Yale student Tyler Carlisle jumped out of window after stabbing Alexander Michaud

Home Top

Hunter who broke both legs in the wilderness wrote goodbye letter to his wife and kids then prepared for suicide - but he changed his mind and crawled for FOUR DAYS to safety
'There were bodies, just everywhere': Survivors describe the horrifying scene after duck boat hit a bus in Seattle and left four students dead and 52 injured
Nursery staff 'encouraged' children to fight on camera as Texas mother launches court case
Couple recalls the stomach-churning moment they saw their waiter's spit in their soda...and the cops proved it was him with a DNA test
Saudi prince arrested on suspicion of a sex crime after neighbors claim they saw a bleeding woman screaming for help and trying to climb out of his LA compound
Revealed: How Hillary's right-hand woman Huma Abedin avoided disclosing her husband's business dealings after Clinton PERSONALLY signed off on employment deal
Watch the terrifying moment world's largest passenger plane lurches to one side as it battles high winds during dramatic landing
Baptist church members vote to FIRE pastor who kicked out a 103-year-old member after she disagreed with his services
Frat boy who told freshmen which girls to invite to parties, how to get them drunk and ranked them by hotness is expelled
Pope Francis in the Big Apple: Pontiff will kick off whirlwind New York City visit with speech at the United Nations followed by visit to the 9/11 memorial and mass at Madison Square Garden
Michelle Obama wore a $2,300 dress to meet Pope Francis in Washington earlier this week despite his views on unbridled capitalism
Trump gets BOOED by the crowd as he turns up to see the Pope - after he rejected Francis' call for compassion on immigration
Touching moment Pope Francis blesses girl, 17, in a wheelchair who is suffering from spina bifida and wants to be an actress
Justice Ginsburg appears to doze off as Pope Francis gives historic address to Congress - nine months after falling asleep during the State of the Union
'I'm gunna take my shoe off and throw it at his head': Hot mic catches woman making threats at Pope Francis moments before he walked into Congress
PIERS MORGAN: The Pope's right - America doesn't have to be a country driven by gun-toting, blood-thirsty, planet-destroying bigots
Revealed, the 10 best stress-busting foods - and the good news is chocolate's on the list!
How your child's teddy could trigger food poisoning: 80% of cuddly toys harbour harmful bacteria - while one in four are contaminated with faeces
Hero high school teen who defended blind classmate who was being beaten by a bully is SUSPENDED and kicked off football team
California's Giant Sequoias under threat from drought: Researchers say 3,000 year old trees showing signs of stress
The ultimate laser cannon: 'Gatling gun' can focus multiple beams to create super powerful weapons
How Gestapo thugs waltzed into plum jobs after the war: Their horrors are well chronicled, but new book reveals a deeply shocking twist
Lawyer mom is arrested INSIDE a courtroom for leaving her two toddlers in the car while she represented a client
Empire returns with a whopping 16.2million viewers... making it Fox's most successful season premiere in six years

Tyler Carlisle, 21 stabbed friend Alexander Michaud in the neck on May 26 and then jumped out a window to his death
The police report from the incident now reveals the two men had been having a threesome with another woman at the time
Michaud, now 22, told an officer that Carlisle had become jealous when he thought the girl was not paying enough attention to him and stabbed him
Carlisle was pronounced dead on the scene, less than one week after graduating from Yale
The unnamed female was unharmed in the incident, and she and Michaud still attend Yale

Published: 11:56 EST, 23 September 2015 | Updated: 18:21 EST, 23 September 2015

357

View
comments

A Yale student who jumped out a window to his death after stabbing his friend earlier this year had flown into a jealous rage during a threesome.

Tyler Carlisle had graduated just days prior from the Ivy League university in New Haven, Connecticut, when he stabbed friend Alexander Michaud in the neck with a knife at around 5:30am on May 26, leaping out an apartment window soon after and falling six stories.

He was pronounced dead on the scene, and his motive for stabbing his friend and then taking his life was not disclosed to the public.

Gawker has now obtained the police report however that reveals Carlisle stabbed Michaud after he felt that his friend was receiving too much attention from the woman they were having a threesome with at the time.

Scroll down for video

Terror: Tyler Carlisle (left) stabbed friend Alexander Michaud (right) in the neck on May 26 and then jumped out a window to his death

Awful: Carlisle was pronounced dead on the scene (building above in foreground), less than one week after graduating from Yale

Motive: The police report from the incident now reveals the two men had been having a threesome with another woman at the time (Carlisle at his graduation above)

One of the three officers on the scene, Tiffany Ortiz, wrote in her report after speaking to Michaud in the hospital; 'Michaud, [redacted female], and Carlisle had all been drinking. The three of them were having sex in the bedroom, and Carlisle started to get jealous of Michaud and [redacted female].

'Carlisle grabbed a knife that was on the nightstand next to the bed. Carlisle stabbed Michaud in the neck area.

'Michaud does not remember how he got to the living room. Michaud sat on the chair in the living room and told [redacted female] to "call 911.”

[Redacted female] grabbed a white t-shirt and held it to Michaud’s neck to stop the bleeding. Carlisle then went to the living room and started pacing back and forth, saying "I’m sorry."

'Carlisle sat on the window sill and said he was going to jump. Michaud did not see Carlisle jump out of the window.'

Michaud was declared in 'stable condition' after being taken to the hospital and the female suffered no injuries.

Fight: Michaud (left) told an officer that Carlisle (right) had become jealous when he thought the girl was not paying enough attention to him and stabbed him

The report notes that the female was 'too distraught' at the time to be able to give police a statement.

Gawker reached out to the female for comment but she did not respond, while Michaud told the site; 'I have no interest in talking to any member of the press about this.'

Michaud, Yale class 2017, was a member of the comedy and a capella group Mixed Company of Yale.

According to the Yale Daily News, both Michaud and Carlisle were active members of the Party of the Right, a constituent party of the Yale Political Union.

On its website, the political organization is described as 'the Right-most of the seven Parties in the Yale Political Union.'

Both Michaud, now 22, and Carlisle were originally from Manchester, New Hampshire and had grown up together.

A friend of Carlisle's told the New Hampshire Union Leader shortly after his suicide; 'You expected him to be a senator.'

To speak to a skilled, trained counselor, call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline on 1800 273 8255.