Hillary Clinton accused of offending Native Americans by saying she's 'dealt with men who get off the reservation' when asked about Trump's attacks
- Hillary Clinton was asked by CNN's Jake Trapper how she plans to deal with Donald Trump's offensive comments
- Looking to reassure Trapper she's unfazed, Clinton quipped 'I have a lot of experience dealing with men who sometimes get off the reservation'
- Native American commentators swiftly denounced Clinton's language
- The saying originally referred to Native Americans who broke 19th century laws by literally walking off reservations
Hillary Clinton raised eyebrows Thursday when she quipped that Donald Trump has gone 'off the reservation' in reference to his frequent personal attacks.
The Democratic presidential candidate made the remark in an interview with CNN's Jake Tapper.
Clinton was asked whether she felt she learned anything about how to deal with Trump's offensive comments by watching the reactions of Trump's republican opponents.
'I have a lot of experience dealing with men who sometimes get off the reservation in the way they behave and how they speak,' Clinton responded, hesitating slightly before pronouncing the word 'reservation.'
Hillary Clinton's 'off the reservation' comment came in response to a question of what she's learned about Donald Trump's offensive comments by watching the Republican debates
CNN's Jake Trapper let the comment slide - but Clinton took heat from Native American commentators who deemed her quip offensive
She then went on to say she 'could really care less' about Trump's rhetoric and said he's welcome to continue with his 'insult fest.'
The CNN reporter let the 'reservation' remark pass - but Native American commentators swiftly denounced the candidate's wording.
'She has some battle tested Native women with her campaign, but the way she has interacted with communities of color is mind boggling... "Super predators", "hot sauce" and now "off the reservation" among a huge list of problematic speech and behavior,' said Johnnie Jae of Native Max magazine, according to Native News Online.
In a statement to Native News Online, Bernie Sanders' national tribal outreach director Nicole Willis said:
'This is one of many sayings that marginalize the experience of American Indians and Alaska Natives. I'm disappointed that politicians who should have ample opportunity to interface with tribal representatives still use such expressions.'
Indian Country Today Media Network called the remark 'offensive.'
Later on Friday, in a conversation with former Democratic State Senator and Sanders supporter Nina Turner, Tapper admitted he, too, found the wording offensive.
'A — yeah, a lot of people not aware of it, but the term "off the reservation," very offensive to a lot of Native Americans. Thanks for that reminder,' Tapper said in response to Turner's denunciation of Clinton's comment.
Donald Trump is known to seize at any offensive or bizarre comments made by his opponents - but had not commented on Clinton's remark as of Saturday morning
In a 'Word Watch' story from 2014, National Public Radio explained the history of the saying.
The idiom has been around since at least 1878, and was used to refer to Native Americans who literally wandered off reservations - against the laws of the time.
'Off the reservation is a common phrase, which many people use without considering the context of its original meaning. Namely, that Native American peoples were restricted to reservations created by the U.S. government, and their freedom was severely limited by the terms of the treaties they were often forced to sign,' NPR's Kee Malesky wrote.
Malesky noted the saying, in a political context, has taken on a different meaning. According to the 2008 book Political Dictionary:
'Remaining nominally within a party, but refusing to support the party's candidate... The phrase first surfaced in the Atlanta Constitution in 1909.'
In a comment to NPR, Rob Capriccioso, citizen of the Sault Tribe of Chippewa Indians, and Washington D.C. Bureau Chief for Indian Country Today wrote:
'I bristle when I hear the phrase because many of the people who use it nonchalantly have likely never thought about its origin, nor have they probably ever visited a reservation.'
'To me, there are indeed many more offensive words involving American Indians than this phrase — including the name of the Washington football team — but I believe it is the common use of phrases like 'off the reservation' that allows people to end up being comfortable going further — to the point of using a slur to name a football team that supposedly honors Indians, but not realizing that it is actually a slur.'
- Hillary Clinton's "Off the Reservation" Comments Raises Eyebrows Among American Indians - Native News Online
- Trump Has Gone 'Off the Reservation,' Clinton Says; Sanders Campaign Calls the Comment 'Disappointing' - ICTMN.com
- Should Saying Someone Is 'Off The Reservation' Be Off-Limits? : Code Switch : NPR
- Exclusive: Clinton weighs in on Trump, Sanders - CNN Video
- The Queen and Prince Harry respond to the Obamas in style!
- A hummingbird plays with the California dog that saved her
- Shocking moment police officer brutally attacks woman
- Former Olympic wrestler takes on seven officers during...
- Frantic 911 call audio of crash survivor Abby Short
- Protesters force Trump's motorcade to make a detour
- Del Taco employee lays into customers with profanity-laden...
- Wasteland: A 4-day post-apocalyptic festival in CA
- Austin Stephanos and Perry Cohen leave on fishing trip
- 'Be careful what you wish for!' Obamas hit back at Prince...
- Son left in bloody mess as father forces him to 'fight'
- Helicopter rotor continues spinning after detaching from...
- Prince 'was diagnosed with AIDS six months before he died...
- 'Oh really? Please!' Queen puts down the Obamas after they...
- Enter the Thunderdrome: Inside the world's largest...
- Kirk Cameron urges wives to be submissive and 'follow their...
- 'She has a total crush on him': Adorable hummingbird refuses...
- Surveillance footage captures moment missing teen fishermen...
- The digs keep coming: Kelly Ripa asks Michael Strahan about...
- Forget the kids... meet the 'Rich Parents of Instagram' with...
- Stunning photos capture New York City in the tumultuous...
- 16 bottles of wine a day. Piles of coke. So how, at 75, does...
- Man, 25, 'killed 52-year-old grandmother and stole her...
- Father of Scientology leader David Miscavige tells how he...