The Vulnerability of Men

by Vincent Bach

I have been gathering my thoughts on what I think is the primary force behind circumcision in our culture - circumcised men. Iím not discounting secondary forces such as Medicaid and other health insurance providers, kooky doctors, foreskin aftermarket, etc. However, if there werenít so many circumcised males running around, I think the secondary forces would quickly disappear.

I see on the boards many times where a pregnant wife is frustrated when attempting to discuss the issue with her circumcised husband. She wants to leave her son intact but he wonít listen to reason. Well, the rest of this article is written specifically to try and offer some insight and suggestions for those ladies. I hope it helps someone. As an intact man who grew up and has lived among circumcised men, I think I have some insight into what drives their behavior on the issue of circumcision. Of course this doesnít apply to all of them, but I think my generalizations may be useful for you in dealing with this issue with your husband.

First of all, you need to understand that circumcised men are cornered on this issue. They were circumcised without their consent and have no inherent knowledge of what being intact is like. Even though they rarely will discuss the issue, they are keenly aware that they have been surgically altered in a very private way. There are several ways for a man to deal with this issue but the safest way, psychologically speaking, is to believe at all cost that the surgery performed on them was an enhancement and is preferred by women. Confirmation of this belief is essential to their sexual self-image. Do I need to tell you that sexual self-image is a major issue for men? Didnít think so.

Now put yourself in the shoes of the circumcised man. He asks for very little. All he wants is football on Sunday and to be assured that there is nothing wrong with his package. A nice bonus would be that women actually prefer it the way it is. Then along comes the newly pregnant wife and the issue of circumcision is no more personal to her than a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and she starts openly discussing it with him with all the casualness that she would with her gal pals down at the salon. Yikes! Batten down the hatch. Incoming torpedo!!!! At first the strategy is to dismiss her without appearing to be alarmed. Heíll probably toss back the usual "It's not clean" or "That could cause health problems" hoping this will scare her off since he assumes sheís heard those things before. He wonít seem particularly disturbed at first. Its part of being a man to not show vulnerability.

If this doesnít work and the wife mentions that she heard otherwise, heíll be shifting uncomfortably in his chair just a little but still keep his cool. At this point he may try plan B which is to make fun of you for your silly ideas. Maybe make a joke about turtlenecks. If you persist, heíll bring out the olí "I want him to be like me" knowing you women are suckers for us men when we talk of bonding and emotional attachment - any kind. Finally, if this doesnít work, heís probably going to relate some made up or exaggerated story from his school days when some uncircumcised kid at school was teased mercilessly until he circíd himself right in the middle of Shop class. The resulting low mark the kid received in Shop kept him out of Harvard and he had to settle for a life as a carnival worker. Do you REALLY want that for your son?

If you havenít given in by this time, he is probably now showing signs of agitation. Youíre close to getting the olí "I have the penis so I have the last word!" Most men wonít go beyond this point in the discussion. They will clam up and refuse to discuss it any more. If heís particularly panicked, heíll probably enlist the help of sympathetic family members or friends to weigh in on what a mistake it would be not to circumcise your son.

I think it's important to acknowledge that its perfectly understandable that our circumcised friends react this way. Men who have been circumcised have an extremely difficult dilemma. For them to acknowledge that the practice is unnecessary and harmful means that they must acknowledge a painful personal reality. For that reason circumcised men can be forgiven if they don't want to lead the parade in the fight against routine infant circumcision. I can empathize and therefore understand completely why so many men will voluntarily offer their sons up for the same procedure without giving it a second thought. To do otherwise opens them up to some vulnerable feelings that can be most unpleasant. Society puts lots of expectations on women but it also puts a couple on men. One of them is that he be sexually virile. You know - masculine, strong, potent GRRRRR!! I think many circumcised men accept without question and perpetuate the myths regarding the intact penis in order to cope with this particular expectation.

So, the problem is how do we save our sonís genitals without psychologically emasculating their fathers?

Hmm...well I think the first step is having a better understanding of just how personal an issue this is for him. The reason I spent so long discussing it is because it's extremely important and heís not going to tell you about it.

Going into the discussion, youíll be much better off knowing whatís really bothering him. Trust me, he really doesnít give a hooey whether his sonís penis looks like his. What is important is that his bulb is not dimmed. Probably not a good idea to refer to the practice in initial discussions as genital mutilation (although it certainly is that). The thing that you need to get across to him with all your female charm is that you love him EXACTLY the way he is and wouldnít change a thing. In other words, I think the best strategy is probably to build him up as high as you can before lowering this boom on him. The ship can only take a hit so big before going under. So get your armor out and start fortifying his self-image. What means everything to him is that he is the best lover and provider that you could ever hope for.

Please donít use my lame words exactly. I ainít got no feminine charm :-). I suspect you get it and can take it from here. Ironically, if you succeed, youíll be giving your man a huge future reward in that his son will someday be a man and will know all too well the tremendous courage it took for his father to break with this barbaric custom and leave him intact. With circumcision rates falling drastically and RIC possibly even being illegal by then, I predict heíll be forever thankful to the both of you. Good luck! Your son and family deserve your best effort.

writingsfor more original articles by vincent bach, return to regarding circumcision and intactness.

artwork and graphics by
b8 graphics
all original content © 2002 except as otherwise indicated
click for contact information and comments