Science and Technology at Scientific SEPTEMBER ISSUE AVAILABLE NOW:
 September issue >
 - Subscribe >

 Scientific American Mind >
Hurricane Backgrounder WEB HIGHLIGHTS:
 Health Channel
 Environment Channel
 Advanced Search
Home Latest Science News In Focus Science Stories Ask the Experts your science questions Recreations -- puzzles and interactive games Science image gallery Subscribe to the magazine or digital Scientific American Digital: more than a decade of science archived
September 10, 2005 Newsletters | RSSxml
July 2004 issue

Link to this article
E-mail this article
Printer-friendly version
The Mystery of the Voynich Manuscript
New analysis of a famously cryptic medieval document suggests that it contains nothing but gibberish
By Gordon Rugg
  1   2   3   4   next »
Image no longer available. The full versions of this and other articles from the print edition--including all graphics and sidebars--are available for purchase at Scientific American Digital.
STRANGE IMAGES  of heavenly spheres, fantastic plants and nude women adorn the pages of the Voynich manuscript, which is written in an odd script that does not match that of any known language. The manuscript now resides at the Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library at Yale University.

Overview/A Medieval Mystery

In 1912 Wilfrid Voynich, an American rare-book dealer, made the find of a lifetime in the library of a Jesuit college near Rome: a manuscript some 230 pages long, written in an unusual script and richly illustrated with bizarre images of plants, heavenly spheres and bathing women. Voynich immediately recognized the importance of his new acquisition. Although it superficially resembled the handbook of a medieval alchemist or herbalist, the manuscript appeared to be written entirely in code. Features in the illustrations, such as hairstyles, suggested that the book was produced sometime between 1470 and 1500, and a 17th-century letter accompanying the manuscript stated that it had been purchased by Rudolph II, the Holy Roman Emperor, in 1586. During the 1600s, at least two scholars apparently tried to decipher the manuscript, and then it disappeared for nearly 250 years until Voynich unearthed it.

Voynich asked the leading cryptographers of his day to decode the odd script, which did not match that of any known language. But despite 90 years of effort by some of the world's best code breakers, no one has been able to decipher Voynichese, as the script has become known. The nature and origin of the manuscript remain a mystery. The failure of the code-breaking attempts has raised the suspicion that there may not be any cipher to crack. Voynichese may contain no message at all, and the manuscript may simply be an elaborate hoax.

ADVERTISEMENT (article continues below)
Critics of this hypothesis have argued that Voynichese is too complex to be nonsense. How could a medieval hoaxer produce 230 pages of script with so many subtle regularities in the structure and distribution of the words? But I have recently discovered that one can replicate many of the remarkable features of Voynichese using a simple coding tool that was available in the 16th century. The text generated by this technique looks much like Voynichese, but it is merely gibberish, with no hidden message. This finding does not prove that the Voynich manuscript is a hoax, but it does bolster the long-held theory that an English adventurer named Edward Kelley may have concocted the document to defraud Rudolph II. (The emperor reportedly paid a sum of 600 ducats--equivalent to about $50,000 today--for the manuscript.)

Image no longer available. The full versions of this and other articles from the print edition--including all graphics and sidebars--are available for purchase at Scientific American Digital.
Perhaps more important, I believe that the methods used in this analysis of the Voynich mystery can be applied to difficult questions in other areas. Tackling this hoary puzzle requires expertise in several fields, including cryptography, linguistics and medieval history. As a researcher into expert reasoning--the study of the processes used to solve complex problems--I saw my work on the Voynich manuscript as an informal test of an approach that could be used to identify new ways of tackling long-standing scientific questions. The key step is determining the strengths and weaknesses of the expertise in the relevant fields.

Baby God's Eye?
The first purported decryption of the Voynich manuscript came in 1921. William R. Newbold, a professor of philosophy at the University of Pennsylvania, claimed that each character in the Voynich script contained tiny pen strokes that could be seen only under magnification and that these strokes formed an ancient Greek shorthand. Based on his reading of the code, Newbold declared that the Voynich manuscript had been written by 13th-century philosopher-scientist Roger Bacon and described discoveries such as the invention of the microscope. Within a decade, however, critics debunked Newbold's solution by showing that the alleged microscopic features of the letters were actually natural cracks in the ink.

The Voynich manuscript appeared to be either an unusual code, an unknown language or a sophisticated hoax.

Newbold's attempt was just the start of a string of failures. In the 1940s amateur code breakers Joseph M. Feely and Leonell C. Strong used substitution ciphers that assigned Roman letters to the characters in Voynichese, but the purported translations made little sense. At the end of World War II the U.S. military cryptographers who cracked the Japanese Imperial Navy's codes passed some spare time tackling ciphertexts--encrypted texts--from antiquity. The team deciphered every one except the Voynich manuscript.

  1   2   3   4   next »
The Climax of Humanity
Can Extreme Poverty Be Eliminated?
Mindful of Symbols
The Mysteries of Mass
Scientific American Digital Learn more Subscribe to Digital Scientific American Digital: science coverage from 1993 to the present
Subscribe to Scientific American Magazine Renew your subscription Give a gift subscription Scientific American Magazine Susbscription Center
The Human Odyssey
Our Ever Changing Earth
Infectious Diseases
The Human Odyssey
  The man who saw it coming
  Cosmic 'cigar' spins at astonishing pace
  Hurricane seasons warm up
  Fit body for a fit mind
News from Scientific American Mind
See your ad here
Weekly Review E-Newsletter Exclusive Online Issues Alert TechBiz Alert SciAm MIND Alert
New Issue Alert Special Editions Alert Best-Seller List Alert
© 1996-2005 Scientific American, Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
Subscribe  |  Customer Care  |  Subscriber Alert  |  Order Issues  |  Site Map  |  Search  |  About Us  |  Contact Us
Advertising  |  Scientific American Digital  |  Institutional Site License  |  International Editions
Privacy Policy  |  Visitor Agreement  |  Permissions  |  Reprints  |  Custom Publishing  |  Partnerships/Licensing