News & Information for Technology Purchasers
NewsFactor Network Sites: Security CRM Business Sci-Tech Newsletters White Papers XML/RSS Feed  
Home Enterprise I.T. Hardware Software Network Security More Topics...
Global Network Solutions
Download this white paper
on Virtela's unique multi-carrier

approach to Global Networking.
World Wide Web
Average Rating:
Rate this article:  
Death Knell Sounds for Wikipedia, Death Knell Sounds for Wikipedia,
By Frederick Lane
December 14, 2007 12:23PM

Digg It!   Bookmark to
The common consensus in the media is that Google's new "knol" tool will be aimed squarely at Wikipedia, and in fact the sample Web page on display in Udi Manber's blog post does bear some passing resemblance to a typical Wikipedia page. But other features suggest Google's target is less Wikipedia than it is

Related Topics




In relatively quiet fashion, search engine giant Google announced the testing of a new tool for organizing and disseminating knowledge on the Web. The new tool is built around the concept of a "knol," which the company says stands for "a unit of knowledge."

"A knol on a particular topic," wrote Udi Manber, Google's vice president of engineering, "is meant to be the first thing someone who searches for this topic for the first time will want to read."

Manber said that, unlike Wikipedia, which relies on the collective and relatively anonymous contributions of many different editors, Google's knols will be primarily written by a single, identified author whose credentials will be displayed at the top of each knol.

"Google will not serve as an editor in any way, and will not bless any content," Manber emphasized. "All editorial responsibilities and control will rest with the authors. We hope that knols will include the opinions and points of view of the authors who will put their reputation on the line."

More Than Wikipedia

The common consensus in the media is that Google's knols are aimed squarely at Wikipedia, and in fact, the sample Web page on display in Manber's blog post does bear some passing resemblance to a typical Wikipedia page. At the top of the page is a brief summary, beside which is a table of contents with links to various sections of the page.

But Google is considering several different features, the most provocative of which is a ranking system that will affect how high the knols appear in Google search results. Manber said that Google anticipates that there will be competing knols for some topic, and rankings will help readers decide which knols are the most reliable and useful.

Google anticipates that some writers will choose to include Google Ads on their knol pages. "If an author chooses to include ads," Manber said, "Google will provide the author with substantial revenue share from the proceeds of those ads."

That feature alone suggests that Google's target is less Wikipedia than it is, which has built an extensive network of topical ad-supported channels, each one with its own identified human guide. hires writers to serve as Guides on specific titles and then pays them based on page views. The chief difference with Google's knol concept is that any person would be able to create a knol page on any conceivable topic.

No Word on Knol Rollout

Not surprisingly, at this early stage, there are myriad unanswered questions about how all of this will work. Manber also said that, although the concept centers around a specific author, "people will be able to submit comments, questions, edits, additional content, and so on."

Presumably, however, any suggested edits will have to be approved by the page's creator, or the concept of author origin and control will be lost.

It might be a while before the answers are known. A spokesperson for Google said in an e-mail interview that because this is still in the experimental stage, there are no "public-facing knols" for review right now. The company is not releasing any further information about when the knol feature will go live.


Advertisement is the global leader in on-demand CRM, helping 35,300 companies worldwide automate their sales, services, and marketing processes. It�s the most customizable, most integrated, and most global CRM solution on the market. Period. Experience CRM success�starting now. Click here for a FREE 30-day trial of Salesforce.

 World Wide Web
1.   Online Donors Bolster Obama
2.   Yahoo Seeks Help for Journalists
3.   Apostrophes Stir Lot O' Trouble
4.   Microsoft Opens APIs and Protocols
5.   Xbox Live Open to User-Made Games

Google May Have 'Won' FCC AuctionGoogle May Have 'Won' FCC Auction
Verizon floats $4 billion in debt.
Average Rating:
Health Care Net Sites: Surfer BewareHealth Care Net Sites: Surfer Beware
Many sites run by lawyers, not doctors.
Average Rating:
Google Leads Microsoft-Yahoo AttackGoogle Leads Microsoft-Yahoo Attack
Analysts cite cultural differences.
Average Rating:
Product Information and Resources for Technology You Can Use To Boost Your Business

Network Security Spotlight
Cold-Boot Attack Can Crack Disk Encryption
Research shows that a savvy attacker with a can of compressed air and good timing can access encryption keys used by Vista's BitLocker, the Mac's FileVault, and other well-known encryption tools.
Software Piracy on the Decline in 2007
The SIAA, the principal trade association for the software and digital content industry, released its 2007 Anti-Piracy Year in Review, chronicling the SIIA's anti-piracy efforts and other notable achievements.
Data Breaches: A Global Dilemma
An insatiable appetite by U.S. consumers for privacy-related news keeps data breaches here on many people's radar. But recent incidents in the U.K. and Canada highlight the global nature of the problem.

Enterprise Hardware Spotlight
Remote System Will Ease Lost-Notebook Worries
Technology in the next generation of notebook hard drives will help you sleep better if your notebook is lost or stolen. Seagate and Hitachi will build in FailSafe, a remote data-protection system.
Blu-ray Triumphs in High-Def DVD War
The future of high-def DVDs became a lot clearer Tuesday after Toshiba said that by March it will stop making players for its HD DVD format, leaving Sony's Blu-ray as the champion of the format war.
Lose My Laptop, Gimme (Or Don't) $54 Million
If you took your laptop in for repairs to a well-known big box store only to discover its tech contractor lost the machine, lied, faked documentation and finally offered a "We're sorry" gift card -- you'd be steamed.

Mobile Enterprise Spotlight
T-Mobile Testing Unlimited Home Phoning for $10
T-Mobile wants you to talk forever. The wireless provider is testing its Talk Forever Home Phone plan in two cities, Seattle and Dallas. The plan allows unlimited U.S. calling for $10 a month.
Google Looking at Balloons for Wireless Coverage
Google, a company with sky-high valuation and aspirations to match, is seriously thinking about wireless transmission using balloons that Space Data Corp. loads with electronics for a 24-hour journey.
Talk All You Want on Wireless Phones for Just $99.99
Forget about counting minutes. In an unusual synchronicity, three carriers -- AT&T; Wireless, Verizon Wireless and T-Mobile -- have announced unlimited wireless calling plans at the same price.

NewsFactor Network
Home/Top News | Enterprise I.T. | Hardware | Software | Network Security | Wireless Tech | Linux/Open Source | Apple/Macintosh
Microsoft/Windows | World Wide Web | Data Storage | E-Commerce | Personal Tech | Tech Trends | Business Briefing
NewsFactor Network Enterprise I.T. Sites
NewsFactor Technology News | Enterprise Security Today | CRM Daily

NewsFactor Business and Innovation Sites
Sci-Tech Today | NewsFactor Business Report

NewsFactor Services
FreeNewsFeed | Free Newsletters | Free Whitepapers | XML/RSS Feed

About NewsFactor Network | How To Contact Us | Article Reprints | Careers @ NewsFactor | How To Advertise

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
© Copyright 2000-2008 NewsFactor Network. All rights reserved. Article rating technology by Blogowogo.