VOLUME 21 • NO 1 JANUARY 2008 About us Advertise Archive Vacancy  
 
Write to the Editor

Writers' Guidelines

SEARCH
HSA WWW

RECENT ISSUES


DOWNLOAD
The Departure of Benazir Bhutto

pIC BY KANAK M DIXIT

The 'daughter of the East' is dead. The assassination of Benazir Bhutto in Rawalpindi is a tragedy that puts Pakistani politics in a tailspin, forestalling a return to democracy and heralding ever more violence in the public arena. The killing sends a tremor across the political landscape of Southasia. The former prime minister was one of the best-known faces among the region's politicians, a modern and urbane woman who dared to join the hurly burly of grimy politics.

Nearly continuous military rule over the decades has left the Pakistani polity fragile and brittle. With the elections slated for 8 January 2008, the hope was that Pakistan would, once again, attempt the transition to sustained democracy. There were critics who questioned Benazir's willingness to end her days in exile to join an imperfect electoral terrain as defined by President Pervez Musharraf. But there was no question that even flawed polls would nudge Pakistan away from military rule and towards democratic functioning. If the people of Pakistan would prosper in peace under a democracy, Benazir held out the hope for its ushering.

The practice of politics has become deadly and insecure in Pakistan. How can politics be conducted in the absence of mass rallies? How can leaders galvanise from behind bullet-proof glass, or from the distance of the television screen? Is this, then, the way of Southasian politics in the days ahead, an inexorable distancing between the leader and the masses? And is it right that so much of leadership's mantle be invested in one person, that her departure should create a chasm that leaves a society so bereft?

Himal Southasian's January 2008 issue, takes a look at the evolving politics of Pakistan in the context of the autumn of discontent just past. This issue was prepared before Benazir Bhutto's assassination, but hopefully will provide the context to understand the evolution of the Pakistani polity in the coming months.

27 December 2007, Kathmandu

The general has no clothes

Get wallpaper DOWNLOAD

Pervez Musharraf has now tried to placate his opponents – by lifting the state of emergency, setting a date for elections, and, ostensibly, shedding his uniform. Despite the seeming success of activists and lawyers long calling for this last action, our cover image this issue, by Islamabad cartoonist Fauzia Minallah, depicts the true nature of the general’s decision: a naked power-grab by an autocrat who has silenced the Constitution and compromised the political parties.

Indeed, General (retd) Musharraf has now started down a time-tested road laid down by autocrats immemorial: when the laws don’t suit you, do some face-saving but don’t hesitate to change the rules! When justice has to be seen to be done, if not actually done, then just remove the judiciary! When the media persists in doing its job of informing the public, just ban it! When politicians don’t agree to some convenient deal-making, just blackmail them into submission! And, when the country’s beleaguered people come out onto the streets, just ignore them! Above all, use the fear of chaos, the stranglehold of the military over society, and the geopolitical weight of the US to bolster your place amidst a sullen populace.

Away from the cities, hurtling with increasing speed into chaos, are the tribal areas of Pakistan. In these frontiers and neglected regions, as in the populous Punjab and Sindh, frustrated citizens have next to no faith that any election drama will be able to do much more than ‘legitimise’ a regime that has no moral right to stay in power. The task of building credible democratic institutions is tough; pushing for accountability is even harder, particularly in a country caught in the web of military rule for too long. But it must be done, by people’s movements and political parties alike, before any hope of democracy is forsaken.


COVER FEATURE
Khaki president
By |
Zia Mian, A H Nayyar
‘The fight for constitutional primacy
By | Shamshad Ahmad
Borderland bullets and the ballot
By | Aurangzaib Khan
The colonial judciary burden
By | Amjad Bhatti
Bol! Bol! Bol!
By | Raza Rumi

COMMENTARY
Awaiting the people’s move
Misdiagnosis from Dr Singh
Strange Bedfellows
‘Moonlight’

ANALYSIS
Counting Muslim votes in Modi’s Gujarat
By | V K Shashikumar

ESSAY
Flooding out and drying up in Southasia
By | Sunita Dubey, Ananth Chikkatur

SPECIAL REPORT
The questions of industrialisation
Jagirdari governance
Jayanta Bandyopadhyay
Industrialisation without employment
Amit Bhaduri
Oblivion of idealism
Ashok Mitra
No collateral damage
Debabrata Bandyopadhyay
Goodbye, apolitical fundamentalism
Sumit Chowdhury
Fat cats and the left rupture
Vijay Prashad

MEDIAFILE
SOUTHASIAN BRIEFS
CONTRIBUTORS
MAIL
REPORT
Cracks in Project Malaysia
By | Eric Paulsen
The right of return to Jaffna
By | Sharika Thiranagama
Beyond the Bali-hoo
By | Kunda Dixit

TIME AND A PLACE
Survivorhood in Dardpora
By | Sumona Das Gupta

REFLECTIONS
The Bengali urban middle-class psyche
By | Garga Chatterjee, Priyanka Nandy, Somnath Mukherji

OPINION
Of flags, faces and fascism
By | Sumana Roy

SIGHTING
No chowkidar!
By | Satyadeep S Chhetri

PHOTO FEATURE
Last days of Sidr
By | Munem Wasif, Naeem Mohaiemen

SOUTHASIASPHERE
Life and the meaning of living
By | C K Lal

REVIEW
Bookshelf
‘Caught between tradition and modernity: Pakistani films
By | Oishik Sircar
Finessing fluid feuds: Ramaswamy R Iyer
By | G Narasimha Raghavan

 
Taslima and Aitzaz
  By | Kanak Mani Dixit
EDITORIAL FROM THE REGION
SOUTHASIA THIS WEEK
UPDATES !
PAKISTAN: Beena Sarwar
Benazir Bhutto – the ultimate sacrifice.
27 Dec 07
PFUJ Islamabad Eid Protest and others.
21 Dec 07
Geo Back (Sort of) and others...
20 Dec 07
BURMA: Solidarity
Burmese Opinion on Benazir's assassination
27 Dec 07
EU special envoy hails Beijing's fundamental role in Myanmar and others...
21 Dec 07
U.N. weak in Myanmar
19 Dec 07

DEVELOPMENT CLASSIFIEDS
Health Adviser - Nepal
  Human Rights Research Positions - Nepal

ANNOUNCEMENTS
Call for Papers‘
Voices from the Waters
Film South Asia '07
Festival of Southasian Documentaries-
Jury Statement for FSA '07
 
 
Rewrite the Future of Education in Nepal
Save the children
Conference: South Asian Feminisms: Gender, Culture ans Politics
University of Pennsylvania
Call for Submissions
Adventures in Desiland: A Collection of Children's Stories

PANOS ROUNDTABLE
Conflict and the India-Pakistan media
Nagarkot, Nepal (May 2002)

The nuclear weaponisation of Southasia
Bellagio, Italy (July 2003)

The India-Pakistan ‘Composite Dialogue’
Bentota, Sri Lanka (September 2004)

The question of Kashmir
Istanbul, Turkey (December 2005)
Are India and Pakistan really in control of the situation?
Cairo, Egypt (November 2006)
The Southasia Trust, GPO Box: 24393, Kathmandu, Nepal. Phone: +977 1 5547279, Fax: +977 1 5552141