Skip to main content

Go to:   
Guardian Unlimited
Search:
Guardian Unlimited Web
SocietyGuardian.co.uk
Home Health Communities Local government Voluntary sector Social care Talk
Conferences Books Big issues Comment Careers advice Jobs Help

Climbie inquiry

  Search Society


Sensationalism will obscure the point of the Climbié inquiry



David Batty
Monday January 21, 2002
SocietyGuardian.co.uk


If the chief executive of Railtrack had gone before the public inquiry into the Paddington rail crash and denied any responsibility for the disaster there would have been no end of public outrage.

Yet when the former chief executive of Haringey council took exactly this attitude at the inquiry into the tragic fate of Victoria Climbié - the eight-year old girl abused and murdered while in the care of the London borough - there was barely a whiff of interest. Even though the former local authority chief was Gurbux Singh, head of the commission for racial equality.

The contrast between this apparent indifference and last week's blanket coverage of the hysterical testimony of the great aunt who murdered Victoria could not have been more marked.

What's more it highlighted that we are in danger of losing sight of the aims of the inquiry: to discover how the child protection services failed to protect Victoria and recommend how the system should be overhauled to best prevent such tragedies in the future.

It would be disingenuous to suggest that Kouao's lurid disclosures of alleged sexual abuse and her paranoid claims to be the victim of a conspiracy did not offer a more exciting - and accessible - story than the damning but dry revelations of professional incompetence.

Draped in a scarlet shawl, her greying hair tied back tightly from her drawn but severe face, she spat out "I am not a monster" before launching into a heartless attack on Victoria's parents.

But for all its shock value, the killer's ranting and raving told us nothing we didn't already know: that she is unstable and unrepentant.

In contrast, Mr Singh's evidence fundamentally questioned the role of public sector chief executives - if he was not ultimately accountable for the failings of Haringey's child protection staff then who was?

The inquiry team has certainly tried to get across that the impact of its investigations could be as significant as the Macpherson report into the murder of Stephen Lawrence.

But among the national press only the Guardian and the Independent have regularly devoted substantial column inches to the evidence of the professionals involved in Victoria's case.

This is not surprising given the complexities of the inquiry - and that much of the evidence has been concerned with social services, which many other papers view as a politically correct waste of money for the undeserving.

A cynic might suggest the decision to bring Kouao before the inquiry was based on a desire to re-invigorate the media's interest. Inquiry chairman Lord Laming and his team must have known the killer refused to cooperate at the murder trial - so did they really think she would shed any new light on Victoria's plight?

The lesson of the Alder Hey inquiry into organ retention is that exploiting the media's desire for theatrics and the macabre can result in losing control of the message.

This poses a dilemma to the Climbié inquiry team - without the oxygen of publicity lessons will not be learned but in playing by the media's rules they risk their aims being obscured by sensationalism.

For if the impression we are left with is that Victoria's death was simply down to a madwoman and a bunch of incompetent social workers this would allow those who are paid good wages to take the buck to escape accountability again.




 Related articles
09.01.2002: Killer shows no remorse at Climbié inquiry
21.12.2001: NSPCC told to explain discrepancies in evidence
20.12.2001: Politcial correctness 'puts children at risk'
19.12.2001: Singh washes his hands of blame
18.12.2001: 'Social services cash went to education'
18.12.2001: Ex-council chief: 'I could not have prevented Victoria's death'
14.12.2001: Climbié murderer to give evidence in person
13.12.2001: Fears of Climbié inquiry 'injustice'
11.12.2001: Council chief under fire for 'sorry saga' of delays
04.02.2002: Key figures in the Climbié case
21.02.2002: Timeline: the Climbié inquiry phase one
24.09.2001: Timeline: the lead up to the Climbié inquiry
20.11.2001: Climbié parents may sue over care failings
19.11.2001: Climbié PC shirked visit for fear of scabies
16.11.2001: 'Hundreds of Climbié cases waiting to happen'
12.11.2001: Haringey blasted for 'attempt to influence' Climbié inquiry
12.11.2001: Risk of abuse in private fostering arrangements
08.11.2001: 'Inconsistencies' in Climbié nurses' statements
19.10.2001: Climbiés 'badly served' by Brent social services
18.10.2001: Overstretched child care service 'unravelled'
17.10.2001: Climbié social worker 'barred from working with children'
13.10.2001: Day that could have saved Victoria
12.10.2001: 'I was wrong' admits Climbié social worker
12.10.2001: Climbié doctor admits errors put girl at risk
12.10.2001: Doctor 'suspected abuse'
11.10.2001: Chairman demands urgent investigation into chaotic council
09.10.2001: Climbié council closed cases inappropriately
05.10.2001: 'Chaotic' department lost track of Victoria
05.10.2001: Hospital visit key missed opportunity to save Victoria
28.09.2001: Councils underspent for children's services, Climbié inquiry told
28.09.2001: 'Inexperienced' social worker left to make complex decisions
01.10.2001: Social services were told Victoria's life was in danger
09.05.2001: Head of inquiry's target is to prevent child abuse tragedies

 Big issue
The Climbié inquiry

 Useful sites
Climbié inquiry official site
Department of Health quality protects programme
Department of Health children's taskforce (pdf)
Department for Education children and young people's unit
NSPCC
NCH Action for Children
Childline






Printable version | Send it to a friend | Save story



UP


SocietyGuardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media Limited 2007