Check Back tomorrow for complete analysis of this data. For some brief, top-level analysis and notes on how the data was compiled, click here.
100. NHL 08 X360/PS2/PS3/PC 460K 85% September/Sports EA Sports/EA Canada Matthew Kato (Game Informer): “EA has clearly put some good work in here, and I suggest you reward it with some ice time.”
99. Ninja Gaiden Sigma PS3 Exclusive 470K 88% June/Action Tecmo/Team Ninja Gavin Ogden (GamesRadar): “Once mastered, you'll find an immersive action romp full of original challenges, incredible environments and interesting characters. This game might have been around for years, but the intensity of the gameplay has yet to be bettered.”
98. Cooking Mama: Cook Off Wii Exclusive 470K 61% March/Other (Cooking) Majesco/Office Create Sterling McGarvey (GameSpy): “Simple exercises, such as rolling pasta dough, become torturous experiences, not because the game itself is challenging, per se, but largely because the controls don't feel precise or intuitive enough for the nature of the gameplay.”
97. Naruto: Ninja Council 3 DS Exclusive 470K 57% May/License D3Publisher/Eighting D.F. Smith (G4 TV): “It seems like the developer started with that good idea, but couldn't figure out how to make the details work -- how to design levels that worked with the controls, instead of constantly getting in the way.”
96. NASCAR 08 PS2/PS3/X360 490K 56% July/License EA/EA Tiburon Sam Bishop (IGN): “…NASCAR's underlying experience is so incredibly average. With so many amazing racing games, from sims to arcade crash-a-thons, NASCAR 08 no longer fills a niche larger than the actual sport, and while that may be good enough for die-hard fans of the sport, it's definitely not going to satisfy casual racing fans.”
95. EA Playground Wii/DS 500K 66% October/Other (Party) EA/EA Canada Chris Antista (GamesRadar): “Cynical adults will write it off, and rightly so, but the fact that each of the well designed games offers multiplayer support could mean that Playground will be around much longer than we expected.”
94. Turok X360/PS3 500K 69% February/Shooter Touchstone/Propaganda Games Xbox World 360 (CVG): “Basically, it's just extremely generic and has that 'safe' feel about its design that suggests that its spent more time with the marketers than it has the artists.”
93. Bee Movie Game DS/Wii/PS2/X360/PC 530K 58% October/License Activision/Beenox (PS2/X360/PC), Smart Bomb (Wii), Vicarious Visions (DS) Frank Provo (GameSpot): “You could argue that the reason the game is simple and short is because it's geared toward young kids. While there's some merit to that argument, it really doesn't explain why the overall design and presentation are so underwhelming.”
92. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion PS3 (other versions came out earlier and are not counted here) 530K 93% March/RPG Bethesda/Bethesda Joe Rybicki (1Up): “But if you don't own a 360 or a high-end gaming PC, I have this piece of advice for you: Run -- do not walk, run -- to your local game retailer and buy this game.”
91. Resident Evil: The Umbrella Chronicles Wii Exclusive 540K 75% November/Shooter (Rail Shooter) Capcom/Capcom, cavia Michael Gapper (GamesRadar): “A slow start makes way for more intense action on later levels, and though it never feels like an all-out shooter or a true RE experience, it occasionally touches on both.”
NEXT: 540K to 600K
|