Big Four supermarkets lose £5 to £7 on every online order: How chasing internet shoppers is 'like selling tenners for a fiver'
- Soaring grocery delivery popularity leaves £500m black hole
- The more online shoppers they gain the more money lost, expert says
- Murphy said: 'You are selling tenners for a fiver but you're convinced that if only you can sell enough, at some point it will become profitable.'
- Supermarkets unwilling to admit the 'crippling pain'
The soaring popularity of grocery delivery has left a £500million black hole in the profits of Britain's biggest supermarkets which will worsen as more shoppers use the service.
Dan Murphy, a partner at global retail consultants Kurt Salmon, is warning that supermarkets are caught in an 'Emperor's new clothes' scenario and have 'blinded themselves to the reality' of the loss-making nature of food delivery.
'They lose between £5 and £7 on every order and the more orders they attract and more it grows the more they lose,' he said.
Profits blackhole: Big Four supermarkets are in for online delivery losses of £500million
Murphy said retailers were aiming to boost their online delivery businesses in an attempt to justify the plan in the long term.
But he warned profitability could never match that of customers visiting stores unless delivery charges rose significantly.
'The big supermarkets are trying to convince themselves that this is the right thing to do,' he said. 'They're all completely convinced that they have got to make it work.'
The overall costs of delivery have been escalating as volumes have risen. At the same time profits have been squeezed by a price war with the German discounters Aldi and Lidl, which has shaved margins and left the delivery model under even more pressure.
An estimated 90 per cent of internet food orders at the 'Big 4' supermarkets – Tesco, Sainsbury's, Asda and Morrisons – are painstakingly picked by hand in store and delivered in refrigerated vans.
Murphy said the process is time-consuming since most supermarkets are laid out specifically 'to encourage you to visit every corner of the store so it takes twice as long as it should do'.
He said he had upwardly revised previous calculations for online delivery losses of around £300million made last year.
Competition: Murphy said the impending arrival of Amazon Fresh would be 'the nuclear button' for delivery as it does not have to be profitable
Few in the industry are said to be prepared to admit the crippling pain they are bearing.
Delivery costs are even hidden between departments in the same company and many associated expenses – including running websites and call centres – are often omitted from internal calculations as supermarkets try to justify the logic of delivery.
Murphy said: 'You are selling tenners for a fiver but you're convinced that if only you can sell enough, at some point it will become profitable.'
In a rare admission last year, Sainsbury's online director Robbie Feather said supermarkets had 'destroyed' the value in grocery deliveries by undercharging.
Murphy said the impending arrival of Amazon Fresh would be 'the nuclear button' for delivery as it does not have to be profitable.
He added: 'They are about building a critical mass of customers and then they make money from Amazon web services and services they offer to other retailers.'
- Winners and losers from sterling's fall: Pound 'crisis'...
- Is the greatest threat to the euro flying under the radar?...
- Don't drive too close to horses, eat, or splash a...
- RBS destroyed customers' businesses for profit and rewarded...
- Land Rover love-in: RAY MASSEY finds out why people are...
- Nearly half of Britons believe property is the most...
- Monarch boss goes AWOL at event in Abu Dhabi, just one day...
- FTSE CLOSE: Footsie falls after hitting record high as US...
- ALEX BRUMMER: With the pound in a post-Brexit vote slump...
- Demand for highly skilled finance and technology staff gives...
- Consumer confidence in the UK economy hits highest level...
- How low will they go? More pain for savers as top rates on...