The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/all/20060521150733/http://www.velaw.com/resources/resource_detail.asp?rid=322538301&rtype=pub
Health Headlines
Issue No. 05-05
January 31, 2005
Issue Editor: Jason Pinkall
1. OIG ISSUES SUPPLEMENTAL COMPLIANCE PROGRAM GUIDANCE FOR HOSPITALS IN ANTI-KICKBACK AREA — On January 27, 2005, the HHS Office of Inspector General (“OIG”) issued additional compliance guidance for hospitals, supplementing the guidance it issued in 1998.  Among a number of compliance issues addressed, the OIG highlighted and discussed seven areas of potential concern under the federal anti-kickback statute:  (i) joint ventures, (ii) compensation arrangements with physicians, (iii) relationships with other health care entities (such as ambulance companies, home health agencies, and nursing facilities), (iv) recruitment arrangements, (v) discounts, (vi) medical staff credentialing, and (vii) malpractice insurance subsidies.  The guidance also addresses “gainsharing” arrangements under the anti-kickback statute.  The discussion is essentially the same as the draft supplemental compliance guidance the OIG issued in June 2004.  It reiterates past OIG statements from advisory opinions, special fraud alerts, and other guidance that has been widely circulated.  While not presenting any change in the OIG’s perspective on these issues, it is always helpful to know where the OIG is currently focusing its thinking and to confirm that its analysis remains consistent with existing guidance.  Reporter Debbi Johnstone, Houston, 713.758.3420 or mailto:djohnstone@velaw.com.

2. NEPHROLOGIST TRADE ASSOCIATION SUES HHS AND CMS OVER FAIR MARKET VALUE COMPENSATION PROVISION IN STARK II PHASE II REGULATIONS — In a creative lawsuit filed on January 14, 2005, in federal district court in Washington, D.C., the Renal Physicians Association ("RPA") sued the Department of Health and Human Services and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services alleging that the new Fair Market Value Compensation safe harbor in the Stark II Phase II Regulations, which were effective July 26. 2004, will result in nephrologists who serve as medical directors of dialysis facilities being unfairly compensated if the facilities elect to pay them under the safe harbor.  The RPA argues that CMS violated the Administrative Procedure Act by issuing the safe harbor as a final rule with comment period rather than as a proposed rule.  The safe harbor, compliance with which is voluntary, provides protection from challenges that hourly compensation paid to physicians violates the Stark Law’s fair market value requirements if the compensation falls within one of two methods set out in the regulation.  The RPA argues that payment to nephrologists in accordance with these methods would unfairly reduce their compensation as dialysis facility medical directors.  This could result, according to the lawsuit, in a reduction of qualified nephrologists serving in these roles, which would then compromise patient care.  With a questionable likelihood of ultimate success in this lawsuit, it is likely the RPA is trying to dissuade the dialysis facilities, many of which are owned by large, national companies, from implementing the safe harbor’s provisions.  Reporter Debbi Johnstone, Houston, 713.758.3420 or mailto:djohnstone@velaw.com.

3. STATE USE OF INTERGOVERNMENTAL TRANSFERS ANALYZED BY CONGRESS — The apparent concern with the use of intergovernmental transfers by states to draw down federal Medicaid dollars has persisted into the new 109th Congress as the House Energy & Commerce Committee chair, Representative Joe Barton (R. Tex.), has requested that 20 hospitals in 10 states provide information regarding additional federal Medicaid matching funds they may have generated.  Data requested includes:  total net patient revenue, gross Medicaid revenue, cost-to-charge ratio and total Medicaid funds received.  Details of state/provider financing mechanisms were also requested.  The E&C; committee remains concerned that states are using inappropriate “recycling” mechanisms to draw down additional federal matching dollars and that some providers may be receiving Medicaid funds in excess of their legitimate Medicaid shortfall.  For additional information regarding this congressional investigation, please contact Susan Feigin Harris, Houston, 713.758.3465 or mailto:sharris@velaw.com.

4. TX AG INVESTIGATION RESULTS IN FIRST CHARITY CARE SETTLEMENT — In the first publicized agreement concerning charity care, Dallas’ Zale Lipsky University Hospital has agreed to create a $3.5 million endowment devoted to indigent care.  The agreement was spurred by an investigation by the Texas Attorney General into the level of charity care provided by the hospital, as reported on its annual charity care filing required by state law.  The AG had concluded following its review that the hospital had provided less indigent care than required by law, despite the provisions in the law requiring that a “reasonableness” standard be utilized in relation to established community need.  The AG is currently conducting similar Requests to Examine and is actively reviewing the financial strength, the community benefits programs, and the reported charity care activity of several hospitals in Texas.  For more information regarding these audits or compliance with the Texas charity care statute, please contact Susan Feigin Harris, Houston, 713.758.3465 or mailto:sharris@velaw.com.

To view this week's Health Briefs (a listing of Federal and Texas regulations affecting health care), visit our website at http://www.velaw.com/pdf/resources/HB012805.pdf.

For more information about Vinson & Elkins' HIPAA Consortium, please contact Brenda Strama at 512.542.8544 or mailto:bstrama@velaw.com.

*************************************
Editor: J.D. Epstein mailto:jepstein@velaw.com
Issue Editor: Jason Pinkall mailto:jpinkall@velaw.com


This bulletin is intended to afford immediate notice to our clients and friends of certain events in health law. It is not intended, nor should it be used, as a substitute for specific legal advice regarding particular factual situations.

Austin
Amanda Borichevsky
Elizabeth Rogers
Leah Stewart
Brenda Strama
Joe Bill Watkins

Dallas
David Berry
Dean Harvey
Mike Malone

Houston
Dennis Dunn
Gary Eiland
J.D. Epstein
Todd Greenwalt
Pat Holmes
Debbi Johnstone
Nancy LeGros

Washington
Dennis Barry
Douglas Grimm
Chris Keough
Joseph Lynch
Christina McGarvey
Larry Oday
Harry Richards
Andrew Ruskin
Stephanie Webster



>> Back to Top