Skip to main content

Go to:   
Guardian Unlimited
Search:
Guardian Unlimited Web
Guardian UnlimitedSpecial reports
Home UK Business Audio Podcasts The Wrap News blog Talk Search
The Guardian World News guide Arts Special reports Columnists Technology Help Quiz

Special report Crime

  Search this site


Go to...
Special report: crime

Crime archived articles




 In this section
Prosecutor to study evidence before deciding couple's future

Men who buy sex could face prosecution

Nick Cohen: City dwellers have every right to be afraid

New doubts over Madeleine DNA

A powerful tool - but not infallible

McCanns to fly home amid fear of charges

'Essex Boys' murder case may be reopened

Both Madeleine parents now declared suspects

Sympathy for beleaguered parents muted by jeers and suspicion

Traces of blood that turned grieving mother into suspect

What happened on night of May 3?

Mother whose outward poise and control hide her devastation

Victims ... now suspects: police target McCanns

Madeleine McCann case

Madeleine mother questioned for 11 hours

Explainer update

What is an arguido?



James Sturcke
Friday September 7, 2007
Guardian Unlimited


An "arguido" - normally translated as "named suspect" or "formal suspect" - is someone who is treated by Portuguese police as more than a witness, but has not been arrested or charged.

Under Portuguese law, a person declared an arguido - "arguida" in the case of a woman - has legal protection that is not extended to a witness, including the right to remain silent during questioning and the right to legal representation.



Detectives invoke arguido status on someone as a preliminary to an arrest being made or charges brought, a Portuguese law expert, Lita Gale, told Guardian Unlimited today.

"If you are an arguido they have to have suspicion that a crime has been committed by that person," she said.

She added that when someone's status moves from that of a witness to an arguido, the police interview technique changes.

"Depending on the answers they may be moving towards a prosecution. If you cannot provide an alibi or the right answers they may move to prosecute. This is a serious moment. The suspect may be close to being charged," Ms Gale said.

Technically, police should treat someone as an arguido as soon as they have sufficient evidence. However, in some circumstances they may hold back to give somebody "a false sense of security", she added.

In practical terms, a person has to be declared an arguido before he or she can be arrested. Police may also ask a local court to place restrictions on a person's movement and oblige them to not leave the country.

Once a case file is completed, the police pass it to the public ministry, the equivalent of the crown prosecution service, which decides whether an "acusacao" or indictment is brought.

Portuguese authorities express caution against expecting that arrests or charges will automatically follow.

It is not uncommon for people caught up in criminal investigations in Portugal to declare themselves arguidos in order to receive more legal protection, particularly if they feel the line of questioning implies they are a suspect.

The ex-pat Briton, Robert Murat, was declared an arguido in the Madeleine case in May but has not been charged or formally arrested.




Related articles
07.09.2007: Timeline: Madeleine McCann case
08.05.2007: Q&A;: Madeleine McCann
06.05.2007: For parents, our best is not always enough

In pictures
Madeleine McCann

Map
Key sites in Praia da Luz

Special reports
Crime

Useful link
Find Madeleine




Printable version | Send it to a friend | Save story





UP


Guardian Unlimited © Guardian News and Media Limited 2007