اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter


Analysis: Palestinian unity and Israeli arrogance
Published Thursday 05/06/2014 (updated) 08/06/2014 17:13
Font- Font+

Daoud Kuttab is a Palestinian journalist and former professor of journalism at Princeton University.

Politicians the world over weigh their decision and statements on numerous levels: What will be their effect on the position, will they work and how will they affect the politicians' long-term career.

Israeli leaders, especially Premier Benjamin Netanyahu, do not appear to care about the consequences of their position, nor if it will work.

Netanyahu's only preoccupation appears to be pandering to his right-wing constituency in the hope that this will carry him to an unprecedented fourth term.

Take his position on Iran, for example. He went against the world, confronted Israel's strongest ally and failed miserably.

Analysts would say that Netanyahu's overreach was calculated. He exaggerated the Israeli fears of Iran even though his intelligence sources informed him that Iran was moderating its position after the victory of Hassan Rouhani.

Israel's exaggerated position regarding the new Ramallah government also fails to follow normal political calculations.

Netanyahu knew very well that the new government did not have any Hamas members, that it would not be supported by a vote by Hamas legislature and that it will abide by the three conditions set by the International Quartet (under Israeli pressure) in 2007.

Any basic survey of the expected reaction of the world community, including of the Obama administration, would have easily revealed that Washington and Brussels support the new Palestinian government.

Sure enough, in both cases, Netanyahu's outreach has failed to move the world community, including the US. The Obama administration has continued its peaceful negotiations with Iran undeterred and appears to be making progress in restraining any possible nuclear ambition in Tehran.

On the Palestinian front, Netanyahu struck out even quicker and clearer. The US, the EU and the UN have all issued statements of recognition of and support for the new Palestinian unity government, which has publicly committed to continue Mahmoud Abbas' policies.

Hamas leaders in Gaza voluntarily gave up their government seats and publicly approved the new government's policies, which include the two-state solution and adherence to previous agreements.

Ironically, even the pro-Israel lobby group AIPAC has been silent on the new government, except to repeat the known conditions of the Quartet.

So why does Netanyahu do what he does?

Why does a leader of a country take such a radical position on issues that, by all indications, the world community would not accept?

Has Netanyahu's arrogance reached such levels that he thinks he can sway world powers just by saying no to an issue?

Are Israel and its leaders so drunk with power and influence that they refuse to listen to levelheaded advice and experts' forecasts?

Israeli pundits have been calling on their prime minister to get out of his self-imposed isolation and become aware of the fact that the world does not move according to his whims and statements.

Of course, one should not discount the ideological angle, that for decades Netanyahu has trapped himself in an ideological profile and that it is difficult to get out of this straitjacket.

Those who follow Netanyahu know that he is a politician and that he changed his ideological positions in the past.

A more convincing argument for his attitude is political. Netanyahu is pandering to the right-wing Israelis that have become the majority of the population in Israel.

It appears that the influence of the settler ideology is so strong that no Israeli politician can survive elections without speaking their ideological lingo.

As a political animal, Netanyahu probably made the calculation that he can easier withstand international or even US pressure than pressure from his own right-wing politicians.

It seems that Netanyahu must choose between peace with Palestinians and the world or peace with Israeli settlers and the right-wing ideologues.

The views expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily reflect Ma'an News Agency's editorial policy.
1 ) Joe / USA
05/06/2014 22:44
Netanyahu turn to the right-wing extremists to hold on to his government. It is getting weaker by the day by the international pressure and the US pressure to keep the talks going. There is no doubt that all the hateful crimes against Mosques and Churches was the doing of Netanyahu's government a help of right-wing extremists. He chose them to survive in the area. It is sad when you have a government like Israel that chose hatred propaganda than having peace.

2 ) Brian Cohen / Israel
07/06/2014 07:19
Hellooooo......Daoud are you there? Reality check time! You seem to have forgotten that "Arab unity" is an oxymoron. It's still the same Hamas who followed up the killing of hundreds of Fatah members in Gaza by chasing down and blowing the legs off of dozens more to send a "message" - great documentary about this on the TIME magazine website that Kuttab should watch to get himself back into the real world. Hamas is desperate for money, that's the only reason they are "united", for now...

3 ) Mel / USA
07/06/2014 22:29
#2: Helloooo....Brain,are you there? And you think you have a sense of reality?Your reality is not exactly kosher!It's washed &edited; Jabo-crap!You've swallowed all the KKK(KachKahanistKoolaid)& have delusions about Israel being a democratic"victim",LOL!And,you're selective in your examples by omitting that Fatah/PA led a Zionist-OK'd COUP on Gaza,to usurp democracy(taboo in Judocracy for Jews Israel).U need to write a little Red Book,or Green Book? Or maybe Brian's Z Book?LOL!

4 ) Brian Cohen / Israel
08/06/2014 09:03
For those interested, here is the link to the TIME article: http://content.time.com/time/video/player/0,32068,85555888001_1991530,00.html warning: disturbing video content of men with legs shot off learning to walk again.

5 ) Michael Collins / Eire
08/06/2014 21:55
#Brian 2/4 - Your posts never cease to amaze me. No doubt the latest offering will be similar to those put out in the 'troubles' about people who were shot in the kneecaps. At least TIME is a reputable agency, so you've gone a bit up market there. As to watching it, not sure, I might picture you gloating, as I sat & watched all that human suffering (which is a bit hard to take really).

6 ) Tom / USA
09/06/2014 18:40
To the zio-pimps (like Brian): " They call this war a cloud over the land, but they made the weather and then they stand in the rain and say 'Shit it's rain'n" Ruby, Cold Mountain

7 ) Outlier / USA
09/06/2014 19:21
Two things remain absolutely certain; both sides will have to cede long-held dreams in a peace settlement and both sides will hate the settlement. That said, the alternative to a peace settlement is the current situation, which cannot last indefinitely.
Name Country
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.


Analysis: Israeli restrictions on movement strangle Palestinian life
Analysis: What does British vote to recognize State of Palestine mean?
Analysis: Free speech vs. freedom

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2014