South Dakota man sues Coca-Cola after he 'found a DEAD MOUSE in a can of Coke that made him sick'

  • Duane Putzier of Mitchell, South Dakota drank a Coke can on June 7, 2016
  • He claims there was a mouse inside the can and that he became ill
  • Says he missed 60 hours of work and accumulated $1,000 in medical bills
  • Coca-Cola says the mouse would have been in more advanced decomposition
  • Putzier seeks $2,026 plus any general damages proven at trial 

By Associated Press and Forrest Hanson For Dailymail.com

Published: 12:26 EDT, 27 April 2017 | Updated: 19:22 EDT, 27 April 2017

A South Dakota man who claims to have found a dead mouse in a can of soda is suing Coca-Cola.

Duane Putzier is saying that he missed 60 hours of work and accumulated $1,000 in medical bills after becoming ill from the allegedly mouse-infested 16-ounce can of Coke he consumed on June 7, 2016.

He claims he felt an object 'shift toward the opening' of the can as he was finishing the drink, the Grand Forks Herald reported. 

Duane Putzier of Mitchell, South Dakota claims he found a dead mouse in his can of Coca-Cola last June. He said he felt an object shift toward his lips as he was finishing the drink

Duane Putzier of Mitchell, South Dakota claims he found a dead mouse in his can of Coca-Cola last June. He said he felt an object shift toward his lips as he was finishing the drink

James Taylor, left, is representing Duane Putzier in his case. Putzier is asking for $2,026 plus any general damages

James Taylor, left, is representing Duane Putzier in his case. Putzier is asking for $2,026 plus any general damages

In court documents, attorneys for Coca-Cola disputed that there was proof that the mouse ended up in the can during bottling.

The company said the mouse would have been in a more advanced stage of decomposition and the can would have been compromised by consequent gases, The Daily Republic in Mitchell, South Dakota, reported.

Brian Johnson, an attorney for the Atlanta-based company, told the Republic: 'It had fur. It had blood on its nose. It's limbs were intact. There was very minor decomposition.' 

Six weeks had passed between bottling and when Putzier opened the can on June 7.

Johnson said during a motions hearing Tuesday that he anticipates testimony from a veterinary pathologist, who will analyze the mouse's decomposition.

The defense also hopes to get testimony from the quality assurance manager and line supervisor of the Portland, Indiana, plant where the can was bottled.

Coca-Cola is alleging that if the mouse were in fact bottled inside the can, which was consumed by Putzier six weeks after bottling, then it would have been in a more advanced stage of decomposition

Coca-Cola is alleging that if the mouse were in fact bottled inside the can, which was consumed by Putzier six weeks after bottling, then it would have been in a more advanced stage of decomposition

Putzier is seeking $2,026, plus any general damages proven at trial, with interest. He is represented by James Taylor.

He sued under a new South Dakota law that allows certain cases to be handled more quickly, called expedited civil action. Under the law, each side is restricted to one witness and six hours.

But Johnson asked Judge Patrick Smith to change those limits for the case. 

Smith approved three experts for each party and agreed to lengthen the time limit for the trial. Johnson asked for four days, though the trial could take longer.

'Coca-Cola is faced with a claim that's really an attack on its brand,' Johnson said. 'Coca-Cola takes these cases extremely seriously and tries them all.' 

Comments 187

Share what you think

  View all

The comments below have not been moderated.

  View all

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

We are no longer accepting comments on this article.