JEFF PRESTRIDGE: Building society bosses are earning mountains of pay that many customers can only dream about
Although a diminishing force, building societies remain an important part of the personal finance jigsaw, providing us with homes for our money and loans for the houses we want to live in.
I was reminded of their positive impact recently when romping around the fells of the Lake District in brilliant sunshine. For one glorious week I parked myself, running shoes and walking boots in Ambleside, right next door to Windermere. Sublime.
Like most towns up and down the country, Ambleside has its issues, including a high turnover of retailers. But being the southern gateway to the Lakes, tourists (come rain, snow or sun) are always roaming its streets.
Looking to the future: Cumberland Building Society is determined to support the local economy around Ambleside
Ambleside has a winning combination of bed and breakfasts, guest houses, public houses, classy restaurants (Lucy’s, the Old Stamp House and Lake Road Kitchen) and a network of cinema venues (Zeffirellis) ready to come to the rescue when the heavens open – as they do on a regular basis.
Yet despite all this positivity, every mainstream bank – much to the anger of local retailers – has now deserted the town. Only Cumberland Building Society remains on its high street, determined to support the local economy it depends upon to grow as a business.
Cumberland is doing in Ambleside what all building societies should be attempting to do – which is to make a difference, be a force for good and provide a rock-solid financial pillar for the communities they serve.
But sadly, it is the exception, not the norm. I will write in more detail on the support it gives to local communities in the coming weeks.
While many building societies proclaim that they hold the moral high ground over the banks because they are not subservient to dividend-hungry shareholders, it is often a sham. Like the banks, they are not averse to shutting branches (Skipton) or paying meagre interest on savings accounts.
Nowhere is this sham more evident than in the boardroom where chief executives – come Lake District rain or shine – continue to receive inflation-busting increases in their annual remuneration.
Mountains of pay that many customers – borrowers and hard-pressed savers – can only ever dream of receiving. The sums paid, as revealed in our special investigation on the previous page, may not be as eye-catching as the multi-million pound packages received by the bosses of some of the country’s biggest companies.
But they are still bound to annoy many building society customers, not just in terms of size but because of how they have been arrived at.
Often, executive remuneration is inflated by six-figure awards granted under performance schemes that should have no place at a building society.
These schemes – modelled on executive incentive plans in the private sector – are devised by external consultants and accepted with readiness by remuneration committees appointed to preside over executive pay. Of course they are loved by the executives who benefit from them.
Such plans make a mockery of mutuality. Surely, if the executives of building societies want plc-like rewards, they should either venture into the plc world or do the honourable thing and convert their businesses so that they can then come under the same level of scrutiny as stock market-listed companies.
Given the fact that all societies that went down such a demutualisation route in the late 1980s and 1990s are no longer independent businesses, I doubt any of the current crop would survive for long.
It seems many building society executives want to have their cake and eat it too. On the one hand they like to present their organisations as cuddly, member-owned businesses. But when it comes to their own pay, they want it very much modelled on plc principles. More bonanza than fair.
So, if you are a member of a building society that has just sent you an annual general meeting voting pack, I urge you to scrutinise the accompanying financial statement. If the chief executive’s pay has rocketed and it irks you somewhat, may I suggest you vote against the directors’ remuneration report?
In so doing, you will be sending a message – loud and clear – that you want your building society to be run for the benefit of society. Where local communities such as Ambleside are supported (thank you Cumberland) and customers’ – not executives’ – personal financial interests come top of the pile.
Most watched Money videos
- The new Volkswagen Passat - a long range PHEV that's only available as an estate
- Tesla releases new 'Smart Summon' allowing the car to come to you
- German car giant BMW has released the X2 and it has gone electric!
- Mini unveil an electrified version of their popular Countryman
- Iconic Dodge Charger goes electric as company unveils its Daytona
- Skoda reveals Skoda Epiq as part of an all-electric car portfolio
- MG unveils new MG3 - Britain's cheapest full-hybrid car
- How to invest to beat tax raids and make more of your money
- BMW meets Swarovski and releases BMW i7 Crystal Headlights Iconic Glow
- Mail Online takes a tour of Gatwick's modern EV charging station
- Dacia Spring is Britain's cheapest EV at under £15,000
- How to invest for income and growth: SAINTS' James Dow
- Bargain hunters boost B&M; sales as former Wilko shops see...
- Your ultimate guide to bagging a Paris Olympics ticket:...
- Bootmaker Dr Martens warns annual profits could plunge by...
- Noose tightens on Iran... but could there be a 'Ukraine...
- Louis Vuitton and Christian Dior-owner LVMH hit as luxury...
- The 25 trickiest home buying terms explained, from...
- Alfa Romeo EV will NOT be called Milano after claims it...
- Recruiters Hays and Robert Walters make more redundancies...
- BUSINESS LIVE: Superdry to delist; B&M; expects high...
- St James's Place paid £213K to HMRC for my inheritance...
- Craft breweries under threat with a 49% leap in closures...
- Big banks ignoring new rules that let savers open more...
- Royal Mail insists it will keep fining innocent victims...
- Petrol edges towards 150p a litre as drivers see steepest...
- Can you sell a car that has outstanding parking tickets?...
- MARKET REPORT: Global hiring slowdown takes tolls on...
- Superdry to delist from LSE as part of restructuring plan
- Americans win battle for DS Smith: Footsie packaging...