How a humble beach cleaner searching for a stone to crush chillies may have solved the mystery of MH370 by Googling 'plane disasters' after stumbling across 'a weird thing on the shore' 

  • Johnny Begue discovered 6ft wing flap which experts believe comes from a Boeing 777 like Malaysian Airlines plane
  • He also found a battered suitcase on the same beach as the debris, saying: 'It's really weird, it gives me the shivers' 
  • Debris was found on island of La Reunion, east of Madagascar, some 3,500 miles from last-known location of MH370
  • If confirmed, a massive air, land and sea search operation is expected to get under way in the area for other debris 

A humble beach cleaner today told of the moment he stumbled across plane wreckage on an Indian Ocean island, sparking a storm of speculation around the world that it belonged to missing flight MH370.

Johnny Begue was strolling along looking for a pebble to grind up chillies when he suddenly discovered a 'weird thing on the shore'.

The 6ft-long wing flap, which experts believe comes from a Boeing 777 like the Malaysian Airlines plane, was half covered in sand and had barnacles encrusted on its edges. 

Scroll down for video 

Beach cleaner Johnny Begue has spoken of the moment he stumbled across plane wreckage on La Reunion island, sparking speculation  that it belonged to MH370. He is pictured with a shredded suitcase he also found on the beach which is also thought to have from the doomed jet

Beach cleaner Johnny Begue has spoken of the moment he stumbled across plane wreckage on La Reunion island, sparking speculation that it belonged to MH370. He is pictured with a shredded suitcase he also found on the beach which is also thought to have from the doomed jet

Officers carry the 6ft-long wing flap from the beach in Saint-Andre on La Reunion island after it was discovered on Wednesday

Officers carry the 6ft-long wing flap from the beach in Saint-Andre on La Reunion island after it was discovered on Wednesday

'Weird thing on the shore': The 6ft-long wing flap, which experts believe comes from a Boeing 777 like the Malaysian Airlines plane, was half covered in sand and had barnacles encrusted on its edges when it was found by Mr Begue and his team of beach cleaners

'Weird thing on the shore': The 6ft-long wing flap, which experts believe comes from a Boeing 777 like the Malaysian Airlines plane, was half covered in sand and had barnacles encrusted on its edges when it was found by Mr Begue and his team of beach cleaners

He and some colleagues dragged it further inland to avoid it being swept away by the sea and then made the connection to MH370 after Googling 'plane disasters'.

Little did they know that their discovery would draw the world's attention to their tiny island home and may have just solved one of aviation's greatest ever mysteries.

Further adding to the riddle, Mr Begue also found what appeared to be a piece of battered suitcase in the same place as the plane wreckage.

'It is really weird, it gives me the shivers,' he said. 'The piece of luggage was here since yesterday but nobody really paid attention.'

Begue leads a team of eight people charged with cleaning up the coastline and a popular fitness trail in the town of Saint-Andre on the east of the French island of La Reunion.

During an early morning break on Wednesday he wandered off to find a pebble which he planned to use as a pestle to grind up chillies - a key feature of the melting-pot cuisine on the island whose white, palm-fringed beaches are a favourite among tourists.

'It was then that I saw a weird thing on the shore,' said Begue, who called his colleagues over to check it out.

'I immediately saw that it was a piece of a plane,' said his colleague Cedric Gobalsoumy, who added that the group dragged it onto solid ground 'to avoid it being swept into the sea'. 

Crucial piece of the puzzle: Aviation investigators are heading to the island of La Reunion to determine whether this six-foot-long wing flap belongs to missing flight MH370 after it  was found on the beach in Saint-Andre on the French Indian Ocean island

Crucial piece of the puzzle: Aviation investigators are heading to the island of La Reunion to determine whether this six-foot-long wing flap belongs to missing flight MH370 after it was found on the beach in Saint-Andre on the French Indian Ocean island

French police inspect the piece of plane debris which was found on the beach in Saint-Andre on the French Indian Ocean island of La Reunion

French police inspect the piece of plane debris which was found on the beach in Saint-Andre on the French Indian Ocean island of La Reunion

PRIME MINISTER OFFERS HELP FROM BRITISH NAVAL EXPERTS 

David Cameron yesterday offered assistance from British naval experts to help in the search for the remains of MH370 as he made a visit to Malaysia.

In talks with prime minister Najib Razak in Kuala Lumpur, Mr Cameron extended the offer of support from oceanographers to trace where the rest of the wreckage could be based on tidal patterns.

A British official said: 'We have some expertise in the MoD who work in mapping, naval surveys and things like that.

'It's not a detailed offer at this stage. If they are interested we will follow up on it.' The source added: 'We are offering brainpower not ships.' As Mr Cameron arrived for the meetings he told Mr Razak: 'May I start by expressing my condolences for the loss of two Malaysian airliners that has been brought into sharp focus in the past 24 hours with the potential discovery of part of one and Russia vetoing the UN security council [regarding the investigation into the other].' Officials travelling with Mr Cameron said they were working on the assumption that the piece of aircraft came from MH370.

Earlier Mr Cameron ‎criticised Russia's veto of the UN resolution to set up a tribunal to punish those responsible for the downing on MH17.

He told reporters: 'I think it is infuriating and completely wrong.

'Let us not forget: British people died on this flight. Hundreds of people died on this flight. We cannot let one country stand in the way of getting to the truth or one country stand in the way of getting justice.

'If we cannot set up a tribunal through the United Nations route, we will have to look at other ways to make sure this is done.‎ 'As in the case of the Lockerbie disaster, justice must be done.'

In the moments after their discovery, they thought they would just leave the piece of wreckage for 'people walking along the fitness trail and tourists to see'.

But Gobalsoumy said he quickly realised 'we can't do that'.

'A piece of a plane in the sea is not normal. We told ourselves that people could have died in this aircraft and that their families would want to know.'

They decided to alert local police forces. 

'Then a colleague went online with his cellphone and searched for information on plane accidents and found the Malaysian story,' said Begue.

The small group of cleaners were not the only ones to make the connection with the missing Malaysian flight and the news quickly spread around the world as investigators scrambled to inspect the debris.

'I didn't know that by going to find a pestle to crush my chillies I would become famous,' said Begue. 

His remarkable story came after Malaysian officials said it was 'almost certain' the wing flap came from a Boeing 777 – the same model as the Malaysian airlines jet.

The dramatic developments, some 3,500 miles from the doomed jet's last-known location, have fuelled hopes across the globe that one of aviation's greatest mysteries could move closer to finally being solved. 

Aviation investigators are heading to the island to verify the findings after identifying the six-foot-long piece of debris as a 'flaperon' from the edge of a plane's wing.

It also emerged that the code 657-BB that was reportedly found on the debris matches that for a flaperon on a Boeing 777 in the manufacturer's manual, according to AirLive.net.

Malaysian Deputy Transport Minister Aziz Kaprawi said it is 'almost certain' that the debris belongs to a Boeing 777 aircraft, adding: 'Our chief investigator here told me this.'

Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak said it was also 'very likely', adding that the flaperon will be shipped to France for verification by the BEA, the French body responsible for civil aviation accident investigations.

Air crash investigators also have 'a high degree of confidence' the wreckage came from that type of aircraft. 

French, Malaysian, and Australian authorities have all begun looking into the object's origin, with Malaysia saying it was sending a team of experts to the island today.

'We expect in two days we can complete the verification,' Mr Kaprawi said.   

Australia's deputy prime minister also said a number stamped on the debris could help quickly identify whether it came from MH370.

The stamp was not a serial number but could have been some sort of maintenance number that would help with trying to identify it, Warren Truss said.

'This kind of work is obviously going to take some time although the number may help to identify the aircraft parts, assuming that's what they are, much more quickly than might otherwise be the case,' he said. 

David Cameron this morning arrived in Malaysia where he is holding talks in Kuala Lumpur with premier Najib Razak. 

Officials are examining debris found washed up on La Reunion island east of Madagascar to determine if it is related to the missing MH370

Officials are examining debris found washed up on La Reunion island east of Madagascar to determine if it is related to the missing MH370

The debris appears to be part of a wing and was taken onto the island of La Reunion, where it will be thoroughly inspected 

The debris appears to be part of a wing and was taken onto the island of La Reunion, where it will be thoroughly inspected 

Air crash investigators confirmed that they have a 'high degree of certainty' that the component is from a Boeing 777 – similar to MH370

Air crash investigators confirmed that they have a 'high degree of certainty' that the component is from a Boeing 777 – similar to MH370

Officials travelling with the British Prime Minister – who is on a four-day tour of South East Asia – said they were working on the assumption that the wreckage was a part of the missing plane. 

If the wing part is confirmed as coming from MH370, a massive air, land and sea search is expected to get under way in the region for other debris from the aircraft.

A torn-off part of the aircraft suggests that other debris would have drifted from the crash site - and the discovery of the flaperon is a powerful clue as to where other pieces would have ended up. 

If the Indian Ocean currents have carried a large piece of a wing some 3,000 miles, there is a possibility that smaller items from the plane, particularly luggage, seat cushions and blankets could have been carried to the Reunion coastline. 

Locals are expected to be questioned in coming days over whether they have picked up items on the beach - which they might have assumed were worthless pieces of flotsam, but which could now prove to be vital clues as to where the aircraft went down.

Teams from among the 500,000-strong population are expected to be brought together to search the coastline, while it is likely that aerial and sea support from France, Australia, Malaysia and China will be deployed to join in the hunt for debris. 

Circled is the part of the Malaysian Airlines plane that officials believe has washed up on the Reunion Island, east of Madagascar

Circled is the part of the Malaysian Airlines plane that officials believe has washed up on the Reunion Island, east of Madagascar

DID MH370 ACTUALLY FLY OVER THE MALDIVES? DEBRIS BACKS WITNESSES WHO 'SAW LOW-FLYING AIRCRAFT'

The discovery of debris wing flap has now focused attention on where in the Indian Ocean the plane - 'most likely' MH370 - might have crashed.

One possibility, which is gaining credibility, is that it came down after passing over the popular British holiday destination of the Maldives, lying off the southern tip of India.

Islanders on a remote Maldives atoll have been insisting for months that they saw a large jet with the red stripe of Malaysia Airlines jets, flying low overhead on the morning MH370 lost contact - a phenomenon they had not witnessed before.

But their reports were dismissed by their own government as attention turned to a search area some 2,000 miles south west of Australia.

The recovery of a wing flap bearing a maintenance code number that matches Boeing 777 aircraft has led to increasing excitement that the first clue has been found indicating that the missing jet had crashed into the Indian Ocean and not in the Gulf of Thailand or the Bay of Bengal.

The two-metre-long section of wreckage was discovered on the island of La Reunion, east of Madagascar, more than 3,800 miles away from where the aircraft was last seen, north of Kuala Lumpur and some 3,000 miles from the search area west of Australia 

Maldive islanders have claimed that they of saw a low-flying aircraft head away from them in a south-westerly direction - towards Mauritius and La Reunion.

Ocean currents swirling in a clockwise direction, experts agreed, could have carried any debris from an aircraft crashing in the Maldives to the coast of La Reunion, where the wing part was found.

The discovery of the part has given researchers the first real lead - given that the wing part is from MH370 and based on the way the currents run - about a possible crash area.

Based on reports by the Maldive islanders, the currents and the state of the wing part - which was covered in barnacles indicating it had been in the water for probably more than a year - there are strong suggestions that the debris reached La Reunion from the north east.

That covers a vast area of ocean, but that south-west line can be narrowed down when fuel reserves of MH370 are calculated.

What then, did the Maldive islanders see early on that morning of March 8, last year, when contact with MH370 was lost?

A number of residents on the remote atoll of Kuda Huvadhoo have told a local news organisation that it was around 6.15am that they saw a jet larger than any aircraft they had seen before flying very low above them.

One compelling account came from 47-year-old court official Abdu Rasheed Ibrahim, who said he watched a very large plane bank slightly before hearing a 'loud noise'.

The reference to the aircraft banking fits in with a theory that the flaps - which control banking - were down because it is a torn-away wing flap that has been found on La Reunion.

A number of witnesses to the low-flying aircraft have filed police reports, among them Ahmed Shiyaam, a 34-year-old IT manager, who said he was 'very sure of what I saw on a very clear and bright day. And what I saw was not normal. The plane was very big and low.' 

There have been suggestions that the Maldives government, which had dismissed the eyewitness accounts, did so because it was embarrassed that its security services did not have a radar system efficient enough to identify a 'foreign' aircraft entering its air space. 

A cluster of debris will give experts an idea of the direction it has come from, which will in turn give searchers an approximate drift line.

Along with calculations about the aircraft's flying distance on its available fuel, this could all help in discovering the place where it hit the ocean.  

Since the Boeing 777 was introduced in 1994, there have been five incidents – including MH370 – which have led to the destruction of the aircraft, but MH370 is the only plane of its type which has vanished over the sea.

Investigators have identified the six-foot long piece of debris as a 'flaperon' from the edge of a 777 wing, a US official has said.

ONLY FIVE SERIOUS ACCIDENTS INVOLVING THE BOEING 777 

Since the Boeing 777 was introduced in 1995, only five of the aircraft hulls have been destroyed in accidents. 

The first hull loss happened on January 17, 2008 when a British Airways jet landed 1,000 feet short of the runway at Heathrow. 

In July 2011, an Egypt Air 777 caught fire at Cairo International and was destroyed. 

The third was in July 2013 when a 777 operated by Asiana Airways crashed at San Francisco International, killing three people. 

The fourth 777 loss was MH370. 

The fifth was MH17 which was shot down on the Russian/Ukrainian border in July 2014.

The Chief Commissioner of the Australian Transport Safety Bureau Martin Dolan said his organisation was liaising with Boeing over the piece of wreckage. 

He said: 'We know about it and we are trying to work with our French colleagues to try and figure out if this is from MH370. It could take some time. 

'It could take today or longer than that for us to ascertain that.'

At the United Nations, Malaysian Transport Minister Liow Tiong Lai said that he has sent a team to verify the identity of the plane wreckage.

He said: 'Whatever wreckage found needs to be further verified before we can ever confirm that it is belonged to MH370.'

If the debris turns out to be from Malaysia Airlines flight 370, it will be the first major breakthrough in the effort to discover what happened to the plane after it vanished on March 8, 2014, with 239 people on board while travelling from Kuala Lumpur in Malaysia to Beijing.

The component was discovered by people cleaning up a beach in La Reunion, east of Madagascar – more than 3,800 miles away from the last known location of MH370. 

It is also more than 3,000 miles from where the main underwater search for wreckage is taking place, off the coast of Australia.

One witness said: 'It was covered in shells, so one would say it had been in the water a long time.' 

Xavier Tytelman, an expert in aviation security, said it could not be ruled out that the wreckage belonged to MH370. 

He noted that local media photos showed 'incredible similarities between a #B777 flaperon and the debris found,' referring to a Boeing 777 – the type of plane that disappeared. 

He added: 'This code is not a plane's registration number, nor serial number. 

'However... it's clear that this reference would allow a quick identification. In a few days, we will have a definitive answer.'

MAP PREPARED BY OCEAN EXPERTS ONE YEAR AGO EERILY PREDICTED DEBRIS WOULD ARRIVE IN MADAGASCAR 

This chart created by oceanographers one year ago predicted debris from missing Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 could end up on the island of La Reunion.

Aviation experts say it is entirely possible a piece of airplane debris found on La Reunion, located off the coast of Madagascar and about 5,600km (3,500 miles) from the MH370 search site, belongs to the doomed plane.

Oceanographers from the University of Western Australia (UWA) say the location of the newly-discovered aircraft debris is 'entirely consistent' with a graphic they created 12 months ago showing the potential drift patterns of the missing plane. 

Oceanographers created this chart one year ago showing the potential drift of MH370, starting from the Indian Ocean search zone. Experts say the chart's predicitions are 'entirely consistent' with the location of newly-found debris on La Reunion, off the coast of Madagascar

Oceanographers created this chart one year ago showing the potential drift of MH370, starting from the Indian Ocean search zone. Experts say the chart's predicitions are 'entirely consistent' with the location of newly-found debris on La Reunion, off the coast of Madagascar

Authorities centred their search in the southern Indian Ocean based on satellite pings from the plane, which went missing in March 2014 with 239 passengers on board.

UWA oceanographer Charitha Pattiaratchi was part of the team that examined surface currants in the region around the search zone to track the dispersal pattern of any possible debris.

'It makes sense based on some of the modelling we did 12 months ago, that some time within 18 to 24 months after [the crash] this could be the area the debris would have ended up in,' said Prof Pattiaratchi. 

Aviation expert Xavier Tytelman reported the discovery of the mystery wreckage which is currently being examined by a team of experts

Aviation expert Xavier Tytelman reported the discovery of the mystery wreckage which is currently being examined by a team of experts

The section of wreckage, believed to be from an aircraft, was found in La Reunion, pictured, with is a French overseas department

The section of wreckage, believed to be from an aircraft, was found in La Reunion, pictured, with is a French overseas department

WRECKAGE FIND WON'T ALTER UNDERWATER SEARCH AREA PLAN

The man in charge of finding MH370 said the discovery of a part of a Boeing 777 in La Reunion will not alter his search plans.

Australian Transport Safety Bureau Chief Commissioner Martin Dolan, who heads the seabed search, said that if the find proved to be part of the missing aircraft, it would be consistent with the theory that the plane missing crashed within the 120,000 square kilometer (46,000 square mile) search area 1,800 kilometers (1,100 miles) southwest of Australia.

'It doesn't rule out our current search area if this were associated with MH370. It is entirely possible that something could have drifted from our current search area to that island.'

Dolan said search resources would be better spent continuing the seabed search with sonar and video for wreckage rather than reviving a surface search for debris if the find proved to be from Flight 370.

He added: 'Confirmation that the wing part was the first trace of Flight 370 ever found would finally disprove theories that the airliner might have disappeared in the northern hemisphere.'

Eric Chesneau, a French air transport police officer, urged caution following yesterday's discovery.

He said: 'People are getting ahead of themselves over this. It is more than likely plane debris, (but) we don't know what exact part it may be.'  

An Australian-led operation has scoured more than 19,000 square miles of the seafloor, about 60 per cent of a search zone in the Indian Ocean that was determined via expert analysis of signals from MH370 that were detected by a satellite.

However the four search vessels towing 10-kilometre cables fitted with sophisticated sonar systems that scan the seabed have turned up little except shipping containers and a previously uncharted shipwreck.

Rough weather, the pitch-black extreme depths of up to 4,000 metres, and the rugged nature of the previously unmapped seafloor have made for a slow, frustrating search. 

A comprehensive report earlier this year into the plane's disappearance revealed that the battery of the locator beacon for the plane's flight data recorder had expired more than a year before the jet vanished. 

However, the report said the battery in the locator beacon of the cockpit voice recorder was working.

Investigators hope that if they can locate the two recorders they can get to the bottom of what has become one of aviation's biggest mysteries.

The unsuccessful search for Flight 370 has raised concern worldwide about whether airliners should be required to transmit their locations continually via satellite, especially when flying long distances over the ocean.

Apart from the anomaly of the expired battery, the detailed report devoted page after page to describing a flight that started off completely normal.

The 584-page report by a 19-member independent investigation group went into minute details about the crew's lives, including their medical and financial records and training. 

It also detailed the aircraft's service record, as well as the weather, communications systems and other aspects of the flight. Nothing unusual was revealed. 

Neither the French civil aviation authority DGAC nor the BEA, the agency responsible for investigating aviation accidents, were immediately available for comment. 

However, the company said if could not confirm whether engineers were en-route, but added that it remained 'committed to supporting the MH370 investigation and the search for the airplane'.

The airline manufacturer said: 'We continue to share our technical expertise and analysis. 

'Our goal, along with the entire global aviation industry, continues to be not only to find the airplane, but also to determine what happened - and why.'  

 

Environmental scientists believe that the supposed crash site west of Australia could see the debris carried west towards La Reunion

Environmental scientists believe that the supposed crash site west of Australia could see the debris carried west towards La Reunion

The object appears very similar to part of the flap mechanism from a large passenger jet such as the missing MH370 Boeing 777

The object appears very similar to part of the flap mechanism from a large passenger jet such as the missing MH370 Boeing 777

Airline expert Xavier Tytelman said the wreckage looked like it came from a Boeing 777, the same model as the missing MH370

Airline expert Xavier Tytelman said the wreckage looked like it came from a Boeing 777, the same model as the missing MH370

With the search proving fruitless, speculation on the fate of the plane remains focused primarily on a possible mechanical or structural failure, a hijacking or terror plot, or rogue pilot action.

However nothing has emerged to substantiate any of these scenarios.

The lack of solid information has sustained a flow of conspiracy theories, with books, documentaries and a thriving online debate positing a range of possibilities.

These include suggestions that the plane was commandeered to be used as a 'flying bomb' headed for US military installations on the Diego Garcia atoll, and was shot down by the Americans. The United States has dismissed this.

US aviation expert Jeff Wise suggested earlier this year that the MH370 was commandeered to a Russian facility in Kazakhstan, possibly an effort by President Vladimir Putin to intimidate the West during the Ukraine crisis, or to gain access to a certain passenger or item in the hold. 

Australian investigators have so-far ruled out restarting a surface search for wreckage despite yesterday's discovery 

Australian investigators have so-far ruled out restarting a surface search for wreckage despite yesterday's discovery 

SO WHAT EXACTLY HAPPENED TO MH370... SOME OF THE LEADING THEORIES INTO THE MYSTERY EXAMINED  

DID THE PILOT HIJACK HIS OWN PLANE? 

Pilot Zaharie Ahmad Shah planned mass murder because of personal problems, locking his co-pilot out of the cockpit, closing down all communications, depressurising the main cabin and then disabling the aircraft so that it continued flying on auto-pilot until it ran out of fuel.

That was the popular theory in the weeks after the plane's disappearance. 

His personal problems, rumours in Kuala Lumpur said, included a split with his wife Fizah Khan, and his fury that a relative, opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim, had been given a five-year jail sentence for sodomy shortly before he boarded the plane for the flight to Beijing.

But the pilot's wife angrily denied any personal problems and other family members and his friends said he was a devoted family man and loved his job.

This theory is also the conclusion of the first independent study into the disaster by the New Zealand-based air accident investigator, Ewan Wilson.

Wilson, the founder of Kiwi Airlines and a commercial pilot himself, arrived at the shocking conclusion after considering 'every conceivable alternative scenario'.

However, he has not been able to provide any conclusive evidence to support his theory.

The claims are made in the book 'Goodnight Malaysian 370', which Wilson co-wrote with the New Zealand broadsheet journalist, Geoff Taylor.

It's also been rumoured that Zaharie used a flight simulator at his home to plot a path to a remote island.

However, officials in Kuala Lumpur declared that Malysian police and the FBI's technical experts had found nothing to suggest he was planning to hijack the flight after closely examining his flight simulator. 

IF NOT THE PILOT, WAS THE CO-PILOT RESPONSIBLE FOR THE MYSTERY?

Co-pilot Fariq Abdul Hamid, 27, again for personal problems, was suspected by rumour-spreaders to have overpowered the pilot and disabled the aircraft, flying it to its doom with crew and passengers unable to get through the locked cockpit door.

Theorists have put forward the suggestion that he was having relationship problems and this was his dramatic way of committing suicide.

But he was engaged to be married to Captain Nadira Ramli, 26, a fellow pilot from another airline, and loved his job. There are no known reasons for him to have taken any fatal action.

Others have suggested that because he was known to have occasionally invited young women into the cockpit during a flight, he had done so this time and something had gone wrong.

Young Jonti Roos said in March that she spent an entire flight in 2011 in the cockpit being entertained by Hamid, who was smoking.

Interest in the co-pilot was renewed when it was revealed he was the last person to communicate from the cockpit after the communication system was cut off. 

DID THE RUSSIANS STEAL MH370 AND FLY THE JET TO KAZAKHSTAN

An expert has claimed the missing Malaysia Airlines flight 370 was hijacked on the orders of Vladimir Putin and secretly landed in Kazakhstan.

Jeff Wise, a U.S. science writer who spearheaded CNN's coverage of the Boeing 777-200E, has based his outlandish theory on pings that the plane gave off for seven hours after it went missing, that were recorded by British telecommunications company Inmarsat.

Wise believes that hijackers 'spoofed' the plane's navigation data to make it seem like it went in another direction, but flew it to the Baikonur Cosmodrome, which is leased from Kazakhstan by Russia.

However, Wise admits in New York Magazine that he does not know why Vladimir Putin would want to steal a plane full of people and that his idea is somewhat 'crazy'.

Wise also noted there were three Russian men onboard the flight, two of them Ukrainian passport holders.

Aviation disaster experts analysed satellite data and discovered - like the data recorded by Inmarsat - that the plane flew on for hours after losing contact.

Careful examination of the evidence has revealed that MH370 made three turns after the last radio call, first a turn to the left, then two more, taking the plane west, then south towards Antarctica.

MH370 WAS USED BY TERRORISTS FOR A SUICIDE ATTACK ON THE CHINESE NAVY

This extraordinary claim came from 41-year-old British yachtsman Katherine Tee, from Liverpool, whose initial account of seeing what she thought was a burning plane in the night sky made headlines around the world.

On arrival in Thailand's Phuket after sailing across the Indian Ocean from Cochin, southern India with her husband, she said: 'I could see the outline of the plane - it looked longer than planes usually do.There was what appeared to be black smoke streaming from behind.'

Ms Tee's general description of the time and place was vague and she lost all credibility when she later stated on her blog that she believed MH370 was a kamikaze plane that was aimed at a flotilla of Chinese ships and it was shot down before it could smash into the vessels.

Without solid proof of the satellite data, she wrote on her blog, Saucy Sailoress, the plane she saw was flying at low altitude towards the military convoy she and her husband had seen on recent nights. She added that internet research showed a Chinese flotilla was in the area at the time.

THE JET LANDED ON THE WATER AND WAS SEEN FLOATING ON THE ANDAMAN SEA  

On a flight from Jeddah to Kuala Lumpur that crossed over the Andaman Sea on March 8, Malaysian woman Raja Dalelah, 53, saw what she believed was a plane sitting on the water's surface.

She didn't know about the search that had been started for MH370. She alerted a stewardess who told her to go back to sleep.

'I was shocked to see what looked like the tail and wing of an aircraft on the water,' she said.

It was only when she told her friends on landing in Kuala Lumpur what she had seen that she learned of the missing jet. She had seen the object at about 2.30pm Malaysian time.

She said she had been able to identify several ships and islands before noticing the silver object that she said was a plane.

But her story was laughed off by pilots who said it would have been impossible to have seen part of an aircraft in the water from 35,000ft or seven miles.

Ms Raja filed an official report with police the same day and has kept to her story.

'I know what I saw,' she said.

THE AIRCRAFT SUFFERED A CATASTROPHIC SYSTEMS FAILURE AND CRASH-LANDED ON THE OCEAN

A catastrophic event such as a fire disabling much of the equipment resulted in the pilots turning the plane back towards the Malaysian peninsula in the hope of landing at the nearest airport.

Satellite data, believable or not, suggests the aircraft did make a turn and theorists say there would be no reason for the pilots to change course unless confronted with an emergency.

A fire in a similar Boeing 777 jet parked at Cairo airport in 2011 was found to have been caused by a problem with the first officer's oxygen mask supply tubing.

Stewarts Law, which has litigated in a series of recent air disasters, believes the plane crashed after a fire - similar to the blaze on the Cairo airport runway - broke out in the cockpit.

After an investigation into the Cairo blaze, Egypt's Aircraft Accident Investigation Central Directorate (EAAICD) released their final report which revealed that the fire originated near the first officer's oxygen mask supply tubing.

The cause of the fire could not be conclusively determined, but investigators pinpointed a problem with the cockpit hose used to provide oxygen for the crew in the event of decompression.

Following the 2011 fire, US aircraft owners were instructed to replace the system - it was estimated to cost $2,596 (£1,573) per aircraft. It was not known whether Malaysia Airlines had carried out the change.

If either pilot wanted to crash the plane, why turn it around? So the turn-around suggests they were trying to land as soon as possible because of an emergency.

THE US SHOT DOWN THE AIRCRAFT FEARING A TERROR ATTACK ON DIEGO GARCIA  

The Boeing 777 was shot down by the Americans who feared the aircraft had been hijacked and was about to be used to attack the U.S. military base on Diego Garcia atoll in the Indian Ocean. So conspiracy theorists claim.

And former French airline director Marc Dugain said he had been warned by British intelligence that he was taking risks by investigating this angle.

There is no way of checking whether Dugain received such a warning or why he believes the Americans shot down the plane.

But adding to the theory that the aircraft was flown to Diego Garcia, either by the pilot Zaharie or a hijacker, was the claim that on the pilot's home flight simulator was a 'practice' flight to the island.

Professor Glees said: 'The Americans would have no interest in doing anything of the kind and not telling the world.

'In theory, they might wish to shoot down a plane they thought was attacking them but they wouldn't just fire missiles, they'd investigate it first with fighters and would quickly realise that even if it had to be shot down, the world would need to know.'

Mr Rosenschein said: 'The U.S. would not have been able to hide this fact and in any event, if it were true, they would have admitted their action as it would have prevented a successful terrorist action on this occasion and acted as a deterrent for future terrorist attacks.' 

The comments below have not been moderated.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

By posting your comment you agree to our house rules.

Who is this week's top commenter? Find out now