WSWS
: News &
Analysis : Middle
East : Iraq
Britain: Blair and Hoon plead ignorance of human rights abuses
in Iraq
By Julie Hyland
12 May 2004
Use
this version to print
| Send this
link by email | Email the
author
The British governments corruption and cynicism were
on full display in parliament on Monday May 10. Defence Secretary
Geoffrey Hoon sought to fend off charges that he had ignored allegations
of abuse of Iraqi prisoners by British and American forces, claiming
that he had not read the reports until recently.
For more than a week, the government had tried to lay low as
dozens of horrendous images were published of US soldiers gleefully
humiliating and torturing helpless Iraqi detainees.
Every effort was made to portray the photographs as the outcome
of a few rogue elements in the US army, and to claim that British
forces would never descend to such depths.
Such claims were undermined by photographs published in the
Daily Mirror allegedly showing British soldiers abusing
Iraqi detainees.
The photographs had forced Deputy Defence Minister Adam Ingram
to make a statement to parliament last week, in which he denied
that he had received any reports about prisoner abuses. That elicited
a rebuttal from the International Committee of the Red Cross ICRC),
which said it had sent a report to the government earlier this
year detailing how coalition forces were breaking the Geneva Convention
in Iraq and that it had held several meetings with leaders of
the coalition, urging them to end the widespread ill treatment
of those in its custody.
The confidential report, much of which has now been leaked,
mainly dealt with abuses by US forces, but also included specific
criticisms of areas under British command. These included the
case of nine men arrested by British forces in Basra on September
13 who were made to kneel, face and hands against the ground,
as if in a prayer position. The soldiers stamped on the back of
the neck of those raising their head.
The report says the men were later severely beaten
by coalition troops.
One of the arrestees died following the ill-treatment....
Prior to his death, his co-arrestees heard him screaming and asking
for assistance.
Two of those arrested were placed in hospital with severe
injuries.
The report also raised criticisms about interrogation methods
at Umm Qasr camp, run jointly by US and UK forces, which included
the use of hoods and flexi-cuffs.
Amnesty International also disclosed that it had warned the
government last May that prisoners were being tortured.
It had sent a letter to the Ministry of Defence last year detailing
the death of one Iraqi prisoner at the hands of British troops.
Amnesty had met Defence and Foreign Office officials in June over
the matter and had sent another memo detailing the mistreatment
of prisoners in July, and a letter to Hoon in October.
That month, the government had replied promising an investigation
into the allegations, but this secretive study had
been published by an arm of the defence forces, the Royal Military
Police.
British claims to have known nothing about the type of depraved
torture techniques being used by the US forces, as depicted in
the so-called trophy pictures taken at Abu Ghraib
prison, were further undermined by reports in the Observer
newspaper.
This revealed that British military intelligence officers were
at the jail when the first reports of torture came to light. The
newspaper said that the Ministry of Defence had confirmed that
three military personnel had been stationed at the
prison between January and April of this year, and that the intelligence
service MI6 had also visited the jail regularly.
The revelations threaten to drag the British government
into the heart of the international scandal over coalition abuse
at Abu Ghraib, the paper stated.
This was the context in which Hoon finally appeared in parliament
to answer the allegationsand where he sought to defend himself
and the government by claiming ignorance.
He had not read the ICRC report until it was leaked because
it was an interim document, Hoon said, which had been
passed to Britain in confidence by the US head of the coalition,
Paul Bremer, in February. Copies also went to Sir Jeremy Greenstock,
the UK military representative in Iraq, and the Permanent Joint
Headquarters in London. Officials there had decided that as the
issues relating to British forces were being dealt with, ministers
did not need to know, Hoon claimed.
Blair took the same tack, telling reporters, I have not
seen this document. But let me make it clear my understanding
is the two issues that are raised by the Red Cross document in
respect of abuses of Iraqi prisoners, there is one specific case
on that issue and those were actually dealt with.
Hoons and Blairs claims are transparent. Just one
year ago, photographs depicting British soldiers torturing Iraqi
detainees came to public attention when a photographic developer
raised the alarm. These depicted an Iraqi prisoner suspended from
a forklift truck, and another of a prisoner apparently forced
to perform oral sex on his jailer. Although at least six British
soldiers have been under investigation for the assaults, none
have yet been charged.
Last week, lawyers acting on behalf of 12 Iraqi families took
their case to the London High Court, charging British armed forces
with murdering their relatives in separate, unprovoked instances.
A subsequent report by Amnesty International has listed 33 cases
of civilian deaths, injuries or ill treatment in Iraq, including
the shooting death of an eight-year-old girl.
Despite his denials in parliament of these widespread abuses,
Hoon unintentionally confirmed that he had known British troops
were behaving illegally when he claimed that the army had been
instructed in September to end the hooding of Iraqi
prisoners under their control, breaking a 30-year ban on the practice.
Having washed his hands of any responsibility for events, Hoon
sought to divert attention entirely from the government and its
armed forces, by attacking the Mirror for publishing its
photographs.
The newspaper has been singled out for opprobrium by the government
and much of the media for publishing the photographs as well as
the accounts of several soldiers backing up the torture allegations.
But after almost two weeks, neither the government nor the army
has been able to prove the photographs are fake. Nor was Hoon
able to do so in parliament. His efforts to turn the tables on
his accusers focused on the claim that there were strong
indications that a truck seen in the pictures was not used
in Iraq. Later, when pressed on Channel Four, Hoon stated categorically
that the photos were fake.
Hoons evasions have only deepened the governments
crisis. His denials, if taken at face value, only mean that British
officials willfully covered over hundreds of complaints regarding
the actions of US and British forcesproving once again that
the government is prepared to swallow anything in order to defend
its decision to go to war and its alliance with the US. And more
worrying for sections of the British establishment, these compaints
would prove that the government really has no control over events
in Iraq and that it is simply being dragged along in Americas
wake and into a bloody quagmire.
The efforts of the government and the media to exonerate Britains
armed forces of allegations of systematic and willful abuse still
leave Blair and company guilty by their association with Washington.
Having insisted that his support for US military intervention
was the right course, despite massive public opposition, and having
justified it continuously ever since, the prime minister is regarded
even by his allies as the joint architect of the present disaster
in Iraq.
In the last few days, speculation has become routine that Blair
may have to be pushed to one side, with former Labour Minister
Denis Healy and the film director (and the prime ministers
close personal friend) Lord Puttnam only the latest to say he
must step down.
See Also:
Soldiers report British torture of Iraqi
civilians
[8 May 2004]
Top of page
The WSWS invites your comments.
Copyright 1998-2007
World Socialist Web Site
All rights reserved |