|
| ||||||||||||
Public Eye Home Get Our Newsletter Public Eye Bios E-mail Public Eye Send In A Tip About Public Eye Public Eye RSS Feed CBS News RSS Feeds + Add To Favorites BROWSE TOPICS + 4th Estate Debate + All About Us + The Public Eye Chat + How It Works + CBS News Issues + Stuff We Like + From The Vault + Media Issues + In The News + Across The Media Universe BROWSE AUTHORS + Brian Montopoli + Hillary Profita + Vaughn Ververs + Dick Meyer BLOG ROLL + About The Blog Roll media CJR Editor & Publisher The Editors Weblog Journalism.org (PEJ) Lost Remote Media Bistro Media In The Mirror Media Matters Media Nation Media Research Center NRO Media Blog Romenesko others The Anchoress Buzz Machine Captain’s Quarters Crooks And Liars Daily Kos Global Voices Online Michelle Malkin The Moderate Voice Powerline Talking Points Memo The Plank Vodkapundit |
A Heartbreaker From Eichenwald And The TimesAnyone need a reminder that the New York Times is a great newspaper? Well, here you go: Kurt Eichenwald's heartbreaking story about a 13-year-old boy who got sucked into the world of online child pornography via his webcam. It began when someone offered Justin Berry $50 to take his shirt off, and from there escalated to the point where he was being paid thousands of dollars to have sex in front of the camera. And that's just the beginning. The Times pulled out all the stops on the story: In addition to Eichenwald's lengthy story, they offer video of Eichenwald's interview with Berry, a story about the nature of Berry's customers (many work with children), a piece on how the web invigorated the child pornography trade, and, perhaps most fascinatingly, Eichenwald's reporter's essay that details the story behind the story. It's a doozy. Eichenwald identified himself as a "fan" of Berry, not a reporter, and began an online conversation that went on for weeks; he then proposed that they meet in Los Angeles. There he identified himself as a reporter to Berry, who was shocked but agreed to speak to Eichenwald: Over the next two days, I interviewed the person I now knew was Justin Berry. By then, I was aware that Justin was addicted to cocaine and marijuana. With no expectation that he would agree, I asked him to stop. I also urged Justin to quit responding to messages from his adult admirers. Justin agreed to both requests.The strategy undertaken by Eichenwald, who consulted with his editors throughout the process, probably violated some of the standard conventions of the journalist-subject relationship, but I think even the most traditional journalism ethics professor would be hard pressed to make a case against him, in light of the larger picture. (Though a Romenesko reader asks: "What does [Poynter ethicist] Bob Steele make of this? Interesting ethical question.") The story is reminiscent of that which brought down Spokane mayor Jim West, a three-year investigation by the Spokesman-Review which detailed allegations of child molestation against the mayor, as well as allegations that he developed relationships with young men he met in gay.com chat rooms. The paper even hired a forensic computer consultant to pose as a teenager and exchange emails with West – emails which the paper posted online. The coverage kicked off an ethical debate in the journalism community. (You can read my interview with Spokesman-Review editor Steve Smith here.) Posted by Brian Montopoli at 12:27 PM : December 19, 2005 Read more posts in Stuff We Like E-mail this story Printable version
+ Public Eye |