that a couple of days later, the unemployment rate in the US fell to a four-year low. But Shadow Chancellor Ed Balls has been over on the East Coast, conferring with another leading Democrat economist, Larry Summers, the former President of Harvard. Their view is different. America has had a recovery, and ours in the UK would be even better if we had followed expansionary fiscal policies like those of the Obama regime.
One problem with this argument is that the Americans have been busily cutting public sector jobs. Public sector employment is half a million lower than it was three years ago, and the private sector has created five million net new jobs. Here in the UK, the story is the same. Job cuts in the public sector have been easily outweighed by job creation in the private sector.
Keynes himself was fundamentally a monetary economist. In his 1930 book, A Treatise on Money, he argued that if a recession were allowed to gather sufficient momentum, conventional polices carried out by the central bank would fail to correct the situation. He called for what, in his flamboyant style, he described as ‘monetary policy a l’outrance’. By this he meant that the central bank should saturate the market and be willing to take losses on its bond market operations. Both the British and American governments have been following this policy, except that we now call it quantitative easing.
This policy is certainly a key reason why the massive falls in output seen in the 1930s have not been repeated. Recovery has been slower than anyone would like, but the financial crisis of 2007-2009 was exceptionally severe.
Keynes also attached great importance to psychology, to business sentiment, which is very difficult to control. Optimism leads to spending, which feeds back to create even more optimism. American firms have simply been more optimistic than British ones, and this is the key reason why our recovery patterns differ.
Paul Ormerod is an economist at Volterra Partners LLP, a director of the think-tank Synthesis and author of Positive Linking: How Networks Can Revolutionise the World
blog comments powered by Disqus
Unit 4 Macro: John Kay on Quantitative Easing [22 Jul 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: IMF Report on UK Economy calls for Increased Investment [18 Jul 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: Public Social Spending and the Welfare Cap [17 Jul 2013]
Notes from the Economics Teacher Conference [26 Jun 2013]
Bill Phillips’ (of Phillips curve fame) and the ultimate teaching resource [26 Jun 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: The History of Bubbles [25 Jun 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: Croatia Joins the European Union [9 Jun 2013]
UK Economy: Has High Inflation Damaged the Economy? [21 May 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: Does High Home Ownership Cause Unemployment? [13 May 2013]
Analysis of Youth Unemployment [5 May 2013]
UK Economy Revision - Policies to Reduce Unemployment [3 May 2013]
Paul Ormerod: The Reinhardt and Rogoff miscalculation [25 Apr 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: Investment in UK Economy Remains Low [8 Apr 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: Revision on Interest Rates [6 Apr 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: The Great Productivity Puzzle [5 Apr 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: Unemployment in Germany - The Hartz Reforms [4 Apr 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: Growth and Development in Angola [3 Apr 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: Interest Rates and Business Failure Risk [3 Apr 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: Unemployment in Europe (March 2013 Update) [2 Apr 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: Fresh Serving of Acronym Soup - ZIRPs and PLOGs [2 Apr 2013]
Revision Quiz: AS Economics: Monetary Policy (1) [1 Apr 2013]
Revision Quiz: AS Economics: Unemployment (1) [1 Apr 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: Revise and Test - Aggregate Demand [28 Mar 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: Revise and Test - Macro Objectives [27 Mar 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: Revise and Test - The Circular Flow [27 Mar 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: The Fiscal Austerity Debate [13 Mar 2013]
Paul Ormerod: How expert are experts? Time to end the independence of the Bank [7 Mar 2013]
The Governor Offers Lending Advice [6 Mar 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: New research on fiscal austerity and the sovereign debt crisis [1 Mar 2013]
Paul Ormerod: What would Keynes have said? Ouija board active! [1 Mar 2013]
Monetary Policy not as we know it [26 Feb 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: The AAA Credit Rating Downgrade [23 Feb 2013]
Unemployment and hysteresis [10 Feb 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: The UK Economy and the Euro [10 Feb 2013]
The New Guv’nor Hits Town [8 Feb 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: Business Taxes - A Race to the Bottom? [27 Jan 2013]
UK Economy - Triple Dip Recession Looms Large [25 Jan 2013]
Monetary Policy Fest [23 Jan 2013]
Teaching Macro: Introduction to the UK Economy [13 Jan 2013]
Teaching Macro: Charts on the US Economy [13 Jan 2013]
Unit 4 Macro: The Failure of Austerity [5 Jan 2013]
Prospects for the UK Economy in 2013 [2 Jan 2013]
Unit 2 Macro: Unemployment in a Recession [12 Dec 2012]
New Governor New Target New Policy? [12 Dec 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Underemployment in the UK Economy [1 Dec 2012]
Nobel Winner address youth unemployment [22 Nov 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Unemployment Rises as Hovis Factory Closes [21 Nov 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Revision Resources on Inflation and Unemployment [18 Nov 2012]
Bangladesh: As good as it looks on paper? [18 Nov 2012]
Paul Ormerod: Our Friends in the North are trapped in a monetary union [8 Nov 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Ford announces the closure of UK assembly plants [26 Oct 2012]
Monetary Policy in the news [19 Oct 2012]
Paul Ormerod: Policy makers have learned from the mistakes of the 1930s [11 Oct 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: The UK Economy - What Would Keynes Do? [7 Oct 2012]
The Fiscal Cliff - What Could be Done About it? [3 Oct 2012]
60 Second Adventures in Economics- The Impossible Trinity [20 Sep 2012]
60 Second Adventures in Economics - The Phillips Curve [20 Sep 2012]
Unit 4 Macro: What is Economic Development? [8 Sep 2012]
Improving your A2 Macro: Growth Slowdown in World Economy [6 Sep 2012]
Paul Ormerod: How Big is My Multiplier? [6 Sep 2012]
Contour Crafting: Automated Construction as a Destructive Technology [29 Aug 2012]
Unit 4 Macro: Keynesian Insights for Financial Markets [8 Aug 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Youth Unemployment and Startup Milk Rounds [19 Jul 2012]
Unit 4 Macro: Can Spain Remain Competitive? [17 Jul 2012]
Unit 4 Macro: Fiscal Policy in the UK - A Question of Credibility [12 Jul 2012]
More unsettling news on Spain [15 Jun 2012]
End Depression Now! Paul Krugman at the LSE [30 May 2012]
Happy Tax Freedom Day! [29 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Cyclical and Structural Economic Issues Facing the UK [23 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Evaluation on Supply-Side Policies [21 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Positive and Negative Multiplier Effects [20 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Measuring Unemployment in the UK [20 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Measuring Inflation in the UK [20 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Real Interest Rates [20 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: The Output Gap [20 May 2012]
Revision notes on unemployment [20 May 2012]
Unit 1 Micro: Economics of a Minimum Wage [12 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Government Spending [11 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Revision Notes on Supply-side Policies [10 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Monetary Policy and Inflation Glossary [5 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Trade and Balance of Payments Glossary [5 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Unemployment Glossary [5 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Fiscal Policy Glossary [5 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Economic Cycle Glossary [5 May 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Aggregate Demand Glossary [5 May 2012]
Macro Revision - Key Statistics on the UK Economy [4 May 2012]
Unit 1 Micro: Using the Cost-Benefit Principle [30 Apr 2012]
Macro Revision: Putting Things in Context [29 Apr 2012]
Unit 4 Macro: Spanish unemployed head to Argentina [29 Apr 2012]
Unit 4 Macro: The Euro Zone Crisis (Revision) [22 Apr 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Better news on jobs in the UK? [19 Apr 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Skills Shortages Hold Back Recovery [12 Apr 2012]
Superb article on unemployment [8 Apr 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: How the Economic Cycle affects Businesses [6 Apr 2012]
Unit 4 Macro: Floating and Managed Floating Exchange Rates [2 Apr 2012]
Unit 4 Macro: Unemployment Scarring Effects [2 Apr 2012]
Unit 4 Macro: Pain in Spain as Fiscal Austerity Bites [1 Apr 2012]
Unit 2 Macro: Revision on Capital Investment [30 Mar 2012]
Blanchflower calls for more action to address youth jobless crisis [28 Mar 2012]
Life in the Slow Lane - UK Growth in 2011 Lags the Euro Area [28 Mar 2012]
AS & A2 Economics Revision / Exam Coaching Workshops Coming Up:
Monday 11 March 2013 - Portsmouth (Vue, Gunwharf Quays)
Wednesday 13 March 2013 - Fulham (Vue, Fulham Broadway)
Thursday 14 March 2013 - Stratford City (Vue, Westfield)
Friday 15 March 2013 - Bristol (Vue, Cribbs Causeway)
Monday 18 March 2013 - Birmingham (Vue, Star City)
Tuesday 19 March 2013 - Manchester (Vue, Salford Quays)
Thursday 21 March 2013 - Newcastle (Odeon, Metro Centre)
Friday 22 March 2013 - Leeds (Vue, The Light)
Monday 22 April 2013 - Stratford City (Vue, Westfield)
Join over 10,000 Economics teachers who receive our regular Economics Teacher Resource Newsletter:
