Colorado theater shooting jury decides James Holmes IS eligible for death penalty

Home Top

Good Samaritan dad shot three times in front of his wife and young children by robbers, who knocked their door asking for help
Mystery hero of the train terror attack is American professor: Academic was first to respond and was shot when he spotted suspicious gunman in bathroom - prompting airman to take him down
Father of hero National Guardsman blasts political-correctness brigade for being terror apologists after French train attack
BREAKING NEWS: IndyCar driver Justin Wilson has died after suffering a head injury following a crash at Pocono Raceway
Oscar winner Julianne Moore leads campaign to change her high school's name, which honors a slave-owning Confederate general
James Holmes caught YAWNING in formal sentencing where victims' and their families gave tearful testimony
How cleaning with wipes may actually SPREAD deadly bacteria, including MRSA
Wall St free fall: Dow Jones closes down nearly 600 points after a historic market roller coaster ride caused by China's 'Black Monday'
As stocks plunge in value, Trump says: I told you so! Tycoon blames market drama on the American economy's strong links with China
'Black Monday' on Chinese stock market as shares plummet by more than 8% and the world's second biggest economy continues its freefall
I stand by saying 'anchor babies' says Jeb - but it's Asian not Hispanic immigrant who are taking advantage of America's laws
Columbine-inspired Pokémon plotters nicknamed 'squeaky' and 'Stumbo' denied bail as court hears they planned to kill rivals in 'mass shooting' at game's world championship
A heartless killer or brainwashed by love? Honor student 'who sent 1,000 texts urging boyfriend to kill himself' listens as her lawyer claims dead boy lured HER into 'Romeo and Juliet suicide plot'
Celebrity mobster moved out of 'Supermax' prison that holds the Unabomber and into more relaxed facility with a soccer field
Heroic Safari guide mauled to death by charging lion as he protected his guests in the same Zimbabwean park as Cecil was illegally hunted last month
Is an ancient manuscript that claims Jesus married REAL? Study of ink used in ancient papyrus suggests it could be authentic
Sixteen-year-old girl disappears after texting friends that someone is 'following her' and never makes it to first day of school
She should have entered the 9,999m race! American 10,000m runner loses the World Championships bronze to her teammate after she started CELEBRATING a stride too soon
EXCLUSIVE: NASA employees caught buying child porn from site which showed three-year-olds being abused - but they escape prosecution and now their names are being kept secret
Are YOU at risk of developing dementia? Revealed, the 9 factors that increase your risk of Alzheimer's... and how you can reduce your risk
Inside the mysterious Florida town where EVERYONE claims to be psychic: Remote town inhabited almost entirely by mediums and mystics who say they talk to the dead
Why your dog doesn't feel guilty... even when he looks like this! Experts say sad eyes and wrinkled brows aren't evidence of contrition at all
$Fear the Walking Dead Sunday, August 23, 2015 \nA dysfunctional blended family is forced together when they realize the onset of the undead apocalypse is upon them.\nWhat did the world look like as it was transforming into the horrifying apocalypse depicted in "The Walking Dead"? This spin-off set in Los Angeles, following new characters as they face the beginning of the end of the world, will answer that question. \n$ It killed it! Fear the Walking Dead becomes most-watched series debut in cable history with 10.1M viewers despite poor reviews
'My husband wants to die in my arms': Celine Dion reveals her husband Rene Angelil's heart-breaking request as he battles throat cancer

The twelve-person jury announced Monday that James Holmes is eligible for the death penalty
The trial will now move onto the third and final phase, during which the jury will decide whether to sentence him to death or life in prison
Holmes was found guilty last month of killing 12 in a 2012 attack on a showing of the movie The Dark Knight Rises in Aurora, Colorado

By Associated Press and Dailymail.com Reporter

Published: 12:34 EST, 3 August 2015 | Updated: 16:22 EST, 3 August 2015

110

View
comments

Life or death: the trial against Aurora, Colorado theater shooter James Holmes will now progress to a third and final phase, during which the jury will decide whether to sentence him to life in prison or death

Jurors in the Colorado theater shooting trial declined to rule out the death penalty Monday as they move toward sentencing James Holmes, finding his defense failed to persuade them to show him mercy.

The decision clears the way for a last plea from both sides, including what is expected to be gripping and emotional testimony from victims about the harm and suffering Holmes caused with his slaughter.

After those arguments, the jury will make its final decision on whether the 27-year-old should die by lethal injection or spend the rest of his life in prison.

The same jury last month convicted Holmes of killing 12 people and injuring 70 in the July 2012 attack at a suburban Denver movie theater.

Jurors rejected the defense claim that mental illness had so warped his mind that he could not tell right from wrong.

In the first step of Colorado's complicated death sentencing process, prosecutors argued Holmes sprang a terrifying and cruel ambush on hundreds of unsuspecting victims.

Jurors agreed and said the crime was so heinous that the death penalty could be appropriate.

In the second step, defense lawyers pleaded with jurors to show mercy, saying it was mental illness and not free will that drove Holmes to murder.

They called dozens of former teachers, family friends, and Holmes' parents and his sister, who told jurors Holmes had been a happy, friendly child known as 'Jimmy' but kept to himself in his later years.

Scroll down for video

Facing the charges: Holmes wore a blue button-down shirt and khaki pants as the jury announced that he would be eligible for the death penalty on Monday

Bloodbath: Above, a view of the movie theater Holmes targeted in 2012, killing twelve during a showing of The Dark Knight Rises

Holmes' parents, Robert and Arlene Holmes, testified that they never suspected their son was mentally ill. But Robert Holmes acknowledged they rarely communicated with Holmes in the months before the shooting and, in his family, emotions just weren't talked about.

Taking the stand last Wednesday, Arlene Holmes described a kind, polite child who had never hurt a soul before he opened fire inside a theater in Aurora, Colorado, killing a dozen moviegoers and injuring 70.

Breaking down in tears, she said she still loved her son despite his actions, saying: 'I understand he has a serious mental illness that he didn't ask for. Schizophrenia chose him. He didn't choose it.'

Emotional: James Holmes's mother Arlene took the stand last Wednesday, breaking down in tears as she said that she still loved him despite his actions

Perfect childhood: Arlene Holmes (left) described a kind, polite child who had never hurt a soul before he opened fire inside a theater in Aurora, Colorado, killing a dozen moviegoers and injuring 70

A forensic psychiatrist testified that the younger Holmes was 'genetically loaded' for mental illness, as Robert Holmes' father and twin sister had been hospitalized with mental illness.

'He was not a violent person. At least not until the event,' Robert Holmes said, referring to the theater attack.

Jurors deliberated for less than three hours before reaching their latest decision. They found the appealing portrait of a younger, kinder Holmes didn't outweigh the heinous nature of his methodical and calculated attack on defenseless moviegoers.

Now both sides can call witnesses and present evidence before the jury deliberates one last time to decide whether Holmes lives or dies.

Holmes was a promising student in a demanding neuroscience Ph.D. program at the University of Colorado when his life went awry. He broke up with his first and only girlfriend and dropped out of school, abandoning his longtime goal of becoming a scientist.

In an eerie notebook introduced as evidence in his trial, Holmes laid out his plans of attack, diagnosed himself with a litany of mental problems and wrote that he hid the depths of his problems - and his homicidal plans - from everyone.

Shortly after midnight on July 20, 2012, he slipped into the suburban Aurora theater and opened fire with a shotgun, assault rifle and semi-automatic pistol before surrendering meekly to police outside.