The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/all/20050402061031/http://www.whatbooks.com:80/fiction/girl_stand.php
Book Reviews
home Books Music DVD's Video Games Software contact
USA What-Books UK What-Books Canada What-Books


Here's a list of our most recent reviews in the 'Fiction' section

Men and Cartoons
Cold Spring Harbor
Mansfield
Cold Spring Harbor
The Time Traveler's Wife
December Heat
A Girl Could Stand Up
Mr. Vogel
 
 
 
Go back to our 'Fiction Books' section. Click Here

fiction
childrens
food & drink
home & garden
history
humor
thrillers & horror
reference
best of 2003
best of 2004
award winners
author focus
Bill Bryson
Tom Clancy
J. K. Rowling
Dan Brown
John Grisham
camera & photo store
NEW: magazines store
 
View Larger Picture of A Girl Could Stand Up  by Leslie Marshall

A Girl Could Stand Up

List price: $24.00
Our price: $16.32
(You save: $ 7.68 )


Read more about A Girl Could Stand Up
Bookmark A Girl Could Stand Up for later

A Girl Could Stand Up
by Authors: Leslie Marshall

Hardcover

Orphaned at the age of six, Elray Mayhew is forced to confront a bizarre adult world that is trying to shelter her from grief. Although her uncle Harwood and his cross-dressing brother Aunt Ajax lovingly embrace their new roles as parents, when a fiercely efficient Irish lawyer intervenes to sort out compensation surrounding the accidental death of Elray's parents, she is not convinced that the court will favor the eccentric family set-up. And Ajax still insists upon feeding her niece rose-petal water from the garden - a routine that Elray finds far less extraordinary than her psychiatrist's probing fascination with her parents.

The narrative voice is continually shifting and Marshall blurs the distinction between the exterior landscapes and the "mind-movies" of a sharply observant child trying to make sense of a comically irrational world.

Average Customer Rating:

Great fun

Quick read, never lags. Quirky characters and a few plot twists. Shame on Publisher's Weekly for giving away so many plot details. I'm glad I read the book before reading their review. A little fanciful, but where's the harm in that?

Read more about A Girl Could Stand Up


Delightfully quirky first novel

Oh, man, prepare to suspend belief and just sit back and enjoy this one. I mean, when the book starts out with a little kid's parents being electrocuted in the Tunnel of Love and her being sent off to be raised by two bachelor uncles (one of whom is a transvestite), you just have to go with the flow. Things flow along, and Elray (that's the girl - don't ask about the silly name) meets Raoul, who introduces her to the concept of sexuality; then she meets Granny Harwood, long dead - but she's not. Then she meets...well, just read it.
It's all a little over the top, and one gets the sense that the author is sometimes trying too hard. But, in spite of some faults, A Girl Could Stand Up stands as a testament to the 'new' definition of Family, in all its myriad manifestations.

Read more about A Girl Could Stand Up


Promising start, disappointing follow-through

This book could have used a good editor. For my money, the book ends on page 272; unfortunately, the book is 372 pages long. There are some seeds of good story telling here, but the writer doesn't trust herself to stay with her main characters and give the reader a satisfying journey with them. Instead, she introduces new characters right up to the last page of the book, relinquishing or giving short shrift to the ones we've grown interested in. I also found myself growing exasperated with the self-conscious quirkiness of the characters. A little goes a long way with a story like this, and it's much easier to relate to characters who who don't seem to have their idiosyncracies pasted on. The book jacket draws parallels between this writer and John Irving, and it's true to some extent. But it's Irving's weaknesses she seems to share, not his strengths, ie., his tendency to dispatch characters heartlessly, to throw in ill-advised and unnecessary plot twists, to leave us with the sense that we've spent a very long time with characters we still don't fully know.

Nevertheless, I was very taken by the premise of the book -- the child who loses her parents in a freak accident and ends up being parented by two flawed uncles. If she could have stayed with that, and the boy Raoul whom she finds in her loneliness, the book would have held my attention much more.

Read more about A Girl Could Stand Up


Have you read this book? or have read a book by this author before? If so then please give the book a review so that we can advise other users on a books' potential.

Name:
Comment: 

Can't find what you're looking for? Then try Google.
Google



A Whole World of Trouble: A Novel

Good Grief

The Monk Downstairs : A Novel

The Center of Everything

Sleep Toward Heaven : A Novel
HOME | USA STORE | UK STORE
DISCLAIMERWHAT MUSIC | FPGA ONLINE | MAGAZINE SUBSCRIPTIONS | CAMERA & PHOTO | NEW PAGES
STEPHEN KING | TOM CLANCY | BILL BRYSONJK ROWLING | JOHN GRISHAM | DAN BROWN | CHILDRENS BOOKSAWARD WINNING BOOKS
FOOD & DRINK | HOME & GARDEN | HORROR FICTION | FICTION BOOKS | HISTORY | HUMOR