National LegislationAGD continuously monitors national legislation so that the organization can communicate the interest of the general dentist to interested parties. In addition, the organization maintains policies to communicate the AGD position when speaking to national legislators on the general dentists’ behalf. AGD encourages its members to advocate on behalf of the profession as well. Review the current list of the AGD dental care and legislative policies to use in your communications with local lawmakers. In addition, the AGD publishes updates on national legislation that may affect general dentists. Click on the links below to learn more about national legislation that the AGD is monitoring or view earlier legislative updates from the AGD by click on the archive link on the right.
Under fast-moving circumstances, the House Oversight and Government Reform Domestic Policy Subcommittee held a hearing on Wed., Nov. 14, 2007, to discuss the impact of dental amalgam on the environment. Federal Agencies on the Stand The first testimony came from Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) officials, who stated that dental amalgam accounts for 20 to 30 percent of all mercury that gets into wastewater. They also were criticized for not doing more to study and reduce the environmental effects of mercury used in dental fillings and offices. During this criticism, the chair of the subcommittee holding this hearing, Dennis Kucinich (D-OH-10), asked many questions. In response, Ephraim King, director of the Office of Science and Technology in EPA's Office of Water, acknowledged that the figure of mercury leached into wastewater from dental offices could be closer to 36 percent. Following that statement, King noted, “[w]hat we are trying to do is to get municipal wastewater systems to work with dental offices to find ways to improve that number." Two Members of Congress Berate Dental Amalgam Rep. Dan Burton (R-5-IN) berated King and Norris Alderson, director of the Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) Office of Science and Health Coordination, for lack of action. Particularly, Burton pressed the question of why mercury cannot be removed altogether from dental fillings, noting, “[t]his really bothers me because we continue to say that mercury is toxic if we burn things with mercury in it or eat more than 12 ounces of fish, but you continue to say that if we put mercury in our mouths it doesn't have any adverse affects on humans." Another longtime critic of dental amalgam, Rep. Diane Watson (D-33-CA), pushed for an assessment of how mercury affects the environment and people, telling the witnesses about her adverse reaction to fillings she received when she was nine years old. She repeatedly asked Alderson if the FDA would do “an assessment of the danger.” To date, this has not been done by the FDA. Dentistry Responds, Noting Scientific Data When Rod Mackert, DMD, PhD, an American Dental Association spokesperson, testified later in the hearing, he noted that recent estimates show that dental amalgams only account for approximately 30 percent of all dental restorations. He detailed all the work accomplished by the dental community, specifically noting the development of best management practices for amalgam waste. Citing the use of chairside traps and vacuum pump filters (if compatible) remove approximately 77 percent of the scrap amalgam from dental office wastewater as well as other efforts of the profession, he concluded that mandates to regulate dental amalgam in the dental office would be unnecessary, as the profession clearly is mobilized to resolve this issue.
Peruse the text or watch a video of those who testified at the hearing.
Impact on General Dentists: It is not clear why this hearing was scheduled, and why it was not announced earlier. However, while this hearing was set up quickly, it is quite unlikely that legislation banning the use of mercury will move as quickly. The AGD will continue to monitor the situation and advise members accordingly should momentum start developing for this legislation.
|