Farmers' fury over proposed £3bn funding cuts: Former minister calls to cut ALL subsidies to UK agriculture once Britain leaves the EU
- Former Environment Secretary Owen Paterson spoke at a secret ‘Brexit seminar’
- He said that Theresa May should follow the example of New Zealand
- New Zealand ended government help for farmers virtually overnight in the 1980s
Farmers reacted with fury last night to a proposal to axe their £3 billion in taxpayer handouts after the UK leaves the EU.
Former Environment Secretary Owen Paterson told a secret ‘Brexit seminar’ of former Cabinet Ministers at an Oxford college that Theresa May should follow the example of New Zealand, which ended government help for farmers virtually overnight in the 1980s.
The shock forced a radical shake-up in the country, with sheep farms replaced by deer parks and vineyards.
But critics claim it led to widespread economic distress and a sharp rise in suicides.
New Zealand, pictured, ended government help for farmers virtually overnight in the 1980s
During the session at All Souls College, attended by Eurosceptics John Redwood, Iain Duncan Smith and Peter Lilley, Mr Paterson argued that there were ‘clear lessons to be learnt from the policy adopted by New Zealand… which demonstrated that food production can increase when farmers are given the freedom to react to the market’.
In his speech, which has been studied by Environment Secretary Andrea Leadsom, Mr Paterson said that since subsidies were removed, ‘sheep numbers have halved, but a spectacular increase in productivity means New Zealand still produces a similar quantity of meat’. But last night, the National Farmers Union hit back, saying New Zealand now had the ‘highest rate of farmer suicides in the world’.
And one pro-Remain MP called it a ‘potty plan’ which would drive food producers out of business.
The £3 billion which British farmers receive each year from the EU’s controversial Common Agricultural Policy accounts for around half of their total national income.
The Government has only guaranteed that the subsidies will continue at their current level – covered by UK taxpayers – until 2020, the year after Brexit.
A source close to Ms Leadsom said yesterday that Ministers were unlikely to follow the New Zealand precedent directly because ‘the rug had been pulled away too abruptly’, although the way in which subsidies are applied would be looked at closely.
But Mr Paterson told The Mail on Sunday that the results in New Zealand had been ‘spectacular’: ‘With subsidies, you had all these sheep doing terrible damage to the landscape, and disgusting wine which was only fit to be used as a car coolant.
‘Now they have a fabulous viniculture and a highly productive, diversified sector. There is still a role for government subsidies, but only if there is a transparent public good or environmental benefit.’
Former Environment Secretary Owen Paterson told a secret ‘Brexit seminar’ of former Cabinet Ministers at an Oxford college that Theresa May should follow the example of New Zealand
At the Oxford gathering in January – convened by Mr Redwood, an All Souls Fellow – Mr Paterson said: ‘The lesson from New Zealand is surely that farmers must look for the opportunities that exist both at home and beyond their borders. The rural collapse which was predicted by some did not occur… there were only 800 forced sales from the 80,000 farms, and only around one per cent of farmers were forced to leave the industry.’
He added that he believed farmers should still receive taxpayer support, but it should be directed at areas such as the Lake District with specific needs, and where food production would not be economically viable without government help.
Minette Batters, deputy president of the NFU, said: ‘There is a lot of hype spoken about New Zealand. It is an entirely different natural environment, and after all the changes they have endured the country has the highest rate of farmer suicides in the world.’
Labour MP Mary Creagh, from the Brexit Open Britain campaign, said: ‘As Britain leaves the EU, hard-working farmers need all the support from the Government they can get. It will terrify farming communities across Britain that hard Brexit enthusiasts are plotting in Oxford colleges to propose scrapping farm subsidies lock, stock and barrel after Brexit.
‘Britain is not New Zealand, and evidence suggests that huge numbers of UK farms would be forced to shut their gates if Paterson’s potty plan was put into action.’
Most watched News videos
- Pentagon release footage of MOAB being dropped in Afghanistan
- Bad parker gets blocked by two Jeeps to teach him a lesson
- Muslim woman refuses to remove hijab for airport security in Rome
- 'Mother of all bombs' tested by the US military in 2003
- US Air Force releases footage of the first MOAB bomb test
- Shocking moment a horse attacks an alligator in Florida
- Rapturous reception for Kim Jong Un opening residental complex
- FIRST EVER trailer unveiled for Star Wars: The Last Jedi
- Mega blast after Russia tests non-atomic 'Father Of All Bombs' 2007
- 'You have to drag me': David Dao just before United incident
- 'Look at me when I am talking to you!': Moscow blasts UK
- Silverback gorila attacks a group of tourists in Rwanda
- ‘We will pulverize the headquarters of evil and...
- Hilarious moment two Jeep drivers get their own back on...
- Hell unleashed: Pentagon releases new video showing the...
- Kidnapped from the cotton fields of Virginia and sold to...
- Putin’s ‘Father Of All Bombs’ is FOUR TIMES more powerful...
- 'You are not safe for us': Muslim woman films Rome...
- Easter carnage as drunken revellers take advantage of the...
- How the Mother of All Bombs kills people: Vaporized...
- EXCLUSIVE - 'He should have seen this coming': Chilling...
- Harry flies to Toronto for Easter with Meghan:...
- European couple say they are 'devastated' after the Home...
- Shocking moment the roof of the world-famous Bellagio...
- Britain's prettiest streets are revealed with The...
- Christians in Philippines nail themselves to crosses and...
- His and Hers jets, paid for with YOUR tax dollars:...
- 'Security is really tight on campus so no worries at...
- Angry father 'chops off a 15-year-old boy's PENIS and...
- Instagram mommy-shamers accuse pop star Kelly Clarkson of...