Send As SMS


My Sacristy Wall

Leading the Anglican Inquisition

With nice vestments and tea at 4.


Don't you?

Commemorations

James of Jerusalem

23 October
James of Jerusalem
Bishop and Martyr

Read more on the Christian Year.

Thinking

"Avoid, like the plague, a clergyman who is also a businessman."
- St. Jerome

"Slander is worse than cannibalism."
- St. John Chrysostom

"If we continue to love one another and to join in praising the Most Holy Trinity - all of us who are sons of God and form one family in Christ - we will be faithful to the deepest vocation of the Church."
- St. Ambrose of Milan

"Tradition is the living faith of the dead. Traditionalism is the dead faith of the living."
- Jaroslav Pelikan

"The Jesus of Suburbia is a lie."
- Green Day

"The Church claims to be the most comprehensive human society there is - the new human race in embryo. And it claims this because of its belief that it is established not by any human process grounded in and limited by events, cultures and so on, but by God's activity."
- Rowan Williams

"When talk is unrestrained, when gossip becomes the food of the soul, then destruction of others can't be far behind. When talk is loud and boisterous, when we make light of everything, when nothing is spared the raillery of a joke, the seriousness of all of life is at stake and our spirits wither from a lack of beauty and substance."
- Joan Chittister, OSB (link)

"It's true romance is dead
I shot it in the chest and in the head"

- Fall Out Boy

Me!

Saint Martin's Church, Canterbury

On My Desk

The New Testament and the People of God, N.T. Wright

A Long Obedience in the Same Direction: Discipleship in an Instant Society, Eugene Peterson

Thus Spake Zarathustra, Frederick Nietzsche

Systematic Theology, Vol. 1: The Living God, Thomas C. Oden

Against All Heresies, Irenaeus of Lyons

One Right Reading? A Guide to Irenaeus, Mary Ann Donovan

View my library
My Amazon.com Wishlist
Buy some of my books on Half.com

ChristianBookReviews.net

Purchase from Bean Books!

The Local Manifestation of the Body of Christ of Which I am Part

Lexington Vine and Branches Christian Community
Oxford Diocese of Oxford
Oxford hOME
England The Church of England

New Coats

Jesse in Med School

Gross! Anatomy
New Toys
Modern Art
Euthanasia and Oaths

Fellow Travelers

Lexington
Saint Patrick's Church
The Rock / La Roca United Methodist Church
Cincinnati Vineyard Central
USA The Anglican Communion Network
Oxford Saint Clement's Church
England Fresh Expressions
UK The Baptist Union of Great Britain
The Rest of the World
The Anglican Communion
The Holy See

Group Blogs

The Vine and Branches Community Weblog Church
The Sparkgrass Community Politics
Oxford M.Th. 2005 Classmates

Anglo-Catholic Bloggers

Anglo-Catholic Bloggers
Join / List
Previous / Next / Random
Powered by RingSurf

Blogging Episcopalians

Blogging Episcopalians
Join / List
Previous / Next / Random
Powered by RingSurf

At the Cafe

Friends of this Blog and Other Interesting People

Aaron Klinefelter
Adam Glover
Adam Stacey
Addison Road
Aimee Milburn
Alan Creech
All Too Common
Allison Mabley
American Papist
Amy Palmer
Amy Welborn
Andrew Jones
Antony H., Obl.S.B.
Ben Finger
Benjamin Myers
Brad
Brother Maynard
Bryan Sherwood
Chris Langston
Darron McNutt
Darrell Pursiful
Dave Walker's Cartoon Church
David A. Brandt
Debi Warford
Elizaphanian
Eric Kieb
Eternal Dialogue
Euangelion
Frank Lockwood
Get Religion: Faith behind the News
Fighting for a Lost Cause
Gladly Suffering Fools
Internet Monk
James Olson
Jared Cramer
Jennifer Orr
Jeremy Shoulta
Jesse Darland
Jim Barker
J. Walker
Joseph Howard
Joshua Hearne
Josh Williams
Katie Eating Popcorn
Kendall Harmon
Kylelonius Potter
Lefty Tude
Liz Creech
Mac and Greg
Mark Mossa, S.J.
Matt Rees
The Metaphysical Club
Mike Noakes
Monastic Mumblings
Normal Life Adventure
Naomi Hill
Nazarenes for Liturgical Renewal
Nothing New Under the Sun
Paul Fromont
Peter Matthews
Peter White
Pontifications
Real Live Preacher
Richard Body
Richard Beebe
Rick Luoni
Rob the Cuban
Roger Jasper
Ryan Hall
Seán Cardinal O'Malley
Selva Oscura
Stephen Lawson
Stephen Peltz
Steven Harris
Suzie Lipscomb
Tobias Valdez
Tom Mohan
Waiter Rant
Way of the Fathers

Theology and Literature

Flannery O'Connor

3 August
Flannery O'Connor
Writer from the American South


Ralph C. Wood

Prayer and Liturgy

Renovaré
The Method of Centering Prayer
Lectio Divina
The New Monasticism
Common Worship: Services and Prayers for the Church of England
Universalis: Liturgy of the Hours Online
Daily Prayer Online, Church of England
Latin Phrases

Biblical Studies

The NT Wright Page
Audio: The NT in Greek and Latin
Audio: The Greek NT
Zhubert: Greek and Hebrew

Church History

Patristics Blog: Way of the Fathers
Maria Lectrix: Church Fathers on Mp3
The Christian Classics Ethereal Library
Early Christian Writings
The Tertullian Project
The North American Patristics Society Internet Resources
Walter Rauschenbusch

Theologians

Cavanaugh Internet Archive
Hauerwas Online
Brian Walsh
Online Theology Lectures

Theology @ Oxford: Bibliographies

Patristics
Ancient Christianity
Christian Spirituality

Things I Like

Recipes: The Food Network
Get Fuzzy
Doonesbury
PostSecret

Publishers

Brazos Press
Wipf and Stock
Zondervan
The Liturgical Press
Abingdon Press
Westminster John Knox Press
Fortress Press
Paraclete Press
Baker Academic
InterVarsity Press
Cowley Publications
Duke University Press
Eerdmans
Orbis Books







 

Powered by Blogger

Atom Site Feed

 

 

 

 

Monday, October 30, 2006
The Black Death... and some links
Ordinary Time

I'm still in Colorado this morning, suffering from a bit of a cold. It's been a good time, though. I slept and watched Shaun of the Dead yesterday afternoon while my family visited the local aquarium, but managed to get myself off the couch for buffalo burgers. It was pretty sweet. I think we're visiting the US Mint this morning, and I think my sister wants to work in a Celestial Seasonings factory tour before dropping us at the airport around lunchtime.

I've been reading John Kelly's The Great Mortality: An Intimate History of the Black Death, the Most Devastating Plague of All Time. I enjoy how HarperCollins thought it necessary to put that little explanation in the book's subtitle. It's pretty interesting. General mortality during Europe's plague outbreaks was about a quarter to a third, but in some places could reach 40 or 50%. That's incomprehensible to me. It made me quite a bit more grateful for the life that I live; I mean, I just have a cold, and that's that. When I go back home, my roommates will likely be alive, and none of them turned into zombies.

And that's just the way I like it.

The Legal Alien at Gladly Suffering Fools has posted cute photos of his "filthy beggar" children.

Josh Williams discusses his journey "From Guilt to Grace."

According to the American Family Association of Kentucky, you should vote entirely based upon superstition, rather than ethical reflection. Frank Lockwood: "Did Clinton Save America from God's Wrath?" I've told you guys why Baptists hate Clinton, right? 'Cause he got away with things that they don't even get to think about. It's envy, not righteous indignation. Tee hee!

Oh, and here we go... Gladly Suffering Fools: "Homophilia."

Speaking of which, Geoff at Sparkgrass is Not Happy about about early reports of the new guidelines for ministering to gay and lesbian Catholics. I've not read them yet, but if you want to get a jump on me, get to it.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , ,

posted by Kyle @ 8:52 AM   0 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

Sunday, October 29, 2006
A Theology of Vestments?
Ordinary Time

Let's talk about vestments: specifically, the pretty frocks that priests and acolytes wear during the divine liturgy as it is performed by traditional congregations. Just to say, I realize that from the way I talk and write, folks often assume that I'm censing the high altar at a cathedral every weekend. While I certainly think that would be fun and poignant, I don't. I am, when it's all said and done, part of a house church. And alas, we have no liturgical dress, and won't be getting any anytime soon.

Why is special dress for the celebrant and assistants (essentially the "lead worshippers," if I might use the language of evangelicals) a good idea? I think the answer is both theological and anthropological. People engage in ritual for important observances. Particular modes of dress are part of that: it expresses reverence (or irreverence!) and makes the statement: "this is something extraordinary we're doing, and it deserves to be attended to in an extraordinary way." To simply refuse special rituals and dress for special observances is to make a particular political statement - one that I disagree with rather vehemently. When some people complain about liturgical dress, it sounds to me like, "Why should we act like the Eucharist is some kind of special observance?"

That being said, when I visited St. Aldates (Oxford) and a young woman ascended the platform in a sweater and jeans and started chatting, and by the end of the little speech she had moved into the prayer of consecration, I was shocked. It's not merely because she was wearing "civvies," or that the words she spoke were to some degree improvised and extemporaneous (I don't think there's anything wrong with those things as such), but because the way I "read" the entire action was, "I don't think this is a big deal, and you guys shouldn't think this is a big deal either." For a reason I can't quite put my finger on, it seems to me that in a larger, more "public" setting, reverence must be far more intentional than that to be really reverant.

At the same time, I never see the way hOME or VBCC attends to the Mysteries to be anything less than reverent - even though there are no vestments in sight. In the smaller setting - kind of public but actually quite intimate - full on eucharistic vestments would seem out of place. For some reason, I think that "simplicity" is reverant in a small setting, but irreverant in a larger one. Does that make sense?

As for the pastoral issue, let me explain that it's not "pretty frocks" that I'm really talking about. Priests generally wear stoles when performing priestly functions. Visualize a simple stole here, rather than a medieval carnival. I think it is at the very least pastorally useful because it makes the statement that the chief consecrator is functioning as a priest. In those moments, the celebrant isn't just my friend (let's call him) Bill, but Bill the priest. Bill's personality isn't erased (now, who would want that?), but ritual action and vestments are visual indicators of the theological reality that this man through his functioning as a priest empowers and even enables the people to present themselves to God in the Sacrifice. As chief consecrator Bill the priest has a divine authority to ask God to do what he does in that moment for the Church that has nothing to do with whether he's a nice man or if people like him. Vestments, then, are a kind of pedagogical tool to remind us that we're Catholics and not Donatists.

I guess I don't get all that hot and bothered about it (really!) because I know that someone can be both my friend and my priest, and that sometimes the most spiritually efficacious thing is that he is my priest. Some people complain that this creates a harmful division between clergy and laity. And for all of that, I'd think I'd answer that there's a difference between a clergy/laity "distinction" and a "division." It's not an Indian caste system, and if we let ourselves talk about it like it is, we only hurt ourselves. When we ordain people, we create a distinction. What we do with it, how we talk about it, how we understand it - that's the question. The distinction is there as soon as we say that one person can consecrate the bread and wine, and another can't. As soon as somebody is to any extent "in charge" or a facilitator of religious activities, that happens. Happily, it's the way of the Church to ordain people so that we can be upfront about it and learn to be healthy about it. I'm reminded of all the Baptists I've known who refuse to say they have a theology of ordination or even of ministry, but will affirm that the Holy Spirit comes upon the preacher when he enters the pulpit. Saying the distinction isn't there doesn't make it true, it just keeps us dishonest and schizophrenic in our theologies.

I have yet to meet anyone bothered by vestments whose church uses them. The people I hear protest (ahem) the loudest are in traditions and churches that do not, and would not use them. Why are those people so certain about what the practice means and what it does to people?

People I expect to agree with me: Hearne, Noakes, and Cramer.
People who will put up a fight: Jasper, Messer, Rob the Cuban, and SaintSimon.
People I'm not sure about: Jesse, Alan, and Shoulta.
People who won't care: Antony, Debi, and James Bush

So, did I call it?

Technorati Tags: ,

posted by Kyle @ 6:09 PM   15 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

Saturday, October 28, 2006
Did You Know?
Ordinary Time

Kentucky claims two American presidents: Abraham Lincoln and Jefferson Davis.

Shhh...

posted by Kyle @ 12:24 PM   1 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

Friday, October 27, 2006
Update
Ordinary Time

I'm in Colorado. I'm being entertained by local campaign ads. I left my books behind, so I'm perusing my sister's library. I'm really enjoying Confessions of a Tax Collector: One Man's Tour of Duty in the IRS. I'm so serious.

Technorati Tags: ,

posted by Kyle @ 10:30 PM   7 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

Thursday, October 26, 2006
Single Issue Voting
Ordinary Time

The Democrats want to make it illegal to torture people that the secret military courts think might be terrorists. The Republicans like to say that makes them soft on terror.

The Republicans want to make it illegal to abort the fetuses that might become terrorists. So who's soft on terror now?

Technorati Tags: ,

posted by Kyle @ 9:22 PM   12 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 


Honestly...
Ordinary Time

I love many books, but my favorites have photographs of dogs dressed in funny clothes.

Technorati Tags: ,

posted by Kyle @ 9:21 PM   2 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 


Links!
Ordinary Time

Dr. Platypus smacks around the Baptists:
There is not a Christian in the world who reads the whole Bible—or even the whole New Testament—with rigid, brutal consistency. There are parts we choose to emphasize and parts we choose to disregard or explain away. We don’t usually “greet one another with a holy kiss” (Rom 16:16; 1 Cor 16:20), much less worry about whether the meat on our table is trefa (Acts 15:20, 29). Only the most radical Christians (Francis of Assisi, the Waldensians, certain Anabaptist sects, etc.) advocate a life of “evangelical poverty” (Mk 10:17-27). And speaking in tongues (1 Cor 14:5, 39) seems as odd and suspicious to many Baptists as female church leaders (Rom 16:1, 7, 12).
You might also skim through his recent entries to find some really good writings on early Christian worship - it's a great introduction to what our best and earliest sources tell us about the liturgies of those communities.

Think monastics are nuts? Did you see The Monastery last weekend? Check out Antony: "What Do We Really Need to Be 'in Touch' With?"

So lots of Republicans think Hilary Clinton is an inconsistent Christian, even a liberal one, which is another word for 'evil.' So how consistent is Hilary-bashing with Christian commitment: read about the repentance of a Republican at GetReligion.

Antony offers some good discussion about hospitality as well, here and here.

Suggest additions to the rosary at Selva Oscura.

Douglas Knight suggests that it is not "you" or "I" who will be resurrected at the last day, but rather, "the Church." Check it out:
It is not that I am being transformed as a merely individual entity. Rather I am being turned outwards so that I can no longer be thought of as someone cut off and isolated from others. I am being adapted to fit each other living person. We are all of us being fitted to one another. Resurrection means that I am brought into living relationship with, and so made alive to, every other person, and they to me. The (future) body of Christ will be made of every living person. We are being broken out of our present partial and sectarian community and brought into a much bigger one, indeed into the universal community. Our small local sectarian loaf is being re-dissolved and baked into a much bigger loaf – one that is made of all.
Sweet.

Nothing makes Enlightenment-grounded, 'freedom of conscience is the most important gospel freedom' liberals angrier than a phrase like "the pastoral action of excommunication." Check the comments here.

Pax vobiscum

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

posted by Kyle @ 10:28 AM   4 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

Tuesday, October 24, 2006
Networking Site
Ordinary Time

Okay, so generally speaking, networking sites irritate me. They're usually long on cuteness and short on interesting content. On some occasions, I've gotten back in touch with folks because of them, which is really cool. Now that I've gotten to "e-know" some more people through them (hello, new readers!), I'm warming up to the idea.

Mike Morrell has put me on to MyChurch.org. There has been some talk in the past few months about ghettoized "Christian" versions of MySpace, but I don't think this is part of that (which would be crap). Here's why I find this site interesting: it lets me view the communal internet presence of local churches. If I want to know about a church, I can visit them (if I'm really curious) or (more likely) I can check out their advertising or websites. If they don't get into advertising, my hat's off to them. Websites are still a certain kind of PR, and that's fine. This site could let folks know what kind of people (sorta) are part of particular churches. You should sign up so I can learn about your church by learning a little about who you people are. Make sense?

Here's my profile.

Frankly, I'm trying to find an excuse to say "The Church meets Web 2.0." There, I did it. I feel silly now.

I wonder what Alan will think? Will he take us to Web 2.0?

(See what I did, there?)

Okay, back to the books...

Technorati Tags: ,

posted by Kyle @ 11:01 AM   5 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 


Books Again
Ordinary Time

One of the odd things about working at the bookstore is that really simple things can become difficult. One takes for granted the meaning of certain phrases that realy need to be expounded upon with the aid of charts and diagrams.

Customer: Do you have any copies of Book X?
Me [checking computer system]: No, I'm afraid we don't.
Customer: Why not?
Me [continuing to check computer]: My information describes that title as out of print.
Customer: So can you order it?
Me: No sir, I'm afraid I can't.
Customer: Well, you should carry more books by Author X.
Me: Of course, sir. We try our best. However, since Author X is local and uses small publishers with a small print run, his/her books tend to go out of print fairly quickly. The only thing I can get copies of is the newest book, Book Y.
Customer: Barnes and Noble could get it for me.
Me: No sir, they couldn't. I know that for a fact. I'm happy to recommend some local used book sellers, or some websites if you wish, but I'm afraid I can't help you any further than that.
Customer: No, I'll just go to Barnes and Noble.
Me [smiling cheerily]: Very good. Good day, sir.

Here's the thing. I am happy to spend 5-10 minutes with anybody who comes to the Help Desk, trying to hook them up with the book they're looking for - even when it doesn't exist. What I never do is stand and listen to someone pout that they can't get their way.

Another (apparently) painful experience of cognitive dissonance sets in when I have to explain to someone that the book they're so certain they need does not in fact exist. I always try to break the news gently. Interestingly enough, the older someone is (and presumably the more shaky their memory) the more certain a customer tends to be that they have the book's author and title exactly right.

Customer: Do you have the new book by Author A?
Me [checking computer]: Let me see. Are you sure it's not Author B (who shares a surname with Author A)?
Customer: No.
Me: I'm sorry, I can't find that name. Would you please spell the last name for me?
Customer: Well, it's not hard. [spells]
Me [thinking about how my education really probably does make me better than this person, then feeling slightly badly about it, then checking Google and Wikipedia to see what I can find out about "Author" A]: I'm sorry, but the only records I'm finding for Person A is either a cartoonist who died in 1951 or a recently retired Canadian MP.
Customer: Well, that's not him.
Me: Clearly. Do you know the title of the book?
Customer: [names an approximation of the title of the new and popular book by Author B, who shares a surname with Author A.]
Me: Yes, that's by Author B.
Customer: No, I'm sure that's not it.
Me: I'm sorry, but I don't believe the author you're looking for exists.
Customer: That's okay, I'll just go to Barnes and Noble.

Yah, we'll see how long they put up with either one of you.

You know, I'm pretty sure of myself. I'm a graduate student, and I've worked in a bookstore for many months, and as a library tech for a year. I was trained to catalogue this stuff. It's not a Master of Library Science, but it's not nothing. If I say a book does or does not exist, I'm right. If I tell you the best way to aquire a certain title, I'm right about that, too. Just that much - it's not exactly hard. I wonder if there's a T-shirt I can wear to get this idea across...?

It gets even more sensitive when I must interfere with the logic of "I think Book C should exist, therefore someone did write it and a publisher did print it, and all bookstores must therefore have it.

Okay, that's all.

Technorati Tags: ,

posted by Kyle @ 7:52 AM   9 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 


Irritable.
Ordinary Time

Pursiful called it.
"Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary Trustees: '1 Corinthians 14.39 Not Inerrant.'"
HA!

They'll fire you if you say the Bible's not inerrant, and they'll fire you if you fall to forbid ecstatic 'prayer languages.' Weak. Which brings us back to what the real issue is in Baptist life: you must agree to the inerrancy of Baptist teachings about the Bible's teachings. The real difference between Nashville and Rome is that the Roman magisterium doesn't vote on truth.

[Cartman voice] "Nyah nyah nyah nyah nyah nyah ha ha ha ha ha ha"

Meanwhile, if you want to engage with some edifying, Aquilina's audio introduction to Ignatius of Antioch has been posted.

Cute.

So much for civil liberties. RIP, Habeas Corpus. Should you be accused of any crime (or suspected!) related to "terror," you can be put in prison. Man, I hope that liberal Supreme Court reminds the executive branch that it's supposed to protect and defend the US Constitution sometime soon.

Oh, and put that lighter down. The first amendment doesn't apply if a flag is involved.

Now go watch the video.
"Other rights accorded to the people? Well, if you can name them during your waterboarding, you can have them!"

Technorati Tags: , ,

posted by Kyle @ 7:50 AM   2 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

Monday, October 23, 2006
Books
Ordinary Time

Oxford University Press' top five religion/theology titles are all written by Bart Ehrman. Brother Bart, what did you do to get so sexy and marketable?

I would rather be punched in the face (where's Noakes?) than finish Spencer Burke's A Heretic's Guide to Eternity. But now that I've said it, I feel obligated to do just that, and then tell you why.

I'm glancing through the Fall Books issue of The Christian Century to see if I should take a look at anything, if you're wondering. I'm working at LTS today.

Hey, go check out the Open Forum from the City Church of San Francisco. They've offered recent podcasts of talks from Lauren Winner and N.T. Wright about their recent books. I listened to both of them last week, and think both the discussions and the books themselves are very worthwhile. Wright is discussing his Simply Christian: Why Christianity Makes Sense and Winner her Real Sex: The Naked Truth About Chastity. Go there. Download. Listen. Smile. You'll thank me.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

posted by Kyle @ 10:08 AM   4 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 


Anecdotes
Ordinary Time
+James of Jerusalem


Ooh, it's been too long since I've written. I've worked a lot this week. This was Homecoming Weekend at Georgetown College, so I spent some time up there. I spent some time with Danny and (surprise) assorted PHAs, talking about the usual stuff: theology, calling, and just living with people. Zac tried to impress me with his Tony Campolo books, while Messer and Patterson have a fake fireplace. I'm jealous. If anybody needs me, I'll be at Lowe's (you know, like usual). Glover and McNutt did a great job with songfest, and Patrick was sauntering about rather prominently in the PHA skit. As he does.

Did everybody see the videocast Patrick and I did at Canterbury? You should - click here.

I'll be spending the weekend before All Souls/Saints with my mother and uncle, visiting my sister in Colorado. I'll let you know how that goes. She's studying for a Master of Taxation degree at Denver. Yes, that exists. Scary, huh? Speaking of which, Darrell Pursiful has reminded us that Hallowe'en is the Christian alternative to the pagan Harvest Festival.

Can anybody recommend a good zombie film?

If anyone wants to be part of a great church in Lexington, let me know. I'll let you know the score (heh heh).

I attended the liturgy at Saint Patrick's yesterday; they were baptizing a baby and initiating two adults into the catechumenate. Liturgies of Christian initiation are amazing; we need to be reminded like that, that new life in Jesus really is possible, and that we really can be healed and freed from all the death in our lives by virtue of who he is and what he's done.

Josh and Indie Jesse (no longer emo, he's moved on) joined us for the Liturgy with Vine and Branches; we discussed the passage in Mark in which Jesus explains that Kingdom authority isn't like that of the world - it's about love, service, and laying down one's life for the good of others. May God make us people like that.

Alan put us onto the new TLC series, the Monastery. Jesse and I watched it last night: from the look of it, it's going to be both entertaining and enlightening, teaching a lot of people some good things about a tradition they know very little about. Check it out next Sunday at 10 (or 1am). Did anyone else see it?

In other news, Jesse showed up to school last week in a shirt, tie, and white coat. One of his profs told him he looked "just like a miniature doctor."

Ouch. Little Doc, where's our next blog post?

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , ,

posted by Kyle @ 9:28 AM   10 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

Tuesday, October 17, 2006
Deconstructing Christian Clichés
If you will indulge me, I'm re-introducing a piece I wrote last Advent. Let me know what you think of the piece, and if you want to revisit the original discussion, click here. If you don't know me, let me introduce myself.

Ornery (adj.) : having an irritable disposition : CANTANKEROUS
- or·neri·ness noun

see also
Potter, Kyle: "We simply must kill any gods who are incapable of raising the dead."





Let's have a chat. I have been given the grace for the last eight years of my life to be apprenticed to Jesus in the fellowship of his Church. I love the way God sees us, and what he has made us. I am always learning to love us as we are, "warts and all." Note that I will not talk about Christ's Church as if it were somehow an institution or group of people who live separately either from me or from him. I have been baptized into him, together with everybody else who's been dipped or sprinkled or splashed in the name of the Trinitarian God. We're all bloody well stuck with each other. So understand this, if nothing else: any criticism I'm offering, I do so in the context of committment.

I want to make a suggestion about Christian clichés, some of the unfortunate phrases we use when trying to offer spiritual counsel to one another. Many of our Christian communities fail to provide a safe place to be real and vulnerable because of the unhelpful language that fills the air. When folks are threatened by the doubts and struggles of others, they will sometimes say things like
"Just give it over to the Lord"
"Just trust God"
"Have faith"
"Surrender more of your life to Jesus"
"Let go and let God" [Josh W.]
For many of you who have been raised in faith communities, it can be hard to realize how vacuous, how literally empty of meaning that these phrases are. Eugene Peterson suggests stronger language still in a discussion about "fear-of-the-Lord":
... There is ... something about the sacred that makes us uneasy. We don't like being in the dark, not knowing what to do. And so we attempt to domesticate the mystery, explain it, probe it, name and use it. "Blasphemy" is the term we use for these verbal transgressions of the sacred, these violations of the holy: taking God's name in vain, dishonoring sacred time and place, reducing God to gossip and chatter. Uncomfortable with the mystery, we try to banish it with clichés.

- Christ Plays in Ten Thousand Places: A Conversation in Spiritual Theology, 42.
It may not be immediately obvious, but when people offer these phases, these stock answers, it sends a clear and demoralizing message: "I don't take your struggles seriously, and I'm not prepared to muster the theological depth to share them with you."

This might be a harsh assessment, but this is a great problem, and worthy of such consideration. If you use these Christian platitudes, these unholy clichés in your care for your brothers and sisters, I urge you to carefully consider dropping them. If you find your friends using them on you, forgive them, then challenge them. Muster some courage and tell them you find those words to be theologically empty and pastorally cold. It's the only way we're going to grow and learn to struggle together.

Let's respect each other enough to never be satisfied with platitudes.

Instead, let's struggle together, ask God the hard questions, and learn the peace that comes with honesty. Truly, for Christ's sake and for the care of his Church, let's be honest.

For my part, I have offered my thoughts on four common Christian platitudes, with suggestions as to how we might replace them with more honest and clear attempts to tell the story of who we are in Christ Jesus.

Captain Sacrament's Antitheses
N.B.: These articles are not meant to be exhaustive treatments of the topics at hand, to say nothing of chapters in a systematic theology. They're talking points. Theology is a work of the people of God together. I can tell you about how I choose to talk about these things, but not in any definitive way how you should. That's for you to discern and share if you see fit. And if you do want to share, that's what the comments are for.

And don't forget to read the conclusion of the series, "And the Glory of the Lord Shall Be Revealed," in which I bring the discussion back to the Advent context - making space for our coming King.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

posted by Kyle @ 8:13 PM   11 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 


Hooray for Visitors!
Ordinary Time

Frank Lockwood, the religion reporter for the Herald Leader, has kindly added me to his blogroll. Welcome, visitors! I always enjoy Lockwood's work, and find him quite knowledgable and fair, especially with the local Anglican controversies in the last couple of years. If you like that kind of thing, do continue to check out GetReligion as well.

For those of you visiting me for the first time, let me introduce myself.

Technorati Tags: ,

posted by Kyle @ 10:22 AM   5 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 


Around the House
Ordinary Time

Every morning I rise at 6:30 to make coffee. I eat breakfast with Jesse, and we talk about what he'll be doing to that poor cadaver today, and about my reading. He disappears into the dark, rainy morning. Chris gets up a little later, and I try to ask clever questions about math. It doesn't work. He disappears into the dark, rainy morning also. I go to my desk with my second cup of coffee to skim blogs and taunt Noakes over IM. I usually say prayers or pick up the first book of the day, and chat with Alan around midmorning. I usually do e-mail in the morning, too. I just wrote an editorial (move to the edge of your seat now), and in a moment I'll say morning prayer, shower, and write some e-mails.

The other Kyle is coming over for lunch. We'll do work this afternoon, and catch up with Emo Jesse and Mike after a simple dinner. And more studies. Graduate life rocks.

I had lunch with Katie yesterday. She's great. Sadly (for her new and old Kentucky friends) she's back in Dallas now.

Technorati Tags: ,

posted by Kyle @ 10:20 AM   4 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

Monday, October 16, 2006
Weekend
Ordinary Time

Alan's continuing to talk about how our church does things: "live teaching."

Aly Hawkins reflects on protest songs.

If he writes this book, Mark Van Steenwyk will be one of my new heroes.

Steven Harris interviews the Internet Monk.

I'm thinking about taking measures to increase my audience with this thing. Any suggestions for a "Best of Captain Sacrament" collection?

Shameless self-aggrandizement, I know.

I had a fun weekend; my housemates and I went out for Darron's birthday on Friday, and Jesse and I made dinner for Josh to recognize his 21st. We made one of my favorite stand-bys, "Fantasy Chicken." It's a fried chicken dish with a cream-based lemon gravy that a friend taught me in Dallas.

The Divine Liturgy was fun last night; I was quite disconcerted to learn that my co-religionists are still caught up on this whole "justification by faith" thing. We'll deal. I love you guys! Zac Bailes hung out with us this weekend and joined us for worship; other illustrious guest stars included Katie (Eating Popcorn) and Jesse Darland. Katie's in to visit a friend, so it's been great to meet her! I would never have guessed a couple of years ago that I'd have "internet friends." Hm. I prefer to call y'all "pen pals" of a sort. That just sounds... different.

It's been good to finish up those nasty essays and see people again, ha!

posted by Kyle @ 9:22 AM   7 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

Sunday, October 15, 2006
Four Years Ago
Ordinary Time
Teresa of Avila


Disclaimer. This entry is unpleasant, but I was kind of feeling like writing it anyway. If we were sitting down for coffee and a beer today, you and I and a couple of other good friends, this is what I'd talk about today.

I remember most vividly the smell of the rain and the grass. I love autumn, but I did not love combing it out of my beard. I don't remember when my face was pressed into the ground, but I do remember the itching of the sod, and the caked blood, and the washing of the rain.

I remember the spinning car, and how the wheel crushed my chest and kept me suspended from the ground. It was a funny thing, bleeding upside down. I did not like it.

I didn't expect to die alone that evening. Now I never fail to anticipate it.

I remember tubes and hoses. Tubes in, tubes out. I remember the creation of orifices where there were no orifices before. I remember how they made me try to answer yes and no questions by nodding my head, before they discovered that my neck was broken.

My lungs had collapsed, pierced by my ribs. The skin on the left side of my torso turned purple for about ten days; I never saw it myself. It was three weeks before I would sleep again. Passing out for a couple of hours every night is something different from that entirely. I was only in the hospital for maybe a dozen days; as soon as I could be moved from the bed to a chair and back, I was to be sent home.

After the first night, I didn't get back in bed for about two weeks. I couldn't lie down and breathe at the same time. I remember more individual hours than you might suppose. Indeed, I counted them.

I broke C1, L2, and L3. I also broke three ribs and a clavicle. I don't know what you call whatever happened to my sternum. Cracked? Broken? Eating sucked. Drinking sucked. Sleeping sucked. I broke several teeth (the dentist made them pretty again!). I stayed in the wheelchair for perhaps three weeks, and the walker for another two. I had physical therapy until April, 2 or 3 times per week. I never missed a session. I wore the halo until December 17 - you can google that on your own. I have funny stories, you should remind me to tell them. Well, I mean they're kind of funny.

Okay, I'm done for now.

posted by Kyle @ 9:38 PM   6 comments links to this post  

...............................................................................................

 

About Me


Kyle Potter
Lexington, KY, USA
Oxford, England


See my complete profile
See my photos
E-mail me
Facebook me
MySpace
MyChurch
Main Page

Introductions

Who Is This Guy?
"Vindicated"?
Podcasts
Four Things About Me
Silly Things About Me
My Religious Journey
Storytime

Comments that suck will be deleted
Comment Policy

Visit Captain Sacrament

Regarding Language
and "Doing Theology"

Casting Down Strongholds: Deconstructing Christian Clichés
Why "Liberal" Really is a Dirty Word
Heretics: Watch Your Damned Language
On Being Right
Wordplay
On Being in Seminary
Five Things I Believe and Trust
Five Things I Reject
Christology
What is Evangelical Christianity?
Does "Evangelical" Matter?
On Evangelical Grammar
Katie: 59 Cents
The Gospels and the Historical Jesus

Epiclesis

Patrick and I at the 11th century altar of Mary the Virgin, in the ruins of Saint Augustine's Abbey, Canterbury

On the Emerging Churches
or "Putting Up with Pomo Crayon-Doodlers"

What is the Emerging Church?
Facing Opposition: An Open Letter to "Emergent" Christians
On Criticizing Religion
That's Our Word. Stop Using It."
From the Apostolic Sees
The Post-Modern Morass
Are We Idealistic?
More on Being Post-Modern
Opus Dei and the Emerging Church
Relevant?

Ecclesiology:
Living in God's New Community

On The Church
God's Model T?
Superpowers: On the Holy Spirit in the Community
On the Eucharistic Life
"...and Occasionally Prophecy": Thoughts on Authority
On the Day of Ashes: Community is Hard
The Great Vigil: Signs of Life
Schism
Risking Love
Why it Hurts
A Matter of Trust
Authority Issues
Trust and Obedience
The Communion of Saints
Understanding Our Community
On "Having Church"
On Being a Diaspora Christian
Homosexuality and Evangelical Churches
Unity and Exclusion
Excommunication and Redemption
Ecumenism
The Minimum

Rublev Trinity

The Holy Trinity: Participating in God

On the Sacraments

Baptism: An Interactive Poll
Baptism: Is Repetition a Good Thing?
A Eucharistic Index
"Evangelicals and Catholics Together"?

The Baptism of Our Lord

Christianity as Bodily Practices:
Doing the Jesus Thing

On Spiritual Disciplines
"But Will it Work for Me?"
On Worship
On Prayer
The Liturgy of the Hours: An Introduction
Liturgy of the Hours: Your Practices
Liturgy of the Hours: My Take
In Defense of Praise Choruses
The Sign of the Cross
On Being a Good Christian
The Sacrifice of Praise
Remaining in Christ

Harrowing of Hell

Practice Resurrection

Darkness and Light:
Seasons of the Christian Year

The Advent Hope
Advent: Waiting on the Lord
Epiphany
Entering Lent
On Lent: Understanding the Tradition
Lenten Practices
The Day of Ashes
Safe to Die
Everything You Know is Incorrect
Maundy Thursday
Holy Saturday: Mourning, Waiting
The Great Vigil: "How Blessed is This Night"
The Great Vigil: Signs of Life
Eastertide: Meet Me On This Road
Pentecost

The Twelve Apostles

Ancient Christianity:
Engaging the Fathers

The Didache
Polycarp of Smyrna
Ignatius of Antioch, I
Ignatius of Antioch, II
Clement of Rome
Diognetus, I
Diognetus, II
Taking Back the Fathers
Justin Martyr
Antony of the Desert
Athanasius of Alexandria, I
Athanasius of Alexandria, II
Apostolic Succession
The Vincentian Canon

Patriotism:
Before the Altar of Caesar

The Glories of War
World War One: Religious Support
World War One: "I Am Not a Christian"
Porter Memorial and the Powers That Be
"The Church of Jesus Christ does not have the luxury of patriotism"
"Every Knee Shall Bow: Anschließ den Reichskirchen"
Christians and the State
Closure
New Comments Go Here
Desecration
Howl
Worshippers of Mars

Considering Ministry

My +3 Apostolic Succession Beats Your Spell of Arius
A Conversation That Did Not, and Would Not, Happen
Qualifications of the Presbyterate
The Professional Ministry
Is Itinerant Ministry Valid?
Validation
Vocation: I Am Really Awfully Right and Reverend

Rembrandt, Return of the Prodigal

Singleness and Celibacy

The Problem with Singles Ministry
A Holy Celibacy: More Than Absence
Celibacy as "Space for God"
Obstacles to a Theology of Celibacy
Emo Meme

Silly Things

Anathemas
My War on Christmas
I Want You! For the War on Christmas
Choose This Day
The Sacristy Wall
Of Geeks and Nerds
No, Really.
Amsterdam
Pilgrimage
Books!

Poetry

Benediction
Easter
Emmaus
Ordinary

Recent Posts

The Black Death... and some links
A Theology of Vestments?
Did You Know?
Update
Single Issue Voting
Honestly...
Links!
Networking Site
Books Again
Irritable.

Archives:
Calling Out Your Apostasy Since December 2002

December 2002
January 2003
March 2003
April 2003
July 2003
October 2003
November 2003
December 2003
January 2004
February 2004
March 2004
April 2004
May 2004
June 2004
July 2004
August 2004
September 2004
October 2004
November 2004
December 2004
January 2005
February 2005
March 2005
April 2005
May 2005
June 2005
July 2005
August 2005
September 2005
October 2005
November 2005
December 2005
January 2006
February 2006
March 2006
April 2006
May 2006
June 2006
July 2006
August 2006
September 2006
October 2006

Some of My Favorite Books

 

 

vindicated, oxford, england