Man United 0-3 Liverpool: Two Gerrard penalties and Suarez down Moyes' woeful Reds at Old Trafford... and skipper misses third spot-kick as Vidic is sent off

By Martin Samuel

|

Man United 0-3 Liverpool - Match Zone

Click here for your ultimate stats package from the big game, including Steven Gerrard's defensive heat map for Liverpool

Steven Gerrard heat map vs Manchester United

As the Liverpool players cavorted in one corner, from the Stretford End came a roar of defiance.

They were singing about the number of times Manchester United had been champions. Twenty.

The last came less than a year ago but it already sounds like ancient history. The forlorn rebelliousness that used to be the preserve of Liverpool fans.

Now they look forward on Merseyside. ‘Make us dream,’ read one banner. All the talk was of winning the league; and not in some distant era when it was called Division One, either. Liverpool have a chance in the here and now.

They are four points behind leaders Chelsea, with a game in hand, to be played at home against Sunderland on March 26. Manchester City and Chelsea also have to visit Anfield in April. And this is a team in form.

VIDEO Scroll down for Brendan Rodgers and David Moyes' post-match analysis

Unbelievable: Luis Suarez celebrates after scoring the third in the 3-0 win at Old Trafford

Unbelievable: Luis Suarez celebrates after scoring the third in the 3-0 win at Old Trafford

Mind the gap: Liverpool are now 14 points clear of United and just four points off leaders Chelsea

Mind the gap: Liverpool are now 14 points clear of United and just four points off leaders Chelsea

Slotted home: Suarez scores to round off the 3-0 victory and put Liverpool to within four points of Chelsea

Slotted home: Suarez scores to round off the 3-0 victory and put Liverpool to within four points of Chelsea

Contrast: Suarez gives his side the thumbs up as Wayne Rooney complains to his team-mates

Contrast: Suarez gives his side the thumbs up as Wayne Rooney complains to his team-mates

Togetherness: Liverpool were outstanding at Old Trafford, despite United's indiscipline

Togetherness: Liverpool were outstanding at Old Trafford, despite United's indiscipline

All together: Liverpool boosted their title hopes with the win at Old Trafford

All together: Liverpool boosted their title hopes with the win at Old Trafford

Up and down: United are now 14 points behind Liverpool, who are now major contenders for the title

Up and down: United are now 14 points behind Liverpool, who are now major contenders for the title

Penalty king: Gerrard celebrates scoring his second from the spot just after half-time at Old Trafford

Penalty king: Gerrard celebrates scoring his second from the spot just after half-time at Old Trafford

One up: Liverpool's Steven Gerrard scores the opening goal of the game from the penalty spot

One up: Liverpool's Steven Gerrard scores the opening goal of the game from the penalty spot

Match facts

Man Utd: De Gea 6, Rafael 5,Jones 5, Vidic 5, Evra 5.5, Fellaini  5 (Cleverley 76, 6), Carrick 5, Mata 4.5 (Ferdinand 87), Rooney 4.5, Januzaj 5 (Welbeck 76, 6), Van Persie 4.5.

Subs: Lindegaard, Young, Valencia, Kagawa.

Booked: Rafael, Vidic.

Sent off: Vidic

Liverpool: Mignolet 7, Johnson 7, Skrtel 8, Agger 7.5, Flanagan 7.5, Henderson 7.5, Gerrard 8.5 (Lucas 87), Allen 8, Sterling 6 (Coutinho 72, 6), Sturridge 8, (Aspas 90+1), Suarez 8.

Subs: Brad Jones, Moses, Sakho, Cissokho.

Booked: Flanagan, Gerrard, Skrtel, Sturridge

Goals: Gerrard pen 34, pen 46, Suarez 84

Man of the match: Steven Gerrard

Referee: Mark Clattenburg (Tyne & Wear)

*Player ratings by Ian Ladyman at Old Trafford

Justice was done at Old Trafford. The scoreline did not flatter Liverpool in the least, adding to the feeling of sea change.

Liverpool have been coming to Manchester for 118 years and have won away to United on just 16 occasions.

Even when they were the best team in the land this was not a happy hunting ground. 'I’ve come here and been played off the park,' said man of the match Steven Gerrard. 'To come here and dominate from start to finish was a good feeling.'

Gerrard scored two penalties and missed a third, a fair return considering the first two were correctly awarded and the third wasn’t.

Liverpool could have had another two penalties from referee Mark Clattenburg, however, and Manchester United should have been reduced to ten men after 34 minutes, so the champions got off lightly.

Near the end, with captain Nemanja Vidic dismissed – wrongly, it really wasn’t Clattenburg’s best day – David Moyes sent on Rio Ferdinand for Juan Mata.

Already trailing 3-0 with just three minutes of normal time remaining it seemed a bizarre move, but Moyes was merely trying to prevent complete humiliation – two late goals to establish the type of margin that can get a manager the sack. Even one with a six-year contract.

It is easy, of course, to observe everything that happens at Old Trafford through the lens of Manchester United’s failings, as if the opposition are incidental.

From the spot: Liverpool celebrate Gerrard's opening goal in the 34th minute

From the spot: Liverpool celebrate Gerrard's opening goal in the 34th minute

Accusation: Nemanja Vidic screams at Liverpool's Daniel Sturridge after conceding the third penalty

Accusation: Nemanja Vidic screams at Liverpool's Daniel Sturridge after conceding the third penalty

Disbelief: Manchester United fans show their emotions in the stands as their side crumble

Disbelief: Manchester United fans show their emotions in the stands as their side crumble

Risky challenge: Sturridge is awarded a penalty kick from a challenge by Nemanja Vidic

Risky challenge: Sturridge is awarded a penalty kick from a challenge by Nemanja Vidic

No need: Phil Jones clumsily hauled down Joe Allen inside the area just after the break

No need: Phil Jones clumsily hauled down Joe Allen inside the area just after the break

All yours: Gerrard celebrates as Wayne Rooney scratches his head in dismay

All yours: Gerrard celebrates as Wayne Rooney scratches his head in dismay

Back again: Gerrard celebrates scoring the second goal by kissing the camera, just as he did five years ago

Back again: Gerrard celebrates scoring the second goal by kissing the camera, just as he did five years ago

Jubliation: Gerrard and Suarez slide in front of the travelling Liverpool fans after going 2-0 up

Jubliation: Gerrard and Suarez slide in front of the travelling Liverpool fans after going 2-0 up

Everywhere: Steven Gerrard's touch map at Old Trafford (attacking goal at top)

Everywhere: Steven Gerrard's touch map at Old Trafford (attacking goal at top)

Yet this would do Liverpool and Brendan Rodgers a terrible disservice. They won thanks to their own sharpness and good planning, not merely because United are a team in steep decline.

Liverpool had the better defence, the livelier midfield, the most dangerous forward line. Only Wayne Rooney, of the men in red, did not deserve to be on the losing side and even his performance was more perspiration than inspiration.

As for Liverpool, where to start? How about at left-back where in Jon Flanagan the club appears to have found its equivalent of Gary Neville: the local lad with a grudge against the rivals and a uniquely personal appreciation of this fixture.

Flanagan – sent off in a reserve match here last season for a minor assault on Adnan Januzaj – embodied Liverpool’s spirit. His energy level, his combativeness, were both on the north side of high.

He was first in the book after 31 minutes but that didn’t stop him clattering into Rafael in the second-half – fairly, despite the Brazilian’s histrionics – and playing with a level of commitment that demonstrated what clubs lose when they stop mining talent close to home. Gerrard was very much a man on a mission, too.

Camera friendly: Gerrard kisses the lens after scoring in Liverpool's 4-1 victory at Old Trafford in March 2009

Camera friendly: Gerrard kisses the lens after scoring in Liverpool's 4-1 victory at Old Trafford in March 2009

It's me again: Liverpool's skiper seeks out the cameraman in the corner flag

It's me again: Liverpool's skiper seeks out the cameraman in the corner flag

Familiar ground: Gerrard kisses the camera at Old Trafford, as he did in 2009 and 2010

Familiar ground: Gerrard kisses the camera at Old Trafford, as he did in 2009 and 2010

Legend of the game: Maradona looking on in the crowd at Old Trafford

Legend of the game: Maradona looking on in the crowd at Old Trafford

Top bin: Gerrard hit the first penalty perfectly, sending De Gea the wrong way

Top bin: Gerrard hit the first penalty perfectly, sending De Gea the wrong way

Over the top: Gerrard is jumped on by Luis Suarez after putting Liverpool ahead

Over the top: Gerrard is jumped on by Luis Suarez after putting Liverpool ahead

No second yellow: Suarez appeals for the penalty before claiming Rafael should have been sent off

No second yellow: Suarez appeals for the penalty before claiming Rafael should have been sent off

Yet Liverpool’s triumph was that, all over the pitch, players were putting their bodies on the line for this win. Luis Suarez was outstanding, as he has been all season, and the defence, including goalkeeper Simon Mignolet, held firm.

Not that United offered the most testing resistance. It took them until the 44th minute to carve out a real opportunity, when great work from Januzaj put Rafael in, and his cross found Rooney who forced an excellent save from Mignolet, followed by a brave block from Martin Skrtel.

Robin Van Persie, insipid to say the least, missed with a header and a shot in the second-half, Wayne Rooney struck a free-kick high in injury time and Marouane Fellaini skied the ball widly, the one chance he had, but it was meagre fare.

Stretching: Fellaini attempts to knock the ball beyond Liverpool full-back Jon Flanagan

Stretching: Fellaini attempts to knock the ball beyond Liverpool full-back Jon Flanagan

Flying in: Daniel Sturridge of Liverpool is challenged by Nemanja Vidic

Flying in: Daniel Sturridge of Liverpool is challenged by Nemanja Vidic

Luis Suarez's heat map vs Manchester United- click here for more from our Match Zone service

Luis Suarez heat map vs Manchester United

Head down: Rooney says the 3-0 defeat to Liverpool was a nightmare

Head down: Rooney says the 3-0 defeat to Liverpool was a nightmare

Down and out: Fellaini walks off at half-time after a poor opening 45 minutes for United

Down and out: Fellaini walks off at half-time after a poor opening 45 minutes for United

FROM THE SPOT

Liverpool have now won 126 penalties in the Premier League, more than any other side

United had few answers to Liverpool’s movement and ingenuity, which perhaps explains why this was a match decided on penalties, yet lasting no more than 90 minutes.

It was just three minutes old when Daniel Sturridge had his first crack at goal and only five minutes had gone when the visitors should have had their first penalty.

It is a familiar scene now, the referee waving away an appeal from Suarez only for the replay to show the Uruguayan was more than justified. Yes, he used to dive, but he doesn’t any more. Can’t they accept that now, and start treating him like the other strikers?

Absent again: Striker Robin van Persie picks himself up off the ground

Absent again: Striker Robin van Persie picks himself up off the ground

Flattened: Manchester United's Wayne Rooney lies flat out on the Old Trafford pitch

Flattened: Manchester United's Wayne Rooney lies flat out on the Old Trafford pitch

No room to breathe: Rooney is surrounded by Liverpool players as he attempts to make inroads

No room to breathe: Rooney is surrounded by Liverpool players as he attempts to make inroads

Having a word: Jordan Henderson of Liverpool protests to referee Mark Clattenburg

Having a word: Jordan Henderson of Liverpool protests to referee Mark Clattenburg

On this occasion, Suarez deserved two penalties, Fellaini having one crack at him that made him stumble, and then a second that made him fall. Clattenburg waved both away, setting the standard for his performance.

TOP PREMIER LEAGUE PENALTY SCORERS

1. Alan Shearer 56

2. Frank Lampard 43

3. Steven Gerrard 26

4. Matt Le Tissier 25

In the 31st minute, Rafael caught Gerrard late and was booked and just three minutes later he deliberately handled while trying to stop Suarez, and wasn’t.

A penalty was given, and in front of the Stretford End, but Clattenburg choked on the bigger call. Rafael’s handball was impossible to ignore and not one of those unfortunate ones, either.

Suarez dinked it past him on the by-line and, realising he had been beaten, the right-back patted it down. It wasn’t a deflection, he wasn’t off balance, he had plenty of time to get his arm out of the way.

All cut up: Fellaini shows his battle wounds after a challenge from Steven Gerrard

All cut up: Fellaini shows his battle wounds after a challenge from Steven Gerrard

Just enough: Phil Jones just manages to get a touch on the ball as Suarez moves past

Just enough: Phil Jones just manages to get a touch on the ball as Suarez moves past

Surrounded: David Moyes started with Marouane Fellaini at Old Trafford, but he struggled early on

Surrounded: David Moyes started with Marouane Fellaini at Old Trafford, but he struggled early on

Hefty challenge: Robin van persie slides through Jon Flanagan early on at Old trafford

Hefty challenge: Robin van persie slides through Jon Flanagan early on at Old trafford

Robin van Persie's sparse heat map vs Liverpool - click here for more from our Match Zone service

Robin van Persie heat map vs Liverpool

In his wake: Jon Flanagan of Liverpool skips past Juan Mata early on

In his wake: Jon Flanagan of Liverpool skips past Juan Mata early on

It was cheating, pure and simple, yet Clattenburg chose to manage the game rather than apply the rules, and kept 11 against 11.

It really is a curse, this latest trend. Gerrard put the ball smartly to David De Gea’s left – but Clattenburg’s faintheartedness could have conjured a travesty.

Had the score stayed at 1-0 for a length of time, who knows if Liverpool might have been vulnerable to pressure? As it was, from the first attack of the second-half, United cracked and lost the game.

Jordan Henderson chipped the ball into the penalty where Joe Allen was bundled over by Phil Jones, whose clumsiness is hardly a defensive asset, and Clattenburg’s decision summoned Gerrard into action again, doubling Liverpool’s lead.

50/50: Manchester United's Marouane Fellaini (right) challenges Liverpool's Raheem Sterling

50/50: Manchester United's Marouane Fellaini (right) challenges Liverpool's Raheem Sterling

Foul: Liverpool's Jon Flanagan (right) pulls back Manchester United's Wayne Rooney

Foul: Liverpool's Jon Flanagan (right) pulls back Manchester United's Wayne Rooney

No problems: Patrice Evra and Luis Suarez shake hands prior to the match at Old Trafford

No problems: Patrice Evra and Luis Suarez shake hands prior to the match at Old Trafford

By the time Gerrard stepped up to attempt a hat-trick of penalties, United were in disarray.

The replays showed Vidic did not make contact with Sturridge, and the Manchester United man was furious with his opponent, complaining bitterly to him even after the red card had been shown, but it was hard to have too much sympathy.

Vidic had gone in rashly, and forcefully, on a player running fast in the penalty area. It really was an accident waiting to happen. The same could not be said of Gerrard’s kick, having scored at that moment 30 of his last 33.

Long time coming: Liverpool are looking to win the title for the first time since 1990

Long time coming: Liverpool are looking to win the title for the first time since 1990

Looking down: Former United manager Sir Alex Ferguson takes his seat before the start of the game

Looking down: Former United manager Sir Alex Ferguson takes his seat before the start of the game

He missed. Hit the left post to ensure United would not be punished twice. And if Sturridge did make a meal of Vidic’s challenge there was payback four minutes later when he was plainly tripped by Michael Carrick but Clattenburg waved his appeal away.

Suarez got the better of Jones after 83 minutes, forcing a brilliant save from De Gea, but the Spaniard was powerless a minute later when a scuffed Sturridge shot fell at Suarez’s feet for only his second league goal since January.

The numerical distance between the teams was now reflective of the gulf on the day.

The home fans tried to drown out Liverpool’s celebrations, but it would appear Manchester United now have another set of noisy neighbours, and some very thin walls.

 

 
 

 

 

The comments below have not been moderated.

As a spurs "fan" (the less said the better) I would really love to see Liverpool win the league. They play football as it should be played, exciting, attacking football. When Liverpool went 1-0 up at spurs, they kept on attacking , when arsenal went 1-0 up at spurs, they sat back and were boring. Rooting for you Liverpool.

0
3
Click to rate

Can we play u ever week manc?

0
2
Click to rate

I think the most hilarious comment I read today was a united fan saying that after moyes gets sacked the next manager will kick off another 20yrs of domination......are you fans blind? or just plain dumb? United's time is over-SAF was special-had this sad pathetic excuse of a football club playing well over their potential. except for maybe RVP and rooney, everybody else is terrible. face it reds it is OVER! Serves most of you fair weather fans right, since the only reason you ever found yourself rooting for united is because of their success. so enjoy the next few yrs of Europa league. that's if you can qualify lol love it

1
15
Click to rate

I do think moyes is good coach but man United have a squad that are not good enough. also the players aren't playing for him giving 100 percent there body language is poor. From a Liverpool point the longer the season's gone on the better we have become and long may it continue.

1
11
Click to rate

Watching united at the moment makes me physically vomit and I'm a united fan.

5
6
Click to rate

dear david take some advice, you look awful ,it is taking its toll on your health, get out before you sadly suffer a stroke or heart attack from the worry and stress.........it is not worth it all, believe me , you have aged 30 years......look after your body.

1
8
Click to rate

MANUGIRL What's up with you? Are you angry cause most of the united fans left in the 70th min and your use to having most of them hanging out the back of you???? Now stop moaning and go give your dad a gobble.

4
3
Click to rate

jimbojamesrobson is very conspicuous by his absence....maybe the news hasn't reached new york yet??! good result for lfc but if we want a strong showing in the CL we need united in the top four. ..arsenal and city haven't got a jar of glue!!

8
6
Click to rate

Top Tool Granpard scored 8 goal from penalties. Not a top top player he lives of scraps from Sewerez and Sluridge dives. Come on now show us your PL medals.

40
7
Click to rate

Real, er, 'quick draw' comment that.....

1
11
Click to rate

Perhaps you should go down the mountain as it appears the thin air is affecting your ability to think clearly?

0
0
Click to rate

hilarious how much uni-ted have fallen. there in shambles and the refs are finally not worried about giving decisions against them like they were with saf. also if moyes wont play mata in central attacking midfield then he shouldnt of bought him. mata is not a winger and will make him a lesser player. even if things get worse for uni-ted to the point they want moyes replaced, who can they replace moyes with????? lol.

1
22
Click to rate

COCO THE CLOWN.LOL

0
10
Click to rate

They need to use the formation we used - midfield diamond with Mata at the top and RVP and Rooney as 2 traditional strikers - but have they got 3 midfielders who could do the job behind them? At the moment the answer is a big, fat no. Fellani did well against West Brom but he was awful today against decent opposition.

0
5
Click to rate

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

By posting your comment you agree to our house rules.

Who is this week's top commenter? Find out now