Government rejects child smacking ban
Last updated at 16:22 20 May 2004
The current law permits smacking if only done lightly to ensure discipline.
Opponents of corporal punishment moved an amendment during detailed committee stage debate of the Children Bill in the Lords, to totally outlaw the physical punishment of children.
But after debate, the amendment was not forced to a vote.
Rejecting the proposal, junior Education Minister Baroness Ashton of Upholland said the Government would not support a complete ban on smacking, though she stressed that they remained committed to protecting children from being abused.
It was important to look at ways in which children could be supported in the context of family life, and she invited the amendment's supporters to have discussions with her along these lines.
Violence at home
Lady Ashton said existing legislation already gave children protection from violence at home.
If the amendment became law, even minor smacks administered as discipline would become illegal and technically liable to prosecution, she added.
Uncertainty would be created in the criminal justice system, and in the minds of parents and social workers, about what was legal and what was not.
Lady Ashton said the issue was "too important" for the Government to allow a free vote for its supporters, if there were a division.
It is still possible the issue could be voted on during the later stages of the Bill which has yet to go through the Commons.
The current law allowing for "reasonable chastisement" of children dates back to 1860 and means that children have less protection from being hit than adults.
Most watched News videos
- Moment 'disruptive' couple is arrested on flight headed to LA
- Debbie Reynolds dies at 84, a day after her daughter Carrie Fisher
- George Michael gives Oprah a tour of his Oxfordshire home
- Billie Lourd arrives at hospital where her mother was admitted
- Girls engage in a mass brawl on the top deck of Birmingham bus
- Intense moment manager and shopper fight at Florida mall
- Cars crash into each other on the A40 due to thick fog
- Cam Newton makes Christmas wish come true for sick 10-year-old
- Eddie Fisher with his wife Debbie Reynolds together in 1954
- Debbie Reynolds & daughter Carrie Fisher celebrate award win
- Hilarious moment dog is caught opening family's Christmas presents
- Look back at Debbie Reynolds on the red carpet through the years