Group of black women kicked off Napa wine tour for 'laughing too loudly'

Home Top

She should have entered the 9,999m race! American 10,000m runner loses the World Championships bronze to her teammate after she started CELEBRATING a stride too soon
Father shot three times in front of his wife and children by teen robbers who knocked on their door claiming to have a flat tire in horror ambush
How cleaning with wipes may actually SPREAD deadly bacteria, including MRSA
James Holmes caught YAWNING in formal sentencing where victims' and their families gave tearful testimony
'What on Earth were you thinking?' Courtney Love writes heartbreaking note to Kurt Cobain 21 years after his suicide
Scientists are 'one step closer' to creating a universal flu vaccine: New jab could protect against ALL strains of the virus
Wall St free fall: Dow Jones closes down nearly 600 points after a historic market roller coaster ride caused by China's 'Black Monday'
As stocks plunge in value, Trump says: I told you so! Tycoon blames market drama on the American economy's strong links with China
'Black Monday' on Chinese stock market as shares plummet by more than 8% and the world's second biggest economy continues its freefall
I stand by saying 'anchor babies' says Jeb - but it's Asian not Hispanic immigrant who are taking advantage of America's laws
Afghan translator's pregnant wife lost her baby after brutal attack by Taliban thug with knuckleduster after she refused to reveal where her husband was
Tragedy as father suffering with an inoperable brain tumor accidentally kills his daughter, 3, while parking in the family's garage
Celebrity mobster moved out of 'Supermax' prison that holds the Unabomber and into more relaxed facility with a soccer field
What is 'Bigfoot' carrying? Sasquatch hunter claims to have video footage of the mysterious creature struggling with something wrapped in a cloth
Two men arrested trying to fly 'spice', prescription pills and porn into a maximum security prison using a drone
Is YOUR baby racist? Scientists discover a way to reverse racial bias in young children
Outrage at male students' vulgar signs for a 'freshman daughter drop off' where parents are told their girls will have a 'good time'
EXCLUSIVE: NASA employees caught buying child porn from site which showed three-year-olds being abused - but they escape prosecution and now their names are being kept secret
Are YOU at risk of developing dementia? Revealed, the 9 factors that increase your risk of Alzheimer's... and how you can reduce your risk
Why your dog doesn't feel guilty... even when he looks like this! Experts say sad eyes and wrinkled brows aren't evidence of contrition at all
$Fear the Walking Dead Sunday, August 23, 2015 \nA dysfunctional blended family is forced together when they realize the onset of the undead apocalypse is upon them.\nWhat did the world look like as it was transforming into the horrifying apocalypse depicted in "The Walking Dead"? This spin-off set in Los Angeles, following new characters as they face the beginning of the end of the world, will answer that question. \n$ It killed it! Fear the Walking Dead becomes most-watched series debut in cable history with 10.1M viewers despite poor reviews
'My husband wants to die in my arms': Celine Dion reveals her husband Rene Angelil's heart-breaking request as he battles throat cancer
Russia and China send out a message to the West with joint military drill in the Sea of Japan focussing on 'landing missions'
North and South Korea finally agree deal to end military standoff following two days of talks after Pyongyang finally apologises for landmine incident

The women, who were on the Napa Valley Wine Train on Saturday, were escorted off by police
The wine train company claims they were asked to leave after other passengers complained about the noise
A fellow passenger named Danielle who witnessed the incident later wrote that it was 'racially motivated'
The women, who included an 83-year-old grandmother, were given a refund but want a public apology from the company as well
Group member Lisa Johnson said: 'I felt like it was a racist attack on us... we were being singled out'

Published: 07:43 EST, 24 August 2015 | Updated: 12:16 EST, 24 August 2015

461

View
comments

A group of black women from a book club were kicked off a wine tour in Napa at the weekend - sparking accusations of racism on the company's part.

One of the women, Lisa Johnson, said it was 'humiliating' when she and her friends were escorted off the Napa Valley Wine Train by a police officer.

The company said the women had been spoken to several times by the train manager after complaints from other customers that they were laughing and talking too loudly.

But one passenger who witnessed the incident later claimed that it was clearly racially motivated.

Scroll down for video

Lisa Johnson (left on Napa Valley Wine Train shortly before being asked to leave) was among the group of women who were told to leave

Officers from Napa Valley Railroad and St. Helena police departments stood by to escort them off the train

A fellow passenger called Danielle later wrote on Yelp that the incident was 'racially motivated' (above)

The Napa Valley Wine Train offers a 'three-hour journey through world famous vineyards: wine tours, wine tasting & great dining'.

The women - who all wore matching T-shirts with their book club's slogan, 'Sistahs on the Reading Edge' - departed on the train on Saturday shortly before noon.

They admit that they were laughing and talking with one another as they enjoyed their wine.

At one point, a fellow passenger told the ladies - including an 83-year-old grandmother - 'this isn’t a bar', while a manager said they needed to quiet down.

Johnson said no one was 'intoxicated' but that a few of the ladies were 'rambunctious' at times, which most passengers did not seem to mind as they chatted with the women and snapped photos.

After the manager spoke to the women a second time, some of them became silent said Johnson, and were confused as to why they were being singled out.

The manager then said to them that 'this isn’t going to work' and had them get off in front of all the other passengers at the next stop.

Officers from both the Napa Valley Railroad and St. Helena police departments stood by to escort them off the train.

'People were looking at us,' said Johnson. 'To get escorted into the hands of waiting police officers. That’s the humiliating part.'

'I’m really offended to be quite honest,' she said in an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle.

'I felt like it was a racist attack on us. I feel like we were being singled out.'

The women, who are all from the same book club, had been hoping to enjoy a day of food and wine

But they were forced to gather their belongings and leave the train during their wine tour on rails

One of the women to be booted off was this 83-year-old grandmother, who has not been named by the group

The Napa Valley Wine Train wrote in a Facebook post soon after: 'Following verbal and physical abuse toward other guests and staff, it was necessary to get our police involved.

'Many groups come on board and celebrate. When those celebrations impact our other guests, we do intervene.'

The post has since been deleted and the women have all been given a full refund for the trip which start at $124, though Johnson also wants a public apology.

Spokeswoman Kira Devitt said in a statement; 'The Napa Valley Wine Train does not enjoy removing guests from our trains, but takes these things very seriously in order to ensure the enjoyment and safety of all of our guests.'

Johnson found the entire experience 'bizarre', adding; 'The train is set up to be with your friends, to drink wine and have a good time.'

The women noted that fellow passengers stopped to talk with them and take photos of the group

The train, pictured, takes guests on a three-hour journey through Napa Valley's vineyards and includes fine dining and wine-tasting

After witnessing the incident, a fellow passenger named Danielle called out the company in a review on Yelp.

'Definitely not an organization I would recommend or ever support again. I watched in disbelief as staff harassed a group of people who were merely drinking wine and laughing,' she wrote.

'I'd like to think it wasn't a racially motivated act, but given the fact that other, non-black guests were behaving in the same way and not removed, I can only conclude that it was discrimination.

'This business belongs in the "what is wrong with our country" category. Steer clear if you would like to be part of the solution, rather than the problem of white supremacy and racism.'

Devitt said the company is now 'conducting an internal audit to make sure all of our policies were followed and options were offered'.