Question: Do you review the police report in preparing for a Maryland DUI case? Can you attack the police report as part of the defense?
Answer: Yes, we definitely review the police report. In fact, it’s the only real-time answer that we get as far as what actually occurred out there on the roadway, unless there’s video. So we kind of have to take, you know, start our case from reading through the discovery to get an idea of what the officer’s going to testify to. And yes, they’re extremely formulaic. They are obviously cut-and-paste.
There’s a lot of times where you’ll see a defendant’s name, a totally different name—you know, you’ll see Adams in there, defendant Adams, and that was obviously somebody who would have been arrested prior to your client because your client’s name was Martinez. They generally use the exact same wording on almost every DUI. I’m not sure if there’s as many attorneys that do as many DUIs as my office does, but the statement of charges are sometimes almost virtually identical outside of the names being changed.
And yes, it’s absolutely something that we use against them. When an officer uses a word to describe the odor of alcohol that is, say, “overly pungent” or “extremely pungent,” something like that, it’s kind of a unique term. So when you see him use that on, just recently I was in court, I had two cases with the same officer and he used the exact same statement. Well, if you’re trying to embellish the odor of alcohol by using a word like “pungent,” and you use the exact same word for both, you can cross-examine him and say, during the first trial he says, “Oh, well it was overwhelming, it was unusually strong,” and then, you know, attack him because he obviously used it recently as well. So yes, they’re very formulaic; you can attack them.
Often the officer just memorizes, you know, their fact pattern and then will throw in the person’s name every once in a while testifying. It’s the easiest way for them to be able to testify sort of uniformly. You can subpoena prior police reports written by that officer and basically attack his credibility and memory of the incident if it appears to be overly pre-written. So, yes, that is something that is a great way to attack a case and the officer’s credibility, when you find out or are able to prove that he uses pretty much the same writings.
Popular DUI/DWI Topics
› Frequently Asked DUI Questions and Education
› Payment Plans and Financing a DUI
› Example DUI/DWI Case Results
› Pleading Guilty and Going To Jail
› Do I need a lawyer? Can’t I represent myself in my Maryland DUI/DWI case?
› Appear in Court for DUI charge
› Do most DUI/DWI cases go to court in Maryland?
› Do most DUI/DWI cases go to trial in Maryland?
› Can you explain the MVA hearing in Maryland?
› What is the look back period for a DUI/DWI in Maryland?
› Will a DUI/DWI in Maryland cause a person to lose his job?
› Will a standard background check show a DUI/DWI arrest and/or conviction in Maryland?
› How accurate is the preliminary breath test in Maryland and am I required to take it?
› How accurate is the official breath alcohol test in Maryland?
Free Case Evaluation
DUI/DWI Defenses and Court
› What are some common tactics that you use to get a DUI case reduced or dismissed in Maryland?
› Why would an innocent person plead guilty to a DUI/DWI charge in Maryland?
› Are there alternative or therapeutic courts available in Maryland?
› What are some ways to attack the field sobriety tests in Maryland DUI cases?
› DUI Charge & Pleading No Contest
› Why would you need an expert witness in a DUI case in Maryland?
Penalties
› Can you explain the penalties for a first offense DUI in Maryland?
› What are some of the repercussions later in life from a DUI conviction in Maryland?
› Will a DUI/DWI conviction in Maryland affect my credit score?
› Are there any places that I cannot drive to with a restricted driver’s license in Maryland?
› What is an ignition interlock device and when might one be required in Maryland?
› What is the average cost of a Maryland ignition interlock device?
› DUI Accidental Death Penalties
› DUI Causing Injury Penalties
Roadside Test & Police
› What happens if you refuse the roadside breath test in Maryland?
› What should I say if a Maryland police officer asks if I have been drinking?
› Are Maryland police reports ever inaccurate?
› What is the difference between a hospital blood draw and a police blood draw in Maryland?
› How do police conduct drunk driving investigations in Maryland? What are they looking for?
› Can there be other causes for the physical signs of intoxication?
› What role does the police report play in a Maryland DUI/DWI case?
› Should I record a traffic stop with my smartphone? Can the video be used as evidence?
› Do police have to be within their jurisdiction to pull me over for DUI in Maryland?
› DUI Roadblocks or Checkpoints
› Odor of Alcohol & DUI Reports
Laws
› What does probable cause mean in Maryland?
› Can you explain what “per se” means in Maryland?
› What does implied consent mean in Maryland?
› Can a Maryland DUI/DWI charge affect my right to vote, carry a weapon, or other rights?
› Noah’s Law Impact on DUI Cases
Field Sobriety Tests & Defenses
› Is refusing to take a breath test considered a criminal act in Maryland?
› Are there ways to contest the blood test in Maryland?
› What are the repercussions for refusing the official state breath test in Maryland?
› What is the impact of a BAC number whether it is above or below a .08 in Maryland?
› Can a fever affect a Maryland DUI blood or breath test?
› Can the way a person blows into the Maryland breath test machine impact the results?
› Is it better for my case if I to fail the breath test or if I refuse a Maryland DUI breath test?
› Can you explain the Maryland HGN test?
› Can you explain the Maryland one leg stand test?
› What are some defenses you have used against the one-leg stand field sobriety test in Maryland?
› Can you explain the Maryland walk and turn test?
› What are some defenses for someone who failed walk-and-turn test in Maryland?
› What are some defenses you have used for a client who failed the roadside breath test in Maryland?
› Can I request an independent breath or blood test in Maryland?
› What are some medical conditions that could affect the breath alcohol test in Maryland?
› Can you explain the Maryland breath test observation period?
› Required to Take Field Sobriety Tests
› Non-Standardized Field Sobriety Tests
FAQ
› What is the first thing a person should do after a DUI/DWI arrest in Maryland?
› What can you do to be proactive about your pending DUI case in Maryland?
› Do I need to hire an attorney from the area in which I got the DUI?
› Can you explain a rising blood alcohol level in Maryland?
› What is mouth alcohol in Maryland?
› What happens if I plead guilty to DUI/DWI in court in Maryland?
› Can being nervous impair a person’s driving ability?
› Can I be charged with DUI if I am on private property in Maryland?
› What are the laws in Maryland regarding boating under the influence?
› Difference Between DUI and DWI
› DUI Reported Licensing Board or Commission
› DUI Charge Impacts Professional Licenses
› Represent Medical Doctor at Disciplinary Hearing
› DUI Charge but Live in another State
Non-Driving DUI
› Do I have to be driving a vehicle to be charged with DUI in Maryland?
› What are the factors considered in a non-driving DUI case in Maryland?
› How might a keyless ignition impact a non-driving DUI charge in Maryland?
Drug Related Offenses
› Can you explain drugged driving in Maryland?
› How do Maryland police show impairment in marijuana DUI cases?
› Prescribed Medication & Impaired Driving
About the Firm
› What sets Bruce Robinson & Associates apart from other DUI/DWI attorneys and firms in Maryland?
› What made you interested in practicing law and DUI defense specifically?
› Can you discuss several of your most recent Maryland DUI/DWI case wins?
› What sets Bruce Robinson apart from other DUI attorneys in Maryland?