On CBSNews.com: Facebook And Your Boss
BNET Business Network:

March 6th, 2009

Cydia and Apple: Lawsuits will be a sideshow

Posted by Kevin O'Marah @ 7:05 am

Categories: Intellectual Property, Supply Chain Risk

Tags: Supply Chain, Lawsuit, Apple Inc., Cydia, Supply Chain Management (SCM), Enterprise Software, Software, Kevin O'Marah

Today’s Wall Street Journal has a big article about a new renegade competitor that is challenging Apple’s App Store and in the process whetting the appetites of IP lawyers. With all due respect to the legal eagles involved, technology and the global supply chain should make this debate moot. 

The deal is this: Cydia’s founder is an application developer who, like many, doesn’t see himself as an enemy of the cool company of Cupertino. He does, however, want to have other app developers able to get to market and get paid for their IP. Apple, however, stands to lose some pretty serious margin contribution (30% commission on estimated 2009 sales of $800M, according to Piper Jaffray) and, arguably, a degree of control over the cherished User Experience. The legal issue is that Cydia’s apps work only on “jailbroken” iPhones, a process (or crime) that involves installing software written to modify the operation of the device. Cydia’s founder, Jay Freeman, claims 1.7 million iPhones have installed this software to date. Apple, understandably, sees a copyright infringement. Lawyers see an irresistibly interesting case pitting the little, ironically named Freeman, against the sinister controlling monopoly—almost like the famous 1984 Apple Super Bowl ad being shown in reverse.

The interesting thing for technology and supply chain folks, however, has less to do with the potential precedent-setting debate surrounding this matter than with the design, production, and distribution strategies that a smart company like Apple can come up with to put the issue to bed. Apple is number 1 in our Supply Chain Top 25 (by the way, supply chain professionals are welcome to vote in our 2009 Supply Chain Top 25), and not because of their lean or six sigma discipline. The secret sauce is in how industrial design, software design, and electronic design weave together into an irresistible whole. In recent years, Apple has added another layer to its supply chain innovation—retailing. The Apple stores, not to mention the AT&T distribution deal for iPhones, puts this once totally vertically-integrated computer manufacturer squarely in the business of relating to consumers all the way from concept to profit. 

Defending the App Store will ultimately depend more on technical and business decisions made in component supplier collaboration, retail promotion, and technical support systems than decisions in the courtroom. Good lawyers will buy time to let Apple’s strategists work out the best way to protect its cash relationships with consumers. Hopefully, this will also allow creative types like Mr. Freeman to get paid for their creative work. But as the music industry learned the hard way with Napster, IP law is not enough to protect a business—physical supply chains must be part of instantiating control.

Kevin O'Marah is chief strategist at AMR Research.
  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 10 Talkback(s)
People were forced to buy an iPhone
I guess I missed the part where Apple forced you to buy an iPhone

Hey, if the battle cry from those who have never purchased anything other than Macs is "Microsoft is evil because you ar... (Read the rest)
Posted by: NonZealot Posted on: 03/09/09 You are currently: Logged In as: a Guest  | Login | Terms of Use
Typical of Apple  Mectron | 03/06/09
Apple Better Lose  voyager529 | 03/06/09
no, numbnutz...  Pederson | 03/06/09
Full blown PC without multitasking or copy and paste  NonZealot | 03/06/09
incorrect...  Pederson | 03/07/09
iPhone needs cut and paste  hscohen | 03/09/09
Been using an iPhone since day 1. You are wrong.  BillDem | 03/09/09
What is truly, truly sad is that these aren't complicated features  NonZealot | 03/09/09
I missed it  jragosta | 03/07/09
People were forced to buy an iPhone  NonZealot | 03/09/09

What do you think?

No Trackbacks Yet

The URI to TrackBack this entry is:


Recent Entries



Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

Printers Unleashed

  • Printer companies are figuring out what customers want, and are now focusing on mobility, speed, and convenience like never before. From wireless connectivity to advances such as inkless printing and the new Memjet technology, innovation is breathing new life into the printing industry.
  • From Our Sponsors
  • Every cartridge. Every day.
  • Recycle ANY ink & toner and get $3 back in Staples Rewards. See how it works and save money
Click Here