Joint replacements and IVF could be rationed to save money

Home Top

show ad

Home Top

Child star of Everybody Loves Raymond commits suicide at 19: Actor who played Ray Romano's twin son shoots himself dead
Was Baltimore suspect killed by deadly paddy wagon 'nickel ride'? Freddie Gray was NOT wearing a seatbelt and may have been tossed to death in abusive practice that's killed before
Apple smartwatch on sale from today... but not in stores: Customers will have to wait until June to get delivery after ordering online
Mystery of the passing out passengers remains unsolved: Investigation finds NOTHING wrong with plane which was forced to dive 30,000ft as people on board lost consciousness
The IKEA relationship curse! Experts warn trips to the store can spell doom for couples and say loved-up patrons must avoid hard-to-build item known as the 'Divorcemaker'
Woman who shot her lawyer boyfriend dead as he tried to split up with her before his date with beauty queen is guilty of murder
Our climate models are WRONG: Global warming has slowed - and recent changes are down to 'natural variability', says study
Why Lenin's corpse looks better with age: Scientists reveal experimental embalming methods used on the Soviet leader
Back to work! Disgraced ESPN sports reporter Britt McHenry returns to the sideline this weekend just a week after furore over vicious verbal attack on tow clerk
Judge who stunned the nation by saying a 14-year-old was partly responsible for her own RAPE receives a lifetime achievement award
Two extra bodies on drone cam were first sign that strike had gone terribly wrong: CIA officials tell of shocking realization that they might have killed innocent hostages
Wife of American in drone strike condemns the White House for treating her husband as an 'annoyance'
American jihadist killed in drone strike was former Little Leaguer who grew up to become Osama Bin Laden's spokesman
A hug from the executioner... then two gay men are stoned to death: ISIS murderers stage show of kindness for the cameras before brutal killing
'ISIS militant' from San Diego who was caught out by his AK-47 Facebook photos is charged with lying to the FBI
'We came to this country looking for peace': Families of Minnesota ISIS suspects accuse FBI of setting them up
Dzohokar Tsarnev's family - but not his mother - arrive in the US ahead of his defense testimony
Trial hears how Boston victim Martin Richard, 8, suffered 'visceral pain' before he died as jury decides if Dzohkar Tsarnaev should be executed
Male student sues Columbia over backlash he suffered after classmate carried a mattress around campus and accused him of raping her
EXCLUSIVE: Bill Cosby confidential: Disgraced comic files papers to prevent release of his sealed deposition in 2005 sexual assault lawsuit settled out of court
Three new women accuse Bill Cosby of sexual assault: Alleged victims say they were drugged by star in claims that bring total number of accusations to 38
WNBA star Brittney Griner, 6'8", arrested after argument with her 6'3" fiancee turned physical and relatives were unable to break them up
Dr. Oz comes out fighting! 'America's physician' says he's being hounded for speaking out against GM foods
'I was a survivor and I LOVED my life': Young mother, 44, writes heartbreaking obituary for herself before she passes away after long battle with cancer

More than a third of health trusts are considering rationing some surgery
Several admit they may impose 'eligibility' rules refusing some patients
Obese patients could be denied knee and hip replacements and breast ops
While smokers may be told they cannot have IVF procedures on the NHS

By Sophie Borland, Health Correspondent for the Daily Mail

Published: 10:01 EST, 22 April 2015 | Updated: 02:22 EST, 23 April 2015

340

View
comments

Patients who are too fat could be denied routine operations to save money, a survey of health bosses has revealed.

More than a third of NHS trusts are considering rationing some types of surgery and other treatments.

Several have admitted they may impose 'eligibility' rules which could affect smokers as well as the overweight.

More than a third of health trusts are considering rationing some types of surgery and other treatments to save money, according to a new study

The criteria for accepting patients for operations would be based on their Body Mass Index, which measures obesity.

When senior managers at 67 Clinical Commissioning Groups – local health trusts – were asked, 39 per cent said they were planning to 'limit access' to routine treatment for financial reasons.

Procedures affected include varicose vein treatment, hip and knee replacement, and breast reduction surgery. Others said smokers might be denied some treatments, most commonly IVF.

Senior doctors criticised the plans and accused health managers of denying patients vital treatment simply because they were considered to be 'undeserving'.

Dr David Paynton, of the Royal College of GPs, said: 'Decisions about whether our patients are eligible for surgery or treatment need to be made on a case-by-case basis and by whether surgery will benefit a patient's long-term physical and mental health.

'It should not be the role of CCGs to impose blanket bans on patients' access to surgery, nor to decide who is and who is not deserving of potentially life-saving treatments based on their lifestyle choices.

Obese patients could be denied varicose vein treatment, hip and knee replacement, pictured, and breast reduction surgery, while smokers could be banned from having IVF on the NHS

'Of course, some procedures cannot be performed on patients who are above a certain weight.

'In these cases, a clinical decision needs to be made about whether surgery would be beneficial if the patient lost weight – but this is a separate issue.'

It is easy to target vulnerable patients and we must be very careful not to unfairly discriminate against people who aren't always able to speak out

Katherine Murphy, chief executive of the Patients Association

Katherine Murphy, chief executive of the Patients Association, said: 'Each case must be individually assessed and each decision must be ethical and in the best interests of the patient.

'It is easy to target vulnerable patients and we must be very careful not to unfairly discriminate against people who aren't always able to speak out.'

A Conservative Party spokesman said: 'If health bodies stop patients from having treatments on the basis of cost alone, then we will take action against them.'

There are 211 CCGs in England so the survey by the Health Service Journal covered just under a third.

Last year, a CCG in Devon threatened to ban all non-urgent treatments for anyone severely obese with a BMI above 35. This is equivalent to a 5ft 6in woman of 16st or a 6ft man being 18st 13lb. After an outcry, the policy was dropped.

A survey by GP magazine last month found that 80 per cent of CCGs ration at least one procedure to patients who are very obese.

DOCTORS: SUGAR, NOT LAZINESS, DRINKING OR SMOKING, MAKES US FAT

Doctors have blamed excess sugar and carbohydrates for the surge in obesity – not the lack of exercise.

They said poor diet was now recognised as being responsible for more disease than physical inactivity, alcohol and smoking combined.

Yet, said the experts led by cardiologist Dr Aseem Malhotra, the public wrongly believed that obesity was due to a sedentary lifestyle.

The doctors claimed that obesity has rocketed in the past 30 years, despite little change in physical activity levels.

‘This places the blame for our expanding waistlines directly on the type and amount of calories consumed,’ said Dr Malhotra.

‘Let us bust the myth of physical inactivity and obesity. You cannot outrun a bad diet.’

In the British Journal Of Sports Medicine, the doctors added that the ‘false perception’ on the cause of obesity stems from corporate marketing ‘chillingly similar’ to that used by the tobacco industry. They cited Coca-Cola associating its products with sport ‘suggesting it is OK to consume their drinks as long as you exercise’.

Dr Malhotra, who works at Frimley Park Hospital, Surrey, is an adviser to the campaign group Action on Sugar. Around two-thirds of Britons are overweight or obese.

The Government’s obesity adviser Professor Susan Jebb said the doctors failed to note that the best way to lose weight was combining a better diet with physical activity.

‘Rather than trade one off against the other – sugar vs fat, diet vs activity, individual vs population – we need to take action across the full range,’ she added.

Tackling obesity without addressing physical activity was ‘tying one hand behind our backs’ said the professor. ‘It makes good sense to seek to change both diet and activity behaviours.’