Get THR Mobile Alerts        FREE Newsletters
Music Reviews
Concert Review: Change Begins Within
By Frank Scheck, April 05, 2009 03:46 ET
Paul McCartney, left, and Ringo Starr (Getty Images photo)
Bottom Line: Paul and Ringo's rare reunion is but one highlight of a stirring, if at times overly meditative, benefit concert.
In terms of teasing musical foreplay, this was downright frustrating.

During Paul McCartney's show-closing set for David Lynch's "Change Begins Within" concert at Radio City, an empty drum kit sat tantalizingly behind him. As the ex-Beatle delivered rousing versions of such hits as "Jet," "Lady Madonna" and "Let It Be" among others, the entire audience waited breathlessly in anticipation. When would Ringo Starr, who had just finished his own solo set, be joining him?

It wasn't until nearly the end of the marathon four-hour evening that McCartney announced that the presence of a special guest, one "Billy Shears." Sure enough, the ebullient Ringo bounced out, sharing a microphone with his former bandmate on "With a Little Help From My Friends" and thrilling the sold-out crowd with the closest thing now possible to a Beatles reunion.

Watching Ringo behind the drums while McCartney and the rest of the all-star line-up performed "Cosmically Conscious" and "I Saw Her Standing There" made it seem, if only for a little while, that everything was all right in the world.

Not that everything was necessarily all right with the show, which raised some $3 million for Lynch's foundation's goal of teaching the practice of meditation to 1 million "at risk" children around the world.

Hosted by Lynch and actress Laura Dern, the evening featured a gallery of musical stars, but the inclusion of endless earnest speeches about the glories of Transcendental Meditation too often made it seem like a glorified infomercial.

It also served as a reunion of sorts for veterans of the Beatles' 1968 sojourn to India to study with the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, including Donovan (who performed "Hurdy Gurdy Man" accompanied by My Morning Jacket's Jim James, among other hits); flautist Paul Horn; and Mike Love of the Beach Boys.

Many of the stars performed material clearly inspired by the occasion. Sheryl Crow, accompanied by Ben Harper, covered George Harrison's "My Sweet Lord." McCartney paid tribute to John Lennon with "Here Today." And Harper and Eddie Vedder killed with a rendition of Queen and David Bowie's "Under Pressure."

Other highlights included Moby and Bettye LeVette dueting on "Natural Blues" while accompanied by the "TM Kids Choir"; Vedder's intense solo acoustic renditions of such songs as "Far Behind" and "Rise"; and pianist Angelo Badalamenti's show-opening rendition of his eerie "Twin Peaks" theme.

Other surprise guests included Jerry Seinfeld ("Don't meditate on me, I gotta do some jokes here," he cracked) and an uncharacteristically serious Howard Stern, who announced that he's been meditating for 38 years and who credited TM with saving his depressed mother's life many years ago.

Venue: Radio City Music Hall, New York (Saturday, April 4)
Concert Review: Change Begins Within
By Frank Scheck, April 05, 2009 03:46 ET
Paul McCartney, left, and Ringo Starr (Getty Images photo)
Bottom Line: Paul and Ringo's rare reunion is but one highlight of a stirring, if at times overly meditative, benefit concert.
In terms of teasing musical foreplay, this was downright frustrating.

During Paul McCartney's show-closing set for David Lynch's "Change Begins Within" concert at Radio City, an empty drum kit sat tantalizingly behind him. As the ex-Beatle delivered rousing versions of such hits as "Jet," "Lady Madonna" and "Let It Be" among others, the entire audience waited breathlessly in anticipation. When would Ringo Starr, who had just finished his own solo set, be joining him?

It wasn't until nearly the end of the marathon four-hour evening that McCartney announced that the presence of a special guest, one "Billy Shears." Sure enough, the ebullient Ringo bounced out, sharing a microphone with his former bandmate on "With a Little Help From My Friends" and thrilling the sold-out crowd with the closest thing now possible to a Beatles reunion.

Watching Ringo behind the drums while McCartney and the rest of the all-star line-up performed "Cosmically Conscious" and "I Saw Her Standing There" made it seem, if only for a little while, that everything was all right in the world.

Not that everything was necessarily all right with the show, which raised some $3 million for Lynch's foundation's goal of teaching the practice of meditation to 1 million "at risk" children around the world.

Hosted by Lynch and actress Laura Dern, the evening featured a gallery of musical stars, but the inclusion of endless earnest speeches about the glories of Transcendental Meditation too often made it seem like a glorified infomercial.

It also served as a reunion of sorts for veterans of the Beatles' 1968 sojourn to India to study with the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, including Donovan (who performed "Hurdy Gurdy Man" accompanied by My Morning Jacket's Jim James, among other hits); flautist Paul Horn; and Mike Love of the Beach Boys.

Many of the stars performed material clearly inspired by the occasion. Sheryl Crow, accompanied by Ben Harper, covered George Harrison's "My Sweet Lord." McCartney paid tribute to John Lennon with "Here Today." And Harper and Eddie Vedder killed with a rendition of Queen and David Bowie's "Under Pressure."

Other highlights included Moby and Bettye LeVette dueting on "Natural Blues" while accompanied by the "TM Kids Choir"; Vedder's intense solo acoustic renditions of such songs as "Far Behind" and "Rise"; and pianist Angelo Badalamenti's show-opening rendition of his eerie "Twin Peaks" theme.

Other surprise guests included Jerry Seinfeld ("Don't meditate on me, I gotta do some jokes here," he cracked) and an uncharacteristically serious Howard Stern, who announced that he's been meditating for 38 years and who credited TM with saving his depressed mother's life many years ago.

Venue: Radio City Music Hall, New York (Saturday, April 4)
1 of 1 Pages
1
The Billboard Hot 100
Issue Date: 2009-04-11
This Week Last Week Title, Artist
Imprint | Catalog No. | Distributing Label
Peak
Position
Weeks
on
Chart
1 2 Poker Face, Lady GaGa 
Streamline/KonLive/Cherrytree 012715* | Interscope |
1 15
2 1 Right Round, Flo Rida  2
Poe Boy 517992* | Atlantic |
1 9
3 3 Kiss Me Thru The Phone, Soulja Boy Tell 'em Featuring Sammie 
ColliPark DIGITAL | Interscope |
3 14
4 4 Dead And Gone, T.I. Featuring Justin Timberlake 
Grand Hustle DIGITAL | Atlantic |
2 17
5 7 Blame It, Jamie Foxx Featuring T-Pain 
J 46266* | RMG |
5 11
Source: Billboard View Full Chart »
 


Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Username: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
Videos
The Hollywood Reporter Key Art Awards honor excellence in movie marketing.; Key Art Awards; Promotion; marketing; Reviews Index http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid1078667197http://www.brightcove.com/channel.jsp?channel=769341148
THR on DIGG
Music Reviews
Albums Reviews
  • Back to Tennessee
    Say what you will about Billy Ray Cyrus, the man has long since exceeded any expectations critics placed on him when "Achy Breaky Heart" made him an overnight sensation in 1992.
  • R.O.O.T.S.
    The acronym in the title of Flo Rida's sophomore set stands for "Route of Overcoming the Struggle," but "R.O.O.T.S." doesn't bother the listener with much in the way of hardship.
  • Jigsaw
    On her second album, "Jigsaw," the feisty rapper Lady Sovereign experiments with dancier beats, cleaner production and electronic vocals that sometimes find her singing rhymes instead of rapping them.
Singles Reviews
  • Then
    "Then," the first single from Brad Paisley's new album "American Saturday Night" (due June 30), is a heartfelt song about how true emotions continue to deepen with time.
  • Lord Help Me Be the Kind of Person (My Dog Thinks I Am)
    Howard and David Bellamy have always had a knack for clever lyrics and their latest single is no exception, with a hook line sure to elicit a chuckle from pet lovers.
  • Knock You Down (not listed)
    Keri Hilson traveled a long road to release her debut album "In a Perfect World," dating back to its first single, "Energy," in May 2008.
Concerts Reviews