Gift shops are everywhere on Bald Head Island.  There are several different stores on the island that provide apparel, gifts, souvenirs, and BHI insignia's.
  
The Lighthouse Keeper provides the best coffee and ice cream available on Bald Head Island.  Sit back, chat with locals, look over the marina and watch the day go by.  Also available here is nautical attire, paintings of BHI from local artists, jewelry, hats and apparel Bring some money with you, something is sure to catch your eye. 

Turtle Central on East Beach provides sweatshirts, hats, jewelry and other items dedicated to the preservation of the endangered sea turtles.  These funds contribute to funding the sea turtle preservation program.  Before heading to Turtle Central, make sure your golf cart is fully charged.

On the beach, close to the ferry, is Island Passage.  This is a great place to buy BHI insignia products.  As well as tee shirts, sweat shirts and beach towels.  It is the only place around to rent extra bikes and golf carts.  Ask for Pop's.

Last, but not least is Ship's Chandler.   For all your grocery needs, while on Bald Head Island.  The Ship's Chandler provides a deli, wide selection of grocery items, beach towels, tee shirts, fishing rod's and bait, and spirits.