Did exaggerated records make global warming look worse? Scientists to investigate whether 'adjusted' temperatures skewed data
- Climate sceptic group Global Warming Policy Foundation launch inquiry
- Panel drawn from leading universities includes experts with differing views
- Will look at whether 'adjustments' made to records cancel each other out
- Says it hopes people from all areas of climate change will help the panel
An international panel of scientists will today launch a major inquiry to discover whether official world temperature records have exaggerated the extent of global warming.
The panel, convened by the Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF), the ‘climate sceptic’ think-tank led by the former Tory Chancellor Lord Lawson, will focus on thousands of ‘adjustments’ that have been made to temperature records kept at individual weather stations around the world.
Sceptics have argued that the effect of such adjustments – made when instruments are replaced or recalibrated, or heat-producing buildings are erected close to weather station sites – has skewed the records.
Sceptics: The panel will look at whether 'adjustments' made to temperature records around the world have made climate change appear
The panel will also examine ‘extrapolations’ – when the records include virtual figures from places where there is no actual measuring station, instead basing them on the figures of other stations in the same region. In some areas, such as the Arctic, these may be hundreds of miles away. Sceptics claim that the effect of the adjustments is usually to revise temperatures from decades ago downwards, and to increase recent readings, so that the warming trend of the past 150 years looks larger than it really is.
The panel has been drawn from leading universities around the
Panel member Professor William van Wijngaarden, a physicist and climate expert from York University in Toronto, said he had been concerned about the records’ quality for many years, after noticing that when you examined an individual station ‘you’ll see a sudden jump’.
Such jumps, he said, were not natural, but the product of adjustments. ‘Sometimes you get “corrected” data without knowing exactly how it has been changed. I’m a scientist. I’m not going into this with any preconceptions. But if some of the corrections have not been properly made, then we’ll find out. We want to see all the actual station data.
Dr Benny Peiser, the GWPF director, said the panel would try to look at all the thousands of stations whose data goes into the three main world temperature records – those kept by the Met Office, Nasa, and the US government agency that deals with weather.
Tensions: The group have brought together people from all sides of the debate to look
‘The question is, do the adjustments balance each other out?’ he asked. ‘Do they make half the stations a little warmer, and half a little cooler, or is there evidence of bias?
‘It may turn out there is no problem. It may that there is.
He said the panel’s work would be ‘transparent’, with all data made available
The panel’s chairman is Professor Terence Kealey, former vice-chancellor of the University of Buckingham. He
‘We hope to perform a valuable public service by getting everything out into the open.
‘We hope that people who are concerned
- Terrifying moment Great White shark attacks boat in NZ
- Moment drunken model was 'slammed to the ground' by cops
- Terrifying moment avalanche hits Everest base camp
- CCTV in Kathmandu catches the moment earthquake struck
- News reporter robbed at Baltimore protest LIVE on camera
- Eerie scenes as Kathmandu sky fills with birds after...
- Bruce Jenner reveals he 'is a woman' in emotional interview
- Three women jailed following Russian WWII memorial 'twerk'
- Surveillance footage shows scale of violent Nepalese...
- 7.9 magnitude earthquake in Nepal that caused Everest...
- Inside the avalanche: Climber films as they struggle to...
- Cecily Strong lays into the Washington Hilton and Secret...
- 'We're in a race against time to get off': Desperate rescue...
- Images of transgender prisoner whose face was 'pulverized'...
- Number of Americans missing in Nepal rises: Families hunt...
- Miracle of the Mengele babies: Truly astounding story of how...
- Drunken model left scarred for life after cops 'grabbed her...
- EXCLUSIVE: 'They have never been apart': Relatives share...
- Over 75? Sign here if you're ready for death: GPs to ask ALL...
- Oil exec and his son shot dead 'execution-style' by heavily-...
- Freddie Gray protesters in Baltimore steal reporter's...
- Woman unearths whopping 3.69 carat white diamond at famed...
- Startling images from Nepal earthquake epicenter reveal...
- 'I don't think this is such a brilliant idea': Watch the...