Donald Trump retreats from mandatory database to track Muslims in US

Home Top

Married father-of-five arrested for raping and murdering the seven-year-old daughter of an old school friend who was discovered dead in a creek after vanishing from football game for just 25 minutes
Massacre in Mali: Bodies lie piled up in pools of blood in gore-spattered corridors of hotel where at least 27 hostages were slaughtered by gunmen as one-eyed 'Marlboro Man' jihadist is blamed for attack
'We shouldn't be scared - we are still going out': Defiant Parisians pack the streets of the French capital to honour of those killed exactly one week ago
'This is for Paris': Russian pilots write messages of support for terror victims on their bombs before launching latest air raids and cruise missile strikes against ISIS
'Cowgirl' cousin did NOT blow herself up... but died when third ISIS terrorist detonated suicide vest standing next to her in Paris siege apartment, police reveal
'Every one of you are terrorists': Virginia man disrupts public meeting about a Mosque and launches a 25-second tirade of hate denouncing all Muslims
Air France plane traveling from Paris to San Francisco performs mystery u-turn over the English Channel and lands back at Charles de Gaulle airport
'We didn't know how close we were to being killed': Friends who only survived the Paris massacre because jihadi's AK-47 ran out of bullets tell of their incredibly lucky escape
$Pic shows: Cumba Ibrahim, 6yo and medical staff.\n\nThis youngster is the latest casualty of the tragic mass migration of refugees after he was tied up and thrown into a coalfield bunker to die when he became separated from his parents.\n\nThe boy has been identified as 6-year-old Cuma Ibrahim from Syria, authorities have managed to discover that his father is dead, his mother has vanished, and only his grandmother could be located but she has so far refused to have anything to do with him.\n\nAccording to her, the lad suffers from learning difficulties and is a liability who she cannot cope with. She said he was with his parents and had no idea how he had ended up with his legs tied, and left to freeze and starve to death in the coal bunker.\n\nHe was found by somebody who heard his cries, and when rescuers pulled him out from the coal bunker in the Yakutiye district of the Erzurum Province, in eastern Turkey, he was suffering from hypothermia.\n\nThe starving child was immediately t$ Mentally disabled six-year-old Syrian migrant is found abandoned in a Turkish coal bunker after his family tied up his legs and left him to die
CNN suspends global affairs correspondent over tweet criticizing House bill to block Syrian refugees from the United States
The ISIS bombs hidden inside dolls and toys to kill CHILDREN: Iraqi military reveal IEDs placed in toys by Islamists in Iraq
ISIS dismiss Anonymous hackers as 'idiots' for threatening to shut down their Twitter accounts... when they can just open new ones
Trump in retreat over Muslim database as he says he didn't suggest mandatory registration - after firestorm of criticism comparing him to the Nazis
'The Islamist threat in this country is inside our gates': Kansas commissioner gives a slideshow presentation of criminals named Mohammed in 'warning' to citizens
'Christmas is a charade': Pope says atrocities such as Paris massacre have made festivities meaningless in a world which has chosen 'war and hate'
'Where's yours?' Muslim Marine is swamped with support after posting his Armed Forces ID card on Twitter in challenge to Donald Trump after candidate calls for all US Muslims to be put on a database
Brother of Paris mastermind was arrested in Morocco last month after arriving in his father's hometown and has been held in custody ever since
Newlywed couple let seven frightened strangers fleeing from the Paris terror attacks join them in their honeymoon suite for the night
Dozens of people in America are being tracked by the FBI but there is NO 'credible' ISIS threat, officials say
EVERY traveler entering Europe will be checked against terror watch lists under emergency plan to be agreed by EU ministers today
Half of the Paris terrorist squad were known to US intelligence for months and had been 'watched' or placed on no fly lists
'We are prepared to change the rules of engagement in fight against ISIS': US Defense Secretary warns of tougher stance in wake of Paris attacks
The puppy who will grow up to be France's next Diesel: Little Dobrynia is donated by Russia as a sign of solidarity to replace hero canine killed by suicide jihadi
'If that person doesn't feel safe, let them take the bus': Passenger calls police after he was stopped from boarding flight because another traveler said they were scared to fly after hearing him speaking Arabic with a friend

Republican front runner made the comments at an event in Iowa on Thursday night
He said Muslims would be obliged to sign up at different check points
Comments have provoked outrage and comparisons to Nazi Germany
Jeb Bush denounced the proposal as 'abhorrent' and Ted Cruz accused him of violating the First Amendment
Ben Carson says idea 'would create a pretty dangerous precedent,' John Kasich says remark shows Trump 'trying to divide people'
Trump retreated later Friday morning, denying he suggested a database

By J. Taylor Rushing, U.s. Political Reporter, For Dailymail.com and Associated Press and Reuters

Published: 01:12 EST, 20 November 2015 | Updated: 16:45 EST, 20 November 2015

578

View
comments

Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump came under intense fire today for saying he would force Muslims to register in the wake of the Paris attacks.

He was branded 'abhorrent' and accused of creating a 'toxic environment' for Muslims after he voiced support for the idea.

Comparisons were immediately made to the registration of Jews in Nazi Germany by one Muslim group.

'I would certainly implement that. Absolutely,' Trump told an NBC News reporter between campaign events in Newton, Iowa, according to video posted on MSNBC.com.

He said Muslims would be signed up at 'different places,' adding: 'It would just be good management... It's all about management.'

Asked whether registering would be mandatory, Trump responded: 'They have to be.'

Scroll down for video

Support: This is the moment Donald Trump voiced backing for a register of Muslims. Asked whether registering would be mandatory, Trump responded: 'They have to be.'

Trump's campaign posted this tweet Friday morning

Trump also told NBC, 'There should be a lot of systems, beyond databases. We should have a lot of systems.'

But he retreated quickly Friday morning, posting a note on his Twitter page that said, 'I didn't suggest a database - a reporter did. We must defeat Islamic terrorism & have surveillance, including a watch list, to protect America.'

That tweet came as Trump was under immediate fire from his own party on Friday.

Jeb Bush, his Republican rival for the White House, called the database suggestion 'abhorrent', Breitbart reported. Ben Carson and Ted Cruz said they oppose religious registries. John Kasich criticized the front-runner for trying to 'divide people'.

'That's just wrong,' Bush added said on CNBC on Friday. 'It's manipulating people's angst and their fears. That's not strength. That's weakness.'

What else can you compare this to except to prewar Nazi Germany?

Ibrahim Hooper, national spokesman for the Council on American-Islamic Relations

Carson, speaking on the campaign trail in Concord, N.H., called for a national database on 'everybody who comes into this country,' but said focusing on Muslims is wrong.

'I don’t think it’s a good idea to treat anybody differently. One of the hallmarks of America is that we treat everybody the same,' Carson said, adding that picking out individual groups sets aa pretty dangerous precedent, I believe.'

Cruz, at a media availability in Sioux City, Iowa, called himself 'a big fan of Donald Trump's but I'm not a fan of government registries of American citizens.'

He said the move would interfere with the First Amendment.

'The First Amendment protects religious liberty and I’ve spent the past several decades defending the religious liberty of every American,' Cruz said.

On the rack: Donald Trump was on the stump in South Carolina today as rivals from his own party laid into his plan to register every Muslim

Trump at Friday's rally in Spartanburg, South Carolina

Kasich, whose Super PAC is launching a $2.5 million series of attacks against Trump, said the proposal proved the real estate mogul was not worthy of the White House.

'The idea that someone would have to register with the federal government because of their religion strikes against all that we have believed in our nation’s history,' Kasich said in a statement.

'It is yet another example of trying to divide people, one against the other. Donald Trump is unable to unite and lead our country.'

Ibrahim Hooper, national spokesman for the Council on American-Islamic Relations, said he was 'at a loss for words' after hearing Trump's plan, adding: 'What else can you compare this to except to prewar Nazi Germany?'

The Muslim-American group also accused Trump - and Carson, who has compared refugees to 'rabid dogs' - of creating a 'toxic environment'.

The latest comments come less than a week after the deadly attacks on a concert hall, sports stadium and restaurants in Paris.

They have elevated fears of terrorism across the U.S. and prompted calls for new restrictions on Syrian refugees fleeing their war-torn country.

While some of his rivals have been chastised by the president for suggesting that Christian Syrian refugees be given preference over Muslims, Trump has gone further in his rhetoric, advocating new restrictions on civil liberties and enhanced surveillance activities, including inside mosques.

He said earlier this week that the country was 'going to have no choice' but to close certain mosques because 'really bad things are happening, and they're happening fast.'

The first reference to the database idea came in an interview with Yahoo News published earlier Thursday in which the billionaire real estate mogul did not reject the idea of requiring Muslims to register in a database or giving them special identification cards noting their religion.

'We're going to have to - we're going to have to look at a lot of things very closely,' Trump told Yahoo News.

He also suggested he would consider warrantless searches, according to the outlet, saying: 'We're going to have to do things that we never did before.'

Asked by reporters Thursday night to explain his Yahoo comments, Trump suggested his response had been misconstrued. 'I never responded to that question,' he said.

The Council on American-Islamic Relations issued a statement Thursday condemning Trump for what the group described as 'Islamophobic and unconstitutional' comments targeting American Muslims and Syrian refugees.

They also criticized Carson, who on Thursday compared blocking potential terrorists posing as Syrian refugees from entering the U.S. to handling a rabid dog.

The New York billionaire has remained at the top of the Republican presidential field in almost every national poll since late July

Friday's Trump event was a town hall forum at Wofford College

His words were a reaction to debates surrounding Syrian asylum seekers (pictured) and terrorism concerns

'If there's a rabid dog running around in your neighborhood, you're probably not going to assume something good about that dog,' Carson told reporters at a campaign stops in Alabama. 'It doesn't mean you hate all dogs, but you're putting your intellect into motion.'

'By mainstreaming Islamophobic and unconstitutional policies, Donald Trump and Ben Carson are contributing to an already toxic environment that may be difficult to correct once their political ambitions have been satisfied,' CAIR's Robert McCaw said in a statement.

Trump was in Iowa Thursday for a televised question-and-answer session hosted by WHO-TV at the Des Moines Area Community College.

Trump arrived at the interview eight minutes late, forcing hosts to ad-lib as they awaited his arrival live on air.

Many in the audience were former employees of a Maytag plant that shut down in 2007 and the questions focused on economic issues, including how a Trump White House would help low-income workers pay for skills-training necessary to find new jobs.

'Well, one of the things that I see in this country is a lot of people have lost hope, they've lost their spirit, they've lost their mojo, you know, to go out and go to the community college,' Trump responded.

'We can talk economics, we can talk everything, but one of the things is we have to give people their spirit back, we have to give people hope.'

At a rally afterward, Trump again railed against accepting Syrian refugees, professed his love for Iowa and took a few shots at his fellow candidates.

He said Carson's campaign was in 'freefall' and said Sen. Marco Rubio 'never shows up to vote because he's campaigning.'

Before he left, Trump spent about fifteen minutes shaking hands and taking photos on a rope line. He also ordered pizza from Dominos to feed the entire crowd.

The White House has not commented on the plan. The president was in Malaysia when the comments were made and his spokesman was asked a series of questions by travelling White House reporters but none asked about the Trump comments.

FAITH GROUPS COMPARE TRUMP'S COMMENTS TO 'NAZI GERMANY' WHICH FORCED JEWS TO REGISTER THEIR RELIGION IN 1938

Faith groups have today compared Trump's comments on creating a Muslim registry to Hitler's policies in Germany in the build up to the Second World War.

The Republican frontrunner's rhetoric has been condemned across the board, with politicians of all stripes stepping forward to voice their objections.

Ibrahim Hooper, national spokesman for the Council on American-Islamic Relations, said he was 'at a loss for words' after hearing the statement, adding: 'What else can you compare this to except to prewar Nazi Germany?'

In 1938, dubbed 'The Fateful Year' in Nazi documents, Jews were required to register their religion, issued with identity cards - and all new passports were required to be stamped with the letter 'J' (pictured)

Rabbi Jack Moline, executive director of the nonprofit Interfaith Alliance, drew the same comparison, telling NBC: 'My father was in World War II, and he fought to preserve America against what the Nazis were doing.

'This is exactly why there is an America, to not be like that.'

After seizing power in an effective political coup in 1933 following the Reichstag Fire, Hitler began passing legislation that laid the groundwork of a Nazi state.

While the Nazis started publishing legislation against Jews from 1933, it mostly targeted Jewish businesses or employees who could be identified through family census data.

Jews were also forced to adopt 'traditionally Jewish' names so they could be identified. Women were forced to add 'Sarah' (pictured in this passport)

In 1938, dubbed 'The Fateful Year' by Nazi documents, Jews were required to register their religion and were issued with special identity cards marking them out as Jews.

Anyone identified as Jewish, which the Nazis defined as having three of four Jewish grandparents, was also forced to adopt a 'typically Jewish' name - men were forced to add Israel, women were forced to add Sarah.

All of their passports were also declared invalid, and anyone who wished to get a new passport was reissued with one bearing the letter 'J' - meaning Juden, or Jew.

Singling out Jews in this way led, in part, to the events of Kristallnact - or 'the night of broken glass' when many Jewish businesses were vandalized or burned.

Following Kristallnact and Jewish registration, persecution of the Jewish population at large began in earnest, with restrictions placed on movement, seizures of personal property, and the infamous edict requiring Jews to wear a yellow Star of David.

Areas of eastern Germany also began the forced deportation of Polish Jews, rounding them up and pushing them back across the border.

The registration and yellow stars allowed Jews to be effectively cut off from regular society, and for their businesses, jobs and possessions to be taken away.

Jewish children were excluded from non-Jewish schools, while Jews were barred from attending non-Jewish hospitals and even banned from having sex with non-Jews.

When Hitler began the 'final solution' during the war, the SS used the registry documents in order to round up the population and put them in concentration camps, before millions were systematically killed.

Source - United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Yad Vashem