The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/all/20060325202624/http://www.whatbooks.com/fiction/men_cartoons.php
Book Reviews
home Books Music DVD's Video Games Software Camera Magazines Kitchen contact
USA What-Books UK What-Books Canada What-Books


Here's a list of our most recent reviews in the 'Fiction' section

Man with the Golden Arm
Empress Orchid
Men and Cartoons
Cold Spring Harbor
Mansfield
Cold Spring Harbor
The Time Traveler's Wife
December Heat
A Girl Could Stand Up
Mr. Vogel
 
 
 
Go back to our 'Fiction Books' section. Click Here

fiction
childrens
food & drink
home & garden
history
humor
thrillers & horror
reference
best of 2003
best of 2004
best of 2005
award winners
author focus
Bill Bryson
Tom Clancy
J. K. Rowling
Dan Brown
John Grisham
Nick Hornby
camera & photo store
magazines store
 
View Larger Picture of Men and Cartoons : Stories  by Jonathan Lethem

Men and Cartoons : Stories

List price: $19.95
Our price: $13.57
(You save: $ 6.38 )


Read more about Men and Cartoons : Stories
Bookmark Men and Cartoons : Stories for later

Men and Cartoons : Stories
by Authors: Jonathan Lethem

Hardcover

During the first story in this meager collection, someone assumes a "Lou Brock-style" stance and lifts "one Nimoyesque eyebrow", while another character tells a tale with a "Clint Eastwoodian climax". Even readers who feel at home with the references to baseball park, space opera and film back catalogue are likely to ponder some uneasy questions. Is this parasitic language really (as the publisher claims) "revelatory" writing? Does it define and consecrate an "ironic, heartbroken, eerie and absurd territory" or is it merely part of a checklist of mawkish adolescent allusions?

The answers aren't encouraging.

Sometimes these new stories seem like reheated portions from Jonathan Lethem's recent disappointing novel, The Fortress of Solitude. That book relied far too much on the presumed numinous associations of pop trivia. The title was taken from Superman comics; there were endless recitals of the names of trashy television shows and forgettable punk bands. There is much more of the same here. There is also another kitten killed accidentally by a child, and yet another cryptic postcard mailed from out West. Too many people are again involved in teaching at New York colleges or hanging around the Manhattan art world.

Lethem is plainly aware - as the title suggests - that bringing together childhood tastes and mature lives offers an opportunity for wry observation. He is, however, too lenient towards his principal characters. They are frequently verbose and solitary men, involved in slack scenarios where they re-encounter an old school friend, feel some kind of disturbing rivalry and find themselves psychologically defeated. But for all the knowing talk about these adults having once been "quarantined in their shared nerdiness" or about the inadequacies of "howling nostalgia" or "high-school-sensibility", the irony remains indulgent and self-servingly simplistic.

Universities and pop culture are present as the twin props of a milieu that is far less broad and sophisticated than it congratulates itself on being. Phrases such as "I was at Rutgers then, on a second postdoc" or "I was on the phone with my Hollywood agent" induce a feeling of all too predictable boredom rather than stimulation or deferential respect. The over academic approach easily becomes a bad habit. One narrator describes a prank he and a fellow student used to play in school (taping crude paper spectacles on a bronze bust of Toscanini) and then adds unnecessarily that "the glasses stood for our own paper-thin new sensibilities".

The disturbing possibilities present in strange narrative juxtapositions are dissolved by the warm flood of sentimentality washing over them. A science fiction writer, known as the Dystopianist, imagines a "Sylvia Plath Sheep" that can communicate its suicidal despair to other species, and then finds the creature knocking on his door and addressing him sarcastically. The uncanniness seems merely arbitrary; the sense of potential portent reduced to vulgar facetiousness, as conventional and unremarkable realism is willfully injected with a feebly transgressive dose of magic. Although he has been widely praised for his fine style, Lethem's language is often clumsy. He uses clichés such as "shrouded visages" and "mortal pang", or allows himself redundancies such as "a queasy earth-shifty sensation" or "pure vertigo, cliff-side terror".

Favored metaphors are awkwardly repeated. There are rhetorical flourishes ludicrously inappropriate to their circumstances. Someone's soul "creaked in irrelevant despair"; someone else wonders "where to steer the speeding motorcycle of one's own innocence"; a school bus is like an orange juice carton "spilling out the human vitamin of youthful lunacy".

The apparent ethical concern in Lethem's stories can be perfunctory and insultingly frivolous. His characters are intrinsically too foolish and fragile for the moral weight they are supposed to bear. Big themes are referenced. But the loft), solemnity is unearned. The stories are trifling despite their obtrusive wish not to be. Although they gesture towards the realm of adult responsibility, they remain emotionally stuck in the seventh grade.

Average Customer Rating:

Beware of Sylvia Plath sheep . . .

If you sit down with Lethem expecting a straightforward narrative, you'd better look elsewhere. He always incorporates something of the experimental, the bizarre, or the just plain odd in his work, whether his consistently novels or his relatively less known short work. These nine stories are a good introduction, including "Access Fantasy," a very good science-fictional story about life in the extremely slow (not to say non-moving) lane, and "Vivian Relf,"an intriguing thought piece about deja vu all over again. The best story, I think, is the first in the volume: "The Vision," about parlor games and curiosity and finding out more than you really wanted to know. On the other hand, "Super Goat Man," is a not entirely successful yarn is about a not very successful comic book hero relegated to academe and the narrator's interactions with him over the years, and "The National Anthem," in the form of a letter from one old friend to another, left me wondering what Lethem's point was. Even though they're not all equally successful, though, there's a great deal to enjoy in this short collection.

Read more about Men and Cartoons : Stories


The Lethem Style at Work

With a Jonathan Lethem novel, you're never quite sure what genre you will be reading. Motherless Brooklyn is, on the surface at least, a mystery, with a PI as main character. The Fortress of Solitude is an epic that spans thirty years and encompasses all that described the 70's, 80's and 90's--drugs, war, racial relations.

Lethem's latest, Men and Cartoons, is a mixed bag of nine short stories. From fantasy ("Super Goat Man" and "The Spray") to futuristic ("Access Fantasy") and surrealistic ("The Dystopianist, Thinking of His Rival, Is Interrupted by a Knock on the Door"), what you will find in this collection is Lethem's incredible style of writing, his imaginative and creative way of turning a phrase, and his realistic dialogue. Characters are vivid and memorable, and subject matter is often dark and disturbing, many times encompassing social satire and the human condition.

Read more about Men and Cartoons : Stories


A well deserved break, but nothing like his last 2 books

If, like me, you thought Lethem's last 2 books were phenomenal, you can forgive him this somewhat uneven collection. He's clearly taking a break from writing original fiction and he deserves it.

Read more about Men and Cartoons : Stories


Have you read this book? or have read a book by this author before? If so then please give the book a review so that we can advise other users on a books' potential.

Name:
Comment: 

Can't find what you're looking for? Then try Google.
Google



The Disappointment Artist

The Fortress of Solitude (Vintage Contemporaries)

This Shape We're In

Motherless Brooklyn

As She Climbed Across the Table : A Novel (Vintage Contemporaries)
HOME | USA STORE | UK STORE
DISCLAIMERSILICON CLOUD | WHAT MUSIC | MAGAZINE SUBSCRIPTIONS | CAMERA & PHOTO | KITCHEN | NEW PAGES
STEPHEN KING | TOM CLANCY | BILL BRYSONJK ROWLING | JOHN GRISHAM | DAN BROWN | CHILDRENS BOOKSAWARD WINNING BOOKS
NICK HORNBY | FOOD & DRINK | HOME & GARDEN | HORROR FICTION | FICTION BOOKS | HISTORY | HUMOR