Posted: Tue., Sep. 4, 2007, 4:16pm PT


I'm Not There


'I'm Not There'
Click here for the trailer.

A Weinstein Co. (in U.S.) release of an Endgame Entertainment, Killer Films, John Wells and John Goldwyn (U.S.) production, a VIP Medienfonds 4 (Germany) production, in association with Rising Star, in association with Grey Water Park Prods. (International sales: Celluloid Dreams, Paris.) Produced by James D. Stern, John Sloss, Goldwyn, Christian Vachon. Executive producers, Hengameh Panahi, Philip Elway, Andrea Grosch, Douglas E. Hansen, Wendy Japhet, Steven Soderbergh, Amy J. Kaufman, Wells. Co-producer, Charles Pugliese. Directed by Todd Haynes. Screenplay, Haynes, Oren Moverman; story, Haynes, inspired by the music and many lives of Bob Dylan.
Jack/Pastor John - Christian Bale
Jude - Cate Blanchett
Woody - Marcus Carl Franklin
Billy - Richard Gere
Robbie - Heath Ledger
Arthur - Ben Whishaw
Claire - Charlotte Gainsbourg
Allen Ginsberg - David Cross
Journalist - Bruce Greenwood
Alice Fabian - Julianne Moore
Coco Rivington - Michelle Williams
A densely idiosyncratic, cubist-like cinematic portrait of a man who often calls to mind Bob Dylan, Todd Haynes' "I'm Not There" resembles a film a precocious grad student in musicology might make about a creative hero. Stylistically audacious in the way it employs six different actors and assorted visual styles to depict various aspects of the troubadour's life and career, the film nevertheless lacks a narrative and a center, much like the "ghost" at its core. Dylan fans and '60s-era pop-culture mavens will constitute pic's most reliable audience, as mainstream interest will remain unstirred.

Haynes' unconventional approach to biography was no doubt the reason this became the first project about Dylan's life anointed by the man himself, who allowed the use of his songs, both in original form and in covers. Dylan's own taste in cinematic ventures has been questionable over the years, but "I'm Not There" is decisively superior to "Masked & Anonymous."

As it jumps around in time and explores assorted Dylan personae backed by one of the 20th century's most impressive greatest-hits collections, "I'm Not There" is never dull and rarely aggravating. Some of Haynes' most daring ideas -- such as having the youthful, Woody Guthrie-idolizing Dylan portrayed by an 11-year-old black boy, and expressing the impact of the Dylan-goes-electric Newport concert by having the singer and his band literally machine-gun the folky audience -- come off surprisingly well, and the general let's-try-this approach is broached in such a genial manner that it encourages the viewer to abandon any preconceptions and follow where Haynes leads.

Such open-mindedness is further spurred by the first "Dylan," who receives significant screentime. Young Marcus Carl Franklin is charmingly forthright as a guitar-toting kid who, in 1959, rides the rails, '30s-style, and identifies himself as Guthrie when he doesn't claim to be Arthur Rimbaud. Little "Woody" is admired for his talent wherever he travels, until he is upbraided one day by a wise lady who admonishes him to "Live in your own time."

And so he does, materializing in Greenwich Village in the guise of "Jack" (Christian Bale) and taking the progressive music scene by storm with "The Times They Are A-Changin' " and other early gems.

At this stage, pic begins to fracture itself, for good and ill. Heath Ledger turns up as "Robbie," a moody actor who stars as a Dylan-like figure in a Hollywood film called "Grain of Sand." A docu format reminiscent of Martin Scorsese's "No Direction Home" takes over to accommodate straight-to-camera interviews with the likes of former intimate Alice Fabian (Julianne Moore), and the verite vein persists in an attempt to explain why Jack cut his ties with the protest movement shortly after JFK's assassination, around the time Robbie meets painter Claire (Charlotte Gainsbourg).

Getting it on with Claire to the strains of "I Want You," Robbie, in a charming scene, takes her to the country to pick up a motorcycle, and they eventually marry and have two kids.

The film suddenly jolts to life at the 40-minute mark with the cataclysmic New England Jazz & Folk Festival; not only is the music now plugged in, but the central figure, "Jude," is impersonated by Cate Blanchett. Scrawny, her eyes often concealed by large shades and topped by a curly mop identical to Dylan's at the time of "Don't Look Back," Blanchett is, appropriately enough, truly electrifying at first; she's uncannily got down the skittish movements, wary eyes, curt mumble and occasional flashes of brilliance, and comes far closer than anyone else to approximating the Dylan the public knows.

As the performance goes on -- it's by a fair distance the dominant turn in the picture, both in impact and duration -- and the character becomes increasingly wigged out by drugs and paranoia, the reliance on mannerisms over psychological depth becomes more apparent. Still, Blanchett's casting and performance rep a daring coup, and she can now rightly claim to be the only thesp on Earth ever to have been asked to channel both Bob Dylan and Katharine Hepburn, and to have done so successfully.

Jude's British tour and associated events provide the core and highlight of "I'm Not There," due to a combination of Blanchett; the encounters with notables such as Allen Ginsberg and the Beatles (in a throwaway, "A Hard Day's Night"-style gag); the visual elan Haynes and lenser Edward Lachman achieve in black-and-white by subtly segueing in style from D.A. Pennebaker and Richard Lester to the sleeker, swinging-London look of John Schlesinger's "Darling"; Jude's seemingly futile pursuit of an elusive Edie Sedgwick-type blonde named Coco (Michelle Williams); his defiance in the face of audience fury at his new sound; and the probings of an intelligent journalist (an excellent Bruce Greenwood), intent upon exposing Jude as a fraud.

Unfortunately, after steadily gaining steam and conviction through its midsection, the film grinds to a virtual halt when it again radically shifts focus to gaze upon "Billy" (Richard Gere), a reclusive mountain man intent upon leaving behind a celebrated and/or notorious past. This interlude clearly reflects not only on Dylan but on Sam Peckinpah's "Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid," in which Dylan played a supporting part.

Meant to echo both Peckinpah and "McCabe & Mrs. Miller," this unduly protracted section is poorly conceived on every level, as it dramatizes and contributes nothing. Impossible as it no doubt would have been to eliminate a star like Gere from the picture, the end result unquestionably would have been superior without this meandering Western material, for which Haynes seems to have no feel.

Having hit this crossroads and proceeded down the wrong path, pic more or less stumbles the rest of the way, as do the various Dylan incarnations. Only a final, haunting closeup image of the real Dylan in performance brings things fleetingly back to life.

Dylan freaks and scholars will have the most fun with "I'm Not There," and there will inevitably be innumerable dissertations on the ways Haynes has both reflected and distorted reality, mined and manipulated the biographical record and otherwise had a field day with the essentials, as well as the esoterica, of Dylan's life. All of this will serve to inflate the film's significance by ignoring its lack of more general accessibility. In the end, it's a specialists' event.

Production looks and sounds great. Montreal-area locations superbly stand in for such diverse settings as the northeastern U.S., London and environs, and Paris, a tribute as well to production designer Judy Becker. Costume designs by John Dunn, along with makeup, hair and assorted accoutrements, provide further crucial period verisimilitude, and the use of Dylan's music is intelligent and invigorating.

"I'm Not There" may not be all there, but it doubtless provides lots to talk about.

Camera (color/B&W;, widescreen), Edward Lachman; editor, Jay Rabinowitz; music supervisors, Randall Poster, Jim Dunbar; production designer, Judy Becker; art director, Pierre Perrault; costume designer, Jon Dunn; sound (Dolby Digital), Patrick Rousseau; sound designer, Leslie Shatz; special effects supervisor, Louis Craig; visual effects supervisor, Louis Morin; assistant director, Pedro B. Gandol; casting, Laura Rosenthal. Reviewed at Telluride Film Festival, Aug. 31, 2007. (Also in Venice Film Festival -- competing; Toronto Film Festival -- Special Presentations; New York Film Festival.) MPAA Rating: R. Running time: 135 MIN.


Variety is striving to present the most thorough review database. To report inaccuracies in review credits, please click here. We do not currently list below-the-line credits, although we hope to include them in the future. Please note we may not respond to every suggestion. Your assistance is appreciated.

Date in print: Mon., Sep. 10, 2007, Weekly


Here is what others are saying about this review:

For people not familiar with Bob Dy... read more >

Watch the first teaser from Ron Howard and Tom Hanks 'Da Vinci Code' prequel, 'Angels & Demons.'; 'Angels & Demons' trailer; teaser; Tom Hanks; trailers; variety; video; The first teaser trailer for New Line Cinema's remake of the horror classic. ; 'Friday the 13th' trailer; 2008; 2009 Variety; horror; jason; new; teaser; trailers; Anne Hathaway and Kate Hudson square off in the new comedy from 20th Century Fox. ; 'Bride Wars' trailer; Anne Hathaway; Kate Hudson; movies; variety; video; The newest trailer for Tom Cruise's upcoming WWII drama. ; 'Valkyrie' new trailer; Tom Cruise; trailers; valkyrie; variety; video; Will Smith stars in the emotional story about a man who changes the lives of seven strangers.; Clint Eastwood stars in the new drama from Warner Bros. ; 'Gran Torino' trailer; Clint Eastwood; variety; video; Warner Bros. trailers; Zac Efron and Matthew Perry star in the teen comedy from New Line Cinema. ; '17 Again' trailer; High School Musical; Matthew Perry; trailers; vanessa hudgens; variety; Zac Efron; Based on the NY Times bestselling series, a young woman (Kristen Stewart) falls in love with a vampire (Robert Pattinson). ; Kristen Stewart; New 'Twilight' trailer; Robert Pattinson; twilights trailers; vampire; Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet reunite in director Sam Mendes' period drama for Paramount Vantage. ; Nicole Kidman and Hugh Jackman star in Baz Lurhmann's highly-anticpated drama, 'Australia.' ; australia; Baz Lurhman; Drama; Hugh Jackman; movie; Nicole Kidman; trailer; variety; Daniel Craig and Liev Schreiber star in the WWII drama from Paramount Vantage. ; Adam Sandler's bedtime tales comes to life in the new family comedy from Disney. ; 'Bedtime Stories' trailer; Adam Sandler; disney; variety; video; Christian Bale plays 'John Connor' in Warner Bros.' fourth installment of the 'Terminator' series. ; 'Terminator: Salvation' teaser trailer; Christian Bale; Variety Video; A behind-the-scenes look at the prom scene from Disney's highly-anticipated pic, "High School Musical 3: Senior Year."; Warner Bros. brings one of the most popular graphic novels of all time to the bigscreen. ; 'The Watchmen' trailer; variety; video; Watchmen movie trailer teaser; The new trailer for director/creator Frank Miller's graphic novel adaptation starring Samuel L. Jackson, Scarlett Johansson, and Eva Mendes. ; 'The Spirit' new trailer; eva mendes; Frank Miller; Scarlett Johansson; variety; video; Jason Statham returns as action-magnet Frank Martin in the third 'Transporter' installment from Lionsgate. ; 'Transporter 3' trailer; Jason Statham; trailers; variety; video; Angelina Jolie stars in director Clint Eastwood's abduction drama, "Changeling."; Zac Efron and Corbin Bleu give us a behind-the-scene look at the 'Boys' dance sequence in "High School Musical 3: Senior Year."; A heart-wrenching documentary about the tragic life of a beloved man. ; Exclusive trailer 'Dear Zachary' movie; review; trailer; variety; video; Based on a short story by F. Scott Fitzerald, Brad Pitt stars as a man who ages in reverse in David Fincher's chronological drama. ; 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' trailer; angelina jolie; Brad Pitt; David Fincher; movie trailers; trailer download; variety; Warner Bros.; DreamWorks animation is back in the jungle again with 'Madagascar 2: Escape from Africa.'; 'Madagascar 2' trailer; Ben Stiller; Chris Rock; trailers; variety; video; Vince Vaughn and Reese Witherspoon star in the New Line holiday comedy, "Four Christmases."; four christmases trailer; Reese Witherspoon; trailers; variety; Vince Vaughn; Isla Fisher in the adaptation of the bestselling series, "Confessions of a Shopaholic."; 'Confessions of a Shopaholic' trailer; isla Fisher; trailers; Variety Video; Philip Seymour Hoffman stars in writer Charlie Kauffman's directorial debut, "Syndecdoche, New York"; Charlie Kauffman; New York trailer; Philip Seymour Hoffman; Synecdoche; variety; video; "Atonement" director Joe Wright composes Robert Downey Jr. and Jaimie Foxx inthe story of a schizophrenic musician in Los Angeles. ; Rapper Notorious B.I.G.'s life is documented in the upcoming feature from Fox Searchlight. ; 'Notorious' trailer; notrious B.I.G. movie; rapper BIG; variety; video; Sean Penn plays Harvey Milk, the groundbreaking homosexual politician who took San Francisco by storm in the 70's. ; Harvey Milk; Milk trailer; San Francisco; sean penn; variety; video; Based on the memoir by Danny Wallace, Jim Carrey stars as a man who must say 'Yes' to everything for one year. ; 'Yes Man' trailer; Jim Carrey; trailers; variety; Zooey Deschanel; Anne Hathaway plays a drug-addict sibling who returns for her sisters wedding in the Jonathan Demme drama. ; 'Rachel Getting Married' trailer; Anne Hathaway; Jonathan Demme; movie; trailers; Daniel Radcliffe stars in Warner Bros. and author J.K. Rowling's final chapter of the 'Harry Potter' franchise. ; 'Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince' trailer; new; trailers; variety; video; Frank Langella stars as the embattled president in the new drama from 'Queen' scribe Peter Morgan. ; Frank Langella trailers; frost nixon; Frost/Nixon trailer; Richard Nixon; Variety Video; Keanu Reeves and Jennifer Connolly star in Twentieth Century Fox's remake of the sci-fi classic.; 'The Day the Earth Stood Still' trailer; december 12th; Fox; jennifer connolly; keanu reeves; movie trailers; Remake; variety; Josh Brolin stars as George W. Bush in director Oliver Stone's portrayal of the controversial President. ; 'W' trailer; bush; Josh Brolin; Oliver Stone; trailers; variety; video; W trailer; Daniel Craig stars as James Bond in Sony's highly anticipated sequel to 'Casino Royale' ; 'Quantum of Solace' trailer; Daniel Craig; embed; free download; James Bond; trailer; variety; Paul Rudd and Sean William Scott star as two "Role Models" in the new comedy from Universal. ; 'Role Models' movie trailer; Paul Rudd; Sean William Scott; trailers; variety; video; Bill Murray and Tim Robbins star in this fantasy/drama about a illuminous city that slowly begins to fade. ; 'City of Ember' trailer; Bill Murray; embed; free; movie trailers; Tim Robbins; variety; Religulous Movie Trailer; Appaloosa Movie Trailer; Adrien Brody and Mark Ruffalo play two con man attempting to swindle an eccentric heiress in 'The Brothers Bloom.'; 'The Brothers Bloom' trailer; Adrien Brody; variety; video; Mark Wahlberg and Twentieth Century Fox bring the gritty videogame hero to the bigscreen. ; 'Max Payne' trailer; Download; Mark Wahlberg; New Trailer; variety; Eva Mendes, Scarlett Johansson, and Samuel L. Jackson star in comic mastermind Frank Miller's directorial debut. ; The Coen Bros.' follow up to 'No Country' is a quirky drama starring Brad Pitt and George Clooney. (Warning: graphic language); Brad Pitt; Burn After Reading; George Clooney; Joel and Ethan Cohen; John Malkovich; trailer; variety; video; BETWEEN THE LINES explores the Vietnam War through the prism of the surfing sub-culture.; Leonardo DiCaprio and Russell Crowe star in Ridley Scott's adaptation of the CIA thriller. ; 'Body of Lies' trailer; Leonardo DiCaprio; Ridley Scott; Russell Crowe; trailers; variety; Sam Rockwell stars in the bigscreen adaptation of author Chuck Palahniuk's novel, "Choke."; Director Guy Ritchie returns another British gangster film. This time starring '300' stud Guy Ritchie. ; 'RocknRolla' trailer; Gerard Butler; Guy Ritchie; madonna; trailers; Michael Cera and Kat Dennings star in the teen comedy, 'Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist.' ; Kat Dennings; Michael Cera; Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist trailer; video trailers; 'City of God' director Fernando Meirelles directs Julianne Moore and Mark Ruffalo in the adaptation of Jos� Saramago's epidemic novel.; 'Blindness' trailer; Julianne Moore; Mark Ruffalo; trailers; Variety review; video; Tom Cruise stars in the upcoming WWII thriller about the assassination of Adolf Hitler. ; Hitler; katie holmes; Tom Cruise; trailer; valkyrie; variety; video; World War II; Meg Ryan and Annette Bening star in the remake of George Cukor's 1939 film.; 'The Women' trailer; Bette Midler; Diane Keaton; eva mendes; Meg Ryan; variety; video; Vin Diesel returns to the action-genre in Fox's futuristic thriller, 'Babylon A.D.'; 'Babylon A.D.' trailer; August 2008; Fox; variety; video; Vin Diesel; Saw V Teaser Trailer; Rainn Wilson stars as an out-of-work '80's drummer who's called upon for a last-minute gig. (Fox); 'The Rocker' trailer; christina applegate; comedy; Fox; Rainn Wilson; variety; video; College Movie Trailer; Woody Allen is back behind the camera with Penelope Cruz, Javier Bardhem and Scarlett Johansson topping this Spanish romance. ; 'Vicky Cristina Barcelona' trailer; Javier Bardhem; Movie Trailer; Penelope Cruz; Scarlett Johansson; spain; Woody Allen; Dennis Quaid stars in the real-life story of Ernie Davis, the first African-American to win the Heisman trophy. ; 'The Express' trailer; Dennis Quaid; Ernie Davis; Heisman Trophy; variety; video; Twilight trailer 2; A scene from Alex Gibney's upcoming documentary, 'Gonzo: The Life and Work of Hunter S. Thompson' ; 'Gonzo: The Life and Work of Hunter S. Thompson' scene; trailer; variety; Jennifer Aniston, Ben Affleck and more top this star-studded romantic comedy from Warner Bros.; Ben Affleck; Drew Barrymore; He's Just Not That Into You; Jennifer Aniston; Justin Long; trailer; variety; Death Race Movie Trailer; Righteous Kill - Movie Trailer; Sean William Scott and John C. Reilly star as two co-workers vying for the same promotion. ; 'The Promotion' trailer; comedy; John C. Reilly; Sean William Scott; variety; video; Mulder and Scully return to the bigscreen this Summer in FOX and creator Chris Carter's 'X-Files: I Want to Believe.'; Chris Carter; David Duchovney; Fox; Gillian Anderson; Mulder; Scully; trailer; variety; X-Files: I Want to Believe; Seth Rogen and James Franco star in the Judd Apatow produced stoner comedy, 'Pineapple Express.'; 'Pineapple Express' trailer; comedy; James Franco; Judd Apatow; Seth Rogen; stoner; stoners; variety; Lucasfilm is back with another 'Star Wars' movie. This time, however, the jedi's are animated. ; animated movie; Film; George Lucas; jedi; lucasfilm; Star Wars: Clone Wars; trailer; variety; Heath Ledger stars as the Joker in Christopher Nolan's highly-anticipated sequel to 'Batman Begins.'; Kiefer Sutherland stars as an ex-cop who begins to investigate the evil force that has penetrated his home. ; 'Mirrors' trailer; horror; Kiefer Sutherland; Mirrors; trailers; variety; video; 'Disturbia' director D.J. Caruso reunites with Shia LaBeouf in this political assassination thriller. ; 'Eagle Eye' trailer; movie trailers; Shia LaBeouf; variety; video; Trailer for the "The Visitor", directed by Tom McCarthy.; Real-life teens star in one of the most talked about documentaries of the year. ; American Teen; documentary; sundance; trailer; variety; Fox's intergalactic comedy highlights the antics of astronaut chimps with all the �wrong stuff.�; ' Fox; 'Space Chimps; animation; trailer; variety; video; Jack Black and Ben Stiller topline this jungle comedy about a group of Hollywood actors getting caught in the action.; Ben Stiller; comedy; Jack Black; Matthew McConaughey; movie; Robert Downey Jr.; Tom Cruise; Tropic Thunder; Marvel Comics returns to the bigscreen with the second installment of the action/fantasy thriller. ; Hellboy 2; Marvel Comics; movie; Selma Blair; sequel; The Golden Army; Three women are stalked by a killer with a grudge that extends back to the girls' childhoods.; amusement; horror; Sony Picturehouse; Thriller; trailer; variety; Pixar's latest entry tells the story of a loveable yet mischievous robot named 'Wall-E'; Will Smith plays a superhero with some not-so-super habits in Sony's big-budget 'Hancock.'; Angelina Jolie and James McAvoy star in this action-apprentice tale of justice. ; action; angelina jolie; James McAvoy; Morgan Freeman; movie; Thriller; wanted; Twilight - Movie Trailer; Physicist Bruce Banner takes flight in order to understand -- and hopefully cure -- the condition that turns him into a monster.; Pierce Brosnan and Meryl Streep star in the film adaptation of the Broadway hit musical. ; Will Smith plays a superhero with some not-so-super habits in Sony's big-budget 'Hancock.'; Will Ferrell and John C. Reilly star as two step-brothers who must find their way to brotherly love. ; 'Step Brothers' trailer; comedy; John C. Reilly; sony; variety; video; will ferrell; Heath Ledger stars as the Joker in Christopher Nolan's highly-anticipated sequel to 'Batman Begins.'; The newest trailer for the Ed Norton-starrer 'Incredible Hulk.'; America's favorite gal pals jump to the bigscreen this summer. ; Jack Black voices a 600-pound martial arts whiz in the Dreamworks animated film, 'Kung Fu Panda.'; Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull: Movie Trailer; Get Smart: Movie Trailer; Story about six MIT students who were trained to become experts in card counting and subsequently took Vegas casinos for millions in winnings.; Dreamworks Animations presents Kung Fu Panda.; Single business woman who dreams of having a baby discovers she is infertile and hires a working class woman to be her unlikely surrogate.; A team of people work to prevent a disaster threatening the future of the human race.; The attempted assassination of the president is told from five different perspectives.; A story about family, greed, religion, and oil, centered around a turn-of-the-century prospector in the early days of the business.; The last man on earth is not alone.; The rebellion begins. ; A scorching blast of tense genre filmmaking shot through with rich veins of melancholy, down-home philosophy and dark, dark humor, "No Country for Old Men" reps a superior match of source material and filmmaking talent.; movie review; No Country for Old Men; Tommy Lee Jones; variety; Variety review; Directors: Vincent Paronnaud & Marjane Satrapi Starring: Catherine Deneuve, Danielle Darrieux, Tilly Mandelbrot...; THERE WILL BE BLOOD chronicles one Daniel Plainview (Daniel Day-Lewis), who transforms himself from a silver miner into a self-made oil tycoon. ; There Will Be Blood; Movie Trailers

© 2009 Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Use of this website is subject to its Terms & Conditions of Use. View our Privacy Policy.